20. The Imperial Transition - From Persecution to Power

When Constantine saw his vision at the Milvian Bridge in 312 CE, the papacy stood at history's hinge. This episode examines how Popes Miltiades and Silvester navigated Christianity's sudden transformation from persecuted sect to imperial partner. Physical spaces evolved from hidden house churches to magnificent basilicas, while papal authority adapted to unprecedented imperial favor. The revolutionary changes of this period created both opportunities and compromises that would shape the institution for centuries to come.

To become a premium subscriber (no ads and no feed drops) visit caloroga.com/plus.   For Apple users, hit the banner on your Apple podcasts app which seays UNINTERRUPTED LISTENING. For Spotify or other players, visit caloroga.com/plus. You also get 25+ other shows on the network ad-free! 


Unlock an ad-free podcast experience with Caloroga Shark Media! Get all our shows on any player you love, hassle free! For Apple users, hit the banner on your Apple podcasts app. For Spotify or other players, visit caloroga.com/plus. No plug-ins needed!

Subscribe now for exclusive shows like 'Palace Intrigue,' and get bonus content from Deep Crown (our exclusive Palace Insider!) Or get 'Daily Comedy News,' and '5 Good News Stories’ with no commercials! Plans start at $4.99 per month, or save 20% with a yearly plan at $49.99. Join today and help support the show!

We now have Merch!  FREE SHIPPING! Check out all the products like T-shirts, mugs, bags, jackets and more with logos and slogans from your favorite shows! Did we mention there’s free shipping? Get 10% off with code NewMerch10 Go to Caloroga.com

Get more info from Caloroga Shark Media and if you have any comments, suggestions, or just want to get in touch our email is [e-mail]

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:03):
Caalaroga Shark media. On October twenty eighth, three hundred twelve CE,
two armies faced each other at the Milvian Bridge outside Rome.
The outcome would determine not just who would rule the
Roman Empire, but would fundamentally transform the papacy from a

(00:26):
persecuted underground institution into an imperial partner. According to later accounts, Constantine,
before the battle, saw a vision in the sky across
with the words in this sign conquer his victory. The
following day began Christianity's transition from outlawed sect to state religion.

(00:49):
For Pope Miltiades, who had known only a life of
secrecy and persecution, this sudden imperial favor presented unprecedented opportunities
and challenges. Within months, he would receive imperial property for
the church's use and preside over a council in the
Emperor's Palace. The papacy, for nearly three centuries, a marginal

(01:11):
institution leading a minority faith, abruptly found itself with access
to power, wealth, and influence beyond its predecessor's imagination. Today,
we examine the Papacy's initial transformation from the catacombs to
Constantine's court, we explore how the first post persecution popes

(01:32):
navigated their new relationship with imperial power, and how church
structures evolved from hidden house churches to grand public basilicas.
This is the story of the papal revolution that fundamentally
redefined the office for all subsequent history. This is White

(01:54):
Smoke Episode twenty. The Imperial Transition. Pope Miltiades straddled Christianity's
underground and imperial periods. Elected shortly after Emperor Galerius issued
an edict grudgingly tolerating Christianity, Miltiades experienced both persecution's final

(02:15):
phase and Constantine's unexpected patronage. Constantine's victory over rival Maxentius
in three hundred twelve CE fundamentally altered the political landscape.
The new emperor quickly demonstrated favour toward Christianity, returning confiscated
properties and granting new privileges. In three hundred thirteen, Constantine

(02:39):
and his eastern colleague Licinius issued the famous Edict of Milan,
establishing full legal tolerance for Christianity throughout the Empire. For Miltiades,
this sudden shift from persecution to imperial favour required delicate
navigation while welcoming legal protection and returned properties. He needed

(02:59):
to maintain the church's internal integrity and independence. The Roman
Church had developed its theology, structures, and leadership without state support,
indeed under state opposition. Integrating imperial favour without compromising essential
identity posed significant challenges. Miltiades represents a crucial transitional figure,

(03:23):
explains Dr. H. A. Drake, professor of Roman History at
the University of California, Santa Barbara. Having experienced persecution himself,
he suddenly needed to develop protocols for interacting with an
emperor who presented himself as Christianity's protector. There was no
precedent for this relationship. This new relationship became visible when

(03:45):
Constantine asked Miltiades to convene a council at the Lateran
Palace in three hundred thirteen CE to address a chism
among North African Christians, the d an Artist controversy. This
meeting marked the first time a pope presided over ac
council in an imperial setting, establishing a pattern that would
fundamentally reshape ecclesiastical governance. When Sylvester succeeded Miltiades, the partnership

(04:10):
between papacy and empire deepened further. Constantine granted the Lateran
Palace itself to the Church as a papal residence, and
funded construction of major basilicas in Rome, including Saint Peter's
on the Vatican Hill and Saint John Lateran. These massive
structures physically embodied Christianity's new public status and imperial connection. Paradoxically,

(04:35):
Sylvester himself remains a somewhat shadowy historical figure. Despite presiding
over this revolutionary period. He did not attend the pivotal
Council of Nicia in three hundred twenty five CE, instead
sending representatives. This absence from history's most famous church council
contrasts sharply with later legendary accounts that vastly exaggerated his

(04:57):
relationship with Constantine. The historical Sylvester was overshadowed by Constantine
during his lifetime and then by legendary embellishment after his death,
notes doctor Julia Hilner, Professor of Medieval History at the
University of Sheffield. The famous Donation of Constantine a medieval
forgery claiming Constantine granted the pope authority over the Western

(05:21):
Empire projected back onto Sylvester, a political power he never
actually possessed. The actual relationship was more complex. Constantine valued
Christianity primarily as a unifying force for his empire and
expected bishops, including the Pope, to promote this unity. When
doctrinal disputes threatened this unity, Constantine intervened directly, sometimes by

(05:47):
passing or overruling episcopal authority. The Emperor, not the Pope,
convened the Council of Nicia and heavily influenced its proceedings.
For Sylvester and his immediate successors, the challenge was maintaining
ecclesiastical independence while benefiting from imperial patronage. The papacy gained

(06:07):
unprecedented resources and legal protection, but risked becoming subordinate to
imperial priorities rather than maintaining its distinctive spiritual mission. The
Constantinian Revolution transformed not just the papacy's political situation, but
its physical environment. Archaeological evidence reveals a dramatic shift from

(06:27):
the pre Constantinian period, when Christians gathered primarily in adapted
domestic spaces, to the post three point thirteen construction of
monumental basilicas specifically designed for Christian worship. Recent excavations beneath
churches like San Clemente and Santi Giovanni Epaullo in Rome
reveal this architectural transition. Lower levels show typical house church adaptations,

(06:54):
residential spaces modified with wool removals to create larger gathering areas,
decorative elements adding Christian symbols to otherwise typical Roman houses.
Upper levels demonstrate the completely new basilica form that emerged
under Constantine, massive public buildings with standardized layouts optimized for
liturgical functions. This architectural revolution represents more than just increased resources,

(07:20):
explains doctor Nicola Denzi Lewis, Professor of Religious Studies at
Claremont Graduate University. It embodies a fundamental reconception of Christian
worship itself, from intimate gatherings in domestic settings to grand
public ceremonies in monumental spaces. This transition profoundly altered how
ordinary Christians experience their faith and how the clergy, especially bishops,

(07:45):
performed their roles. The new papal basilicus Saint Peters, Saint
John Lateran, Saint Paul outside the Walls, and Santa Maria Majore,
though the latter was built slightly later, establish bish to
monumental sacred geography for Christian Rome that effectively displaced the
traditional pagan sacred sites. The pope, previously leading a marginal

(08:09):
religious community from borrowed or adapted spaces, now presided over
the empire's most magnificent religious buildings. This material revolution extended
beyond architecture to liturgical objects, vestments, and ceremonial practices. Pre
Constantinian Christian worship employed relatively simple implements, often repurposed domestic items.

(08:33):
Post Constantinian churches featured elaborate gold and silver liturgical vessels,
richly embroidered vestments, and ceremonial elements adapted from Imperial court rituals.
Papal tombs similarly reflect this transition. Early popes were buried
in relatively simple graves in community cemeteries later developed into catacombs.

(08:55):
Constantine's construction of Saint Peter's Basilica over the apostles traditional
burial site established a new pattern of monumental commemorative architecture
that subsequent popes would adopt for themselves. The material transition
from catacombs to basilicus created a new kind of papal
presence notes Docota Kate Cooper. Previously, the pope's authority was

(09:18):
primarily personal and moral. Now it became increasingly ceremonial and institutional,
embodied in grand structures and elaborate rituals that paralleled imperial practices.
For ordinary Christians, this transition created both opportunities and challenges.
The new public basilicus enabled larger gatherings and more elaborate liturgies,

(09:40):
but potentially reduced the intimate community experience of house churches.
Christianity became more visible and accessible, but also more formally
structured and hierarchical. Constantine's favor fundamentally altered Christianity's social position,
transforming it from a marginalized occasionally persecuted by not into

(10:00):
an increasingly privileged religion. This transition profoundly affected the papacy's composition,
relationship to society, and internal understanding. Pre Constantinian popes typically
came from relatively modest social backgrounds, often with connections to
trade or commerce, rather than the senatorial aristocracy. The underground church,

(10:23):
while including some wealthy members, primarily drew from middle and
lower social strata. Leadership selection emphasized spiritual qualities and community
respect rather than social status or political connections. Post Constantinian
popes increasingly came from more elite backgrounds as Christianity spread
among the upper classes and church positions became more socially prestigious.

(10:48):
By the late fourth century, many clergy came from senatorial families,
bringing aristocratic values and administrative experience, but potentially reducing the
social diversity of church leadership. This social transformation created both
opportunities and tensions, explains doctor Kate Blair Dixon, historian at
the University of Pennsylvania. The church gained educated leadership familiar

(11:13):
with imperial administration, but risked adopting the very status hierarchies
that early Christianity had often challenged. Bishops, including popes, increasingly
resembled secular officials in their lifestyle, education, and social connections.
This social shift manifested in changing language about church leadership.

(11:34):
Pre Constantinian texts typically described bishops, including the pope, as shepherds, servants,
or elders, emphasizing spiritual care and community guidance. Post Constantinian
language increasingly employed terms like ruler, rector, and governor gubernata,
drawing parallels between ecclesiastical and secular authority. For the papacy. Specifically,

(11:59):
this his transition enabled new forms of cultural production and influence.
Pope Damesas sponsored Jerome's creation of the Latin Vulgate Bible translation,
commissioned elaborate inscriptions for Martyr's tombs, and patronized church construction
and decoration. These activities paralleled traditional aristocratic patronage while directing

(12:21):
it toward distinctively Christian purposes. Damasus exemplifies the new papal
engagement with elite cultural forms. Notes doctor Dennis Trout, Professor
of classical Studies at the University of Missouri. His elegant
Latin inscriptions for Martyr's shrines created a distinctively Christian cultural
program using classical literary techniques. He simultaneously claimed Christian distinctiveness

(12:47):
and demonstrated the Faith's capacity to appropriate and transform classical culture.
This cultural engagement extended to the development of more elaborate
liturgical practices and ceremonial elements that paralleled Imperial court rituals. Processions,
specialized vestments, formal protocols for approaching the pope, and designated

(13:10):
seating hierarchies. All reflected secular administrative practices adapted for ecclesiastical contexts.
These changes generated internal tensions, with some Christians concerned that
the Church was losing its countercultural witness through accommodation to
imperial society. Monastic movements partly emerged as reactions against this

(13:32):
perceived compromise, with desert monks and later urban monastics seeking
to maintain Christianity's prophetic edge amidst its newfound privilege for
the papacy, Navigating these tensions required balancing institutional growth with
spiritual authenticity, imperial partnership with prophetic independence, and cultural engagement

(13:53):
with distinctive Christian witness. Different popes struck this balance differently,
creating ongoing in eternal debates about the proper relationship between
Church and society that continued to resonate in contemporary discussions.
The papacy that emerged in the immediate post Constantine period

(14:16):
demonstrated remarkable institutional adaptability. Figures like Miltiades and Silvester successfully
navigated the transition from persecution to privilege without abandoning essential
Christian principles or traditions. They accepted imperial benefits while maintaining
sufficient independence to prevent the Church from becoming merely a

(14:37):
department of state. Their legacy established patterns that would define
papal development for centuries to come. They created precedents for
church state cooperation that would influence medieval political theology. They
established architectural and ceremonial models that would shape Catholic worship
into modern times. They began the process of integrating crit

(15:00):
ust theology with Roman administrative structures that would eventually produce
the sophisticated canonical system of the medieval Church. Yet their
papacies also revealed tensions and vulnerabilities that would persist throughout
subsequent history. The dependence on imperial favour made the Church
potentially subject to political manipulation. The adoption of elite cultural

(15:23):
forms risked alienation from ordinary believers. The accumulation of property
and prestige created temptations toward worldliness that contradicted Christian teachings
about simplicity and service. These first imperial popes thus established
not just a new institutional reality, but a series of
fundamental questions about the Church's proper relationship to power, culture,

(15:47):
and society that subsequent popes would continue to navigate. Their
revolutionary transformation of the papacy from marginal to central, from
persecuted to privileged create both opportunities and challenges that continue
to shape the institution to the present day. In our
next episode, we'll examine how the theological controversies of the

(16:11):
fourth century, particularly the Aryan Crisis, further shaped papal authority,
and how figures like Pope Damasus the First consolidated and
expanded the Papal revolution begun under Constantine. White Smoke is
a production of Calaroga Shark media, portions of which were
made with the help of a narration