All Episodes

June 24, 2025 • 17 mins
Unearth the chilling and controversial tale of Alfred Packer, "The Colorado Cannibal," with "Whispers From The Dark." Delve into the brutal winter of 1874 and the desperate choices made in the unforgiving San Juan Mountains. Explore the fine line between survival and savagery in this meticulously researched yet hauntingly told account. #TrueCrime #HistoricalHorror #SurvivalStory #Cannibalism #WildWest #ColoradoHistory #Macabre Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:08):
When the lights go out, they speak the vanished, the cursed,
the crueler. Their echoes live here. I'm Raven Vail, and
you've just crossed the threshold. Welcome to Whispers from the Dark,

(00:33):
Whispers from the Dark, the Ballad of Alfred Packer. Greetings,
Whispers from the Dark Fans. Tonight, we journey back to
a time when the American West was still a vast,
untamed wilderness, a place where the line between civilization and
savagery blurred with terrifying ease. We descend into a tale

(00:57):
of snow choked mountains, desperate hunger, and choices so horrific
they continue to echo through the annals of history. The
Ballad of Alfred Packer. Our story begins in November of
eighteen seventy three in the burgeoning, chaotic mining towns of Utah.
The gold fever was rampant, drawing men from all walks

(01:21):
of life, filled with dreams of instant riches. Among them
was Alfred Packer, a man of modest stature with a
seemingly unassuming demeanor, a quiet disposition that belied the dark notoriety.
He would soon achieve he was a prospector, like so
many others. Drawn by the siren call of gold rumored

(01:45):
to lie hidden deep within the treacherous San Juan Mountains
of Colorado, he joined a party of five others, seasoned
frontiersmen and hopeful fortune seekers, eager to make their way
to the silver rush near Breckenridge. These men were Shannon
Wilson Bell, a wiry, determined drifter, George California Noon, a

(02:10):
gruff experienced miner, Frank Miller, a quiet German immigrant, James Humphreys,
a former soldier, and Israel Swann, the oldest of the group,
a man whose wisdom they hoped would guide them through
the wilderness. Together, they formed a disparate crew, bound by

(02:31):
the common thread of ambition and the unforgiving landscape that
lay ahead. Their journey quickly proved to be far more
arduous than anticipated. Winter, a brutal, unforgiving force in the
high Rockies, descended upon them with a ferocity that defied
their preparations. Early snows, heavy and relentless, buried the passers,

(02:56):
trapping them in a desolate, frozen expanse. Supplies dwindled at
an alarming rate. Game became scarce, driven into hiding by
the deepening snow drifts, desperation a cold, insidious beast began
to gnaw at their heels. By February of eighteen seventy four,

(03:17):
the party was utterly lost, Starving and rapidly losing hope.
They stumbled upon a ute Indian encampment led by the
sagacious Chief Oure. The chief, sensing the men's peril, warned
them against continuing their journey through the impassable snows. He

(03:37):
offered them shelter, food, and the wisdom of his people,
urging them to wait until spring. It was an act
of profound generosity, a life line extended in the face
of certain death. Four of the six men, recognizing the
wisdom in Chief Ourey's words, chose to heed his advice,

(04:00):
opting to remain with the ute. But Alfred Packer, driven
by a stubborn, almost obsessive need to reach the mines,
convinced the remaining five bell Noon Miller Humphrey's and Swan
to press on against Chief Aurey's fervent warnings, against the

(04:21):
very instincts of survival, they departed the warmth and relative
safety of the Ute camp, plunging back into the heart
of the frozen wilderness. It was a decision that would
seal their fate and etch Packer's name into infamy. What
transpired next in those snow choked mountains remains shrouded in

(04:44):
horror and conflicting accounts, but the stark facts speak for themselves.
Sixty five days later, in April of eighteen seventy four,
Alfred Packer emerged from the wilderness alone. He was immazed, heated,
frost bitten and gaunt, yet undeniably alive and unsettlingly, he

(05:07):
had money in his pockets, money that belonged to the
men who had vanished. His initial story was one of
incredible resilience. He claimed that, after being stranded by a blizzard,
his companions had perished one by one from starvation and exposure. He,
the sole survivor, had somehow endured the unforgiving elements. But doubts,

(05:33):
cold and sharp as the mountain air, began to circle
the money, his relatively better condition compared to what a
truly starved survivor might exhibit, and the vague evasive nature
of his answers all raised suspicion. As spring thawed the snows,

(05:54):
revealing the desolate landscape, the horrifying truth began to emerge.
Search parties, spurred by growing suspicions, eventually discovered a scene
of unspeakable horror near the head waters of the lake
fork of the Gunnison River. Five mutilated bodies scattered amidst

(06:15):
a crude camp. Their flesh stripped from their bones lay
a stark testament to the unimaginable. It was clear these
men had not merely succumbed to starvation. They had been butchered.
Packard was immediately questioned. Under intense scrutiny, his story crumbled,

(06:37):
he confessed, or rather offered a series of shifting, self
serving narratives. His final and most widely accepted confession painted
a grim picture. He claimed that after weeks of starvation,
the group had resorted to cannibalism, consuming the flesh of Swan,

(06:58):
who had died first from exposure. Then, a heated argument
had erupted between Bell and Humphreys over a piece of meat. Bell,
driven mad by hunger, had attacked Humphreys with a hatchet,
killing him. Packer, in a moment of self preservation or
perhaps sheer terror, claimed he shot and killed Bell in

(07:23):
self defense. He then, by his own admission, butchered and
consumed the remaining bodies to survive. The public reaction was
one of revulsion and outrage. Alfred Packer became a symbol
of the ultimate taboo, the Colorado cannibal. His trial, held

(07:43):
in Lake City, Colorado, was a sensation, drawing national attention.
The prosecution painted him as a cold blooded murderer, a
man who had systematically killed his companions for their meager possessions,
then consumed their flesh to conceal his crimes. The defense
argued extreme duress, the unforgiving conditions of the wilderness, and

(08:07):
the madness induced by starvation. The evidence, however, was damning.
The state of the bodies, the nature of their wounds,
and Packer's shifting accounts all pointed to a more sinister
truth than simple survival. The tools found at the scene,

(08:27):
the lack of definitive defensive wounds on the victims, and
the precise, almost surgical removal of flesh suggested a methodical
approach rather than a desperate, chaotic act of self preservation
in the heat of a moment. On April thirteen, eighteen
eighty three, after years of legal wrangling and appeals, Alfred

(08:51):
Packer was convicted of the premeditated murder of Shannon Wilson
Bell and sentenced to death by hanging. The judge, in
his pronouncement, famously declared there were only six Democrats in
Hinsdale County, and you, you son of a bitch, eight
five of them. While the political jab was likely apocryphal,

(09:16):
it perfectly captured the public's indignant fury. However, a technicality
in the law led to his sentence being overturned. He
was later retried and convicted of manslaughter, receiving a much
lighter sentence of forty years in prison. He served eighteen years,
mostly in the Colorado State Penitentiary in Canyon City, before

(09:40):
being paroled in nineteen o one. Alfred Packer spent his
remaining years living a quiet, almost reclusive life in Littleton, Colorado,
working as a guard at the Denver Post and a
prospector in the area. A shadow of his former notorious self,
he died of complete caations from Bright's disease in nineteen

(10:02):
o seven and was buried in the Littleton Cemetery. His
gravestone simply marked Alfred Packer, but the ballad of Alfred
Packer continues to haunt the American imagination. Was he a
cold blooded killer who used the wilderness as his hunting ground,

(10:22):
or a desperate man pushed to the limits of human endurance,
forced to commit unspeakable acts to survive. The historical record,
while leaning heavily towards the former, leaves just enough ambiguity
to fuel endless debate. The story of Alfred Packer serves

(10:44):
as a chilling reminder of the raw, untamed nature of
the American Frontier, a time when civilizations veneer was thin
and the primal instincts of survival could drive men to
the most horrific acts imaginable. It's a tale of human desperation,

(11:06):
the unforgiving power of nature, and the dark, hidden corners
of the human soul. The sheer brutality of the events
in the San Juan Mountains that winter still holds a
morbid fascination. Consider the isolation, miles from any established settlement,

(11:27):
surrounded by a landscape that actively fought against their survival.
Each foot of snow was a barrier, each biting wind
a threat. These were not men trained for arctic expeditions,
but prospectors driven by a dream that, for Packer and
his companions turned into a nightmare. The psychological toll of

(11:52):
such conditions, the slow, agonizing descent into true starvation, is
almost impossible for us to fully comprehend to time what
happens to the human mind when it is stripped of
all comfort, all hope, all societal norms. This is the fertile,
terrifying ground where the legend of Alfred Packer takes root.

(12:15):
The legal proceedings themselves became a circus fueled by public
disgust and a desire for justice or perhaps vengeance. The
image of the cannibal was a powerful one, evoking primeval fears.
Yet even amidst the clamour, there were those who wondered

(12:36):
about the full story, about the pressures that might drive
a person to such extremes. Packer's repeated changes to his confession,
while suspicious, also hint at a mind struggling to reconcile
horrific actions with some semblance of self preservation. Was he
trying to craft a narrative that would save him or

(12:59):
one that would allow him to live with what he
had done. Even his parole in nineteen o one was controversial,
sparking renewed outrage for many. His crimes were unforgivable, a
stain on humanity itself. Yet he lived out his days
relatively peacefully, a quiet man marked by an unspeakable past.

(13:25):
Did he find any measure of peace? Did the ghosts
of the San Juan Mountains ever truly leave him? We
can only speculate. The story of Alfred Packer isn't just
about a man who committed a monstrous act. It's about
the very edges of human experience. It forces us to
confront uncomfortable questions about our own limits, about what we

(13:49):
might do when faced with the absolute abyss of survival.
It's a stark reflection on the fragility of civilization when
pitted against the raw or power of nature and the
most primal of human needs. And it reminds us that
some horrors are not supernatural, but are born from the cold,

(14:12):
hard realities of the world and the desperate choices made
within them. This narrative, Chilling as it is, serves as
a crucial historical marker, illustrating the stark realities of life
on the American frontier. It underscores the immense risks taken
by those who sought fortune in untamed lands and the

(14:36):
extreme measures individuals could resort to when confronted with the raw,
brutal indifference of nature. It's a testament to how quickly
the veneer of civilization can peel away under the right,
or rather the wrong conditions. The Packer case wasn't just
a local scandal. It became a cautionary tale, whispered around

(15:00):
camp fires and recounted in newspapers across the young nation,
a dark mirror reflecting the deepest fears of a society
grappling with its own expansion into the wild unknown. The
psychological landscape of Packer's mind, particularly during those harrowing weeks
in the mountains, remains a subject of intense speculation. Was

(15:26):
it pure malice or a complete breakdown of sanity under
unimaginable duress. The fragmented accounts, filtered through Packer's self preservation
instincts and the sensationalism of the press make a definitive
psychological profile nearly impossible. This ambiguity is precisely what gives

(15:49):
the tale its enduring power, allowing generations to project their
own fears and interpretations onto the Colorado Cannibal. He exists
as a figure of both historical fact and chilling folklore,
forever bound to the desolate, snow capped peaks where his

(16:10):
grim story unfolded. And so as we close this chapter,
we leave you with the echoes of the San Juan
Mountains and the haunting question that still lingers what truly
happened during those sixty five days of desperate winter? And
join us again upon Whispers from the Dark, as we

(16:32):
continue to explore the unsettling truths and terrifying legends that
lurk just beneath the surface of our world. Until then,
remember the shadows that walk among us and the whispers
that cling to the wild places. The Ante inter Printing

(17:02):
interpret the Internet
Advertise With Us

Popular Podcasts

Stuff You Should Know
Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC

Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

New Heights with Jason & Travis Kelce

New Heights with Jason & Travis Kelce

Football’s funniest family duo — Jason Kelce of the Philadelphia Eagles and Travis Kelce of the Kansas City Chiefs — team up to provide next-level access to life in the league as it unfolds. The two brothers and Super Bowl champions drop weekly insights about the weekly slate of games and share their INSIDE perspectives on trending NFL news and sports headlines. They also endlessly rag on each other as brothers do, chat the latest in pop culture and welcome some very popular and well-known friends to chat with them. Check out new episodes every Wednesday. Follow New Heights on the Wondery App, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to new episodes early and ad-free, and get exclusive content on Wondery+. Join Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. And join our new membership for a unique fan experience by going to the New Heights YouTube channel now!

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.