Skeeter-ial: A Muppet Babies Investigation

Skeeter-ial: A Muppet Babies Investigation

Skeeter is missing! On “Muppet Babies,” Skeeter was seen with baby versions of Kermit, Piggy, Fozzie, Rowlf, Animal, Gonzo the Great, and her twin brother Scooter. All of them grew up to appear on Muppet shows and movies as adults…except Skeeter. On Skeeterial: A Muppet Babies Investigation, Matt Manser and Eileen Mary O’Connell (with the help of special guests) try to answer the question, what happened to Skeeter? Is she okay? Was she killed? We’ll watch every episode of the show to search for answers.

Episodes

April 2, 2018 65 mins
SKEETER? WHERE ARE YOU SKEETER!?! Matt and Eileen still have no idea where everyone's favorite gymnastics-enthusiast (Skeeter, we're talking about Skeeter) is, so this week they’ve called on the help of actress and writer, Amy Vorpahl. The three of them watched season 3 episode 11 of the Muppet Babies (“Around the Nursery in 80 Days”) to look for clues. Amy, a real life twin, offered some twin perspective about Scooter and Skeeter ...
Mark as Played
ACHOO! SKEETER IS STILL MISSING! Matt and Eileen still have no idea where Skeeter is, so they've enlisted the help of writer and Muppet Babies super fan Sara Clarke-Chan. The three of them watched season 3, episode 9 of The Muppet Babies ("Scooters Uncommon Cold") and along the way discussed archeology, another great documentary called "The Magic School Bus," and they got REAL, BABY INSIGHT! But did they find Skeeter? You better li...
Mark as Played
March 12, 2018 61 mins
EXTRA! EXTRA! SKEETER IS STILL MISSING! In "The Daily Muppet," the babies make their own newspaper for Nanny - even though she makes them sleep 8 babies to a crib! But the real front page story should be the disappearance of Skeeter, so Eli Magers (Pack Theater) helps Eileen and Matt with the investigation. They also discuss if Kermit is an evil dictator, if Gonzo is actually a God, and why Eli insists that all of Fozzie's friends ...
Mark as Played
SKEETER, ARE YOU ALIVE!? Matt and Eileen still have no idea where Skeeter is, so they've called upon the help of their friend, comedian and musician Zach Olsen. The three of them watched season 3 episode 7 of The Muppet Babies ("Fozzie's Family Tree") and along the way discuss whether or not Skeeter could be The Count, Eileen's favorite dolphin, and the SUPER AMAZING SONG THAT'S IN THIS EPISODE! Oh, and maybe, just maybe, where Ske...
Mark as Played
CONGRESS, HELP US FIND SKEETER! Matt and Eileen still haven't found Skeeter, so they enlisted the help of Tamra Brown (Liquid Feet) to help finally get to the bottom of the case. In this episode, Kermit becomes president of the nursery and goes to Washington...so can the government finally get involved in solving Skeeter's disappearance? They also talked about if Beaker is a sentient finger, Miss Piggy's "time's up" moment with Ker...
Mark as Played
SKEETER, WHERE THE FRICK ARE YOU!?!?! Matt and Eileen still aren't sure, so they brought in actress/writer Molly Fite to help crack the case. The three of them watched season 3, episode 5 of Muppet Babies ("The Muppet Broadcasting Company") and discussed spider poop, how Molly models her life after Ms. Piggy, and all types of accents. But do they find Skeeter!? You better listen and find out!  See acast.com/privacy for privacy a...
Mark as Played
February 12, 2018 48 mins
SKEETER-IAL IS BACK, BUT SKEETER IS NOT! Eileen and Matt are back with our first new episode of 2018 - and we talk about the BRAND NEW REBOOT OF MUPPET BABIES - that somehow omits Skeeter! We also bring in Kate Huffman ("I'm Too Fat For This Show"), and we discuss if we would buy lemonade from a baby, and also serenade R. Kelly with a rendition of "I Believe I Can Fly." But do we find Skeeter? Listen and find out!  See acast.com/...
Mark as Played
BREAKING NEWS! In the week before Thanksgiving, The Muppets' official YouTube channel posted - for real - a video titled "Happy Thanksgiving from Scooter & Lew Zealand!" Given that our leading theory is that Skeeter may have grown up to become Lew Zealand, this pairing seems like more than just a coincidence. In this episode, Eileen, Matt, and guest Robert Clarke-Chan watch the video (complete with audio clips!) and analyze for mor...
Mark as Played
SKEETER, WHERE ARE YOU? ARE YOU SECRETLY LEW ZEALAND!?! Matt and Eileen are still knee-deep in this mystery, and they've brought back a couple of old friends to help with their investigation. Jeremy Schmidt and Ron Lechler host "The Twilight Zone Zone" but they returned to Skeeter-ial and learned about this Lew Zealand theory theory. The four of them watched season 3, episode 3 of The Muppet Babies ("The Weirdo Zone") and discussed...
Mark as Played
THE SKEETER/LEW ZEALAND MYSTERY CONTINUES!!! Matt and Eileen keep investigating the disappearance of Skeeter...and dig deeper into the possibility that SKEETER GREW UP TO BECOME LEW ZEALAND! They were joined by Charlie Mihelich (UCB, IO West) and they also discussed if Alanis Morissette or Arnold Schwarzenegger is involved in the mystery, who the Muppets' counterparts are on Peanuts, and, for some reason, how the investigation is a...
Mark as Played
November 13, 2017 54 mins
SEASON 3 PREMIERE - DID SKEETER BECOME LEW ZEALAND??? On the season 2 finale, a new Skeeter theory was presented that suggests that Skeeter could have grown up to become boomerang fish-throwing Muppet Lew Zealand. Could it be true? We don't know, but the photos make it seem like a possibility. With the help of Tommy Bechtold (ABC's "The Middle"), we dive further into this theory while also discussing the first episode of Muppet Bab...
Mark as Played
IT'S THE SEASON 2 FINALE AND WE STILL DON'T KNOW WHERE SKEETER IS! But folks, this episode is a GAME CHANGER! Writer/author and Muppet super fan, Ben Greene joined Matt and Eileen on their very important, very serious quest to find the missing Muppet. The three of them watched Season 2, Episode 13 of The Muppet Babies ("When You Wish Upon A Muppet") and along the way, they discussed action figures, Ben's very secret horse notebook,...
Mark as Played
October 16, 2017 60 mins
THIS EPISODE IS NSFW! SKEETER, COME BACK! Still no answer on the disappearance of Skeeter from Muppet Babies. So in this episode, Matt and Eileen got some assistance from Kat Palardy ("New Girl," "Brooklyn Nine-Nine"), who (as an investigative exercise) led us in a game of "F***, MARRY, SKEETER." Like we said, THIS EPISODE IS NSFW! When solving a crime, sometimes stuff comes up that's not safe for work...but is Skeeter safe at all?...
Mark as Played
SKEETER? SKEETER ARE YOU THERE!? Matt and Eileen still haven't found Skeeter, the missing Muppet who was seen on Muppet Babies but never as an adult Muppet with the rest of the gang. This week, Madeline Walter joins them on their quest! You know Madeline from the UCB Theatre and from her podcast, "Definitely Dying." But is Skeeter definitely dead!? The three of them watched season 2, episode 11 of The Muppet Babies ("The Muppet Mus...
Mark as Played
SKEETER, COME BACK! Matt and Eileen couldn't find Skeeter at the Hollywood Bowl, so they went back to watching Muppet Babies episodes in the hopes of finding clues that will lead us to Skeeter. Joining us in the search is Lesley Tsina ("Community," "Transparent"). We discussed Lesley's book "Restart Me Up" (a real book about the fake history of Windows '95), plus we tried to find out if Bunson is actually an avocado, if FedEx drive...
Mark as Played
BONUS EPISODE! The Muppets recently appeared LIVE IN CONCERT AT THE HOLLYWOOD BOWL, and Matt and Eileen were there to investigate! The concert featured performances and appearances by Kermit, Fozzie, Miss Piggy, and ever more recent Muppets like Pepe and Walter...but was Skeeter there? Did Scooter even mention his long lost twin? Joining us in the investigation is Bennie Arthur of "Drunk History." But is Skeeter history? Listen and...
Mark as Played
September 18, 2017 55 mins
SKEETER, WE BEG OF YOU: PLEASE TELL US WHERE YOU ARE! Matt and Eileen still have no idea where Skeeter is but they're confident that this week's guest, Drew Seeley, can help them out. Drew is an actor and a singer, but if Skeeter is found, our hearts will be the ones singing. The three of them watched Season 2, episode 9 of The Muppet Babies ("What's New at the Zoo?") to look for clues and along the way, they discussed love triangl...
Mark as Played
September 11, 2017 61 mins
MORE MYSTERY! Matt and Eileen still can't fine Skeeter, so they enlisted the help of Pam Murphy ("Adam Ruins Everything," "30 Rock). They discussed the Muppet Babies episode titled "Musical Muppets," and talked about if Skeeter is stuck in Tron, if Eileen stared at the eclipse for too long, and a possible spoiler of the movie "Split." But did they find Skeeter? Listen and find out!  See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out i...
Mark as Played
September 4, 2017 57 mins
HELLO? SKEETER? ARE YOU OUT THERE?!?! Matt and Eileen still have no idea where Skeeter is, so they've brought in Cassi Jerkins (Dumb Nerds Podcast) to help them crack this case. The three of them watched Season 2, episode 7 of the Muppet Babies ("I Want My Muppet TV!") and looked for clues. Along the way, they discussed Muppet puberty, which Muppet baby would be the best improviser, and they even held...a seance!? But did they find...
Mark as Played
THE MYSTERY CONTINUES! This week, Matt and Eileen are aided in the search by comedian Chet Wild...but they are not "wild" about Skeeter continuing to be missing! This week, the investigation continues by watching this"Muppet Babies" episode where Skeeter stars as Snow White! Could Piggy's jealousy have been the motivation for Skeeter's Demise? They also discuss if Nanny's on cocaine, if Bunson Honeydew is an actual talking honeydew...
Mark as Played

Popular Podcasts

    The latest news in 4 minutes updated every hour, every day.

    Therapy Gecko

    An unlicensed lizard psychologist travels the universe talking to strangers about absolutely nothing. TO CALL THE GECKO: follow me on https://www.twitch.tv/lyleforever to get a notification for when I am taking calls. I am usually live Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays but lately a lot of other times too. I am a gecko.

    The Joe Rogan Experience

    The official podcast of comedian Joe Rogan.

    The Clay Travis and Buck Sexton Show

    The Clay Travis and Buck Sexton Show. Clay Travis and Buck Sexton tackle the biggest stories in news, politics and current events with intelligence and humor. From the border crisis, to the madness of cancel culture and far-left missteps, Clay and Buck guide listeners through the latest headlines and hot topics with fun and entertaining conversations and opinions.

    Dateline NBC

    Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

Advertise With Us
Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.