October 26, 2024 • 24 mins
In this chilling true crime case, discover the shocking story of Terry Prinzler, sentenced to life in prison after being found guilty of murdering his nephew Tyler in a dark and twisted sexual betrayal. Set in Fort Wayne, Indiana, this gripping tale reveals the devastating secrets that tore the Prinzler family apart, including a scandalous affair between Terry and his sister-in-law Sandra.
FOLLOW now to stay on the edge of your seat and become a part of our growing community of crime-solving aficionados!
Have a true crime case you'd like to share with us?
Contact us here: eddo.lehi@gmail.com
We're waiting...
FOLLOW now to stay on the edge of your seat and become a part of our growing community of crime-solving aficionados!
Have a true crime case you'd like to share with us?
Contact us here: eddo.lehi@gmail.com
We're waiting...
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
In May of twenty fifteen, a quiet suburban neighborhood outside
Fort Wayne, Indiana, became the setting for a shocking crime.
An eighteen year old boy was brutally murdered, and the
investigation that followed uncovered a dark and twisted web of
family secrets. Tyler Prinsler was eighteen years old when he
was murdered. A recent high school graduate, Tyler was preparing
(00:21):
for college and had just accepted a football scholarship to
study graphic design. Known for his quiet, introverted nature, Tyler
wasn't the typical teenage boy. He kept to himself most
of the time and didn't seem interested in the usual
high school parties or social events. His family, especially his parents,
noticed this and were concerned when Tyler's behavior changed even
(00:42):
more during his senior year. Tyler had always been close
to his uncle, Terry Prinsler. Terry, who was fifty four
years old, had been like a father figure to Tyler
for most of his life. While Tyler's father, Stan worked
long hours at the dairy Queen he owner, Terry was
always available, taking Tyler to football games and helping him
with his school projects and overnight sleepovers. Some people found
(01:05):
it strange and disturbing just how close they were. As
Tyler got older, his parents Tan and Sandra felt like
they were losing their son to Terry. By May of
twenty fifteen, Tyler had moved out of his parents house
and was living with Terry full time. This move was
a surprise to the community. Many neighbors in their quiet,
suburban neighborhood outside Fort Wayne, Indiana, talked about how unusual
(01:27):
it was for an eighteen year old boy to league
his parents' home right after graduating high school. Tyler's mother, Sandra,
a stay at home mom, felt hurt and confused by
her son's decision to live with his uncle. She often
expressed her frustration to friends, saying that she barely saw
her son anymore. Meanwhile, Stamp, a stern and traditional man,
had his suspicions about a possible sexual relationship between his
(01:49):
brother and son, but never voiced them out loud. Terry's
home was only a few miles away from Tyler's parents,
but the change in environment was significant. Unlike the structured
life Tyler had with his parents, living with Terry gave
him more freedom. Terry worked as a contractor and had
a flexible schedule often spending entire days with Tyler, drinking
(02:09):
and possibly taking drugs together. Friends noted that Tyler had
become more withdrawn since moving in with his uncle, skipping
social events and not responding to invitations to hang out.
Tyler's family dynamic was clearly strained in the months leading
up to his death, but many thought this was just
a phase. At the time of his murder, Tyler was
focused on preparing for college and hoping to build a
(02:31):
career in graphic design. Despite the distance from his parents,
Tyler still communicated with them occasionally, though the relationship was
far from what it had once been and would never
be again. On the afternoon of May fifteen, twenty fifteen,
Terry Prinsler made a grim discovery. It was around two
thirty pm when Terry, returning home after a job, went
(02:52):
down to the basement of his house to check on
his nephew Tyler. According to Terry, Tyler had been feeling
unwell that morning and stayed home instead of running errands.
Terry said he expected Tyler to be resting, but what
he found instead was horrifying. Tyler's lifeless body was sprawled
on the cold concrete floor of the basement, he had
been beaten to death, his face and chest bruised in
(03:13):
bloody hannicked, Terry dialed nine one one. His voice was
frantic as he tried to explain what he had found,
saying he thought Tyler had fallen or been attacked by
someone who had broken into the house. There's blood everywhere,
Terry reportedly said during the call. When first responders arrived
at the scene, they noted that Terry scened shaken, repeatedly
(03:34):
telling them he couldn't understand how this had happened. His
hands were trembling and his eyes appeared red, as if
he had been weeping. Tyler's body was discovered in an
unfinished part of the basement, near some old exercise equipment
and storage boxes. The room was dimly lit, and the
only light source came from a single window high up
on the wall, casting a faint glow over the scene.
(03:55):
The police immediately secured the area, blocking off the basement
to begin their investigation. Tyler's injuries were severe, with significant
trauma to his head and chest. The coroner would later
confirm that Tyler had been brutally beaten to death with fists,
and the extent of the injury suggested a personal and
extreme rage fueled attack. The discovery of Tyler's body sent
(04:16):
shockwaves through the quiet, suburban neighborhood. People who knew Tyler
described him as a nice, quiet kid, and it was
hard for them to imagine why someone would want to
harm him. Words spread quickly, and by the evening, local
news stations, including w PTA twenty one, had picked up
the story, reporting live from the neighborhood. Residents watched as
(04:37):
news vans lined the streets and reporters interviewed neighbors who
expressed their disbelief. One neighbor, who wished to remain anonymous,
told the Journal Gazette that Tyler had always seemed like
a good kid, but they couldn't help but mention the
unusual closeness between Tyler and his uncle, Terry. This detail
would soon become central to the investigation as police began
(04:57):
to question what really happened in the hours leading up
to Tyler's death. When the police arrived at Terry Prinsler's
home on the afternoon of May fifteen, twenty fifteen, they
were met with a disturbing scene. Officers from the Fort
Wayne Police Department responded to Terry's frantic nine to one
one call and were at the house within minutes. The
lead investigator, Detective Courtney Monroe, a thirty eight year old
(05:20):
with a reputation for being methodical and calm under pressure,
was first on the scene. Alongside her was her partner
in both work and love, Detective Adam Brooks, a forty
five year old veteran of the force known for his
sharp instincts and no nonsense approach. The basement where Tyler's
body was found immediately struck the detectives as odd. The
room was cold and dim, with only a small window
(05:43):
letting a natural light. Tyler's body was found near a
set of weights and old storage boxes. His face and
chest were badly bruised, and there were clear signs of
a violent struggle. Blood spatter marked the walls, and there
were streaks of blood on the floor, indicating that Tyler
may have tried to crawl away from his attacker. The
crime scene was brutal, far more savage than what the
(06:04):
detectives expected in a normal suburban home. Detective Monroe noted
the lack of obvious murder weapons at the scene. There
were no knives, guns, or blunt objects that could have
been used to inflict the injuries. Instead, it appeared that
Tyler had been beaten to death with someone's bare hands.
This suggested that the attack was deeply personal, likely driven
by extreme anger or jealousy. Monroe and Brooks quickly began
(06:28):
to gather evidence, taking photographs of the scene and collecting
samples of the blood for DNA testing. Forensic steams arrived
soon after, using advanced tools to scan for fingerprints and
other clues that could point to the killer. One of
the investigators used Blooster forensic, a chemical that illuminates traces
of blood that may have been wiped away. In this case,
there were no signs of an attempted clean up. The
(06:49):
sheer violence of the attack was clear. The coroner, who
arrived shortly after, estimated that Tyler had been dead for
several hours before being discovered. His time of death was
placed around eleven am that morning. As they continued to
comfort the scene, Monroe and Brooks couldn't help but wonder
about the nature of Tyler's relationship with his uncle Terry.
Terry had been the one to find Tyler's body, and
(07:12):
his reactions seemed genuine. Still, in cases like this, those
closest to the victim were often the first to be questioned.
The detectives knew they would have to dig deeper into
the family's relationships to uncover the truth behind Tyler's tragic death.
The first person police questioned in the investigation was Tyler's father,
Stan Prinsler, at forty five, Stan was a hard working
(07:34):
dairy queen owner who had built a reputation for being
reliable but stern. He was known around town for fixing
classic cars at his garage, where he spent much of
his time. Stan's relationship with Tyler had grown strained in
the months before the murder, and his temper was something
locals in Fort Wayne were familiar with. Detectives Courtney Monroe
and Adam Brooks brought Stan in for questioning on the
(07:55):
evening of May fifteen, just hours after Tyler's body was discovered.
At first, Stan seemed cooperative but tense. He explained that
he hadn't seen Tyler for weeks ever, since his son
had moved out of the family home to live with
his uncle, Terry. Stan admitted to being frustrated with Tyler's decision,
especially because Tyler had been distancing himself from the entire family.
(08:17):
We barely spoke, Stan told the detectives, he just left
and I had no idea why. Monroe and Brooks noticed
Stan's irritation when he spoke about Tyler's close relationship with Terry.
Stan admitted that he had become suspicious of the amount
of time his brother and son spent together, but when
asked directly if he believed Terry had anything to do
with Tyler's death, Stan paused. His response was hesitant. I
(08:41):
don't know. It just doesn't seem like him, he finally said.
The interrogation took a turn when the detectives began to
press Stan on his whereabouts at the time of Tyler's death.
Stan claimed that he had been tinkering all day of
the garage, which was later confirmed by one of his
Dairy Queen employees. Despite having an alibi, Stan's frustration over
tyler Growing distance, paired with his strained relationship with his brother,
(09:03):
kept him as a key suspect early in the investigation.
Throughout the interview, Stan's temper occasionally flared. He raised his
voice when discussing Terry and seemed defensive when asked about
his feelings toward his son. I love my son, no
matter what he said angrily. However, his demeanor suggested there
was much more under the surface. The detectives left the
(09:25):
interview with mixed feelings. Stan's alibi appeared to check out,
but his growing frustration with Tyler and the tension within
the family left lingering doubts. Monroe noted in her report
that Stan's anger towards both his son and brother might
still be a critical piece of the puzzle. With no
concrete evidence linking him to the murder, Stan remained a
person of interest, but the police knew they needed more
(09:46):
to continue pursuing him as a suspect. The investigation took
a sharp turn when detectives found a piece of new
evidence that connected Terry Prinsler, Tyler's uncle, to the murder
in an unexpected way. As police continued to search Terry's home,
where Tyler's body had been found, they came across Tyler's
cell phone hidden in the basement. Forensic experts at the
(10:09):
Fort Wayne Police Department quickly got to work extracting data
from the phone, hoping it would shed light on the
events leading up to his death. Among Tyler's text messages,
social media conversations, and photos, detectives uncovered a series of
deeply sexually explicit messages between Tyler and Terry. What they
discovered was shocking. Tyler and Terry had been involved in
(10:30):
a secret sexual relationship. The messages, spanning several months, revealed
the side of their bond that no one in the
family would ever have suspected. Tyler had often confided in
Terry about his struggles at home, and it seemed that
the close relationship had turned into something more. The text
revealed not only intimate details, but also tensions between the two.
(10:52):
In the days before his death, Tyler had expressed a
desire to move on with his life, go to college,
and leave the relationship behind. Caused friction with Terry, who
appeared increasingly jealous and controlling in his messages. One of
the most revealing exchanges took place just a day before
the murder. Tyler had texted Terry saying he wanted to
start fresh when he went off to college. Terry's response
(11:15):
was angry and possessive, hinting at the control he wanted
over Tyler. Investigators noted that Terry seemed to be struggling
with Tyler's desire for independence, which could have triggered violent
emotions in him. The discovery of the secret relationship led
the detectives to reinterview Terry. During the second interrogation, Terry
initially denied everything, sticking to his earlier story that he
(11:38):
was Tyler's mentor and father figure, but when detectives confronted
him with the messages, Terry's demeanor shifted, his face grew pale,
and after several long pauses, he confessed to the relationship.
He claimed that it had started as a way to
help Tyler through his emotional struggles, but it had quickly
turned into something more. Terry's confession, however, did not include
(11:59):
any admissions about the murder. He insisted that while their
relationship was inappropriate, he had nothing to do with Tyler's death,
but detectives weren't convinced. The new evidence suggested that Kerry's
feelings for Tyler had grown obsessive, and Tyler's desire to
break free might have been the motive behind the brutal crime.
As detectives continued their investigation, they focused on Terry Prinsler,
(12:22):
Tyler's uncle. Terry fifty four, was a successful contractor in
Fort Wayne, known for his charm and outgoing personality. He
had always been a significant influence in Tyler's life. However,
after the shocking discovery of Tyler's body, police felt that
Terry was hiding something important. On May nineteen, twenty fifteen,
Detective Courtney Monroe brought Terry in for another round of questioning.
(12:45):
The atmosphere in the interrogation room was tense. The detectives
laid out the evidence they had gathered, including the sexually
explicit text messages and the notebook that detailed Terry's obsessive
desires for Tyler. As they pressed Terry, his calm exterior
began to crack. Initially, Terry denied any wrongdoing. He maintained
that his relationship with Tyler was simply that of a
(13:08):
mentor and a loving uncle. However, as detectives showed him
the evidence, the weight of the situation began to sink in.
After several minutes of back and forth, Terry finally broke
down and admitted to the detectives that he and Tyler
had been involved in a secret sexual relationship. I never
meant for it to go this far, Terry confessed, visibly shaken.
(13:29):
He told police he loved Tyler and thought he felt
the same way. He explained that their relationship had started
as a way to help Tyler through his emotional struggles,
but it had quickly evolved into something more complex and
deeply intimate. Terry shared that he had become increasingly worried
about Tyler's plans to go to college. I was afraid
of losing him. He was everything to me, he said,
(13:50):
his voice trembling. He mentioned that Tyler had talked about
moving on with his life and starting fresh by moving
to another state for college, which filled Terry with fear
and jealousy. I just wanted him to stay with me.
I thought we could make it work, he added. The
confession was significant. It revealed that Terry's sexual feelings for
Tyler were not only affectionate, but also possessive. The detectives
(14:12):
noted that this emotional turmoil likely played a role in
the events leading up to Tyler's tragic death. The fear
of abandonment and the complexity of their relationship had spiraled
into a toxic situation. Detective Monroe continued to press Terry
for details about the day of the murder. They wanted
to know if the two had argued about Tyler's future.
Terry was reluctant to share specifics, but his demeanor suggested
(14:36):
that the conversation had taken a dark turn. As the
interrogation wrapped up, the detectives left with a clear understanding
of the twisted dynamics at play. Terry Prinsler was now
the prime suspect in the investigation, and his confession about
the secret relationship added a chilling layer to the already
tragic story. As police continued to dig deeper into the case,
(14:57):
they shifted their focus to Sander Prinsler, tyler mother. At
forty two years old, Sandra was a stay at home
mong who had dedicated her life to her family. However,
her marital relationship with Stan had been strained for years,
and rumors of tension within the household were starting to surface.
On May twenty, twenty fifteen, Detective Courtney Monroe brought Sandra
(15:19):
in for questioning. The atmosphere was charged, with Sandra appearing
nervous as she sat in the small interrogation room. As
the detectives began to discuss Tyler's murder, they noticed signs
of discomfort in Sandra's demeanor. She fidgeted with her hands,
and avoided eye contact. When detectives pressed her about her
relationship with Tyler, Sandra seemed defensive. She insisted that she
(15:41):
had always been a protective mother and that her son
meant the world to her. However, as the conversation progressed,
the detectives started to unravel a shocking revelation. Sandra had
been having her own secret affair with Carrie, Tyler's uncle.
Detective Monroe asked Sandra directly about her sexual relationship with Terry.
She hesitated, but then admitted to the affair, saying it
(16:03):
had started months before Tyler's death. Terry was great and
had a giant bleep, but it was so complicated, she confessed.
The detectives realized that Sandra's jealousy over Tyler's own sexual
relationship with Terry might have played a significant role in
the family's turmoil. Sandra explained that she felt sidelined by
the sexual relationship between her son and her brother in law.
(16:25):
It was like I didn't exist anymore. Terry and Tyler
were always bleeping each other, she said, her voice tinged
with frustration. She admitted that seeing her son grow closer
to Terry only fueled her feelings of jealousy. I wanted
to be the one he bleeped, not Tyler, she added.
This revelation added a disturbing layer to the investigation. With
both Sandra and Terry involved in secret sexual affairs with
(16:48):
each other, the family and sexual dynamics were more complicated
than anyone had realized. The detectives began to consider how
these intertwined relationships could have contributed to the tragic events
leading up to Tyler's death. As the interrogation continued, Stander's
emotions fluctuated between anger and despair. She expressed sadness over
Tyler's death, but also frustration with Terry. It was clear
(17:12):
that the complicated feelings within the family could have led
to significant conflict. Detective Monroe left the interview with a
deeper understanding of the tensions at play, with both Sandra
and Terry harboring secrets and feelings of jealousy. The motive
behind Tyler's murder seemed to grow more complicated by the minute.
The investigation into this tragic family saga was far from over.
(17:35):
By late May of twenty fifteen, the investigation into Tyler
Prinsler's murder had taken multiple twists and turns, but all
the clues finally pointed to one person, Terry Prinsler, Tyler's
fifty four year old uncle. Terry had been a successful
contractor and a beloved member of the small Fort Wayne community. Outwardly,
(17:55):
he seemed like the perfect uncle, a mentor who had
taken Tyler under his wing when moved out of his
parents' home. But beneath the surface, there were dark secrets
no one could ever imagined. Detective Courtney Monroe had already
uncovered the disturbing truth about Terry and Tyler's secret sexual relationship.
As the investigation dug deeper, they learned more about Terry's motives.
(18:17):
The once close bond between uncle and nephew had started
to crumble when Tyler began to focus on his future,
college football and independence. Feeling abandoned, Terry became increasingly possessive
and jealous, seeing Tyler's growing independence as a personal betrayal
of their relationship. On May twenty eighth, police received the
final piece of the puzzle. Forensic evidence from Terry's home.
(18:40):
The basement where Tyler's body had been found revealed Tyler's
blood on Terry's clothing. It was a damning discovery that
confirmed what detectives had suspected. Terry had beaten Tyler to
death in a fit of rage, disguise to his nephew
as a new sex style they would be trying out.
Investigators believed Terry's emotional turmoil over losing control of Tyler,
(19:01):
mixed with his sexual jealousy and possessiveness, had driven him
to commit the murder. That same afternoon, at approximately three
thirty p m. Police arrived at Terry's modest home in
Fort Wayne to arrest him. As detectives approached the door,
Terry appeared calm, even smiling, as he invited them inside.
When they informed him he was under arrest for the
(19:21):
murder of Tyler Prinsler, his face remained emotionless. Terry didn't
resist or protests, simply asking how do you figure it out?
As police handcuffed him and led him out of the house.
Neighbors watched from their front yards in shock. Terry had
been a well like member of the community, and seeing
him taken away in a police car was unimaginable to many.
(19:42):
The Prinsler family, already torn apart by Tyler's death, was
devastated by the news Stan and Sander Prinsler were especially
crushed learning that the man they trusted with their son's
well being had been the one responsible for his brutal murder.
Their grief was compounded by the betrayal they felt toward Terry.
The arrest was a turning point in the case, but
(20:02):
the full story of what had led to this tragic
murder would be revealed in the courtroom. In October of
twenty sixteen, Terry Prinsler stood trial for the murder of
his nephew, Kyler Prinsler. The case at Gripfort Wayne, Indiana,
and the courtroom was packed with reporters, family members, and
curious locals. The prosecution, led by thirty seven year old
(20:24):
prosecutor Ashley Madison, painted a clear and disturbing picture of
the crime. She argued that Terry, consumed by jealousy and control,
brutally beat Tyler to death in a fit of rage
after Tyler began distancing himself from their secret relationship. Madison,
known for her methodical approach, laid out the evidence, including
forensic proof of Tyler's blood on Terry's clothes, the chilling
(20:47):
discovery in the basement, and Terry's own confession about their
inappropriate relationship. On the defense side was fifty two year
old attorney Donald P. Hayes, a seasoned lawyer known for
taking on difficult cases. He argued that Terry had not
premeditated the murder. He claimed that the beating was an
accident fueled by an emotional breakdown, rather than a calculated
(21:08):
plan to kill. Hayes tried to present Terry as a
broken man, overcome with guilt and regret for what had happened.
Throughout the trial, Pyler's parents, Stan and Sandra Prinsler sat
quietly in the courtroom. Sandra occasionally wiped tears from her
eyes as details of her son's secret life were revealed.
The strained family dynamics, including Sandra's own affair with Terry,
(21:29):
shocked many in the community. It was a painful reality
that none of them could have imagined before Tyler's death.
The jury deliberated for three days before reaching a verdict.
On October twelfth, twenty sixteen, they found Terry Prinsler guilty
of first degree murder. When the verdict was read, Terry
remained emotionless, his eyes fixed on the floor. His sentencing
(21:50):
came soon after life in prison without the possibility of parole.
For many, the sentencing provided a sense of justice, but
for Tyler's family, no punishment could erase the pain of
losing their son. The trial had exposed dark family secrets
and left deep scars. Friends of Tyler, many of whom
were now in college, expressed sadness and disbelief over the
(22:11):
entire ordeal. As the courtroom emptied, the town of Fort
Wayne was left to grapple with the tragedy and its
lingering effects. After the trial ended in October of twenty sixteen.
The fallout for the Prinsler family was devastating. Terry Prinsler,
who had been found guilty of the murder of his
nephew Tyler, was sentenced to life in prison without the
(22:32):
possibility of parole. The court's decision reflected the severity of
the crime and the betrayal of trust within the family. Terry,
who had once been a respected contractor in Fort Wayne, Indiana,
became infamous overnight. He was transferred to Indiana State Prison,
a maximum security facility, where he began serving his life sentence.
Tyler's father, Stan Prinsler, was left reeling from the revelations
(22:55):
that had come to light during the trial, but discovery
that Terry had harboured a dark secret chattered Stand's trust
in his family. Though Stan had been close to his
brother in the past, their relationship deteriorated quickly after the trial.
In the months that followed, Stan struggled to cope with
the loss of his son and the destruction of his family.
He left his job as a mechanic, moved to Indianapolis,
(23:17):
and attempted to rebuild his life. However, the emotional weight
of his son's death and his brother's betrayal made it
difficult for him to move forward. Sander Prinsler, Stan's wife,
faced public scrutiny after the trial as details of her
affair with Terry were exposed. Though Sandra was never charged
with a crime, her role in the events that led
(23:39):
to Tyler's murder left her ostracized by friends and neighbors.
She moved out of Fort Wayne and sought anonymity in
a small town in southern Indiana. Her marriage to Stan
did not survived the aftermath of the trial, and the
two separated shortly after. Sander tried to lead a quiet life,
but the stigma of her involvement in the scandal followed her,
making it hard to escape passed. The Prinsler family, once close,
(24:02):
had been irrevocably fractured by the events of that tragic
day in May twenty fifteen. While Terry remained in prison,
Stan and Sandra struggled to navigate their lives in the
shadow of their family's dark history. Neither was able to
fully heal from the trauma, and the once strong ties
that bound them were forever broken.
In May of twenty fifteen, a quiet suburban neighborhood outside
Fort Wayne, Indiana, became the setting for a shocking crime.
An eighteen year old boy was brutally murdered, and the
investigation that followed uncovered a dark and twisted web of
family secrets. Tyler Prinsler was eighteen years old when he
was murdered. A recent high school graduate, Tyler was preparing
(00:21):
for college and had just accepted a football scholarship to
study graphic design. Known for his quiet, introverted nature, Tyler
wasn't the typical teenage boy. He kept to himself most
of the time and didn't seem interested in the usual
high school parties or social events. His family, especially his parents,
noticed this and were concerned when Tyler's behavior changed even
(00:42):
more during his senior year. Tyler had always been close
to his uncle, Terry Prinsler. Terry, who was fifty four
years old, had been like a father figure to Tyler
for most of his life. While Tyler's father, Stan worked
long hours at the dairy Queen he owner, Terry was
always available, taking Tyler to football games and helping him
with his school projects and overnight sleepovers. Some people found
(01:05):
it strange and disturbing just how close they were. As
Tyler got older, his parents Tan and Sandra felt like
they were losing their son to Terry. By May of
twenty fifteen, Tyler had moved out of his parents house
and was living with Terry full time. This move was
a surprise to the community. Many neighbors in their quiet,
suburban neighborhood outside Fort Wayne, Indiana, talked about how unusual
(01:27):
it was for an eighteen year old boy to league
his parents' home right after graduating high school. Tyler's mother, Sandra,
a stay at home mom, felt hurt and confused by
her son's decision to live with his uncle. She often
expressed her frustration to friends, saying that she barely saw
her son anymore. Meanwhile, Stamp, a stern and traditional man,
had his suspicions about a possible sexual relationship between his
(01:49):
brother and son, but never voiced them out loud. Terry's
home was only a few miles away from Tyler's parents,
but the change in environment was significant. Unlike the structured
life Tyler had with his parents, living with Terry gave
him more freedom. Terry worked as a contractor and had
a flexible schedule often spending entire days with Tyler, drinking
(02:09):
and possibly taking drugs together. Friends noted that Tyler had
become more withdrawn since moving in with his uncle, skipping
social events and not responding to invitations to hang out.
Tyler's family dynamic was clearly strained in the months leading
up to his death, but many thought this was just
a phase. At the time of his murder, Tyler was
focused on preparing for college and hoping to build a
(02:31):
career in graphic design. Despite the distance from his parents,
Tyler still communicated with them occasionally, though the relationship was
far from what it had once been and would never
be again. On the afternoon of May fifteen, twenty fifteen,
Terry Prinsler made a grim discovery. It was around two
thirty pm when Terry, returning home after a job, went
(02:52):
down to the basement of his house to check on
his nephew Tyler. According to Terry, Tyler had been feeling
unwell that morning and stayed home instead of running errands.
Terry said he expected Tyler to be resting, but what
he found instead was horrifying. Tyler's lifeless body was sprawled
on the cold concrete floor of the basement, he had
been beaten to death, his face and chest bruised in
(03:13):
bloody hannicked, Terry dialed nine one one. His voice was
frantic as he tried to explain what he had found,
saying he thought Tyler had fallen or been attacked by
someone who had broken into the house. There's blood everywhere,
Terry reportedly said during the call. When first responders arrived
at the scene, they noted that Terry scened shaken, repeatedly
(03:34):
telling them he couldn't understand how this had happened. His
hands were trembling and his eyes appeared red, as if
he had been weeping. Tyler's body was discovered in an
unfinished part of the basement, near some old exercise equipment
and storage boxes. The room was dimly lit, and the
only light source came from a single window high up
on the wall, casting a faint glow over the scene.
(03:55):
The police immediately secured the area, blocking off the basement
to begin their investigation. Tyler's injuries were severe, with significant
trauma to his head and chest. The coroner would later
confirm that Tyler had been brutally beaten to death with fists,
and the extent of the injury suggested a personal and
extreme rage fueled attack. The discovery of Tyler's body sent
(04:16):
shockwaves through the quiet, suburban neighborhood. People who knew Tyler
described him as a nice, quiet kid, and it was
hard for them to imagine why someone would want to
harm him. Words spread quickly, and by the evening, local
news stations, including w PTA twenty one, had picked up
the story, reporting live from the neighborhood. Residents watched as
(04:37):
news vans lined the streets and reporters interviewed neighbors who
expressed their disbelief. One neighbor, who wished to remain anonymous,
told the Journal Gazette that Tyler had always seemed like
a good kid, but they couldn't help but mention the
unusual closeness between Tyler and his uncle, Terry. This detail
would soon become central to the investigation as police began
(04:57):
to question what really happened in the hours leading up
to Tyler's death. When the police arrived at Terry Prinsler's
home on the afternoon of May fifteen, twenty fifteen, they
were met with a disturbing scene. Officers from the Fort
Wayne Police Department responded to Terry's frantic nine to one
one call and were at the house within minutes. The
lead investigator, Detective Courtney Monroe, a thirty eight year old
(05:20):
with a reputation for being methodical and calm under pressure,
was first on the scene. Alongside her was her partner
in both work and love, Detective Adam Brooks, a forty
five year old veteran of the force known for his
sharp instincts and no nonsense approach. The basement where Tyler's
body was found immediately struck the detectives as odd. The
room was cold and dim, with only a small window
(05:43):
letting a natural light. Tyler's body was found near a
set of weights and old storage boxes. His face and
chest were badly bruised, and there were clear signs of
a violent struggle. Blood spatter marked the walls, and there
were streaks of blood on the floor, indicating that Tyler
may have tried to crawl away from his attacker. The
crime scene was brutal, far more savage than what the
(06:04):
detectives expected in a normal suburban home. Detective Monroe noted
the lack of obvious murder weapons at the scene. There
were no knives, guns, or blunt objects that could have
been used to inflict the injuries. Instead, it appeared that
Tyler had been beaten to death with someone's bare hands.
This suggested that the attack was deeply personal, likely driven
by extreme anger or jealousy. Monroe and Brooks quickly began
(06:28):
to gather evidence, taking photographs of the scene and collecting
samples of the blood for DNA testing. Forensic steams arrived
soon after, using advanced tools to scan for fingerprints and
other clues that could point to the killer. One of
the investigators used Blooster forensic, a chemical that illuminates traces
of blood that may have been wiped away. In this case,
there were no signs of an attempted clean up. The
(06:49):
sheer violence of the attack was clear. The coroner, who
arrived shortly after, estimated that Tyler had been dead for
several hours before being discovered. His time of death was
placed around eleven am that morning. As they continued to
comfort the scene, Monroe and Brooks couldn't help but wonder
about the nature of Tyler's relationship with his uncle Terry.
Terry had been the one to find Tyler's body, and
(07:12):
his reactions seemed genuine. Still, in cases like this, those
closest to the victim were often the first to be questioned.
The detectives knew they would have to dig deeper into
the family's relationships to uncover the truth behind Tyler's tragic death.
The first person police questioned in the investigation was Tyler's father,
Stan Prinsler, at forty five, Stan was a hard working
(07:34):
dairy queen owner who had built a reputation for being
reliable but stern. He was known around town for fixing
classic cars at his garage, where he spent much of
his time. Stan's relationship with Tyler had grown strained in
the months before the murder, and his temper was something
locals in Fort Wayne were familiar with. Detectives Courtney Monroe
and Adam Brooks brought Stan in for questioning on the
(07:55):
evening of May fifteen, just hours after Tyler's body was discovered.
At first, Stan seemed cooperative but tense. He explained that
he hadn't seen Tyler for weeks ever, since his son
had moved out of the family home to live with
his uncle, Terry. Stan admitted to being frustrated with Tyler's decision,
especially because Tyler had been distancing himself from the entire family.
(08:17):
We barely spoke, Stan told the detectives, he just left
and I had no idea why. Monroe and Brooks noticed
Stan's irritation when he spoke about Tyler's close relationship with Terry.
Stan admitted that he had become suspicious of the amount
of time his brother and son spent together, but when
asked directly if he believed Terry had anything to do
with Tyler's death, Stan paused. His response was hesitant. I
(08:41):
don't know. It just doesn't seem like him, he finally said.
The interrogation took a turn when the detectives began to
press Stan on his whereabouts at the time of Tyler's death.
Stan claimed that he had been tinkering all day of
the garage, which was later confirmed by one of his
Dairy Queen employees. Despite having an alibi, Stan's frustration over
tyler Growing distance, paired with his strained relationship with his brother,
(09:03):
kept him as a key suspect early in the investigation.
Throughout the interview, Stan's temper occasionally flared. He raised his
voice when discussing Terry and seemed defensive when asked about
his feelings toward his son. I love my son, no
matter what he said angrily. However, his demeanor suggested there
was much more under the surface. The detectives left the
(09:25):
interview with mixed feelings. Stan's alibi appeared to check out,
but his growing frustration with Tyler and the tension within
the family left lingering doubts. Monroe noted in her report
that Stan's anger towards both his son and brother might
still be a critical piece of the puzzle. With no
concrete evidence linking him to the murder, Stan remained a
person of interest, but the police knew they needed more
(09:46):
to continue pursuing him as a suspect. The investigation took
a sharp turn when detectives found a piece of new
evidence that connected Terry Prinsler, Tyler's uncle, to the murder
in an unexpected way. As police continued to search Terry's home,
where Tyler's body had been found, they came across Tyler's
cell phone hidden in the basement. Forensic experts at the
(10:09):
Fort Wayne Police Department quickly got to work extracting data
from the phone, hoping it would shed light on the
events leading up to his death. Among Tyler's text messages,
social media conversations, and photos, detectives uncovered a series of
deeply sexually explicit messages between Tyler and Terry. What they
discovered was shocking. Tyler and Terry had been involved in
(10:30):
a secret sexual relationship. The messages, spanning several months, revealed
the side of their bond that no one in the
family would ever have suspected. Tyler had often confided in
Terry about his struggles at home, and it seemed that
the close relationship had turned into something more. The text
revealed not only intimate details, but also tensions between the two.
(10:52):
In the days before his death, Tyler had expressed a
desire to move on with his life, go to college,
and leave the relationship behind. Caused friction with Terry, who
appeared increasingly jealous and controlling in his messages. One of
the most revealing exchanges took place just a day before
the murder. Tyler had texted Terry saying he wanted to
start fresh when he went off to college. Terry's response
(11:15):
was angry and possessive, hinting at the control he wanted
over Tyler. Investigators noted that Terry seemed to be struggling
with Tyler's desire for independence, which could have triggered violent
emotions in him. The discovery of the secret relationship led
the detectives to reinterview Terry. During the second interrogation, Terry
initially denied everything, sticking to his earlier story that he
(11:38):
was Tyler's mentor and father figure, but when detectives confronted
him with the messages, Terry's demeanor shifted, his face grew pale,
and after several long pauses, he confessed to the relationship.
He claimed that it had started as a way to
help Tyler through his emotional struggles, but it had quickly
turned into something more. Terry's confession, however, did not include
(11:59):
any admissions about the murder. He insisted that while their
relationship was inappropriate, he had nothing to do with Tyler's death,
but detectives weren't convinced. The new evidence suggested that Kerry's
feelings for Tyler had grown obsessive, and Tyler's desire to
break free might have been the motive behind the brutal crime.
As detectives continued their investigation, they focused on Terry Prinsler,
(12:22):
Tyler's uncle. Terry fifty four, was a successful contractor in
Fort Wayne, known for his charm and outgoing personality. He
had always been a significant influence in Tyler's life. However,
after the shocking discovery of Tyler's body, police felt that
Terry was hiding something important. On May nineteen, twenty fifteen,
Detective Courtney Monroe brought Terry in for another round of questioning.
(12:45):
The atmosphere in the interrogation room was tense. The detectives
laid out the evidence they had gathered, including the sexually
explicit text messages and the notebook that detailed Terry's obsessive
desires for Tyler. As they pressed Terry, his calm exterior
began to crack. Initially, Terry denied any wrongdoing. He maintained
that his relationship with Tyler was simply that of a
(13:08):
mentor and a loving uncle. However, as detectives showed him
the evidence, the weight of the situation began to sink in.
After several minutes of back and forth, Terry finally broke
down and admitted to the detectives that he and Tyler
had been involved in a secret sexual relationship. I never
meant for it to go this far, Terry confessed, visibly shaken.
(13:29):
He told police he loved Tyler and thought he felt
the same way. He explained that their relationship had started
as a way to help Tyler through his emotional struggles,
but it had quickly evolved into something more complex and
deeply intimate. Terry shared that he had become increasingly worried
about Tyler's plans to go to college. I was afraid
of losing him. He was everything to me, he said,
(13:50):
his voice trembling. He mentioned that Tyler had talked about
moving on with his life and starting fresh by moving
to another state for college, which filled Terry with fear
and jealousy. I just wanted him to stay with me.
I thought we could make it work, he added. The
confession was significant. It revealed that Terry's sexual feelings for
Tyler were not only affectionate, but also possessive. The detectives
(14:12):
noted that this emotional turmoil likely played a role in
the events leading up to Tyler's tragic death. The fear
of abandonment and the complexity of their relationship had spiraled
into a toxic situation. Detective Monroe continued to press Terry
for details about the day of the murder. They wanted
to know if the two had argued about Tyler's future.
Terry was reluctant to share specifics, but his demeanor suggested
(14:36):
that the conversation had taken a dark turn. As the
interrogation wrapped up, the detectives left with a clear understanding
of the twisted dynamics at play. Terry Prinsler was now
the prime suspect in the investigation, and his confession about
the secret relationship added a chilling layer to the already
tragic story. As police continued to dig deeper into the case,
(14:57):
they shifted their focus to Sander Prinsler, tyler mother. At
forty two years old, Sandra was a stay at home
mong who had dedicated her life to her family. However,
her marital relationship with Stan had been strained for years,
and rumors of tension within the household were starting to surface.
On May twenty, twenty fifteen, Detective Courtney Monroe brought Sandra
(15:19):
in for questioning. The atmosphere was charged, with Sandra appearing
nervous as she sat in the small interrogation room. As
the detectives began to discuss Tyler's murder, they noticed signs
of discomfort in Sandra's demeanor. She fidgeted with her hands,
and avoided eye contact. When detectives pressed her about her
relationship with Tyler, Sandra seemed defensive. She insisted that she
(15:41):
had always been a protective mother and that her son
meant the world to her. However, as the conversation progressed,
the detectives started to unravel a shocking revelation. Sandra had
been having her own secret affair with Carrie, Tyler's uncle.
Detective Monroe asked Sandra directly about her sexual relationship with Terry.
She hesitated, but then admitted to the affair, saying it
(16:03):
had started months before Tyler's death. Terry was great and
had a giant bleep, but it was so complicated, she confessed.
The detectives realized that Sandra's jealousy over Tyler's own sexual
relationship with Terry might have played a significant role in
the family's turmoil. Sandra explained that she felt sidelined by
the sexual relationship between her son and her brother in law.
(16:25):
It was like I didn't exist anymore. Terry and Tyler
were always bleeping each other, she said, her voice tinged
with frustration. She admitted that seeing her son grow closer
to Terry only fueled her feelings of jealousy. I wanted
to be the one he bleeped, not Tyler, she added.
This revelation added a disturbing layer to the investigation. With
both Sandra and Terry involved in secret sexual affairs with
(16:48):
each other, the family and sexual dynamics were more complicated
than anyone had realized. The detectives began to consider how
these intertwined relationships could have contributed to the tragic events
leading up to Tyler's death. As the interrogation continued, Stander's
emotions fluctuated between anger and despair. She expressed sadness over
Tyler's death, but also frustration with Terry. It was clear
(17:12):
that the complicated feelings within the family could have led
to significant conflict. Detective Monroe left the interview with a
deeper understanding of the tensions at play, with both Sandra
and Terry harboring secrets and feelings of jealousy. The motive
behind Tyler's murder seemed to grow more complicated by the minute.
The investigation into this tragic family saga was far from over.
(17:35):
By late May of twenty fifteen, the investigation into Tyler
Prinsler's murder had taken multiple twists and turns, but all
the clues finally pointed to one person, Terry Prinsler, Tyler's
fifty four year old uncle. Terry had been a successful
contractor and a beloved member of the small Fort Wayne community. Outwardly,
(17:55):
he seemed like the perfect uncle, a mentor who had
taken Tyler under his wing when moved out of his
parents' home. But beneath the surface, there were dark secrets
no one could ever imagined. Detective Courtney Monroe had already
uncovered the disturbing truth about Terry and Tyler's secret sexual relationship.
As the investigation dug deeper, they learned more about Terry's motives.
(18:17):
The once close bond between uncle and nephew had started
to crumble when Tyler began to focus on his future,
college football and independence. Feeling abandoned, Terry became increasingly possessive
and jealous, seeing Tyler's growing independence as a personal betrayal
of their relationship. On May twenty eighth, police received the
final piece of the puzzle. Forensic evidence from Terry's home.
(18:40):
The basement where Tyler's body had been found revealed Tyler's
blood on Terry's clothing. It was a damning discovery that
confirmed what detectives had suspected. Terry had beaten Tyler to
death in a fit of rage, disguise to his nephew
as a new sex style they would be trying out.
Investigators believed Terry's emotional turmoil over losing control of Tyler,
(19:01):
mixed with his sexual jealousy and possessiveness, had driven him
to commit the murder. That same afternoon, at approximately three
thirty p m. Police arrived at Terry's modest home in
Fort Wayne to arrest him. As detectives approached the door,
Terry appeared calm, even smiling, as he invited them inside.
When they informed him he was under arrest for the
(19:21):
murder of Tyler Prinsler, his face remained emotionless. Terry didn't
resist or protests, simply asking how do you figure it out?
As police handcuffed him and led him out of the house.
Neighbors watched from their front yards in shock. Terry had
been a well like member of the community, and seeing
him taken away in a police car was unimaginable to many.
(19:42):
The Prinsler family, already torn apart by Tyler's death, was
devastated by the news Stan and Sander Prinsler were especially
crushed learning that the man they trusted with their son's
well being had been the one responsible for his brutal murder.
Their grief was compounded by the betrayal they felt toward Terry.
The arrest was a turning point in the case, but
(20:02):
the full story of what had led to this tragic
murder would be revealed in the courtroom. In October of
twenty sixteen, Terry Prinsler stood trial for the murder of
his nephew, Kyler Prinsler. The case at Gripfort Wayne, Indiana,
and the courtroom was packed with reporters, family members, and
curious locals. The prosecution, led by thirty seven year old
(20:24):
prosecutor Ashley Madison, painted a clear and disturbing picture of
the crime. She argued that Terry, consumed by jealousy and control,
brutally beat Tyler to death in a fit of rage
after Tyler began distancing himself from their secret relationship. Madison,
known for her methodical approach, laid out the evidence, including
forensic proof of Tyler's blood on Terry's clothes, the chilling
(20:47):
discovery in the basement, and Terry's own confession about their
inappropriate relationship. On the defense side was fifty two year
old attorney Donald P. Hayes, a seasoned lawyer known for
taking on difficult cases. He argued that Terry had not
premeditated the murder. He claimed that the beating was an
accident fueled by an emotional breakdown, rather than a calculated
(21:08):
plan to kill. Hayes tried to present Terry as a
broken man, overcome with guilt and regret for what had happened.
Throughout the trial, Pyler's parents, Stan and Sandra Prinsler sat
quietly in the courtroom. Sandra occasionally wiped tears from her
eyes as details of her son's secret life were revealed.
The strained family dynamics, including Sandra's own affair with Terry,
(21:29):
shocked many in the community. It was a painful reality
that none of them could have imagined before Tyler's death.
The jury deliberated for three days before reaching a verdict.
On October twelfth, twenty sixteen, they found Terry Prinsler guilty
of first degree murder. When the verdict was read, Terry
remained emotionless, his eyes fixed on the floor. His sentencing
(21:50):
came soon after life in prison without the possibility of parole.
For many, the sentencing provided a sense of justice, but
for Tyler's family, no punishment could erase the pain of
losing their son. The trial had exposed dark family secrets
and left deep scars. Friends of Tyler, many of whom
were now in college, expressed sadness and disbelief over the
(22:11):
entire ordeal. As the courtroom emptied, the town of Fort
Wayne was left to grapple with the tragedy and its
lingering effects. After the trial ended in October of twenty sixteen.
The fallout for the Prinsler family was devastating. Terry Prinsler,
who had been found guilty of the murder of his
nephew Tyler, was sentenced to life in prison without the
(22:32):
possibility of parole. The court's decision reflected the severity of
the crime and the betrayal of trust within the family. Terry,
who had once been a respected contractor in Fort Wayne, Indiana,
became infamous overnight. He was transferred to Indiana State Prison,
a maximum security facility, where he began serving his life sentence.
Tyler's father, Stan Prinsler, was left reeling from the revelations
(22:55):
that had come to light during the trial, but discovery
that Terry had harboured a dark secret chattered Stand's trust
in his family. Though Stan had been close to his
brother in the past, their relationship deteriorated quickly after the trial.
In the months that followed, Stan struggled to cope with
the loss of his son and the destruction of his family.
He left his job as a mechanic, moved to Indianapolis,
(23:17):
and attempted to rebuild his life. However, the emotional weight
of his son's death and his brother's betrayal made it
difficult for him to move forward. Sander Prinsler, Stan's wife,
faced public scrutiny after the trial as details of her
affair with Terry were exposed. Though Sandra was never charged
with a crime, her role in the events that led
(23:39):
to Tyler's murder left her ostracized by friends and neighbors.
She moved out of Fort Wayne and sought anonymity in
a small town in southern Indiana. Her marriage to Stan
did not survived the aftermath of the trial, and the
two separated shortly after. Sander tried to lead a quiet life,
but the stigma of her involvement in the scandal followed her,
making it hard to escape passed. The Prinsler family, once close,
(24:02):
had been irrevocably fractured by the events of that tragic
day in May twenty fifteen. While Terry remained in prison,
Stan and Sandra struggled to navigate their lives in the
shadow of their family's dark history. Neither was able to
fully heal from the trauma, and the once strong ties
that bound them were forever broken.
Popular Podcasts
CrimeLess: Hillbilly Heist
It’s 1996 in rural North Carolina, and an oddball crew makes history when they pull off America’s third largest cash heist. But it’s all downhill from there. Join host Johnny Knoxville as he unspools a wild and woolly tale about a group of regular ‘ol folks who risked it all for a chance at a better life. CrimeLess: Hillbilly Heist answers the question: what would you do with 17.3 million dollars? The answer includes diamond rings, mansions, velvet Elvis paintings, plus a run for the border, murder-for-hire-plots, and FBI busts.
Crime Junkie
Does hearing about a true crime case always leave you scouring the internet for the truth behind the story? Dive into your next mystery with Crime Junkie. Every Monday, join your host Ashley Flowers as she unravels all the details of infamous and underreported true crime cases with her best friend Brit Prawat. From cold cases to missing persons and heroes in our community who seek justice, Crime Junkie is your destination for theories and stories you won’t hear anywhere else. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or new to the genre, you'll find yourself on the edge of your seat awaiting a new episode every Monday. If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people. Follow to join a community of Crime Junkies! Crime Junkie is presented by audiochuck Media Company.
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.