October 31, 2025 • 30 mins
In this gripping episode of True Crime Case Files, we investigate the shocking murder of Melissa Granger, a 33-year-old English teacher in Fort Pierce, Florida, whose secret relationship with her 18-year-old student Ethan Rivera ended in a brutal electrocution in January 2019. From the discovery of her body in a water-filled staff bathroom filled with plugged-in adult toys, to the intense police investigation, multiple suspects, and the shocking twist revealed through Melissa’s journals, this case exposes the dark side of teacher-student relationships, grooming, and manipulation.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-case-files--6127499/support.
JOIN OUR FAN CLUB and become a part of our growing community of crime-solving aficionados!
JOIN HERE
We're waiting for you...
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-case-files--6127499/support.
JOIN OUR FAN CLUB and become a part of our growing community of crime-solving aficionados!
JOIN HERE
We're waiting for you...
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
Fort Pierce, Florida, January twenty nineteen. Treasure Coast High School,
a campus known for palm trees and Friday night football championships,
would soon become infamous for something else. Entirely beneath the
surface of everyday life, a dark and secret relationship between
a teacher and her student ended in brutal murder. This
is the case of Melissa Granger, a young teacher whose
(00:22):
pursuit of love and youth cross boundaries, and the teenager
who killed her. The victim was Melissa Granger. She was
thirty three years old in January of twenty nineteen, living
in Fort Pierce, Florida. Melissa worked as an English teacher
at Treasure Coast High School, a large public school best
known for its football championships and palm tree line campus.
(00:44):
Her classroom sat on the second floor of the main building,
and her students remembered her for her dramatic readings of
poetry and her habit of oversharing personal details. She was
the kind of teacher who wanted to be liked as
much as respected, and she often blurred the line between
being the mentor and being a friend. Melissa had grown
up in Florida, and later earned her degree in English
(01:05):
education from the University of Florida in Gainesville. After graduation,
she quickly found a job in the Treasure Coast School district.
Co Workers described her as energetic, always dressed in colorful outfits,
and often seen chatting in the hallways with students. She
had a laugh that carried down the hall, and while
she was popular with many teenagers, some teachers quietly raised
(01:26):
concerns that she was too friendly with male seniors. For years,
rumors swirled about Melissa's closeness with certain students, but no
formal complaints were ever proven or upheld. Outside of school,
Melissa lived in a small, but cheerful apartment just a
few blocks from the beach. She decorated her home with
sea shells and beach ding dart, and she spent much
of her free time with her beloved Dacshon Kyle. Insider
(01:50):
friends said she treated the dog like her child, often
bringing him along for car rides or posting pictures of
him online. In addition to teaching, Melissa ran a small
at sea shop where she sold handmade seashell jewelry. She
collected shells during long walks on the beach polished them
and turned them into necklaces and earrings. The shop didn't
make much money, but Melissa loved the idea of being
(02:12):
her own boss. One day, she dreamed of expanding it
into a full time business and leaking teaching behind. Melissa's
personality was complicated. Friends and colleagues often described her as flirty, insecure,
and always chasing youth. She spent money on trendy clothes,
hair dye, and skin care products, often talking about wanting
to look younger than she was. She had a restless
(02:34):
energy about her, as if she feared growing older and
being left behind. In conversations, she sometimes compared herself to
her teenage students, telling friends that she still felt twenty
one on the inside. In the days leading up to
her death in January twenty nineteen, Melissa had been busy
balancing her work at the high school, her online jewelry shop,
(02:54):
and her personal life. Her journals, later discovered by police,
showed she was thinking about starting a family. She had
written about her current boyfriend, who was not just younger
but one of her own students. She hinted at wanting
a baby with him, framing it as a way to
secure a permanent bond. To many, Melissa seemed like someone
who wanted love, attention, and admiration wherever she could find it.
(03:18):
She was a teacher, a shop owner, a dog mom,
and a woman trying to hold on to youth. But
beneath her smiling surface, she carried secrets that would soon
come to light in the most tragic way possible. On
the morning of Monday, January fourteenth, twenty nineteen, the start
of a new school week in Fort Pierce, Treasure Coast
High School was just waking up. The sun had barely
(03:40):
risen over the palm trees that lined the parking lot,
and students were beginning to arrive, carrying backpacks and iced
coffees from duncan or McDonald's. The weather was mild, about
sixty five degrees, with a cool breeze off the Atlantic.
Teachers were setting up their classrooms and the hallways echoed
with the usual chatter of teenagers before the first spell.
(04:00):
At around seven forty five am, Martin Reyus, a long
time school janitor, unlocked the staff bathroom on the east wing. Reyus,
fifty eight, had worked at Treasure Coast High for over
a decade, known for his quiet nature, and strong work ethic.
He usually began his mornings by checking bathrooms and restocking supplies.
That morning, he carried a carrying jingling with dozens of keys,
(04:23):
a roll of paper towels tucked under one arm, and
a spray bottle in hand. He expected nothing unusual when
he pushed the heavy staff bathroom door open. However, rayas
stopped in his tracks. In front of him stood a
scene he could not have imagined. A large white bathtub,
an old model that he knew had been sitting unused
in a storage area because of ongoing renovations, was in
(04:45):
the middle of the tiled floor. The tub was filled
with water. Floating inside was the body of a woman.
It took Ray's only seconds to recognize her as Melissa Granger,
the English teacher he had passed many times in the hallways.
Melissa's skin was pale and waxy, Her li long brown
hair spread out across the water like seaweed. What horrified
Rays most were the electrical cords running across the floor
(05:06):
into the tub. Several vibrating adult instruments and other grown
up things still plugged into the wall floated beside her body.
Some of them buzzed faintly in the water, giving off
a low hum. The smell of burt plastic hung faintly
in the air. Ryce's hands began to shake. His roll
of paper towels dropped to the floor with a thud,
unspooling across the tiles. He backed out of the bathroom,
(05:28):
his breathing uneven. He later told investigators that his first
thought was that he had stumbled onto some kind of prank,
but the lifeless look of Melissa's face told him immediately
it was real. Panicked, Reyes pulled out his cell phone
and dialed nine to one one. His voice cracked as
he tried to explain to the dispatcher what he was seeing.
There's a teacher, she's dead. She's in a tub with wires.
(05:51):
His words tumbled out in fragments. The dispatcher asked him
to stay calm and wait for police and medical responders
to arrive. By the time the call ended, the first
bell of the school day was ringing. Students filled the
hallways just steps away, unaware that inside the East Wing
staff bathroom lay the shocking scene that would soon shake
their entire community. The call for help came in just
(06:12):
before eight o'clock am on January fourteen, twenty nineteen, Fort
Pierce police units responded quickly, pulling into the parking lot
of Treasure Coast High School as the morning rush of
students and parents continued around them. Sirens briefly cut through
the normal sounds of cars honking, sneakers hitting pavement, and
kids joking with friends before first period. Officers hurried inside,
(06:34):
trying to keep their presence quiet so as not to
alarm students. Detectives Carla Mendoza forty one, and Brian Kelly,
forty six, were assigned to leave the investigation. Mendoza had
worked homicide for over a decade and was known for
her calm presence and ability to pick up on small
details others might miss. She was measured in her speech
(06:55):
and deliberate interactions, rarely rattled even in difficult cases. Kelly,
on the other hand, was more outspoken and emotional, a
veteran cop who had seen nearly everything, but wasn't shy
about expressing his disgust when a case crossed the line
into shocking. When they entered the East Wing staff bathroom,
both detectives immediately understood they were facing something unusual in
(07:16):
the middle of the tile floor sat a large, old
fashioned bathtub. It had been dragged in from a storage
area where renovation crews had kept spare fixtures. The tub
was filled nearly to the brim with water, and inside
floated the body of thirty three year old teacher Melissa Granger.
Her body was partially submerged, her face pale, her hair
spread across the water's surface. Wires snaked across the floor,
(07:39):
plugged into outlets on the ball. Several vibrating adult instruments
and electric grown up toys floated in the water, some
still faintly humming. The smell of damp plaster mixed with
a faint scent of burning plastic. Kelly shook his head, muttering,
this is the strangest setup I've seen in twenty years.
Mendoza crouched near the tub, carefully observing her face unreadable.
(07:59):
The seam was both chaotic and deliberate. The bathtub didn't
belong there, and dragging it from storage would have required
time and planning. The placement of electrical devices left no
doubt that this was more than an accident. Within hours,
the Saint Lucy County Coroner ruled Melissa's death and electrocution homicide.
Crime seeing technicians moved methodically through the bathroom. They photographed
(08:21):
every angle, capturing the tub, the outlets, and the tangle
of cords. They dusted surfaces for fingerprints, swabbed for DNA
on the tub's edges, and bagged the devices for later analysis.
Investigators measured drag marks on the floor, evidence of how
the heavy bathtub had been moved from storage. Outside the bathroom,
uniformed officers worked to keep students in staff away. Administrators
(08:44):
scrambled to maintain order, ushering teenagers into classrooms and telling
them only that an incident had occurred. Words still spread quickly,
with whispers moving down the hallways. By mid morning, the
detectives had formed their first impressions. Whoever killed Melissa had
access to the school, enough privacy to drag a tub
into place, and the nerve to set up a killing
(09:05):
method both bizarred and cruel. To them, it was clear
this was a calculated act, not a random tragedy. The
first person police looked at was Leonard Moore, a forty
four year old drifter who had been in and out
of Fort Pierce for years. People around town knew him
by his nickname Shaky Lenny, a name that came from
(09:26):
the constant tremors in his hands, the long term result
of drug use. Lenny had spent much of his adult
life in and out of prison. Most recently, he had
served time for burglary and had been released only a
few months before Melissa's death in January of twenty nineteen.
Lenny was trying to piece together a life on the outside,
though not very successfully. He picked up occasional jobs painting houses,
(09:48):
mowing lawns, or hauling junk, but steady work rarely lasted.
More often people saw him panhandling at gas stations, were
standing near intersections holding a cardboard sign that read need help.
He drifted from one cheap motel to another, and sometimes
slept behind dumpsters when money ran out. Despite this, many
locals described him as harmless pitiful, rather than threatening. On
(10:10):
the morning of January fourteenth, the same morning Melissa's body
was discovered, a school janitor noticed Lenny behind the gym
at Treasure Coast High School. It was carrying a torn
canvas bag filled with bits of scrap metal, pipes, old wiring,
and a bent aluminum sign. The janitor, uneasy about his presence,
made note of it and later mentioned the sighting to police.
(10:31):
When word of the homicide spread through the building, to investigators,
the tying was too close to ignore. Detectives Carla Mendoza
and Brian Kelly arranged for Lenny to be picked up
for questioning. He was found wandering near a convenience store
just a mile from the school, still carrying his bag.
Witnesses described him as dirty, jittery, and talking to himself
(10:52):
as he walked. At the station, Lenny appeared nervous, but
not combative. His hands shook so badly he spilled water
on the table when detectives offered him a cup. Mendoza
asked him calmly what he had been doing near the
school that morning. Lennie replied that he was just looking
for scrap metal to sell at the recycling center on
Orange Avenue. He explained that he needed money for food
(11:14):
and was hoping to scrap together enough for a hot meal.
When pressed about Melissa Granger, Lenny's confusion seemed genuine. He
claimed he didn't even know who she was and insisted
he had never stepped foot inside the school. Kelly, skeptical,
leaned on him harder, asking why he was carrying metal
pieces and why he had been spotted so close to
the east wing. Lenny stuck to his story, repeating over
(11:37):
and over, didn't hurt nobody. I was just trying to eat.
Investigators noted his long criminal record, but nothing in his
past suggested a crime as strange and elaborate as Melissa's murder.
Forensic teams compared his fingerprints in DNA to samples from
the bathroom nun matched. Security cameras from nearby buildings showed
(11:58):
him wandering outside the campus, but never entering the school itself.
By the end of the day, detectives began to see
Lenny as more of a distraction than the suspect. He
was pitiable, yes, and guilty of trespassing on school property,
but there was no evidence tying him to Melissa's death.
As one officer later remarked, he was just in the
wrong place at the wrong time. The second person investigators
(12:20):
focused on was Raymond Ray Dyah's age thirty seven. Ray
was Melissa's ex boyfriend, a man well known around Fort
Pierce for his charm, his big smile, and his habit
of sliding by on other people's money. In January of
twenty nineteen, he was working nights as of bartender at
a tichy lounge near the waterfront, a job that let
(12:41):
him mingle with tourists, tell jokes, and poor drinks with flair.
He always had an easy laugh and a smooth line,
but those who knew him well described him as selfish
and oportimistic. Friends of Melissa told detectives that Ray had
never really been in the relationship for love. Instead, they
said he stayed with her because she paid for everything, dinners, rent,
(13:02):
even his car insurance when he was short. When Melissa
finally broke things off, Ray didn't take it well. At
the bar where he worked, he was overheard joking to
coworkers that she was crazy enough to end up on
dateline one day. At the time, they thought it was
just talk, but after her death those words sounded chilling.
Police moved quickly to bring Ray in for questioning. On
(13:23):
January fifteenth, just a day after the murder, two detectives
met him at the Taiky lounge after his shift and
escorted him downtown. He didn't appear nervous. In fact, he
seemed almost cocky, leaning back in the interrogation chair, arms folded,
acting like he was the smartest person in the room.
When asked where he was the night Melissa died, Ray
(13:43):
gave an alibi that raised eyebrows. With a smirk, he
said he had been bleeping a girl like a champ
and added that he had been at her apartment all night.
Detectives pressed him for details, asking the woman's name and address,
but his answers were vague. He seemed more interested in
bragging about his conquest than giving clear information to the investigators.
His story felt shaky. There were gaps in his timeline,
(14:06):
and his dismissive attitude toward Melissa didn't help his case.
Detectives considered the possibility that Ray had grown bitter after
the breakup, especially if he had lost the financial support
he once enjoyed. A jealous or angry ex boyfriend was
often at the top of the suspect list in cases
like this. Still, police needed facts, not just impressions. They
(14:27):
checked his phone records, interviewed the woman he claimed to
be with, and pulled security footage from the area. At first,
the timeline seemed questionable, but within days, surveillance video from
a gas station across town placed raised car miles away
from the school around the time of the murder. Additional
footage from a convenience store later in the evening backed
up his claim that he was not near the crime scene.
(14:49):
By the end of the week, investigators had to admit
that Ray's alibi, while crude and disrespectfully phrased, was solid.
He was arrogant and opportunistic, and his comments about Melissa
were un settling, but the evidence showed he couldn't have
been the killer. As suspicion shifted away from him, detectives
crossed his name off the list and moved on to
other leads. On January eighteen, twenty nineteen, four days after
(15:13):
Melissa Granger's body was discovered, Fort Pierce was soaked in
steady rain. The skies had been gray all morning, the
kind of damp floorida winter day, when puddles gathered quickly
in parking lots and palm frond sagged heavy with water.
Detectives Carla Mendoza and Brian Kelly, still pressing forward with
every lead, turned their attention to Melissa's modest apartment, just
(15:33):
a few blocks from the beach. The one bedroom unit
was small but carefully decorated. Seashells lined the window sill,
reminders of her etsy jewelry business. In the living room,
her dack shunned Kyle lins Eider paced nervously, unsettled by
the absence of his owner. On the kitchen counter sat
an unopened bag of dog food, a half empty bottle
(15:54):
of white wine, and a sticky note reminder about grating papers.
During a thorough search of her bedroom, investigators discovered something
that would change the direction of the entire case. Inside
the drawer of a nightstand, Tucked beneath old receipts and
greeting cards, they found several journals. The covers were brightly colored,
decorated with doodles and stickers, giving the impression of teenage
(16:16):
notebooks rather than the private writings of a thirty three
year old woman. The contents, however, were far more disturbing.
Flipping through the pages detectives red entries filled with intimate
details about Melissa's relationship with Ethan, her eighteen year old student.
She described the excitement of their secret romance and wrote
openly about wanting to start a family with him. On
(16:38):
several pages, she had carefully charted her menstrual cycle, tracking
fertile days. Tucked between the journal entries, was a receipt
for prenatal vitamins purchased earlier that month at a local pharmacy.
In other passages, Melissa wrote about researching legal loopholes that
might allow her to marry Ethan as soon as he
turned eighteen. She detailed questions about parental consent laws, age
(16:59):
of majority statutes, and how quickly a marriage license could
be issued in Florida once he reached adulthood. The tone
of the journals was obsessive, less like the musings of
a woman in love, and more like the careful planning
of someone determined to secure control over a teenager's future.
The discovery stunned the investigative team. Up until then, many
had viewed Melissa primarily as a tragic figure, a young
(17:22):
teacher whose life was cut short in a bizarre and
brutal way. The journals, however, reframed the case entirely. She
wasn't simply a victim of obsession. She had been actively
grooming and manipulating a student preparing to cross lines that
no teacher should ever approach. Detective Mendoza later described the
moment as the air leaving the room what had once
(17:42):
seemed like a story of an ill fated romance. Mout
carried the clear outlines of predatory behavior. Every detail, the vitamins,
the charts, the wedding. Research painted Melissa in a much
darker light. By that rainy evening in January twenty nineteen,
the case file no longer cast Melissa's solely as a target. Instead,
the evidence suggested she had been living a double life,
(18:05):
a respected English teacher on the surface, but privately plotting
a future that blurred dangerous illegal boundaries. The third and
perhaps most troubling suspect was Ethan Rivera, a senior at
Treasure Coast High School and Melissa Granger's secret boyfriend. Ethan
was just eighteen years old, still living with his parents
in a modest ranch style home not far from campus.
(18:27):
Described by classmates as shy but intelligent, Ethan wasn't the
kind of student who drew much attention. He played defense
on the school soccer team, volunteered occasionally at the library,
and kept a small circle of cose friends. Teachers had
praised him for being respectful, diligent, and soft spoken in
the classroom. Ethan had often lingered after the bell, offering
(18:47):
to help Melissa with tasks like organizing books, erasing the whiteboard,
or cleaning up papers. To most students, this looked like
harmless devotion. Some teased him about being teacher's pet, whispering
jokes as he gathered her things at the end of
the day. Few realized that behind the scenes, Heathen was
in the middle of his first serious romance with his
(19:07):
English teacher. By January of twenty nineteen, that relationship had
grown complicated. Melissa, as revealed in her journals, wanted far
more than a high school fling. She was charting her cycle,
buying crenatal vitamins, and even looking up laws about marrying
Ethan after his eighteenth birthday. Ethan, meanwhile, was just beginning
to think about college applications, weekend soccer games, and spending
(19:31):
time with friends. The weight of Melissa's demands for a
shared future, complete with marriage and children left him conflicted
and overwhelmed. On January nineteen, detectives brought Ethan to the
station for questioning. It was a cool, breezy Saturday morning
and the school was quiet, its parking lot empty except
for a few teacher cars. Inside the station, Ethan sat
(19:54):
across from detectives Carla Mendoza and Ryan Kelly, his shoulders tense,
his hands folded tightly in his lap. At first, he
answered questions politely but cautiously. When asked directly about his
relationship with Melissa, he denied anything inappropriate, insisting she had
only been a supportive teacher. His voice shook slightly and
(20:14):
he avoided eye contact. But when Mendoza placed Melissa's journals
on the table and flipped them open to the pages
where she described playing a pregnancy with him, Ethan's composure cracked.
He leaned forward, his face pale, and admitted the truth.
Yes they had been involved, Yes he had spent time
with her outside of school, and yes she had pressured
him about their future. Hethan described feeling trapped, suffocated by
(20:38):
Melissa's intensity and her talk of babies in marriage. He
said he cared for her, but had never wanted such
a serious commitment at his age. Detectives listened carefully, noting
the shift in his tone. Ethan didn't sound like a
love struck teenager. He sounded like someone carrying a heavy secret,
forced into a role he wasn't ready for. When pressed
about the Knight of the Murder, Ethan denied any involvement
(21:00):
saying he had been at home studying for a midterm
and texting friends about soccer practice. Still, his clothes, miess
to Melissa, and the revelations in her journals placed him
firmly of the center of the investigation. For the first time,
detectives began to view Ethan not just as a grieving student,
but as a young man who may have had both
motive and opportunity. By the third week of January twenty nineteen,
(21:24):
investigators had chased multiple leads. At first, they wondered if
Melissa Granger's strange death was the work of an outside intruder,
maybe a drifter like Shaky Lenny or a bitter X
like raydis. But as the days went on, evidence pointed
inward closer to Melissa's own life. The turning point came
when detectives returned to Treasure Coast High School for another
(21:45):
sweep of her classroom on January twenty. While searching her
desk drawers, they discovered a second cell phone hidden beneath
a stack of old lesson plants. The phone was locked,
but once investigators accessed it, the contents revealed a darker
story than anyone had expected. The text messages inside painted
a picture of Melissa as controlling and obsessive. She frequently
(22:05):
pressured Ethan Rivera, her eighteen year old student and secret boyfriend,
into a future he clearly did not want. In one exchange,
she teased him, awe, I'm your first. That means you'll
tell your kids about me. Ethan responded, brainwashed confidence, no, babe,
I'll tell our kids. Dozens of messages echoed the same thing.
(22:26):
Melissa spoke of wanting Ethan's baby, framing it as therefore
ever bond. She sent him articles about young couples starting families,
and even links to baby clothes online. For Ethan, who
was already struggling under the secrecy of their relationship, the
pressure began suffocating. The text showed a growing rift. Ethan
often tried to pull back, writing short responses like ick
(22:47):
or can we not talk about this right now? But
Melissa pushed harder, reminding him of their intimacy and hinting
she would expose their relationship if he ever walked away.
One chilling message read, if you leave me, people will
know everything. For investigators, that threat explained Ethan's mounting desperation.
Piecing together the digital evidence with the Timeline detectives concluded
(23:09):
that on the night of January fourteen, Ethan hatched a
deadly plan. He texted Melissa and convinced her to meet
him in the east wing staff bathroom, a secluded area
then under renovation. He told her he wanted to try
something exciting, a suggestion that fit with the nature of
their hidden relationship. Once Melissa arrived, the trap was set.
(23:29):
The bathroom contained a bathtub that had been dragged in
from storage. Melissa, trusting Athan, stepped into the water. It
was then that he threw in several plugged and vibrating
adult instruments and electric toys for grown ups, devices he
knew would be little. Once they hit the water, the
electrocution killed her instantly. On January twenty, at eleven o'clock pm,
(23:51):
Fort Pierce Police officially named Ethan Rivera as the prime suspect.
Officers arrived at his family's home, a modest house on
a quiet street where his parents had been watching television.
Ethan appeared shocked when they placed him under arrest, but
he didn't resist. News of his arrests spread quickly through
the community. At the courthouse the next morning, Melissa's family
(24:11):
wept openly unable to reconcile the fact that her killer
was one of her own students. For investigators, the case
had turned from puzzling to heartbreaking, revealing the story of secrecy, manipulation,
and a young man's desperate attempt to escape a future
he never wanted. The long awaited trial of Ethan Rivera
began in October twenty twenty three at the Saint Lucy
(24:32):
County Courthouse in Fort Pierce, nearly five years after the
shocking death of English teacher Melissa Granger. The courthouse, with
its pale stucco walls and slow turning ceiling fans in
the hallways, became the center of attention for the Treasure
Coast community. Reporters lined the sidewalks broadcasting updates to a
public still divided over who was the true predator in
the case, Melissa or Ethan. The prosecution was led by
(24:56):
Daniel Worth fifty two, a stern and methodical attorney with
a reputation for being relentless in court. Worth argued that
Ethan had committed a cold and calculated murder. He told
the jury that using electricity as a weapon showed planning
and cruelty. He reminded them of the plugged and vibrating
adult instruments and wires snaking into the water. His voice
stayed firm and controlled as he painted Ethan as someone
(25:19):
who could have walked away but instead chose violence. On
the other side, the defense was handled by Linda Carver
thirty nine, a sharp and outspoken attorney who believed in
building empathy for her clients. Carver described Melissa as the
true manipulator, a thirty three year old teacher who groomed
her student into a secret relationship. She called Ethan a
(25:39):
child in an adult's body, pressured into intimacy and cornered
with threats. Carver argued that his actions were not those
of a cold killer, but of a desperate teenager who
saw no other way out. Inside the courtroom, emotions ran high.
Melissa's parents sat stiff and stone faced through most of
the testimony, clearly torn between grief for their daughter in
shame at the revel relations about her relationship with a student.
(26:02):
Her sister wept openly when Melissa's journals were read aloud,
revealing her obsession with pregnancy plans and her fixation on
Ethan as her forever bond. On the other side, Ethan's
mother quietly wiped tears during defense arguments, while his father
kept his head down, never once looking toward the jury.
After weeks of testimony, the jury retired to deliberate. They
(26:23):
returned two days later with a guilty verdict of second
degree murder. Judge Susan Langley sentenced Ifan Rivera to twenty
five years in state prison. Some members of the public
felt the punishment was far too like given the bizarre
and brutal nature of the killing. Others saw it as
a fair outcome, believing Melissa's predatory role in the relationship
had to be weighed in the balance. But the story
(26:45):
didn't end there. Just months after the verdict, a shocking
scandal unraveled the entire trial. Investigators learned that several jurors
had engaged in sexual relationships with one another during the
weeks of testimony, even organizing secret gatherings that turned into
group encounters. The misconduct came to light after text messages
between jurors were leaked, exposing a pattern of behavior that
(27:07):
violated courtroom rules and destroyed the integrity of their verdict.
In October twenty twenty three, the judge declared the trial invalid,
Ethan's conviction was overturned, and the case was thrown back
into legal limbo. The news stunned the community. Melissa's family,
who had waited nearly five years for justice, were once
again left broken and furious. For many in Fort Pierce,
(27:30):
the shocking collapse of the trial felt almost as disturbing
as the crime itself. In the months following the collapse
of the trial in October twenty twenty three, life for
everyone involved in the Melissa Granger case remained unsettled. Ethan Rivera,
whose conviction had been overturned due to jura misconduct, was
returned to custody and held in a Florida state prison
(27:51):
while awaiting the possibility of a new trial. At twenty
two years old, his once bright future filled with college
plans and soccer, had been completely derailed. Prison guards described
him as quiet and withdrawn, often keeping to himself during
meals and yard time. Advocates for victims of grooming used
the case as a cautionary example, emphasizing the dangers of
(28:13):
manipulation and teacher student relationships. Though Ethan himself remained largely
silent in interviews. Melissa's family retreated entirely from public life. Her
parents closed her Etsy shop selling seashell jewelry, removing the small,
colorful signs that had once brought customers to their website.
Friends reported that the home where she had lived with
her dack shown Kyle Linzider, was emptied of personal belongings.
(28:36):
Kyle was quietly rehomed with relatives, and the family focused
on private mourning rather than media appearances. The pain of
losing Melissa, combined with the public spectacle of the overturned trial,
left the family exhausted and wary of drawing attention to themselves.
Raymond Diaz, Melissa's ex boyfriend, left Fort Pierce soon after
the trial scandal. He moved to another part of Florida,
(28:58):
seeking to escape the ongoing owing attention and gossip. Friends
said he kept a low profile, working nights at a
local bar and avoiding discussions of the case. While he
was never implicated in the murder, of his association with
Melissa's death continued to shadow his reputation. Leonard Shaky Lenny
Moore faded even further into obscurity. After months of drifting
(29:18):
around Fort Pierce and doing occasional odd jobs, he became
little more than a background figure in the city. Police
occasionally checked in on him, but found nothing tying him
to any new crimes. Once a figure of suspicion, he
was now largely forgotten amid the ongoing legal drama surrounding
Nethan Rivera. For detectives Carla Mendoza and Brian Kelly, the
(29:38):
case left lingering effects. They continued their work in Fort Pierce,
investigating other crimes and attending community meetings about public safety.
Yet privately, both admitted that the Melissa Granger case had
left scars. The combination of a brutal and unusual murder,
the moral complexities of the teachers student relationship, and the
jury scandal had tested their patience, judgment, and faith in
(30:01):
the justice system. By the end of October twenty twenty three,
the community of Treasure Coast High School remained cautious. Students
returned to classes amid lingering whispers, Faculty moved quietly through
the halls, and the shadow of Melissa Granger's story continued
to influence conversations about boundaries, trust, and the lasting impact
of secrets. The murder of Melissa Granger blurred the line
(30:24):
between predator and victim, a teacher who crossed boundaries with
her student ended up paying the ultimate price in Fort Pierce,
Treasure Coast High School will forever remember January twenty nineteen,
not for football victories, but for the day a secret
relationship turned into a brutal crime.
Fort Pierce, Florida, January twenty nineteen. Treasure Coast High School,
a campus known for palm trees and Friday night football championships,
would soon become infamous for something else. Entirely beneath the
surface of everyday life, a dark and secret relationship between
a teacher and her student ended in brutal murder. This
is the case of Melissa Granger, a young teacher whose
(00:22):
pursuit of love and youth cross boundaries, and the teenager
who killed her. The victim was Melissa Granger. She was
thirty three years old in January of twenty nineteen, living
in Fort Pierce, Florida. Melissa worked as an English teacher
at Treasure Coast High School, a large public school best
known for its football championships and palm tree line campus.
(00:44):
Her classroom sat on the second floor of the main building,
and her students remembered her for her dramatic readings of
poetry and her habit of oversharing personal details. She was
the kind of teacher who wanted to be liked as
much as respected, and she often blurred the line between
being the mentor and being a friend. Melissa had grown
up in Florida, and later earned her degree in English
(01:05):
education from the University of Florida in Gainesville. After graduation,
she quickly found a job in the Treasure Coast School district.
Co Workers described her as energetic, always dressed in colorful outfits,
and often seen chatting in the hallways with students. She
had a laugh that carried down the hall, and while
she was popular with many teenagers, some teachers quietly raised
(01:26):
concerns that she was too friendly with male seniors. For years,
rumors swirled about Melissa's closeness with certain students, but no
formal complaints were ever proven or upheld. Outside of school,
Melissa lived in a small, but cheerful apartment just a
few blocks from the beach. She decorated her home with
sea shells and beach ding dart, and she spent much
of her free time with her beloved Dacshon Kyle. Insider
(01:50):
friends said she treated the dog like her child, often
bringing him along for car rides or posting pictures of
him online. In addition to teaching, Melissa ran a small
at sea shop where she sold handmade seashell jewelry. She
collected shells during long walks on the beach polished them
and turned them into necklaces and earrings. The shop didn't
make much money, but Melissa loved the idea of being
(02:12):
her own boss. One day, she dreamed of expanding it
into a full time business and leaking teaching behind. Melissa's
personality was complicated. Friends and colleagues often described her as flirty, insecure,
and always chasing youth. She spent money on trendy clothes,
hair dye, and skin care products, often talking about wanting
to look younger than she was. She had a restless
(02:34):
energy about her, as if she feared growing older and
being left behind. In conversations, she sometimes compared herself to
her teenage students, telling friends that she still felt twenty
one on the inside. In the days leading up to
her death in January twenty nineteen, Melissa had been busy
balancing her work at the high school, her online jewelry shop,
(02:54):
and her personal life. Her journals, later discovered by police,
showed she was thinking about starting a family. She had
written about her current boyfriend, who was not just younger
but one of her own students. She hinted at wanting
a baby with him, framing it as a way to
secure a permanent bond. To many, Melissa seemed like someone
who wanted love, attention, and admiration wherever she could find it.
(03:18):
She was a teacher, a shop owner, a dog mom,
and a woman trying to hold on to youth. But
beneath her smiling surface, she carried secrets that would soon
come to light in the most tragic way possible. On
the morning of Monday, January fourteenth, twenty nineteen, the start
of a new school week in Fort Pierce, Treasure Coast
High School was just waking up. The sun had barely
(03:40):
risen over the palm trees that lined the parking lot,
and students were beginning to arrive, carrying backpacks and iced
coffees from duncan or McDonald's. The weather was mild, about
sixty five degrees, with a cool breeze off the Atlantic.
Teachers were setting up their classrooms and the hallways echoed
with the usual chatter of teenagers before the first spell.
(04:00):
At around seven forty five am, Martin Reyus, a long
time school janitor, unlocked the staff bathroom on the east wing. Reyus,
fifty eight, had worked at Treasure Coast High for over
a decade, known for his quiet nature, and strong work ethic.
He usually began his mornings by checking bathrooms and restocking supplies.
That morning, he carried a carrying jingling with dozens of keys,
(04:23):
a roll of paper towels tucked under one arm, and
a spray bottle in hand. He expected nothing unusual when
he pushed the heavy staff bathroom door open. However, rayas
stopped in his tracks. In front of him stood a
scene he could not have imagined. A large white bathtub,
an old model that he knew had been sitting unused
in a storage area because of ongoing renovations, was in
(04:45):
the middle of the tiled floor. The tub was filled
with water. Floating inside was the body of a woman.
It took Ray's only seconds to recognize her as Melissa Granger,
the English teacher he had passed many times in the hallways.
Melissa's skin was pale and waxy, Her li long brown
hair spread out across the water like seaweed. What horrified
Rays most were the electrical cords running across the floor
(05:06):
into the tub. Several vibrating adult instruments and other grown
up things still plugged into the wall floated beside her body.
Some of them buzzed faintly in the water, giving off
a low hum. The smell of burt plastic hung faintly
in the air. Ryce's hands began to shake. His roll
of paper towels dropped to the floor with a thud,
unspooling across the tiles. He backed out of the bathroom,
(05:28):
his breathing uneven. He later told investigators that his first
thought was that he had stumbled onto some kind of prank,
but the lifeless look of Melissa's face told him immediately
it was real. Panicked, Reyes pulled out his cell phone
and dialed nine to one one. His voice cracked as
he tried to explain to the dispatcher what he was seeing.
There's a teacher, she's dead. She's in a tub with wires.
(05:51):
His words tumbled out in fragments. The dispatcher asked him
to stay calm and wait for police and medical responders
to arrive. By the time the call ended, the first
bell of the school day was ringing. Students filled the
hallways just steps away, unaware that inside the East Wing
staff bathroom lay the shocking scene that would soon shake
their entire community. The call for help came in just
(06:12):
before eight o'clock am on January fourteen, twenty nineteen, Fort
Pierce police units responded quickly, pulling into the parking lot
of Treasure Coast High School as the morning rush of
students and parents continued around them. Sirens briefly cut through
the normal sounds of cars honking, sneakers hitting pavement, and
kids joking with friends before first period. Officers hurried inside,
(06:34):
trying to keep their presence quiet so as not to
alarm students. Detectives Carla Mendoza forty one, and Brian Kelly,
forty six, were assigned to leave the investigation. Mendoza had
worked homicide for over a decade and was known for
her calm presence and ability to pick up on small
details others might miss. She was measured in her speech
(06:55):
and deliberate interactions, rarely rattled even in difficult cases. Kelly,
on the other hand, was more outspoken and emotional, a
veteran cop who had seen nearly everything, but wasn't shy
about expressing his disgust when a case crossed the line
into shocking. When they entered the East Wing staff bathroom,
both detectives immediately understood they were facing something unusual in
(07:16):
the middle of the tile floor sat a large, old
fashioned bathtub. It had been dragged in from a storage
area where renovation crews had kept spare fixtures. The tub
was filled nearly to the brim with water, and inside
floated the body of thirty three year old teacher Melissa Granger.
Her body was partially submerged, her face pale, her hair
spread across the water's surface. Wires snaked across the floor,
(07:39):
plugged into outlets on the ball. Several vibrating adult instruments
and electric grown up toys floated in the water, some
still faintly humming. The smell of damp plaster mixed with
a faint scent of burning plastic. Kelly shook his head, muttering,
this is the strangest setup I've seen in twenty years.
Mendoza crouched near the tub, carefully observing her face unreadable.
(07:59):
The seam was both chaotic and deliberate. The bathtub didn't
belong there, and dragging it from storage would have required
time and planning. The placement of electrical devices left no
doubt that this was more than an accident. Within hours,
the Saint Lucy County Coroner ruled Melissa's death and electrocution homicide.
Crime seeing technicians moved methodically through the bathroom. They photographed
(08:21):
every angle, capturing the tub, the outlets, and the tangle
of cords. They dusted surfaces for fingerprints, swabbed for DNA
on the tub's edges, and bagged the devices for later analysis.
Investigators measured drag marks on the floor, evidence of how
the heavy bathtub had been moved from storage. Outside the bathroom,
uniformed officers worked to keep students in staff away. Administrators
(08:44):
scrambled to maintain order, ushering teenagers into classrooms and telling
them only that an incident had occurred. Words still spread quickly,
with whispers moving down the hallways. By mid morning, the
detectives had formed their first impressions. Whoever killed Melissa had
access to the school, enough privacy to drag a tub
into place, and the nerve to set up a killing
(09:05):
method both bizarred and cruel. To them, it was clear
this was a calculated act, not a random tragedy. The
first person police looked at was Leonard Moore, a forty
four year old drifter who had been in and out
of Fort Pierce for years. People around town knew him
by his nickname Shaky Lenny, a name that came from
(09:26):
the constant tremors in his hands, the long term result
of drug use. Lenny had spent much of his adult
life in and out of prison. Most recently, he had
served time for burglary and had been released only a
few months before Melissa's death in January of twenty nineteen.
Lenny was trying to piece together a life on the outside,
though not very successfully. He picked up occasional jobs painting houses,
(09:48):
mowing lawns, or hauling junk, but steady work rarely lasted.
More often people saw him panhandling at gas stations, were
standing near intersections holding a cardboard sign that read need help.
He drifted from one cheap motel to another, and sometimes
slept behind dumpsters when money ran out. Despite this, many
locals described him as harmless pitiful, rather than threatening. On
(10:10):
the morning of January fourteenth, the same morning Melissa's body
was discovered, a school janitor noticed Lenny behind the gym
at Treasure Coast High School. It was carrying a torn
canvas bag filled with bits of scrap metal, pipes, old wiring,
and a bent aluminum sign. The janitor, uneasy about his presence,
made note of it and later mentioned the sighting to police.
(10:31):
When word of the homicide spread through the building, to investigators,
the tying was too close to ignore. Detectives Carla Mendoza
and Brian Kelly arranged for Lenny to be picked up
for questioning. He was found wandering near a convenience store
just a mile from the school, still carrying his bag.
Witnesses described him as dirty, jittery, and talking to himself
(10:52):
as he walked. At the station, Lenny appeared nervous, but
not combative. His hands shook so badly he spilled water
on the table when detectives offered him a cup. Mendoza
asked him calmly what he had been doing near the
school that morning. Lennie replied that he was just looking
for scrap metal to sell at the recycling center on
Orange Avenue. He explained that he needed money for food
(11:14):
and was hoping to scrap together enough for a hot meal.
When pressed about Melissa Granger, Lenny's confusion seemed genuine. He
claimed he didn't even know who she was and insisted
he had never stepped foot inside the school. Kelly, skeptical,
leaned on him harder, asking why he was carrying metal
pieces and why he had been spotted so close to
the east wing. Lenny stuck to his story, repeating over
(11:37):
and over, didn't hurt nobody. I was just trying to eat.
Investigators noted his long criminal record, but nothing in his
past suggested a crime as strange and elaborate as Melissa's murder.
Forensic teams compared his fingerprints in DNA to samples from
the bathroom nun matched. Security cameras from nearby buildings showed
(11:58):
him wandering outside the campus, but never entering the school itself.
By the end of the day, detectives began to see
Lenny as more of a distraction than the suspect. He
was pitiable, yes, and guilty of trespassing on school property,
but there was no evidence tying him to Melissa's death.
As one officer later remarked, he was just in the
wrong place at the wrong time. The second person investigators
(12:20):
focused on was Raymond Ray Dyah's age thirty seven. Ray
was Melissa's ex boyfriend, a man well known around Fort
Pierce for his charm, his big smile, and his habit
of sliding by on other people's money. In January of
twenty nineteen, he was working nights as of bartender at
a tichy lounge near the waterfront, a job that let
(12:41):
him mingle with tourists, tell jokes, and poor drinks with flair.
He always had an easy laugh and a smooth line,
but those who knew him well described him as selfish
and oportimistic. Friends of Melissa told detectives that Ray had
never really been in the relationship for love. Instead, they
said he stayed with her because she paid for everything, dinners, rent,
(13:02):
even his car insurance when he was short. When Melissa
finally broke things off, Ray didn't take it well. At
the bar where he worked, he was overheard joking to
coworkers that she was crazy enough to end up on
dateline one day. At the time, they thought it was
just talk, but after her death those words sounded chilling.
Police moved quickly to bring Ray in for questioning. On
(13:23):
January fifteenth, just a day after the murder, two detectives
met him at the Taiky lounge after his shift and
escorted him downtown. He didn't appear nervous. In fact, he
seemed almost cocky, leaning back in the interrogation chair, arms folded,
acting like he was the smartest person in the room.
When asked where he was the night Melissa died, Ray
(13:43):
gave an alibi that raised eyebrows. With a smirk, he
said he had been bleeping a girl like a champ
and added that he had been at her apartment all night.
Detectives pressed him for details, asking the woman's name and address,
but his answers were vague. He seemed more interested in
bragging about his conquest than giving clear information to the investigators.
His story felt shaky. There were gaps in his timeline,
(14:06):
and his dismissive attitude toward Melissa didn't help his case.
Detectives considered the possibility that Ray had grown bitter after
the breakup, especially if he had lost the financial support
he once enjoyed. A jealous or angry ex boyfriend was
often at the top of the suspect list in cases
like this. Still, police needed facts, not just impressions. They
(14:27):
checked his phone records, interviewed the woman he claimed to
be with, and pulled security footage from the area. At first,
the timeline seemed questionable, but within days, surveillance video from
a gas station across town placed raised car miles away
from the school around the time of the murder. Additional
footage from a convenience store later in the evening backed
up his claim that he was not near the crime scene.
(14:49):
By the end of the week, investigators had to admit
that Ray's alibi, while crude and disrespectfully phrased, was solid.
He was arrogant and opportunistic, and his comments about Melissa
were un settling, but the evidence showed he couldn't have
been the killer. As suspicion shifted away from him, detectives
crossed his name off the list and moved on to
other leads. On January eighteen, twenty nineteen, four days after
(15:13):
Melissa Granger's body was discovered, Fort Pierce was soaked in
steady rain. The skies had been gray all morning, the
kind of damp floorida winter day, when puddles gathered quickly
in parking lots and palm frond sagged heavy with water.
Detectives Carla Mendoza and Brian Kelly, still pressing forward with
every lead, turned their attention to Melissa's modest apartment, just
(15:33):
a few blocks from the beach. The one bedroom unit
was small but carefully decorated. Seashells lined the window sill,
reminders of her etsy jewelry business. In the living room,
her dack shunned Kyle lins Eider paced nervously, unsettled by
the absence of his owner. On the kitchen counter sat
an unopened bag of dog food, a half empty bottle
(15:54):
of white wine, and a sticky note reminder about grating papers.
During a thorough search of her bedroom, investigators discovered something
that would change the direction of the entire case. Inside
the drawer of a nightstand, Tucked beneath old receipts and
greeting cards, they found several journals. The covers were brightly colored,
decorated with doodles and stickers, giving the impression of teenage
(16:16):
notebooks rather than the private writings of a thirty three
year old woman. The contents, however, were far more disturbing.
Flipping through the pages detectives red entries filled with intimate
details about Melissa's relationship with Ethan, her eighteen year old student.
She described the excitement of their secret romance and wrote
openly about wanting to start a family with him. On
(16:38):
several pages, she had carefully charted her menstrual cycle, tracking
fertile days. Tucked between the journal entries, was a receipt
for prenatal vitamins purchased earlier that month at a local pharmacy.
In other passages, Melissa wrote about researching legal loopholes that
might allow her to marry Ethan as soon as he
turned eighteen. She detailed questions about parental consent laws, age
(16:59):
of majority statutes, and how quickly a marriage license could
be issued in Florida once he reached adulthood. The tone
of the journals was obsessive, less like the musings of
a woman in love, and more like the careful planning
of someone determined to secure control over a teenager's future.
The discovery stunned the investigative team. Up until then, many
had viewed Melissa primarily as a tragic figure, a young
(17:22):
teacher whose life was cut short in a bizarre and
brutal way. The journals, however, reframed the case entirely. She
wasn't simply a victim of obsession. She had been actively
grooming and manipulating a student preparing to cross lines that
no teacher should ever approach. Detective Mendoza later described the
moment as the air leaving the room what had once
(17:42):
seemed like a story of an ill fated romance. Mout
carried the clear outlines of predatory behavior. Every detail, the vitamins,
the charts, the wedding. Research painted Melissa in a much
darker light. By that rainy evening in January twenty nineteen,
the case file no longer cast Melissa's solely as a target. Instead,
the evidence suggested she had been living a double life,
(18:05):
a respected English teacher on the surface, but privately plotting
a future that blurred dangerous illegal boundaries. The third and
perhaps most troubling suspect was Ethan Rivera, a senior at
Treasure Coast High School and Melissa Granger's secret boyfriend. Ethan
was just eighteen years old, still living with his parents
in a modest ranch style home not far from campus.
(18:27):
Described by classmates as shy but intelligent, Ethan wasn't the
kind of student who drew much attention. He played defense
on the school soccer team, volunteered occasionally at the library,
and kept a small circle of cose friends. Teachers had
praised him for being respectful, diligent, and soft spoken in
the classroom. Ethan had often lingered after the bell, offering
(18:47):
to help Melissa with tasks like organizing books, erasing the whiteboard,
or cleaning up papers. To most students, this looked like
harmless devotion. Some teased him about being teacher's pet, whispering
jokes as he gathered her things at the end of
the day. Few realized that behind the scenes, Heathen was
in the middle of his first serious romance with his
(19:07):
English teacher. By January of twenty nineteen, that relationship had
grown complicated. Melissa, as revealed in her journals, wanted far
more than a high school fling. She was charting her cycle,
buying crenatal vitamins, and even looking up laws about marrying
Ethan after his eighteenth birthday. Ethan, meanwhile, was just beginning
to think about college applications, weekend soccer games, and spending
(19:31):
time with friends. The weight of Melissa's demands for a
shared future, complete with marriage and children left him conflicted
and overwhelmed. On January nineteen, detectives brought Ethan to the
station for questioning. It was a cool, breezy Saturday morning
and the school was quiet, its parking lot empty except
for a few teacher cars. Inside the station, Ethan sat
(19:54):
across from detectives Carla Mendoza and Ryan Kelly, his shoulders tense,
his hands folded tightly in his lap. At first, he
answered questions politely but cautiously. When asked directly about his
relationship with Melissa, he denied anything inappropriate, insisting she had
only been a supportive teacher. His voice shook slightly and
(20:14):
he avoided eye contact. But when Mendoza placed Melissa's journals
on the table and flipped them open to the pages
where she described playing a pregnancy with him, Ethan's composure cracked.
He leaned forward, his face pale, and admitted the truth.
Yes they had been involved, Yes he had spent time
with her outside of school, and yes she had pressured
him about their future. Hethan described feeling trapped, suffocated by
(20:38):
Melissa's intensity and her talk of babies in marriage. He
said he cared for her, but had never wanted such
a serious commitment at his age. Detectives listened carefully, noting
the shift in his tone. Ethan didn't sound like a
love struck teenager. He sounded like someone carrying a heavy secret,
forced into a role he wasn't ready for. When pressed
about the Knight of the Murder, Ethan denied any involvement
(21:00):
saying he had been at home studying for a midterm
and texting friends about soccer practice. Still, his clothes, miess
to Melissa, and the revelations in her journals placed him
firmly of the center of the investigation. For the first time,
detectives began to view Ethan not just as a grieving student,
but as a young man who may have had both
motive and opportunity. By the third week of January twenty nineteen,
(21:24):
investigators had chased multiple leads. At first, they wondered if
Melissa Granger's strange death was the work of an outside intruder,
maybe a drifter like Shaky Lenny or a bitter X
like raydis. But as the days went on, evidence pointed
inward closer to Melissa's own life. The turning point came
when detectives returned to Treasure Coast High School for another
(21:45):
sweep of her classroom on January twenty. While searching her
desk drawers, they discovered a second cell phone hidden beneath
a stack of old lesson plants. The phone was locked,
but once investigators accessed it, the contents revealed a darker
story than anyone had expected. The text messages inside painted
a picture of Melissa as controlling and obsessive. She frequently
(22:05):
pressured Ethan Rivera, her eighteen year old student and secret boyfriend,
into a future he clearly did not want. In one exchange,
she teased him, awe, I'm your first. That means you'll
tell your kids about me. Ethan responded, brainwashed confidence, no, babe,
I'll tell our kids. Dozens of messages echoed the same thing.
(22:26):
Melissa spoke of wanting Ethan's baby, framing it as therefore
ever bond. She sent him articles about young couples starting families,
and even links to baby clothes online. For Ethan, who
was already struggling under the secrecy of their relationship, the
pressure began suffocating. The text showed a growing rift. Ethan
often tried to pull back, writing short responses like ick
(22:47):
or can we not talk about this right now? But
Melissa pushed harder, reminding him of their intimacy and hinting
she would expose their relationship if he ever walked away.
One chilling message read, if you leave me, people will
know everything. For investigators, that threat explained Ethan's mounting desperation.
Piecing together the digital evidence with the Timeline detectives concluded
(23:09):
that on the night of January fourteen, Ethan hatched a
deadly plan. He texted Melissa and convinced her to meet
him in the east wing staff bathroom, a secluded area
then under renovation. He told her he wanted to try
something exciting, a suggestion that fit with the nature of
their hidden relationship. Once Melissa arrived, the trap was set.
(23:29):
The bathroom contained a bathtub that had been dragged in
from storage. Melissa, trusting Athan, stepped into the water. It
was then that he threw in several plugged and vibrating
adult instruments and electric toys for grown ups, devices he
knew would be little. Once they hit the water, the
electrocution killed her instantly. On January twenty, at eleven o'clock pm,
(23:51):
Fort Pierce Police officially named Ethan Rivera as the prime suspect.
Officers arrived at his family's home, a modest house on
a quiet street where his parents had been watching television.
Ethan appeared shocked when they placed him under arrest, but
he didn't resist. News of his arrests spread quickly through
the community. At the courthouse the next morning, Melissa's family
(24:11):
wept openly unable to reconcile the fact that her killer
was one of her own students. For investigators, the case
had turned from puzzling to heartbreaking, revealing the story of secrecy, manipulation,
and a young man's desperate attempt to escape a future
he never wanted. The long awaited trial of Ethan Rivera
began in October twenty twenty three at the Saint Lucy
(24:32):
County Courthouse in Fort Pierce, nearly five years after the
shocking death of English teacher Melissa Granger. The courthouse, with
its pale stucco walls and slow turning ceiling fans in
the hallways, became the center of attention for the Treasure
Coast community. Reporters lined the sidewalks broadcasting updates to a
public still divided over who was the true predator in
the case, Melissa or Ethan. The prosecution was led by
(24:56):
Daniel Worth fifty two, a stern and methodical attorney with
a reputation for being relentless in court. Worth argued that
Ethan had committed a cold and calculated murder. He told
the jury that using electricity as a weapon showed planning
and cruelty. He reminded them of the plugged and vibrating
adult instruments and wires snaking into the water. His voice
stayed firm and controlled as he painted Ethan as someone
(25:19):
who could have walked away but instead chose violence. On
the other side, the defense was handled by Linda Carver
thirty nine, a sharp and outspoken attorney who believed in
building empathy for her clients. Carver described Melissa as the
true manipulator, a thirty three year old teacher who groomed
her student into a secret relationship. She called Ethan a
(25:39):
child in an adult's body, pressured into intimacy and cornered
with threats. Carver argued that his actions were not those
of a cold killer, but of a desperate teenager who
saw no other way out. Inside the courtroom, emotions ran high.
Melissa's parents sat stiff and stone faced through most of
the testimony, clearly torn between grief for their daughter in
shame at the revel relations about her relationship with a student.
(26:02):
Her sister wept openly when Melissa's journals were read aloud,
revealing her obsession with pregnancy plans and her fixation on
Ethan as her forever bond. On the other side, Ethan's
mother quietly wiped tears during defense arguments, while his father
kept his head down, never once looking toward the jury.
After weeks of testimony, the jury retired to deliberate. They
(26:23):
returned two days later with a guilty verdict of second
degree murder. Judge Susan Langley sentenced Ifan Rivera to twenty
five years in state prison. Some members of the public
felt the punishment was far too like given the bizarre
and brutal nature of the killing. Others saw it as
a fair outcome, believing Melissa's predatory role in the relationship
had to be weighed in the balance. But the story
(26:45):
didn't end there. Just months after the verdict, a shocking
scandal unraveled the entire trial. Investigators learned that several jurors
had engaged in sexual relationships with one another during the
weeks of testimony, even organizing secret gatherings that turned into
group encounters. The misconduct came to light after text messages
between jurors were leaked, exposing a pattern of behavior that
(27:07):
violated courtroom rules and destroyed the integrity of their verdict.
In October twenty twenty three, the judge declared the trial invalid,
Ethan's conviction was overturned, and the case was thrown back
into legal limbo. The news stunned the community. Melissa's family,
who had waited nearly five years for justice, were once
again left broken and furious. For many in Fort Pierce,
(27:30):
the shocking collapse of the trial felt almost as disturbing
as the crime itself. In the months following the collapse
of the trial in October twenty twenty three, life for
everyone involved in the Melissa Granger case remained unsettled. Ethan Rivera,
whose conviction had been overturned due to jura misconduct, was
returned to custody and held in a Florida state prison
(27:51):
while awaiting the possibility of a new trial. At twenty
two years old, his once bright future filled with college
plans and soccer, had been completely derailed. Prison guards described
him as quiet and withdrawn, often keeping to himself during
meals and yard time. Advocates for victims of grooming used
the case as a cautionary example, emphasizing the dangers of
(28:13):
manipulation and teacher student relationships. Though Ethan himself remained largely
silent in interviews. Melissa's family retreated entirely from public life. Her
parents closed her Etsy shop selling seashell jewelry, removing the small,
colorful signs that had once brought customers to their website.
Friends reported that the home where she had lived with
her dack shown Kyle Linzider, was emptied of personal belongings.
(28:36):
Kyle was quietly rehomed with relatives, and the family focused
on private mourning rather than media appearances. The pain of
losing Melissa, combined with the public spectacle of the overturned trial,
left the family exhausted and wary of drawing attention to themselves.
Raymond Diaz, Melissa's ex boyfriend, left Fort Pierce soon after
the trial scandal. He moved to another part of Florida,
(28:58):
seeking to escape the ongoing owing attention and gossip. Friends
said he kept a low profile, working nights at a
local bar and avoiding discussions of the case. While he
was never implicated in the murder, of his association with
Melissa's death continued to shadow his reputation. Leonard Shaky Lenny
Moore faded even further into obscurity. After months of drifting
(29:18):
around Fort Pierce and doing occasional odd jobs, he became
little more than a background figure in the city. Police
occasionally checked in on him, but found nothing tying him
to any new crimes. Once a figure of suspicion, he
was now largely forgotten amid the ongoing legal drama surrounding
Nethan Rivera. For detectives Carla Mendoza and Brian Kelly, the
(29:38):
case left lingering effects. They continued their work in Fort Pierce,
investigating other crimes and attending community meetings about public safety.
Yet privately, both admitted that the Melissa Granger case had
left scars. The combination of a brutal and unusual murder,
the moral complexities of the teachers student relationship, and the
jury scandal had tested their patience, judgment, and faith in
(30:01):
the justice system. By the end of October twenty twenty three,
the community of Treasure Coast High School remained cautious. Students
returned to classes amid lingering whispers, Faculty moved quietly through
the halls, and the shadow of Melissa Granger's story continued
to influence conversations about boundaries, trust, and the lasting impact
of secrets. The murder of Melissa Granger blurred the line
(30:24):
between predator and victim, a teacher who crossed boundaries with
her student ended up paying the ultimate price in Fort Pierce,
Treasure Coast High School will forever remember January twenty nineteen,
not for football victories, but for the day a secret
relationship turned into a brutal crime.
Popular Podcasts
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
Are You A Charlotte?
In 1997, actress Kristin Davis’ life was forever changed when she took on the role of Charlotte York in Sex and the City. As we watched Carrie, Samantha, Miranda and Charlotte navigate relationships in NYC, the show helped push once unacceptable conversation topics out of the shadows and altered the narrative around women and sex. We all saw ourselves in them as they searched for fulfillment in life, sex and friendships. Now, Kristin Davis wants to connect with you, the fans, and share untold stories and all the behind the scenes. Together, with Kristin and special guests, what will begin with Sex and the City will evolve into talks about themes that are still so relevant today. "Are you a Charlotte?" is much more than just rewatching this beloved show, it brings the past and the present together as we talk with heart, humor and of course some optimism.
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.