23. Monks and Missionaries - The Papacy's Expansion North

From Rome's ancient center, a new papal strategy emerges through monastic missionaries dispatched to Europe's pagan frontiers. This episode follows how Pope Gregory the Great's vision of northern evangelization, tensions between Irish and Roman Christian models, and Boniface's systematic organization of Germanic churches fundamentally reoriented papal priorities. The culminating alliance with the Franks, marked by Pope Stephen II's historic Alpine crossing, transformed the papacy from Mediterranean institution to a power increasingly looking north for its future.


To become a premium subscriber (no ads and no feed drops) visit caloroga.com/plus.   For Apple users, hit the banner on your Apple podcasts app which seays UNINTERRUPTED LISTENING. For Spotify or other players, visit caloroga.com/plus. You also get 25+ other shows on the network ad-free!   


Thanks to our sponsor  https://www.booksamillion.com/p/Happiness-Experiment/Carl-B-Barney/9798886452891

Unlock an ad-free podcast experience with Caloroga Shark Media! Get all our shows on any player you love, hassle free! For Apple users, hit the banner on your Apple podcasts app. For Spotify or other players, visit caloroga.com/plus. No plug-ins needed!

Subscribe now for exclusive shows like 'Palace Intrigue,' and get bonus content from Deep Crown (our exclusive Palace Insider!) Or get 'Daily Comedy News,' and '5 Good News Stories’ with no commercials! Plans start at $4.99 per month, or save 20% with a yearly plan at $49.99. Join today and help support the show!

We now have Merch!  FREE SHIPPING! Check out all the products like T-shirts, mugs, bags, jackets and more with logos and slogans from your favorite shows! Did we mention there’s free shipping? Get 10% off with code NewMerch10 Go to Caloroga.com

Get more info from Caloroga Shark Media and if you have any comments, suggestions, or just want to get in touch our email is [e-mail]

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:03):
Calarogu Shark media. In the year five hundred ninety six CE,
a small band of forty monks departed from Rome, venturing
north toward the far edges of the known world, Led
by Augustine of Canterbury. These missionaries had been dispatched by

(00:24):
Pope Gregory the Great to convert the Anglo Saxon kingdoms
of Britain, regions that had largely reverted to paganism after
the Roman withdrawal a century and a half earlier. This
journey represented more than mere religious zeal. It marked a
fundamental strategic shift in how the papacy conceived of its
authority and mission in the post Roman world. While earlier

(00:48):
popes had focused primarily on maintaining ecclesiastical structures within former
imperial territories, Gregory recognized that the papacy's future might lie
beyond those traditional boundaries. By directly commissioning missionaries rather than
working through established metropolitan sees, he created direct relationships between
Rome and newly converted regions, relationships unmediated by the declining

(01:14):
administrative structures of the post Roman Church. Today, we examine
how the papacy's missionary strategy fundamentally transformed the institution between
the sixth and eighth centuries. We explore how monastic networks
became the primary vehicle for papal expansion, how political alliances
with northern kingdoms reshaped papal priorities, and how Roman centralization

(01:38):
gradually replicated itself in regions never governed by the Empire.
This is the story of how monks and missionaries took
the papacy North. This is White Smoke, Episode twenty three.
Monks and Missionaries. Pope Gregory, the only pope alongside Leo,

(02:04):
the first to receive the traditional title the Great, fundamentally
reimagined papal authority for the post Roman world. A former
monk himself and deeply influenced by Benedictine monasticism, Gregory recognized
that the church's future required new organizational approaches distinct from
the declining Late Roman administrative framework. Gregory's genius lay in

(02:27):
recognizing that monasteries could serve as stable institutional anchors in
an increasingly unstable world, explains doctor Conrad Leser, Associate Professor
of Medieval History at the University of Oxford. Unlike traditional
episcopal structures dependent on urban centres and Roman administrative patterns.
Monastic communities could establish themselves in rural areas, maintain internal

(02:52):
discipline amid external chaos, and serve as centres for both
spiritual practice and practical education. Gregory's missionary strategy leveraged these
monastic strengths. When he dispatched Augustine to Britain, he wasn't
merely sending individual evangelists, but establishing a monastic beachhead that
could generate sustained institutional presence. Augustine's community, established at Canterbury

(03:18):
with King Ethelbert's permission, became precisely such an anchor, a
center from which gradual conversion could proceed through both example
and active evangelization. This approach reflected Gregory's practical administrative experience
before becoming pope. He had served as papal representative in
Constantinople and as a civil administrator in Rome itself. He

(03:41):
understood that effective governance required not just theoretical authority, but
functional institutional structures. His missionary strategy aimed to establish such
structures in regions where traditional Roman frameworks had either collapsed
or never existed. Gregory's missionary revision combined spiritual and practical dimensions.

(04:03):
Notes doctor Carol Straw, Professor Emerita of History at Mount
Holyoak College. His famous instructions to Augustine about accommodating local
customs when appropriate, preserved in Bede's Ecclesiastical History, reveal sophisticated
understanding of cross cultural evangelization. Yet he insisted on maintaining

(04:24):
direct connection to Rome through regular communication, episcopal consecration requirements,
and liturgical standardization. This combination of flexibility in methods with
consistency in institutional connection established a pattern that would characterize
papal missionary efforts for centuries. Local adaptation in pastoral approaches,

(04:46):
coupled with Roman centralization in governance and doctrine, created a
distinctive model for expanding papal influence beyond former imperial boundaries.
As Roman missionaries moved northward, they encountered a different Christian
trade addition, already established in parts of Northern Europe, Irish monasticism.
Irish monks had been conducting their own missionary activities across

(05:08):
Britain and the continent, establishing monasteries at Iona, Lindis, Farn
Lux Sui, and Saint Gaul. These Irish foundations operated with
significant independence from Rome. Maintaining distinct liturgical practices, monastic rules,
and ecclesiastical structures. This Irish model offered an alternative approach

(05:30):
to Christian expansion, one emphasizing monastic networks over episcopal hierarchies,
personal spiritual authority over institutional position, and regional diversity over
Roman standardization. The resulting tension between Irish and Roman missionary
patterns would shape Northern Christianity for generations. The Irish model

(05:51):
presented both challenge and opportunity for papal authority, explains doctor
Charles Edwards, Professor Emeritus of Celtic History at Oxford University.
Irish monasticism's independence threatened Roman centralization, yet its ascetic rigor,
intellectual achievements, and missionary zeal offered valuable resources if they

(06:11):
could be integrated into papal frameworks. The Synod of Whitby
in six hundred sixty four CE represented a pivotal moment
in this integration process. King Osweu of Northumbria, whose kingdom
contained both Roman affiliated and Irish affiliated monasteries, convened church

(06:31):
leaders to resolve differences over calculating the date of Easter
and other practices. The Synod's decision to follow Roman rather
than Irish dating methods represented a significant victory for papal
authority in Britain. Whitby wasn't simply about liturgical calendars, notes
doctor Sarah Foot, Regius Professor of Ecclesiastical History at Oxford.

(06:55):
It determined which institutional model would prevail in Northern Europe,
the decentralized Nus network of Irish monasticism or the hierarchical
structure centered on Rome. While both traditions continued to influence
Northern Christianity, Whitby established Roman primacy as the organizational principle.
This formal acknowledgment of Roman authority enabled integration of Irish

(07:18):
monasticism strengths into papal frameworks. Subsequent missionaries from Britain to
the continent, like Willibroud and Boniface, combined Irish ascetic traditions
and missionary techniques with explicit papal authorization and institutional loyalty,
creating a synthesis that proved remarkably effective for Northern evangelization.

(07:39):
If Gregory provided the vision for papal missionary expansion and
the Synod of Whitby secured its theoretical acceptance, Boniface created
the practical organizational structure that would institutionalize Roman authority across
Northern Europe. This Anglo Saxon monk became Rome's most effective
missionary architect through a remarkable career spanning more than three decades.

(08:03):
Unlike earlier missionaries who operated with general papal blessing but
significant local autonomy, Boniface established direct formal relationships with multiple popes.
In seven nineteen, he traveled to Rome to receive explicit
authorisation from Pope Gregory the Second for his missionary work.
This papal commission provided both spiritual legitimacy and institutional protection

(08:27):
for Boniface's activities in Germanic territories. Boniface's approach represented a
new level of papal missionary integration, explains doctor James Palmer,
Professor of medieval History at the University of Saint Andrew's.
He regularly corresponded with Rome, requesting guidance on practical problems
and theological questions. He returned to Rome multiple times to

(08:51):
report directly to successive popes. He explicitly structured his mission
as an extension of papal authority rather than a personal
or monastic anasative. This systematic coordination bore fruit in Germanic territories,
where Boniface worked for decades. He established or reformed bishoprics
according to Roman models, convened synods to implement Roman practices,

(09:14):
founded monasteries following the Benedictine rule favoured in Rome, and
suppressed practices Rome considered unorthodox or inappropriate. His famous felling
of the Sacred Oak at Geismer symbolized not just confrontation
with paganism, but assertion of Roman Christian authority over local
religious traditions. Boniface's organizational work culminated in the reform of

(09:38):
the Frankish Church under the protection of Peep and the Short,
Mayor of the Palace and father of Charlemagne. With papal
authorization and Frankish political support, Boniface reorganized the Frankish ecclesiastical structure,
replaced problematic bishops, established clear hierarchical relationships, and imposed Roman
liturgical practices. This transformation created the ecclesiastical framework that would

(10:04):
later support the Carolingian Renaissance. Boniface effectively translated papal theory
into functional structure. Notes Dr Michael Winterbottom, Emeritus Fellow at
Worcester College, Oxford. His reforms implemented in practice what earlier
popes had claimed in principle, Rome's authority to organize, correct
and govern churches throughout Western Christianity, regardless of political boundaries.

(10:28):
This practical institutionalization of papal primacy would survive Boniface himself
and shape European Christianity for centuries. Boniface's martyrdom in seven
hundred fifty four CE, killed while attempting to convert Pagan's
in Frisia, only enhanced his legacy. His remains, brought to
his foundation at Fulda became a pilgrimage site that further

(10:51):
connected Germanic Christianity to Roman authority. His numerous letters preserved
by his followers provided practical temper pts for implementing Roman
ecclesiastical governance in non Roman cultural contexts. As papal missionary
activity expanded northward, the papacy's political orientation shifted correspondingly. Where

(11:13):
earlier popes had maintained primary political relationships with Constantinople and
local Italian powers, by the eighth century, Rome increasingly looked
to the Frankish Kingdom as its principal secular partner. This
reorientation reflected practical realities. The Byzantine Empire, though still technically
sovereign over Rome until the mid eighth century, had grown

(11:36):
increasingly distant both geographically and culturally. Imperial armies no longer
effectively protected Rome from Lombard pressure. Theological disputes, particularly the
Iconoclast controversy under Emperor Leo the Third, strained ecclesiastical relationships. Meanwhile,
the expanding Frankish Kingdom, officially Catholic since Clovis's conversion around

(11:58):
five hundred CE and recently reformed under Boniface's guidance, offered
potential military protection and political support. The pivotal moment in
this realignment came in seven hundred fifty one CE, when
Pope Zachary gave his blessing to Pipa, the short steposition
of the last mayor of Indian king and assumption of

(12:19):
the Frankish crown. This papal sanction of dynastic change established
a pattern of mutual legitimation. Papal authority sanctified Frankish political power,
while Frankish military strength protected papal interests. This arrangement fundamentally
altered the papacy's geopolitical position, explains Dr Thomas F. X, Noble,

(12:41):
Professor Emeritus of History at the University of Notre Dame.
By aligning with the ascending Frankish power rather than the
declining Byzantine Empire, the papacy secured practical protection while establishing
unprecedented influence over a major secular authority. The Pope's blessing
of pep pinus coronation established a precedent for papal involvement

(13:03):
in royal legitimation that would significantly expand papal political authority.
This realignment culminated in seven hundred fifty four CE, when
Pope Stephen the Second personally traveled north to meet Peepin
and secure military assistance against the Lombards. During this extraordinary journey,
the first papal crossing of the Alps, Stephen anointed Pepin

(13:26):
and his sons, bestowed the title Patrician of the Romans,
and secured the promise of territories that would eventually form
the Papal States. The resulting donation of Pepin established the
temporal foundation that would support papal independence for the next millennium.
Stephen's journey north physically embodied the papacy's strategic reorientation, notes

(13:49):
doctor Rosamond McKitterick, Professor Emerita of Medieval History at Cambridge University.
A pope personally leaving Italy to seek Frankish protection represented
dramatic recognition that Rome's future lay with Northern alliances rather
than Mediterranean traditions. This geographical shift paralleled the institutional shift
from Roman imperial frameworks to new political arrangements with recently

(14:12):
converted Northern kingdoms. By the mid eighth century, the cumulative
effect of missionary expansion and Northern alliances had fundamentally transformed
the papacy. From an institution primarily focused on preserving Roman

(14:36):
traditions within former imperial territories, it had become one actively
expanding its authority into new regions through direct missionary activity.
From a church leadership position operating within Byzantine imperial frameworks,
it had become an increasingly independent authority, forming its own
political relationships and territorial claims. This transformation manifested in multi

(15:00):
dimensions geographic reorientation. The papacy's primary sphere of influence shifted
from the Mediterranean world toward trans Alpine Europe, regions never
part of the Roman Empire, like Ireland, Anglo Saxon, England,
and Germanic territories became increasingly central to papal concerns and identity.

(15:21):
Institutional development. Missionary activities required more sophisticated administrative structures To
maintain connections with distant churches. The papal chancery expanded its operations,
standardized documentation practices, and developed more formal communication channels with
outlying regions. Theological emphasis engagement with new cultural contexts required

(15:47):
clearer articulation of essential doctrines versus adaptable practices. Papal correspondence
with missionaries shows increased focus on establishing doctrinal boundaries while
permitting cultural accommodation within those limits. Cultural synthesis. As Northern
Converts entered church leadership, they brought distinctive cultural elements that

(16:07):
gradually influenced Roman practices. By the eighth century, the papacy
itself reflected synthesis between traditional Roman patterns and Northern European contributions,
particularly in monastic practices, penitential traditions, and artistic styles. The
papacy that emerged from this northern expansion was fundamentally different

(16:29):
from the Late Antique institution Gregory the Great had inherited,
observes doctor Julia Smith, Professor of Medieval History at the
University of Oxford. It operated on a different geographic scale,
engaged with different cultural contexts, utilized different institutional methods, and
conceived of its authority in different terms, yet it maintained

(16:50):
essential continuity in its self understanding as the heir to
Peatrine authority and center of Western Christianity. This transformed papacy
would face significant challenges in the centuries ahead, from Carolingian
dominance to Viking invasions, from reform movements to secular conflicts,
but the institutional foundations established through missionary expansion and northern

(17:14):
alliances provided resilience that would enable the medieval papacy to
survive these challenges and eventually expand its authority to unprecedented levels.
White Smoke is a production of Calaroga Shark Media