March 14, 2025 • 25 mins
EPISODE 1: "DARKNESS BELOW: CAVE RESCUE" This episode examines survival and rescue in natural and recreational cave systems, centering on three dramatic case studies:
This content was created in partnership and with the help of Artificial Intelligence AI
- The Thai Cave Rescue (2018): The miraculous rescue of twelve boys and their soccer coach from Thailand's flooded Tham Luang cave system after 18 days trapped in darkness, featuring the unprecedented sedation technique that made their extraction possible.
- The Nutty Putty Cave Tragedy (2009): The heartbreaking story of John Edward Jones, who became fatally trapped in Utah's Nutty Putty Cave despite rescuers being able to reach and communicate with him.
- The Floyd Collins Incident (1925): America's first mass-media cave disaster, where Kentucky explorer Floyd Collins became trapped, sparking a rescue effort followed by 20 million Americans via newspaper and radio.
This content was created in partnership and with the help of Artificial Intelligence AI
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:00):
Episode one, Darkness below Cave Rescue. The absolute darkness is
the first thing they all mention. Not like the darkness
of night, which still contains ambient light from stars, moon
or distant human sources, cave darkness is complete, impenetrable, a
darkness so profound that the human mind, desperate for visual stimulation,
(00:24):
sometimes manufactures its own phantom lights and patterns. In this
perfect blackness, time loses meaning, minutes stretch to seeming hours,
while days can blur together. And when this darkness comes
with confinement, limited air, and no clear path to the surface,
(00:44):
it creates one of the most primal human fears, being
buried alive. On June twenty third, twenty eighteen, twelve boys
from the Wild Boar soccer team and their coach entered
Thaie Land's time Sam Luang Cave system for what was
supposed to be a brief exploration after practice. The caves
(01:07):
were a local attraction, though signs warned against entry during
the rainy season from July to November. June was typically safe,
but that year, an unusually early monsoon changed everything. We
just wanted to explore a bit and celebrate one of
the boy's birthdays. Assistant coach, Icopol Channawong later explained we'd
(01:29):
been in the cave before and only planned to go
in a short distance. As the group ventured deeper into
the winding passages, heavy rain began falling outside. Water following
the path of least resistance, poured into the cave entrance
and began flooding the tunnels behind them. By the time
they realized the danger, their exit was already submerged. Forced
(01:53):
deeper into the cave system, the group eventually found refuge
on a small mud bank approximately two point five miles
from the entrance, in a chamber that was slightly elevated
above the rising water. With their flashlights providing the only light,
the twelve boys, aged eleven to sixteen, and their twenty
five year old coach found themselves in a situation that
(02:16):
would test the limits of human endurance and spawn one
of the most complex rescue operations in history. When we
realized we couldn't go back, I told the boys not
to lose hope, Ecopol recalled. I told them to stay strong,
that help would come, That help would take ten days
to arrive. The psychological impact of being trapped underground as
(02:38):
multifaceted explains doctor Jennifer Lanier, a psychologist specializing in trauma
and extreme environments. There's the immediate stress response fear, increased
heart rate, rapid breathing, but as hours turn to days,
different psychological challenges emerge. Sensory deprivation from concert darkness can
(03:01):
cause disorientation and even hallucinations. Uncertainty about rescue creates anxiety.
Limited space can trigger claustrophobia. The combination can be overwhelming
for the wild boares. Several factors helped mitigate these effects.
The group Dynamic provided social support. Coach Ekopol, who had
(03:25):
spent ten years as a Buddhist monk, taught the boy's
meditation techniques to calm their minds and conserve energy, and critically,
they had found a chamber with breathable air above water level.
Others trapped in cave systems haven't been so fortunate. On
November twenty fourth, two thousand and nine, John Edward Jones
(03:48):
decided to explore Utah's Nutty Putty Cave with his brother Josh.
The cave, named for its narrow, twisting passages that resembled
nutty putty inconsistency, was popular with local spelunkers despite its
challenging terrain. John twenty six, was an experienced caver, but
(04:10):
hadn't been active in the hobby since before his marriage
and the birth of his first child. Around eight forty
five PM, John entered a passage he thought was the
familiar birth canal route. Instead, it was an unexplored passage
that narrowed dramatically. As he inched forward headfirst on his stomach,
(04:32):
the six foot tall, two hundred pound man found himself
in a vertical shaft barely ten inches across at its
narrowest point, narrower than his shoulders. When he tried to inhale,
his chest couldn't fully expand. Attempting to retreat, he found
that gravity in the passage's confines prevented backward movement. John
(04:55):
Jones was stuck completely immobilized in a position that had
him angled head down at approximately seventy degrees. The position
John was trapped in made his situation particularly dangerous, explains
cave rescue specialist Teresa Williams. Being inverted for extended periods
puts extreme stress on the cardiovascular system, blood pools in
(05:18):
the upper body and head. Breathing is restricted, and the
heart must work harder against gravity. Even without other factors
like dehydration or hypothermia, this position alone can become fatal
if prolonged. When John failed to return from that section
of the cave, his brother Josh alerted other cavers, who
(05:41):
called for help. The first rescuers reached John around twelve
thirty am, establishing verbal contact and providing initial support. What
followed was a twenty seven hour rescue attempt involving more
than one hundred people. The technical challenges were or immense.
The passage was so narrow that rescuers had to work
(06:04):
one at a time in shifts. They couldn't bring much
equipment into the tight space. Standard rescue techniques like using
body harnesses weren't feasible in the confined passage. Even communication
was difficult, with rescuers having to relay messages verbally from
the rescue site to the cave entrance. At one point,
(06:26):
rescuers managed to attach a pulley system to John's feet
and lift him about twelve inches, only for the anchoring
to fail, letting him slip back even deeper into the crevice.
This moment, after hours of progress, was devastating for both
John and his rescuers in confined space. Rescues setbacks are
(06:48):
particularly difficult psychologically, noting notes doctor Lanier, the victim experiences
the physical reality of failing to escape, which can trigger
profound hopelessness. Rescuers experience intense frustration and sometimes guilt, even
when the circumstances are beyond their control. The emotional intensity
(07:10):
in these situations is extreme for everyone involved. Throughout his ordeal,
John remained conscious and communicative, though his condition deteriorated as
hours passed. He spoke with rescuers about his wife, Emily,
who was pregnant with their second child. He mentioned his daughter,
(07:31):
who had just celebrated her first birthday. These connections to
the outside world, to a future he desperately wanted to
return to helped sustain his will to survive. After more
than twenty four hours of rescue efforts, with John still
firmly trapped, medical personnel made the devastating assessment that his
(07:54):
vital signs were declining rapidly. Despite being able to communicate
with him, despite being able to touch him and provide
limited support, rescuers were unable to free John from his
Stone prison. At eleven fifty five p m. On November
twenty fifth, two thousand nine, John Edward Jones was pronounced dead.
(08:17):
The Nutty Putty incident represents a particularly painful type of
rescue failure, says Williams. Rescuers could reach the victim, communicate
with him, even touch him, but still couldn't save him.
That creates a special kind of trauma for rescue personnel,
a sense that somehow they should have been able to
do more, even when technically there was nothing more they
(08:40):
could do. After John's death, the decision was made not
to recover his body, as doing so would have required
dangerous expansions of the narrow passage. Instead, the passage was
sealed with concrete, creating a permanent crypt. The entire nuttye
the Putty Cave was closed permanently in twenty fourteen, a
(09:04):
reminder of how unforgiving underground environments can be. This unforgiving
nature of caves has been known throughout human history. Perhaps
the most famous American case of cave entrapment prior to
modern times was that of Floyd Collins, whose nineteen twenty
five ordeal in Kentucky's Sand Cave became one of the
(09:27):
nation's first media sensation disasters. Collins, an experienced cave explorer,
who had discovered the spectacular Crystal Cave on his family's property,
was searching for new cave passages that might rival Kentucky's
Commercial Mammoth Cave. On January thirtieth, nineteen twenty five, while
(09:48):
exploring a narrow passage in sand Cave, a rock shifted
and pinned his leg. He found himself trapped fifty five
feet below ground in a passage so zhe tight that
he couldn't reach the rock that trapped him. When Collins
failed to return, rescue efforts began. The first rescuer to
(10:09):
reach him was a small man named Jule Estes, who
brought Floyd water and food for days. Rescuers maintained contact
with Collins, working to free him while newspaper reporters converged
on the scene. The Louisville Courier Journal sent reporter William
Burke Eskets Miller, who was small enough to squeeze through
(10:30):
the narrow passage, to interview Collins. Miller's first hand accounts
of conversations with the trapped man became national news, earning
him a Pulitzer Prize. The Floyd Collins case represents a
watershed moment in both cave rescue history and disaster media coverage,
(10:51):
explains historian doctor Robert Montgomery. It was one of the
first disasters to be covered in real time by radio,
creating a show shared national experience, and estimated twenty million
people followed the story daily, and the rescue techniques attempted,
though ultimately unsuccessful, form the foundation of modern cave rescue approaches. Tragically,
(11:17):
after rescuers had maintained contact with Collins for several days,
a collapse in the narrow passage cut off direct access
to him. Rescue efforts shifted to digging a shaft from
the surface, but by the time rescuers reached Collins through
this alternate route, eighteen days after he became trapped, he
(11:38):
had died, likely from exposure and starvation. The Collins case
highlights how quickly conditions can change in cave environments, notes Williams.
Passages that seem stable can collapse, Routes that were viable
can become blocked. This dynamism makes both survival and rescue
(11:59):
exponentially more challenging than in many other environments. This dynamism
was on full display in Thailand's tam Luang Cave in
twenty eighteen. As days passed with no sign of the
Wild Boars team and international rescue operation mobilized. Cave divers
from around the world arrived to assist TI Navy seals.
(12:22):
Experts in hydrology worked to understand and manage the water
flows into the cave system. Engineers set up massive pumping
operations to reduce water levels. Geologists analyzed the cave structure
for potential drilling points. The operations scale was unprecedented. More
than ten thousand people participated, including over one hundred divers,
(12:46):
nine hundred police officers, two thousand soldiers and volunteers from
around the world. The effort required draining more than one
billion liters of water from the caves. The complexity of
the tam Luong rescue cannot be overstated, explains cave diving
expert Richard Stanton, one of the British divers who first
(13:09):
reached the trapped group. We were dealing with extremely narrow passages,
near zero visibility due to silt, strong currents in some sections,
and limited dive windows between rainfall periods. Add to that
the psychological challenge of responsibility for children's lives, and it
was easily the most demanding rescue situation most of us
(13:32):
had ever faced. For ten days, as the search continued
with no confirmation the group was alive, families maintained a
vigil outside the cave entrance. Religious leaders conducted ceremonies, volunteers
provided food and support the entire region, and gradually the
world focused on the cave and the missing boys inside.
(13:57):
The Wild Boars were facing their own challenges. Their flashlights
eventually died, leaving them in complete darkness. Their food supplies
a few snacks they'd brought for the short trip, were
quickly exhausted. They had water dripping from the cave ceiling,
but hunger became intense. The mud bank they occupied was small,
(14:17):
forcing them to sit or lie close together. The air
remained breathable, but was humid and cool, creating uncomfortable conditions.
One of the most remarkable aspects of the Wild Boar's
case was the role of leadership and group cohesion. Notes
Doctor Lanier coach Ecapol used his Buddhist training to teach
(14:38):
the boy's meditation techniques that reduced their anxiety and helped
conserve energy. He established conservation protocols, drinking only the clean
water dripping from the cave ceiling, not wasting energy on
unnecessary movement, and crucially, he maintained a sense of group
identity and purpose. This leadership proved critical to the group's
(15:03):
survival during the long days before rescuers arrived. The boys
later reported taking turns digging at the cave walls with rocks,
not because they believed they could dig their way out,
but because it gave them purpose and hope. They discussed
the meals they would eat when rescued, the activities they
(15:25):
would do with their families, future oriented thinking that psychologists
recognize as a powerful coping mechanism. On July second, two
thousand eighteen, ten days after the group became trapped, British
cave divers John Valentine and Richard Stanton finally reached the
mud bank where the wild boars had taken refuge. Valentthin's
(15:48):
head lamp illuminated the darkness, revealing all thirteen members of
the group alive. In video footage that would be seen worldwide,
valentin can be heard saying, how many of you? When
told thirteen, he responds brilliant. The moment of discovery, while joyous,
marked only the beginning of the next challenge. How to
(16:11):
get the boys and their coach out of the cave.
The route to the entrance required diving through several flooded
sections in near zero visibility. None of the boys knew
how to dive, and several couldn't even swim. The tum
lung rescue presented a unique technical challenge, explains Williams. In
(16:31):
most cave rescues, once you locate survivors, extraction follows established protocols,
medical stabilization packaging for transport and movement through the cave system,
But here the only exit route required untrained children to
make complex dives through flooded passages. There was no protocol
(16:51):
for that. Tragically, the rescue's complexity claimed the life of
former Thai Navy seal Samankunan, who died while delivering oxygen
tanks to the cave. His death underscored the operation's extreme
danger even for professionals, and intensified pressure to find a
solution before anticipated monsoon rains could further flood the system.
(17:16):
After considering options including drilling access shafts impossible given the
location and depth, and waiting months for water levels to
naturally recede, unfeasible given dwindling oxygen levels and the boy's condition,
rescuers developed an unprecedented plan. The boys would be given
(17:37):
crash courses in diving basics, then sedated and transported through
the flooded passages by experienced dive partners. The sedation approach
was incredibly controversial, but ultimately necessary, says Australian anaesthesiologist doctor
Richard Harris, who administered the sedatives inside the cave. We
(17:58):
couldn't risk panic underwater in the conditions. The combination of ketamine,
which provide sedation without suppressing breathing, along with axiolytics and
atropine to reduce secretions created a state where the boys
were compliant but maintained protective reflexes. It was far from ideal,
but the alternatives were worse. Over three days, beginning July eighth,
(18:22):
divers brought the boys in their coach out in groups.
Each boy was given a full face diving mask, loosely
bound to prevent panicked movements, and accompanied by two divers,
one in front carrying their air tank, another behind ensuring
the boy remained on the guide rope. The journey involved
diving through passages as narrow as two feet wide, with
(18:45):
zero visibility against currents four stretches up to forty minutes
under water. Remarkably, all thirteen members of the Wild Boars
team were successfully extracted. The last of the boys and
their coach emerged on July tenth, followed by the dive
team and doctor Harris. The final operation to remove all
equipment and personnel was completed just hours before pumps failed
(19:09):
and the cave system fully flooded again. The Tom Lwong
rescue represents the most successful complex cave rescue in history,
notes Williams. It required innovation, international cooperation, acceptance of significant risk,
and integration of multiple specialties from cave diving to anesthesiology.
(19:31):
It established new protocols that will guide future rescues in
similar situations. For the Wild Boores, the physical recovery was
relatively quick. After initial treatment for malnutrition, minor infections, and
pneumonia concerns. All the boys were released from hospital within
a week. The psychological recovery continues longer, with the boys
(19:55):
receiving ongoing support for post traumatic stress and adjustment issue.
What's remarkable about cases like the Wild Boars is how
resilient children often are, notes doctor Laanier. With proper support,
many survivors of extreme experiences like cave entrapment integrate these
(20:16):
events into their life narrative in ultimately positive ways, recognizing
their own strength, appreciating life more deeply, and developing greater compassion.
That doesn't mean the experience wasn't traumatic, but rather that
humans have remarkable capacity to grow through trauma. This capacity
(20:38):
for post traumatic growth appears in many cave survival stories,
though not all have happy endings. Like the Wild Boars,
the deaths of John Jones and Floyd Collins remind us
of the unforgiving nature of underground environments. Yet even in
these tragic cases, there are lessons that have improved safety
(20:59):
for others. After Jones's death, changes were made to how
cave access is managed in many regions. Permits began requiring
more detailed experience information. Warning systems about specific cave dangers
became more explicit. Rescue teams enhanced their confined space extraction
(21:20):
capabilities and equipment. Similarly, the Collins incident led to the
development of the first specialized cave rescue techniques and equipment.
It highlighted the need for cavers to inform others of
their specific plans and expected return times, and it led
to safer development of commercial caves, benefiting countless visitors. Since
(21:46):
every incident, whether successful rescue or tragic outcome, advances our
understanding of both prevention and response, says Williams, the institutional
knowledge in the cave rescue community is built on these experiences,
each one providing lessons that potentially save lives in future incidents.
(22:06):
This institutional knowledge was evident in other significant cave rescues,
like the two thousand and four extraction of six students
and their instructor from Tygart's Cave in Kentucky after flooding
trap them for three days, or the twenty eighteen rescue
of elderly tourists from Bavaria's Reasoning Cave when one suffered
(22:26):
a brain injury over half a mile underground. What unites
most cave entrapment scenarios is the critical importance of specialized
rescue personnel. Williams emphasizes cave rescue requires unique skills that
combine technical rope work, confined space medicine, flood management, and
(22:49):
sometimes dive capabilities. These aren't skills most emergency responders possess.
That's why dedicated cave rescue teams and international cooper operation
are so crucial. This cooperation was exemplified in the Tom
Luang rescue, where Thai Navy seals worked alongside British civilian
(23:11):
cave divers, Australian medical specialists, American military logistics experts, and
volunteers from dozens of countries. No single organization had all
the capabilities needed, but together they achieved what seemed impossible.
For those who survived being trapped underground, the experience often
(23:32):
leaves lasting psychological impacts. Many report a changed relationship with
darkness and confined spaces, either heightened sensitivity or paradoxically reduced
fear through exposure. Time, perception remains altered for some, with
moments of stress seeming to slow to extraordinary detail, and
(23:56):
many develop a deepened appreciation for human connection and after
experiencing its absence. There's something uniquely primitive about the fear
of being trapped underground, reflects doctor l'aneer. It connects to
ancient human fears of burial, of darkness, of separation from
(24:17):
the sky and open spaces. When people survive these experiences,
they often report a heightened awareness of what truly matters
to them, Relationships, simple pleasures, the freedom to move and
breathe freely. For the wild boars, this appreciation was evident
in their first meals after rescue, simple dishes they had
(24:39):
fantasized about in the darkness. It showed in their emotional
reunions with families captured in photos seen worldwide, and it
continues in their ongoing connection as a group bonded by
an experience few others can truly comprehend. The youngest wild
boar Titan express this sentiment simply, I don't take anything
(25:03):
for granted any more. Not food, not light, not being
able to see the sky. These are gifts from the
darkest places on Earth. This perspective emerges repeatedly a reminder
that sometimes, in losing our connection to the surface world,
we discover our deepest connections to what makes us human resilience,
(25:27):
co operation, and the will to return to the light,
no matter how distant it may seem from the darkness below.
This has been a quiet pleased production. Head over to
quiet please dot a I to hear what matters
Episode one, Darkness below Cave Rescue. The absolute darkness is
the first thing they all mention. Not like the darkness
of night, which still contains ambient light from stars, moon
or distant human sources, cave darkness is complete, impenetrable, a
darkness so profound that the human mind, desperate for visual stimulation,
(00:24):
sometimes manufactures its own phantom lights and patterns. In this
perfect blackness, time loses meaning, minutes stretch to seeming hours,
while days can blur together. And when this darkness comes
with confinement, limited air, and no clear path to the surface,
(00:44):
it creates one of the most primal human fears, being
buried alive. On June twenty third, twenty eighteen, twelve boys
from the Wild Boar soccer team and their coach entered
Thaie Land's time Sam Luang Cave system for what was
supposed to be a brief exploration after practice. The caves
(01:07):
were a local attraction, though signs warned against entry during
the rainy season from July to November. June was typically safe,
but that year, an unusually early monsoon changed everything. We
just wanted to explore a bit and celebrate one of
the boy's birthdays. Assistant coach, Icopol Channawong later explained we'd
(01:29):
been in the cave before and only planned to go
in a short distance. As the group ventured deeper into
the winding passages, heavy rain began falling outside. Water following
the path of least resistance, poured into the cave entrance
and began flooding the tunnels behind them. By the time
they realized the danger, their exit was already submerged. Forced
(01:53):
deeper into the cave system, the group eventually found refuge
on a small mud bank approximately two point five miles
from the entrance, in a chamber that was slightly elevated
above the rising water. With their flashlights providing the only light,
the twelve boys, aged eleven to sixteen, and their twenty
five year old coach found themselves in a situation that
(02:16):
would test the limits of human endurance and spawn one
of the most complex rescue operations in history. When we
realized we couldn't go back, I told the boys not
to lose hope, Ecopol recalled. I told them to stay strong,
that help would come, That help would take ten days
to arrive. The psychological impact of being trapped underground as
(02:38):
multifaceted explains doctor Jennifer Lanier, a psychologist specializing in trauma
and extreme environments. There's the immediate stress response fear, increased
heart rate, rapid breathing, but as hours turn to days,
different psychological challenges emerge. Sensory deprivation from concert darkness can
(03:01):
cause disorientation and even hallucinations. Uncertainty about rescue creates anxiety.
Limited space can trigger claustrophobia. The combination can be overwhelming
for the wild boares. Several factors helped mitigate these effects.
The group Dynamic provided social support. Coach Ekopol, who had
(03:25):
spent ten years as a Buddhist monk, taught the boy's
meditation techniques to calm their minds and conserve energy, and critically,
they had found a chamber with breathable air above water level.
Others trapped in cave systems haven't been so fortunate. On
November twenty fourth, two thousand and nine, John Edward Jones
(03:48):
decided to explore Utah's Nutty Putty Cave with his brother Josh.
The cave, named for its narrow, twisting passages that resembled
nutty putty inconsistency, was popular with local spelunkers despite its
challenging terrain. John twenty six, was an experienced caver, but
(04:10):
hadn't been active in the hobby since before his marriage
and the birth of his first child. Around eight forty
five PM, John entered a passage he thought was the
familiar birth canal route. Instead, it was an unexplored passage
that narrowed dramatically. As he inched forward headfirst on his stomach,
(04:32):
the six foot tall, two hundred pound man found himself
in a vertical shaft barely ten inches across at its
narrowest point, narrower than his shoulders. When he tried to inhale,
his chest couldn't fully expand. Attempting to retreat, he found
that gravity in the passage's confines prevented backward movement. John
(04:55):
Jones was stuck completely immobilized in a position that had
him angled head down at approximately seventy degrees. The position
John was trapped in made his situation particularly dangerous, explains
cave rescue specialist Teresa Williams. Being inverted for extended periods
puts extreme stress on the cardiovascular system, blood pools in
(05:18):
the upper body and head. Breathing is restricted, and the
heart must work harder against gravity. Even without other factors
like dehydration or hypothermia, this position alone can become fatal
if prolonged. When John failed to return from that section
of the cave, his brother Josh alerted other cavers, who
(05:41):
called for help. The first rescuers reached John around twelve
thirty am, establishing verbal contact and providing initial support. What
followed was a twenty seven hour rescue attempt involving more
than one hundred people. The technical challenges were or immense.
The passage was so narrow that rescuers had to work
(06:04):
one at a time in shifts. They couldn't bring much
equipment into the tight space. Standard rescue techniques like using
body harnesses weren't feasible in the confined passage. Even communication
was difficult, with rescuers having to relay messages verbally from
the rescue site to the cave entrance. At one point,
(06:26):
rescuers managed to attach a pulley system to John's feet
and lift him about twelve inches, only for the anchoring
to fail, letting him slip back even deeper into the crevice.
This moment, after hours of progress, was devastating for both
John and his rescuers in confined space. Rescues setbacks are
(06:48):
particularly difficult psychologically, noting notes doctor Lanier, the victim experiences
the physical reality of failing to escape, which can trigger
profound hopelessness. Rescuers experience intense frustration and sometimes guilt, even
when the circumstances are beyond their control. The emotional intensity
(07:10):
in these situations is extreme for everyone involved. Throughout his ordeal,
John remained conscious and communicative, though his condition deteriorated as
hours passed. He spoke with rescuers about his wife, Emily,
who was pregnant with their second child. He mentioned his daughter,
(07:31):
who had just celebrated her first birthday. These connections to
the outside world, to a future he desperately wanted to
return to helped sustain his will to survive. After more
than twenty four hours of rescue efforts, with John still
firmly trapped, medical personnel made the devastating assessment that his
(07:54):
vital signs were declining rapidly. Despite being able to communicate
with him, despite being able to touch him and provide
limited support, rescuers were unable to free John from his
Stone prison. At eleven fifty five p m. On November
twenty fifth, two thousand nine, John Edward Jones was pronounced dead.
(08:17):
The Nutty Putty incident represents a particularly painful type of
rescue failure, says Williams. Rescuers could reach the victim, communicate
with him, even touch him, but still couldn't save him.
That creates a special kind of trauma for rescue personnel,
a sense that somehow they should have been able to
do more, even when technically there was nothing more they
(08:40):
could do. After John's death, the decision was made not
to recover his body, as doing so would have required
dangerous expansions of the narrow passage. Instead, the passage was
sealed with concrete, creating a permanent crypt. The entire nuttye
the Putty Cave was closed permanently in twenty fourteen, a
(09:04):
reminder of how unforgiving underground environments can be. This unforgiving
nature of caves has been known throughout human history. Perhaps
the most famous American case of cave entrapment prior to
modern times was that of Floyd Collins, whose nineteen twenty
five ordeal in Kentucky's Sand Cave became one of the
(09:27):
nation's first media sensation disasters. Collins, an experienced cave explorer,
who had discovered the spectacular Crystal Cave on his family's property,
was searching for new cave passages that might rival Kentucky's
Commercial Mammoth Cave. On January thirtieth, nineteen twenty five, while
(09:48):
exploring a narrow passage in sand Cave, a rock shifted
and pinned his leg. He found himself trapped fifty five
feet below ground in a passage so zhe tight that
he couldn't reach the rock that trapped him. When Collins
failed to return, rescue efforts began. The first rescuer to
(10:09):
reach him was a small man named Jule Estes, who
brought Floyd water and food for days. Rescuers maintained contact
with Collins, working to free him while newspaper reporters converged
on the scene. The Louisville Courier Journal sent reporter William
Burke Eskets Miller, who was small enough to squeeze through
(10:30):
the narrow passage, to interview Collins. Miller's first hand accounts
of conversations with the trapped man became national news, earning
him a Pulitzer Prize. The Floyd Collins case represents a
watershed moment in both cave rescue history and disaster media coverage,
(10:51):
explains historian doctor Robert Montgomery. It was one of the
first disasters to be covered in real time by radio,
creating a show shared national experience, and estimated twenty million
people followed the story daily, and the rescue techniques attempted,
though ultimately unsuccessful, form the foundation of modern cave rescue approaches. Tragically,
(11:17):
after rescuers had maintained contact with Collins for several days,
a collapse in the narrow passage cut off direct access
to him. Rescue efforts shifted to digging a shaft from
the surface, but by the time rescuers reached Collins through
this alternate route, eighteen days after he became trapped, he
(11:38):
had died, likely from exposure and starvation. The Collins case
highlights how quickly conditions can change in cave environments, notes Williams.
Passages that seem stable can collapse, Routes that were viable
can become blocked. This dynamism makes both survival and rescue
(11:59):
exponentially more challenging than in many other environments. This dynamism
was on full display in Thailand's tam Luang Cave in
twenty eighteen. As days passed with no sign of the
Wild Boars team and international rescue operation mobilized. Cave divers
from around the world arrived to assist TI Navy seals.
(12:22):
Experts in hydrology worked to understand and manage the water
flows into the cave system. Engineers set up massive pumping
operations to reduce water levels. Geologists analyzed the cave structure
for potential drilling points. The operations scale was unprecedented. More
than ten thousand people participated, including over one hundred divers,
(12:46):
nine hundred police officers, two thousand soldiers and volunteers from
around the world. The effort required draining more than one
billion liters of water from the caves. The complexity of
the tam Luong rescue cannot be overstated, explains cave diving
expert Richard Stanton, one of the British divers who first
(13:09):
reached the trapped group. We were dealing with extremely narrow passages,
near zero visibility due to silt, strong currents in some sections,
and limited dive windows between rainfall periods. Add to that
the psychological challenge of responsibility for children's lives, and it
was easily the most demanding rescue situation most of us
(13:32):
had ever faced. For ten days, as the search continued
with no confirmation the group was alive, families maintained a
vigil outside the cave entrance. Religious leaders conducted ceremonies, volunteers
provided food and support the entire region, and gradually the
world focused on the cave and the missing boys inside.
(13:57):
The Wild Boars were facing their own challenges. Their flashlights
eventually died, leaving them in complete darkness. Their food supplies
a few snacks they'd brought for the short trip, were
quickly exhausted. They had water dripping from the cave ceiling,
but hunger became intense. The mud bank they occupied was small,
(14:17):
forcing them to sit or lie close together. The air
remained breathable, but was humid and cool, creating uncomfortable conditions.
One of the most remarkable aspects of the Wild Boar's
case was the role of leadership and group cohesion. Notes
Doctor Lanier coach Ecapol used his Buddhist training to teach
(14:38):
the boy's meditation techniques that reduced their anxiety and helped
conserve energy. He established conservation protocols, drinking only the clean
water dripping from the cave ceiling, not wasting energy on
unnecessary movement, and crucially, he maintained a sense of group
identity and purpose. This leadership proved critical to the group's
(15:03):
survival during the long days before rescuers arrived. The boys
later reported taking turns digging at the cave walls with rocks,
not because they believed they could dig their way out,
but because it gave them purpose and hope. They discussed
the meals they would eat when rescued, the activities they
(15:25):
would do with their families, future oriented thinking that psychologists
recognize as a powerful coping mechanism. On July second, two
thousand eighteen, ten days after the group became trapped, British
cave divers John Valentine and Richard Stanton finally reached the
mud bank where the wild boars had taken refuge. Valentthin's
(15:48):
head lamp illuminated the darkness, revealing all thirteen members of
the group alive. In video footage that would be seen worldwide,
valentin can be heard saying, how many of you? When
told thirteen, he responds brilliant. The moment of discovery, while joyous,
marked only the beginning of the next challenge. How to
(16:11):
get the boys and their coach out of the cave.
The route to the entrance required diving through several flooded
sections in near zero visibility. None of the boys knew
how to dive, and several couldn't even swim. The tum
lung rescue presented a unique technical challenge, explains Williams. In
(16:31):
most cave rescues, once you locate survivors, extraction follows established protocols,
medical stabilization packaging for transport and movement through the cave system,
But here the only exit route required untrained children to
make complex dives through flooded passages. There was no protocol
(16:51):
for that. Tragically, the rescue's complexity claimed the life of
former Thai Navy seal Samankunan, who died while delivering oxygen
tanks to the cave. His death underscored the operation's extreme
danger even for professionals, and intensified pressure to find a
solution before anticipated monsoon rains could further flood the system.
(17:16):
After considering options including drilling access shafts impossible given the
location and depth, and waiting months for water levels to
naturally recede, unfeasible given dwindling oxygen levels and the boy's condition,
rescuers developed an unprecedented plan. The boys would be given
(17:37):
crash courses in diving basics, then sedated and transported through
the flooded passages by experienced dive partners. The sedation approach
was incredibly controversial, but ultimately necessary, says Australian anaesthesiologist doctor
Richard Harris, who administered the sedatives inside the cave. We
(17:58):
couldn't risk panic underwater in the conditions. The combination of ketamine,
which provide sedation without suppressing breathing, along with axiolytics and
atropine to reduce secretions created a state where the boys
were compliant but maintained protective reflexes. It was far from ideal,
but the alternatives were worse. Over three days, beginning July eighth,
(18:22):
divers brought the boys in their coach out in groups.
Each boy was given a full face diving mask, loosely
bound to prevent panicked movements, and accompanied by two divers,
one in front carrying their air tank, another behind ensuring
the boy remained on the guide rope. The journey involved
diving through passages as narrow as two feet wide, with
(18:45):
zero visibility against currents four stretches up to forty minutes
under water. Remarkably, all thirteen members of the Wild Boars
team were successfully extracted. The last of the boys and
their coach emerged on July tenth, followed by the dive
team and doctor Harris. The final operation to remove all
equipment and personnel was completed just hours before pumps failed
(19:09):
and the cave system fully flooded again. The Tom Lwong
rescue represents the most successful complex cave rescue in history,
notes Williams. It required innovation, international cooperation, acceptance of significant risk,
and integration of multiple specialties from cave diving to anesthesiology.
(19:31):
It established new protocols that will guide future rescues in
similar situations. For the Wild Boores, the physical recovery was
relatively quick. After initial treatment for malnutrition, minor infections, and
pneumonia concerns. All the boys were released from hospital within
a week. The psychological recovery continues longer, with the boys
(19:55):
receiving ongoing support for post traumatic stress and adjustment issue.
What's remarkable about cases like the Wild Boars is how
resilient children often are, notes doctor Laanier. With proper support,
many survivors of extreme experiences like cave entrapment integrate these
(20:16):
events into their life narrative in ultimately positive ways, recognizing
their own strength, appreciating life more deeply, and developing greater compassion.
That doesn't mean the experience wasn't traumatic, but rather that
humans have remarkable capacity to grow through trauma. This capacity
(20:38):
for post traumatic growth appears in many cave survival stories,
though not all have happy endings. Like the Wild Boars,
the deaths of John Jones and Floyd Collins remind us
of the unforgiving nature of underground environments. Yet even in
these tragic cases, there are lessons that have improved safety
(20:59):
for others. After Jones's death, changes were made to how
cave access is managed in many regions. Permits began requiring
more detailed experience information. Warning systems about specific cave dangers
became more explicit. Rescue teams enhanced their confined space extraction
(21:20):
capabilities and equipment. Similarly, the Collins incident led to the
development of the first specialized cave rescue techniques and equipment.
It highlighted the need for cavers to inform others of
their specific plans and expected return times, and it led
to safer development of commercial caves, benefiting countless visitors. Since
(21:46):
every incident, whether successful rescue or tragic outcome, advances our
understanding of both prevention and response, says Williams, the institutional
knowledge in the cave rescue community is built on these experiences,
each one providing lessons that potentially save lives in future incidents.
(22:06):
This institutional knowledge was evident in other significant cave rescues,
like the two thousand and four extraction of six students
and their instructor from Tygart's Cave in Kentucky after flooding
trap them for three days, or the twenty eighteen rescue
of elderly tourists from Bavaria's Reasoning Cave when one suffered
(22:26):
a brain injury over half a mile underground. What unites
most cave entrapment scenarios is the critical importance of specialized
rescue personnel. Williams emphasizes cave rescue requires unique skills that
combine technical rope work, confined space medicine, flood management, and
(22:49):
sometimes dive capabilities. These aren't skills most emergency responders possess.
That's why dedicated cave rescue teams and international cooper operation
are so crucial. This cooperation was exemplified in the Tom
Luang rescue, where Thai Navy seals worked alongside British civilian
(23:11):
cave divers, Australian medical specialists, American military logistics experts, and
volunteers from dozens of countries. No single organization had all
the capabilities needed, but together they achieved what seemed impossible.
For those who survived being trapped underground, the experience often
(23:32):
leaves lasting psychological impacts. Many report a changed relationship with
darkness and confined spaces, either heightened sensitivity or paradoxically reduced
fear through exposure. Time, perception remains altered for some, with
moments of stress seeming to slow to extraordinary detail, and
(23:56):
many develop a deepened appreciation for human connection and after
experiencing its absence. There's something uniquely primitive about the fear
of being trapped underground, reflects doctor l'aneer. It connects to
ancient human fears of burial, of darkness, of separation from
(24:17):
the sky and open spaces. When people survive these experiences,
they often report a heightened awareness of what truly matters
to them, Relationships, simple pleasures, the freedom to move and
breathe freely. For the wild boars, this appreciation was evident
in their first meals after rescue, simple dishes they had
(24:39):
fantasized about in the darkness. It showed in their emotional
reunions with families captured in photos seen worldwide, and it
continues in their ongoing connection as a group bonded by
an experience few others can truly comprehend. The youngest wild
boar Titan express this sentiment simply, I don't take anything
(25:03):
for granted any more. Not food, not light, not being
able to see the sky. These are gifts from the
darkest places on Earth. This perspective emerges repeatedly a reminder
that sometimes, in losing our connection to the surface world,
we discover our deepest connections to what makes us human resilience,
(25:27):
co operation, and the will to return to the light,
no matter how distant it may seem from the darkness below.
This has been a quiet pleased production. Head over to
quiet please dot a I to hear what matters
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
The Bobby Bones Show
Listen to 'The Bobby Bones Show' by downloading the daily full replay.