35. The Prisoner Pope

Napoleon personally arrests Pope Pius the Seventh and drags him into five years of captivity. The emperor who crowned himself demonstrates that papal spiritual claims provide no protection against military force when imperial ambitions are at stake.

Unlock an ad-free podcast experience with Caloroga Shark Media! Get all our shows on any player you love, hassle free! For Apple users, hit the banner on your Apple podcasts app. For Spotify or other players, visit caloroga.com/plus. No plug-ins needed!

Subscribe now for exclusive shows like 'Palace Intrigue,' and get bonus content from Deep Crown (our exclusive Palace Insider!) Or get 'Daily Comedy News,' and '5 Good News Stories’ with no commercials! Plans start at $4.99 per month, or save 20% with a yearly plan at $49.99. Join today and help support the show!

We now have Merch!  FREE SHIPPING! Check out all the products like T-shirts, mugs, bags, jackets and more with logos and slogans from your favorite shows! Did we mention there’s free shipping? Get 10% off with code NewMerch10 Go to Caloroga.com

Get more info from Caloroga Shark Media and if you have any comments, suggestions, or just want to get in touch our email is [e-mail]

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:03):
Calarogu Shark Media. July sixth, eighteen o nine, The most
powerful man in Europe kicked down the doors of the
Quirinal Palace in Rome, stormed up the stairs, and personally
arrested the Pope. Napoleon Bonaparte had just committed what Catholics

(00:25):
would call the ultimate sacrilege, kidnapping the Vicar of Christ.
Pope Pius the seventh had been walking a tightrope with
Napoleon for years. The little Corsican had already humiliated one Pope,
forcing Pius the sixth to die in exile in French captivity.
Now Napoleon was demanding that Pius join his continental blockade

(00:46):
against Britain, close his ports to British ships, and essentially
make the Papal States a French puppet. Pius refused. He
was the spiritual father of all Catholics, he argued, including
British afflicts. He could not take sides in a purely
political war between European powers. His spiritual authority transcended national

(01:08):
boundaries and political conflicts. This is White Smoke, Episode thirty five.
The prisoner Pope. Napoleon's response was swift and brutal. French
soldiers surrounded the pope's palace, arrested him in his nightclothes,

(01:31):
and dragged him away to five years of imprisonment that
would test the limits of papal authority and demonstrate the
powerlessness of spiritual claims against military force. Today, we examined
the most dramatic confrontation between papal and imperial power in
modern history, when the man who claimed to be God's
representative on earth became the prisoner of an emperor who

(01:53):
recognized no authority higher than his own ambition. The relationship
between the pan and the papacy had begun with mutual
convenience and calculation, rather than genuine respect or religious conviction.
When Napoleon seized power in France through his Coup of
eighteen Brumaire, he inherited a nation that had been torn

(02:14):
apart by revolutionary anti clericalism. Churches had been closed, priests
had been murdered, and the Catholic faith that had defined
French civilization for over a thousand years had been nearly destroyed.
Napoleon understood that lasting political stability required reconciliation with the
Catholic Church that remained the spiritual anchor for most French citizens,

(02:37):
Yet he also recognized that papal authority posed a potential
threat to his own absolute power. His solution was the
Concordat of eighteen oh one, a carefully crafted agreement that
restored Catholic worship in France while ensuring that the Church
remained subordinate to imperial authority. The Concordat represented a masterpiece

(02:57):
of Napoleonic manipulation. Pious the seventh received formal recognition of
Catholicism as the religion of the great majority of French citizens,
while Napoleon retained the right to appoint bishops and control
church property. The pope regained spiritual authority over French Catholics,
but only within limits defined by imperial decree. For Napoleon,

(03:20):
the Concordate served purely political purposes. He privately dismissed religion
as superstition designed to control the masses, famously declaring that
religion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich.
Yet he understood the political utility of divine sanction for
his rule and was willing to manipulate papal authority to

(03:40):
serve his imperial ambitions. The papal coronation of Napoleon as
emperor in eighteen o four revealed the complex dynamics of
their relationship. Napoleon demanded that Pious the Seventh travel to
Paris to crown him, seeking papal legitimacy for his usurpation
of imperial title. Yet when the moment came, Napoleon seized

(04:03):
the crown from the Pope's hands and placed it on
his own head, symbolically asserting that his authority derived from
personal achievement rather than papal blessing. This theatrical gesture perfectly
captured Napoleon's attitude toward papal authority, useful for legitimizing his
rule among Catholic populations, but ultimately subordinate to his own

(04:24):
imperial will. The Pope, who had traveled to Paris expecting
to crown an emperor, found himself reduced to a ceremonial
prop in Napoleon's self aggrandizement. The relationship began to deteriorate
as Napoleon's imperial ambitions expanded beyond France to encompass the
entire European continent. His continental system, designed to destroy British

(04:48):
commerce through economic blockade, required the cooperation of every European power,
including the Papal states. When Pious refused to close Papal
ports to British shipping, Napoleon rans realized that papal independence
posed an unacceptable threat to his grand strategy. Napoleon's demands
escalated throughout eighteen oh seven and eighteen oh eight. He

(05:10):
wanted the Pope to expel British diplomats from Rome, confiscate
British property in Papal territories, and joined the Continental system
as a full military ally. When Pious continued to assert
papal neutrality, Napoleon began treating the Papal states as conquered territory,
stationing French troops in Rome, and imposing imperial administration on

(05:32):
Papal territories. Pious the Seventh's resistance to Napoleonic pressure reflected
both personal courage and institutional principle. Unlike his predecessor, Pious
the sixth, who had been overwhelmed by revolutionary violence, Pious
the Seventh possessed the diplomatic skill and moral authority necessary
to defend papal independence against imperial coercion. Yet Pious also

(05:57):
understood the theological implications of Napoleon's decays. If the Pope
became a mere client of French imperial policy, Papal spiritual
authority would be compromised throughout the Catholic world. Catholics in
nations at war with France would question papal neutrality and independence.
The universal character of papal authority would be destroyed by

(06:19):
subordination to any particular political power. The crisis reached its
climax in June eighteen o nine, when Napoleon formally annexed
the Papal states to the French Empire, declaring that the
Pope is the Bishop of Rome, but he is not
and cannot be, a sovereign temporal ruler. This annexation represented

(06:40):
the complete destruction of papal temporal authority that had existed
for over one thousand years. Pious the Seventh's response was
immediate and uncompromising. On June tenth, he issued the bull
Cool Memoranda, excommunicating Napoleon and all those responsible for the
annexation of papal territories. The spiritual leader of Catholic Christianity

(07:03):
had declared war against the most powerful military leader in
European history. Napoleon's reaction revealed both his contempt for spiritual
authority and his understanding of its political power. Rather than
dismissing papal excommunication as meaningless superstition, he ordered the immediate
arrest of the pope and his deportation from Rome. The emperor,

(07:24):
who claimed to fear nothing, was sufficiently concerned about papal
opposition to risk the scandal of imprisoning the head of
the Catholic Church. The arrest of Pious seventh on July
sixth shocked Catholic Europe and demonstrated the complete subordination of
spiritual to temporal authority in Napoleon's empire. French soldiers broke

(07:48):
into the Quirinal Palace at dawn, found the Pope praying
in his private chapel, and informed him that he was
under arrest by order of the Emperor. When Pious demanded
to see the arrest warrant, he was told that Napoleon's
word was sufficient authority. The Pope's journey into captivity became
a symbolic pilgrimage that exposed the violence underlying Napoleonic claims

(08:10):
to legitimate authority. Transported first to Grenoble, then to Savona
and finally to Fontainebleau. Pious was kept in comfortable but
closely guarded imprisonment while Napoleon attempted to break his resistance
through psychological pressure. Napoleon's treatment of his papal prisoner revealed
the emperor's sophisticated understanding of political manipulation. Rather than martyring

(08:33):
Pious through harsh treatment, Napoleon provided him with adequate accommodation
while isolating him from all communication with the outside world.
The pope, who had excommunicated an emperor, was reduced to
a comfortable but powerless captive. The isolation imposed on Pious
the seventh was designed to force him into submission through

(08:55):
psychological pressure rather than physical coercion from his cardinals. Deprived
of reliable information about world events and subjected to constant
pressure from Napoleon's representatives, the Pope was expected to eventually
accept imperial demands for the sake of peace. Yet Pious
proved remarkably resilient under pressure. Despite his isolation and the

(09:18):
constant stress of imprisonment. He refused to negotiate any agreement
that would compromise papal independence or spiritual authority. His famous
declaration that he would suffer everything for the Church became
a rallying cry for Catholics throughout Europe who opposed Napoleonic domination.
Napoleon's attempts to coerce papal cooperation became increasingly desperate as

(09:41):
his military position deteriorated. The disastrous Russian campaign of eighteen
twelve and the formation of the Sixth Coalition against France
made imperial control over Catholic opinion more crucial than ever.
Yet the imprisoned Pope remained unmoved by imperial pressure, confident
that his suffering served them long term interests of papal authority.

(10:03):
The Concordat of Fontembleau, signed in January eighteen thirteen, represented
Napoleon's final attempt to legitimize his treatment of papal authority
through negotiated agreement. Under enormous pressure and suffering from poor health,
Pious the Seventh initially accepted terms that would have reduced
papal temporal authority while maintaining spiritual independence. Yet within weeks

(10:28):
of signing the agreement, Pious repudiated the Concordat of Fontembleau,
declaring that he had been coerced into acceptance. And that
the terms were unacceptable to papal conscience. This repudiation demonstrated
that even under the most extreme pressure, papal spiritual authority
could not be permanently compromised through temporal coercion. Napoleon's defeat

(10:51):
at Leipsic in October eighteen thirteen and the subsequent collapse
of his empire finally freed Pious the Seventh from captivity.
The Pope's return to Rome in May eighteen fourteen was
greeted by enormous crowds, who saw his survival as divine
vindication of papal authority against imperial tyranny. The imprisonment of

(11:12):
Pious the Seventh had profound implications for the future relationship
between papal authority and European political power. The Pope, who
had suffered for five years rather than compromise papal independence,
became a symbol of spiritual resistance to political oppression that
would inspire Catholic opposition to secular authority for generations. Yet,

(11:35):
the confrontation between Napoleon and Pious also revealed the practical
limitations of papal power in the modern world. The pope,
who claimed spiritual authority over all, Catholics had been rendered
powerless by a single emperor's military force. Papal temporal authority
built up over centuries of careful political maneuvering, had been

(11:55):
destroyed by imperial decree. The restoration of pious the said
seventh to papal authority in eighteen fourteen did not restore
the medieval synthesis of spiritual and temporal power that had
defined papal authority for centuries. The Congress of Vienna returned
most papal territories to Church control, but the principle of
papal temporal sovereignty had been permanently weakened by Napoleon's demonstration

(12:19):
of its vulnerability to military force. More importantly, the Napoleonic
captivity established precedents for future conflicts between papal spiritual claims
and national political authority. The emperor, who had imprisoned a
pope to serve French imperial interests, created a model that
future rulers would invoke whenever papal authority conflicted with national policy.

(12:43):
The prisoner pope's ordeal also transformed Catholic understanding of papal
authority itself. Pious the Seventh suffering had purified papal claims
of their temporal ambitions while strengthening their spiritual foundation. The
pope who emerged from Napoleonic captivity possessed greater moral authority
precisely because he had been stripped of political power. The

(13:06):
confrontation between Napoleon and Pious the Seventh marked the end
of the medieval papal monarchy and the beginning of the
modern papacy's focus on spiritual rather than temporal authority. The pope,
who had been reduced to imperial prisoner, would inspire a
new model of papal leadership based on moral authority rather
than political power. Yet the imprisonment also demonstrated that spiritual authority,

(13:29):
however exalted its claims, remained vulnerable to those willing to
use physical force without moral restraint. The emperor, who recognized
no law higher than his own will, had proven that
papal authority could be neutralized by anyone sufficiently ruthless to
ignore Catholic opinion and international scandal. The prisoner Pope's legacy

(13:51):
would endure long after Napoleon's empire had crumbled into dust,
providing inspiration for Catholics who faced political oppression. While establishing
the modern Papercy's role as moral witness rather than temporal ruler.
White Smoke is a production of Calaroga Shark Media, portions
of which were made with the help of a narration,

(14:12):
but still written and produced by real podcasters Mark Francis
and John McDermott.