Reasonable Doubt

Mark and Gary reflect on a boarded-up downtown LA, escalating protests, and constitutional clashes over the National Guard—plus updates on Karen Read and Weinstein trials.

Watch Beyond A Reasonable Doubt and all Reasonable Doubt video content on YouTube exclusively at YouTube.com/ReasonableDoubtPodcast and subscribe while you're there

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at ...

This week, Mark and Gary dive into the fast-escalating feud between Donald Trump and Elon Musk, breaking down how a spat over spending turned into a full-blown political and personal clash involving Jeffrey Epstein allegations and deleted tweets. Plus, the hosts weigh short-term wins vs. long-term influence, with insight from Geragos’s other podcast '2 Angry Men' with Harvey Levin.

Watch Beyond A Reasonable Doubt and all Re...

Mark and Gary reunite to unpack the defense’s momentum shift in the Karen Read trial and why the prosecution’s closing move may have backfired. They also dive into the controversial use of AI-generated victim impact statements, debating what role technology should play in the courtroom. Plus, a strange case out of Milwaukee involving a judge and a federal standoff leads to a deeper discussion on the limits of judicial prot...

Mark and Gary dive into how the Diddy case has dominated media attention, overshadowing major trials like Harvey Weinstein’s retrial and the Karen Read case. They break down a viral courtroom moment where a prosecution expert gets dismantled over his phony credentials—and what it says about the state of expert testimony. Plus, they share a few AI-suspect viral videos from courtrooms and Congress, including a musical outbur...

Mark and Gary break down the landmark resentencing of the Menendez brothers, the emotional family testimonies, and the long, winding road to potential freedom. From the early habeas filings to the game-changing court decisions, this episode captures the key moments that reignited the brothers’ case and explores what comes next as they approach their first parole hearing.

Watch Beyond A Reasonable Doubt and all Reasonable Do...

Mark and Gary break down the latest twists in the Karen Reed retrial, including explosive cross-examinations and surprising judicial moves, before diving into the long road to resentencing for the Menendez brothers. Plus, Mark shares his thoughts on the controversial return of the death penalty in L.A. County.

Watch Beyond A Reasonable Doubt and all Reasonable Doubt video content on YouTube exclusively at YouTube.com/R...

Mark Geragos and Gary Smith dissect key moments from the Karen Read trial, including a pivotal admission on the stand, and preview what’s ahead as jury selection begins in the Diddy case. From media misperceptions to real trial strategy, they explore what resonates with jurors—and what doesn’t.

Watch Beyond A Reasonable Doubt and all Reasonable Doubt video content on YouTube exclusively at YouTube.com/ReasonableDoubtPo...

Mark and Gary dive deep into the arrest of a Wisconsin judge accused of helping a defendant evade ICE agents—raising urgent questions about judicial immunity, civil vs. criminal protections, and parallels to recent presidential immunity rulings. Plus, updates on Luigi Mangione, Scott Peterson, and Mark’s fiery clash with Nancy Grace.

Watch Beyond A Reasonable Doubt and all Reasonable Doubt video content on YouTube exclusive...

Mark and Gary kick off this episode with an unexpected but entertaining dive into Southern California theme parks—from Knott’s Berry Farm nostalgia to a full ranking of Disneyland, Legoland, Universal Studios, and more. Then, they unpack the media frenzy surrounding Bill Maher’s recent meeting with Donald Trump and his '2 Angry Men' podcast appearance. The conversation rounds out with a deep dive into the high-profile sett...

Mark and Gary unpack a devastating moment in the Menendez case, as Jose’s sister Terry is hospitalized just days after a pivotal hearing. The episode details a controversial courtroom tactic by the DA’s office that re-traumatized the family and sparked outrage. As the fight for resentencing continues, the cost of justice becomes painfully clear.

Watch Beyond A Reasonable Doubt and all Reasonable Doubt video content on YouTu...

Mark Geragos, Alexandra Kazarian and Gary Smith unpack a stunning twist in the Menendez brothers’ resentencing case, calling out the DA’s latest filing as “intellectually dishonest” and pulling back the curtain on political maneuvering inside the LA County justice system. Along the way, AK gives a firsthand look at a recent trial that took some truly unexpected—and hilarious—turns. Add in a dash of homemade Lula kebab and ...

With Mark away, Gary is joined by friend of the show and frequent co-host Alexandra Kazarian to break down the biggest stories in the legal news this week. From Jay-Z’s extortion lawsuit against Tony Buzbee and its potential precedent-setting implications to the shocking decision to retry Karen Read, they analyze the legal maneuvers at play. Plus, they dive into the custody risks facing Kanye West and Kim Kardashian amid c...

After a midweek surprise episode Gary and Mark reconnect for their Sunday edition as they dive deep into the recent testimony of Nathan Wade's former attorney Terrance Bradley. They observe how fed up the Judge in the case seems to be with Bradley's testimony and how former President Trump's lawyers attempting to trip him up at every turn. As the show wraps up, they turn to a clip of former President Trump on the campaign ...

Mark Geragos and Alexandra Kazarian dive into two gripping legal stories making headlines. First, they break down the jaw-dropping $50 million verdict against Starbucks over a scalding hot tea spill, exploring the courtroom strategies, jury reactions, and the shocking settlement rejection. Then, they shift gears to a Hollywood mystery—the puzzling circumstances surrounding the deaths of Gene Hackman and his wife, their unu...

Mark and Gary dive into the DOJ’s recent motion to dismiss charges against NYC Mayor Eric Adams, breaking down its legal and political implications. They discuss the broader issue of prosecutorial weaponization, insights from the legal community, and how defense attorneys navigate an increasingly politicized system. Plus, a side conversation on belt promotions, Costco eggs, and an exciting appointment in the civil rights d...

Mark Geragos welcome back Alexandra Kazarian (a.k.a. AK) to break down the latest in the wild and ever-evolving legal drama between Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni. From the surprising role of Candace Owens in the discourse to the strategic missteps of Hollywood power players, the trio dissects the lawsuit’s latest twists and what it means for celebrity culture, legal strategy, and the court of public opinion. Plus, a loo...

Gary and Mark reconnect and open discussing the recent verdict in A$AP Rocky's trial that led to a somewhat bizarre scene in the courtroom. Mark also harkens back to a similar situation and reminisces on a tale of legend from federal court. They also touch on Luigi Mangione's recent court appearance featuring friend of the show KFA. Follow Los Angeles Magazine on YouTube at YouTube.com/LosAngelesMagazineVideos Watch Beyo...

Mark and Gary link up after a few weeks of guest hosts and pick up right where they left off covering the several crazy stories that broke or saw updates late in the week. After starting with the A$AP Rocky case that saw Joe Tacopina sparring with the D.A. they move on to the Eric Adams situation in New York as Mark highlights some of the wild reactions he's been hearing from friends and colleagues. Watch Beyond A Reasona...

Mark is joined by returning guest co-host Alexandra Kazarian as they dig further into the Justin Baldoni and Blake Lively drama that they started covering in last week's episode. They discuss how quickly the drama has unfolded and how Blake Lively is quickly finding herself abandoned by her most powerful and influential one-time friends. Follow Alexandra on all social media @AKinContempt Watch Beyond A Reasonable Doub...