Creepy Pizza

Creepy Pizza

Are you fascinated by the paranormal, supernatural, spooky, and/or just plain weird? Tune in to hear Britt educate Peter on the creepier things – ghost stories, folklore, urban legends, cryptids, and more. If you enjoy having a good laugh with friends about fiends, grab a slice of some Creepy Pizza!

Episodes

March 8, 2022 58 mins

This week we are telling a tale of the city that doesn't sleep, New York City! A little brownstone house is a home to quite a few ghosts, and all of them have a story to tell. Especially Mark Twain.  BONUS! Peter's computer becomes possessed.

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

Go to the arcade and play FREE game...

Mark as Played

It's Mardi Gras! Let's drink up with a glass-smashing party ghost and have a seance in a poker-player ghost's fixer up.  We're off to Louisiana to New Orleans' infamous Muriel's Jackson Square to meet some spirits that still hang around this haunt.

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

Go to the...

Mark as Played
February 22, 2022 42 mins

This week we hit the big 50! Let's count down the wildest, wettest, weirdest, water cryptids in this world! We are also releasing a bonus bite on Patreon this week! 

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

Find us on Instagram @CreepyPizzaPodcast
An...

Mark as Played

This week we head to Boston, MA to learn about the spooky happenings of the Omni Parker House Hotel. There is a crazy cast of famous guests who have checked in, and some never checked out.

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

Find us on Instagram @CreepyP...

Mark as Played
February 8, 2022 44 mins

Hey there
This week we introduce you to the Loveland Frogman, a cryptid from Loveland Ohio that might have actually just been Peter in a frog costume. We (sort of) answer the questions like: "did vacuums lead to feminism?" and "what is the difference between a frogman and a lizardman?" Grab your banjo, swoop your bangs, and sit down for a slice of Creepy Pizza.

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizz...

Mark as Played

Let's pour some milk out for our homies and learn about the history and traditions of Imbolc. We learn about a goddess that should be your role model, what latitudes are, how the groundhog stole all the fame, and some faerie folklore. Need a reason to spring clean? Imbolc. Need a reason to celebrate the end of Dry January? Imbolc.

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? ...

Mark as Played

This week listen to Britt wine to Peter about a demonic piece of furniture, The Dybbuk Box. Be careful what you're regifting after the holidays, it just might be possessed. 

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

Find us on Instagram @CreepyPizzaPodcas...

Mark as Played

This week Britt takes Peter back to Australia for an exciting tale that will get your heart racing. We learn about the questionable career choices of Frederick Federici and the history of Melbourne's beautiful Princess Theater. We also try to speak with an Aussie accent and fail miserably, mate. At least Britt has her favorite mug.

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories?...

Mark as Played

We plan Peter's burial this week and talk about the Chase Family Vault! Is it a phenomenon caused by natural disasters? Angry ghost who needs some space? Or is it Aliens? Listen and learn!

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

Find us on Instagram @Cr...

Mark as Played

Starting off 2022 with a Haunted Doll story is a weird way to come back from winter break, but at least she's not a murder-doll, right? This week we tell the story of Okiku the Haunted Doll. Britt confronts some childhood clown trauma and Peter is now a rabbit frog. Happy New Year, y'all.

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.c...

Mark as Played

Need a way to keep your crotch goblins in line? Try Gryla and her Yule Lads! Britt has a top ten that is not a top ten to close out the year. We're hoping to get a copy of Gryla's cookbook for Yule, instead of an invitation to dinner. Listeners, if you have some new ideas for moderns Yule Lads, let us know!

This week is our Holiday Special! And our last episode... of the year! We're taking a holiday break an...

Mark as Played

*This week we had some technical issues on Britt's Audio - most likely because she was recording in the haunted room. Our sincere apologies*

CALLING ALL LISTENERS! Have a spooky story about the holiday spirit? send us an email, we'll read it on the show!

This week we're studying a case of demon possession and a case of MURDER. Britt tells Peter about the possession of David Glatzel and the murder of...

Mark as Played

CALLING ALL LISTENERS! Have a spooky story about the holiday spirit? send us an email, we'll read it on the show!

Episode 40! Do you know what that means? We're at another top ten! This week Britt sails through a list of ghost ships, while Peter navigates some terrible puns.
 

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.c...

Mark as Played

CALLING ALL LISTENERS! Have a true ouija board story? send us an email, we'll read it on the show!

In this week's episode, Britt and Peter really dig their graves by saying a certain demon's name like a bazillion times. Join us for a slice of Ouija true stories and spooky history of the demon Zozo.

We also tell a paraphrased story from the  Amazig book True Ghost Stories: Real Haunted Ouija Boards...

Mark as Played

This week we have another first episode of a 3 part series. Britt goes into the origin of the talking boards from spiritualism, and how the Ouija board became what it is today!

We also tell a paraphrased story from the  Amazig book True Ghost Stories: Real Haunted Ouija Boards by Zachery Knowles

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gm...

Mark as Played

We are off to the most haunted place in India! Peter and Britt figure out their next jobs and have a new scent for the Creepy Pizza perfume line in this week's episode. We hear local folklore and the stories of hauntings in this beautiful ancient site.

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

Go to the arcade and play FREE ...

Mark as Played

What does a mobster with syphilis, a dog charged with murder and Quakers have in common?
In this week's episode we learn about the Eastern State Penitentiary, Peter and Britt spend too much time talking about how nice it would be to be in solitary confinement for a couple of days, Britt talks about spooky ghosts of bad guys and the ghost of a good boy who we all believe was innocent!

Visit us on our website www....

Mark as Played

The CP crew would like to wish you a Happy (Belated) Halloween! The history of Halloween is deep and intricate, and we seem to try and sum it up in under an hour. Britt explains the history and why she would be a bad demon,  Pope Bon Iver is a thing now, and we uncover the conspiracy of Big Candy. 

Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.c...

Mark as Played

This week is the stunning(?) conclusion to the cliffhanger from last week's monster round-up. We're talking about the one and only Moth Man! Britt had to edit out about 20 sneezes, Peter is stuffy in more ways than one, the snuffle game is strong with both of them. Need a costume for a Christmas party? how about a green metal suit? Listen and learn more about Moth Man and how to get that booty! Respect the Moth.

Mark as Played

In this week's episode, Britt and Peter take a hike, figuratively, through the Myths, Legends, and Monsters of the Appalachian trail! We are serving creepy up by the slice in this episode! We have true crime, we have magic, stinky monsters, ugly aliens, lawnmowers, grumpy sasquatches, and more! Careful while trekking through this episode, there may be a cliffhanger in your future... dun dun DUN!!

Visit us on our webs...

Mark as Played

Popular Podcasts

    If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.

    The Joe Rogan Experience

    The official podcast of comedian Joe Rogan.

    24/7 News: The Latest

    The latest news in 4 minutes updated every hour, every day.

    The Breakfast Club

    The World's Most Dangerous Morning Show, The Breakfast Club, With DJ Envy And Charlamagne Tha God!

    Dateline NBC

    Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

Advertise With Us
Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.