December 23, 2025 • 33 mins
Descend beneath the marble floors of St. Patrick's Cathedral in New York City, where Gothic spires pierce the winter skyline above Fifth Avenue and Christmas lights glow against ancient stone, while twenty archbishops and cardinals rest in eternal vigil below the high altar. Host Kristin guides listeners through the crypts of America's most iconic cathedral during the season when millions gather for Midnight Mass above—unaware of the voices that linger below. Founded in 1858 on land once considered countryside, this cathedral rose through decades of struggle, its white marble walls climbing skyward as the city around it dressed itself in Yuletide splendor. Explore the stories of men who shaped Catholic life in a city swollen with immigrants, prejudice, and ambition—and one extraordinary layperson whose quiet charity during the coldest seasons earned him a place among princes of the Church.
Featured Historical Figures:
John Joseph Hughes – "Dagger John," New York's first archbishop, whose fiery temperament and unyielding vision drove the cathedral's construction through decades of financial struggle, Civil War interruption, and anti-Catholic hostility. He died in January 1864 with the walls still unfinished, never seeing Christmas lights along Fifth Avenue or hearing Midnight Mass echo through marble vaults—buried beneath a promise made in faith rather than stone.
John McCloskey – The first American cardinal, who rowed across the frozen East River as a boy just to attend Mass and later guided construction to completion after Hughes' death. His quiet endurance transformed ambition into reality, opening the cathedral's doors on a cold November day in 1879 after decades of delay—just in time for its first Christmas season.
Francis Joseph Spellman – "The GI's Cardinal," whose 28-year reign (1939-1967) transformed the archdiocese into a global center of Catholic influence. A confidant to presidents and power broker who visited troops worldwide during wartime Christmases, Spellman cast the longest shadow in the crypt—a reminder of how closely faith and political power once walked together through America's darkest winters.
Pierre Toussaint – Born into slavery in Haiti in 1766, Toussaint became New York's most sought-after hairdresser and the only layperson ever buried beneath St. Patrick's high altar. Called "Saint Pierre" decades before Rome considered the name, he sheltered orphans during harsh winters, fed yellow-fever victims when others fled, and funded Catholic institutions that wouldn't admit children of his own race—practicing holiness without office in an unjust world, his charity warming lives through the coldest seasons.
Fulton John Sheen – The golden-voiced broadcaster whose Christmas programs reached millions of living rooms across America and won Emmy Awards, yet clashed with Cardinal Spellman over independence and moral authority. Originally interred at St. Patrick's near the winter altar, his remains were later transferred to Peoria after legal disputes—a man who spoke to the nation during silent nights but knew the solitude of conscience.
Also Featured:
Terence James Cooke (Servant of God, whose compassion lit the darkest hours), John Joseph O'Connor (who confronted clergy abuse before the full crisis was known), Edward Michael Egan (whose legacy remains burdened by institutional reckoning), architect James Renwick Jr.'s white marble vision that rises pale against December skies, the 1858 cornerstone ceremony that drew 100,000 spectators in summer heat, the Christmas Day 1906 dedication of the Lady Chapel funded by Margaret A. Kelly's deferred gift, and the formal consecr
Support The Grim by buying a cup of our next Grave Grind!
https://buymeacoffee.com/kristinlopes
Find All of The Grim's Social Links At:
https://www.the-grim.com/socialmedia
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Kristin (00:13):
Grim morning and welcome to the Grim.
I'm your host, Kristin.
On today's episode, we'll beopening the gate and entering
the crypt in St.
Patrick's Cathedral, located inNew York City, New York.
The aroma of coffee mingles inthe air.
The gates stand open.
Step carefully.
It's starting to descend intothe hauntings of history.
(00:34):
It's the week of Christmas,dear listeners, if you
celebrate.
As the season settles in, manymake their way to the Big Apple,
drawn by a city that knows howto dress itself in life.
New York gleams in December,its streets draped in garland
and tinsel reflections, alivewith anticipation, and the cold
air curling like smoke aroundhurried footsteps.
(00:57):
Rockefeller Center is often thefirst pilgrimage.
Central Park follows, hushedbeneath winter's weight, and
then their St.
Patrick's Cathedral, risingpale and unyielding along Fifth
Avenue.
Its gothic spires cuttingthrough the glow of storefronts
and traffic, like somethingolder, steadier, and indifferent
to the season's spectacle.
(01:18):
Some of you might be among theparishioners who often return
year after year, quietlysecuring your place at midnight
mass as part of a traditionpassed down through family and
faith.
Others may watch from home, thesoft glow of Christmas trees
reflecting in your screen,listening as bells echo into the
cold night.
However, you arrive, throughbronze doors or by the way of
(01:40):
live stream, the cathedralwelcomes millions each year,
drawn not only by its beauty butby the quiet promise of
belonging.
But tonight we're not here forits beauty, nor its midnight
mass.
We're here for what liesbeneath.
More than twenty archbishopsand cardinals are buried below
St.
Patrick's Cathedral.
Their remains sealed withinbrick-lined crypts and marble
(02:02):
tombs.
Names once spoken withauthority and reverence now
survive only in engraved stone.
Hughes, Farley, Spellden, andCoop.
There were shepherds of a cityswollen with immigrants and
grief, men who presided overChristmas masses, while
influenza crept through itstenements, while telegrams
delivered news of lost soulsoverseas, while hunger lingered
(02:24):
and fires devoured entireblocks, and death they remained
where they served, directlybelow the altar.
Before we descend into thecrypts, we must first understand
the story of the cathedralabove them, its ambition, its
trials, and the hands that builtit.
The Diocese of New York wasfounded in 1808 by Pope Pius
VII, and soon after St.
(02:46):
Patrick's was established toserve the city's small but
growing Catholic population.
The original St.
Patrick's, what's now calledthe Old Cathedral, was dedicated
in 1850 on Mulberry Street,accommodating just 15,000
Catholics at the time, but bythe mid-19th century the
Catholic community had swelledto more than 200,000, many of
(03:08):
them Irish immigrants fleeingfamine and hardship.
The Old Cathedral, though,could no longer hold them.
In 1810, a parcel of land onFifth Avenue, between 50th and
51st Street, was purchased bythe Reverend Anthony Coleman.
At the time it lay far north ofthe city proper, a quiet rocky
stretch of ground whereManhattan thinned into the
(03:29):
countryside.
A Jesuit college rose there,along with a small chapel
dedicated to St.
Ignatius.
Its presence modest butdeliberate.
By 1840, the diocese repurposedthe property, transforming it
into a parish church andorphanage.
Trappist monks fleeingpersecution in France care for
the children until their returnhome in 1815.
(03:51):
Around them, the neighborhoodremained sparse, early streets
sketched into stone and dirt,hinting at a future not yet
imagined.
By 1850, Archbishop John JosephHughes understood the growing
Catholic population could nolonger be contained by its
downtown cathedral.
He envisioned something bolder,a Gothic monument rising along
(04:12):
Fifth Avenue, a dedication offaith and permanence in a city
where Catholics were still metwith suspicion and hostility.
In 1853, Hughes commissionedthe architectural firm of
Renwick and Rodrigue, entrustingthe project to James Renwick
Jr., a young architect deeplyinfluenced by the great
cathedrals of Europe, includingCologne.
(04:33):
Renwick's original plans weregrand with soaring spires,
flying buttresses, and anelaborate ambulatory, yet
ambitions soon met with reality.
Hughes requested modifications,scaling the design to make room
for clergy residences, andremoving several buttresses and
chapels.
Even so, when the cornerstonewas laid on August 15, 1858,
(04:56):
more than 100,000 peoplegathered.
A crowd drawn not just byceremony, but to the promise of
what this building would become.
But such ambition came at acost.
Money was always a problem.
From the beginning, thiscathedral was built in defiance
of scarcity.
James Renwick insisted on whitemarble, stone quarried from
Pleasantville, New York.
(05:17):
Beautiful, durable, andruinously expensive.
Fronton blocks were hauled intoplace as foundations were
carved into shallow bedrock.
Progress though was slow,painfully slow, and then came
the setbacks.
A stonecutter's strike broughtthe work to a standstill, and
then the Civil War erupted.
Construction stoppedaltogether.
(05:38):
Archbishop John Hughes, thecathedral's great champion,
would never see its completion.
When he died, the burden passedto those who followed.
Men like John McCulski, whoinherited not just an unfinished
church, but an unfinishedpromise.
They raised money where theycould, negotiated contracts, and
refused to let the projectcollapse under its own weight.
(05:59):
By the late 1860s, the wallsfinally began to rise again.
Marble climbed skyward alongFifth Avenue.
Stained glass, some of it oncedisplayed at the World's Fair,
was set into place.
Washing the nave in muted reds,blues, and golds.
The roof was then laid down.
Scaffolding filled the interiorlike a skeleton waiting for its
(06:19):
flesh.
And then on November 29, 1877,the doors opened, unfinished,
unpolished, but standing.
Fundraisers in the year thatfollowed drew crowds by the
hundreds of thousands, and in1879, St.
Patrick's Cathedral wasformally dedicated, not as a
monument to wealth or ease, butas a testament to endurance,
(06:42):
faith, and survival.
Every stone, every pane ofglass, every detail, from the
vaulted ceilings above to thecrypts below, tells a story of
ambition and struggle.
This is a cathedral shaped byhands hardened by labor and by
hearts hardened throughprejudice, loss, and
persistence.
It's in this context that thespaces beneath the cathedral
(07:04):
take on their full meaning.
The new St.
Patrick's Cathedral officiallyopened on May 25, 1879, attended
by 35 bishops and sixarchbishops.
The reaction was swift anddivided.
Some newspapers were openlyadmiring.
The Baltimore Sun called St.
Patrick's the finest churchedifice on the American
(07:24):
continent.
Others, though, were far lessgenerous.
Journalist Clarence Cookdismissed the facade as
repetitive, the interior aspaltry.
Criticisms that years later,architectural historian Robert
A.
M.
Stern would argue were rootedless in design and more in
religious and ethnic prejudice.
But praise or protests thecathedral endured.
(07:45):
Alongside Temple and Manuel,St.
Patrick's claimed a place onMidtown Fifth Avenue, making it
one of the first non-Protestanthouses of worship to rise there,
at a time when the neighborhooditself was still on the city's
margins.
It was not being merely justjudged, it was being allowed, or
not, to belong.
James Renwick Jr.
(08:05):
continued shaping thecathedral's world beyond its
walls.
He designed the Archbishop'shouse and rectory on Madison
Avenue.
Buildings meant to anchor thechurch's presence nearby.
Even these drew criticism.
Their dormant windows weremocked as absurd, reminders that
scrutiny followed the cathedralin every form it took.
Money once again slowedeverything.
(08:28):
The spires, those unmistakabletwin towers, were delayed for
years.
Only in 1885 were the fundsfinally secured.
Three years later, in Octoberof 1888, they rose at last,
towering over Fifth Avenue,briefly becoming the tall
structures in New York City, adeclaration at last, that the
(08:48):
cathedral was not temporary, itwas here to stay.
Inside, however, the workremained unfinished, a ceiling
of plaster and wood, but only asa placeholder was never
replaced.
Shortages persisted.
Completion was always just outof reach.
The bells then came next,tested in 1889, then replaced by
(09:09):
a French set blessed in 1897.
Their number eventually grew to19, more than any other church
in the city.
The cathedral might have beenincomplete, but it would no
longer be quiet.
At the turn of the century, onefinal promise remained
unfulfilled.
In 1899, Margaret A.
Kelly left $200,000 for theconstruction of Lady Chapel,
(09:32):
stipulating it be built onlyafter her death.
It was an act of faithdeferred, a gift meant for the
future she would never see.
Architect Charles T.
Matthews was chosen to bringthe chapel to life.
He traveled through Europe,studying shrines and sanctuaries
shaped by his centuries ofdevotion.
When construction began in1901, it was with the
(09:53):
understanding that this wouldnot merely be an addition, but a
cultimation.
On Christmas Day in 1906, thefirst Mass was celebrated within
the Lady Chapel.
By 1908, its interior wascomplete, at a cost far
exceeding its original bequest.
And at last, in 1910, thecathedral's long-standing debt
(10:14):
was cleared.
After decades of delay,interruption, and unfinished
work, St.
Patrick's Cathedral was finallyready.
On October 5, 1910, it wasformally consecrated.
And yet for all those years oflabor and longing, the cathedral
began with loss.
The first man laid to restbeneath St.
Patrick's never lived to see itfinished.
(10:35):
John Joseph Hughes, New York'sfirst archbishop, was born in
Ireland in 1797 and ordained atMaynooth College in 1817.
He arrived in New York in 1826as a young priest in a city raw
with prejudice, where Irishimmigrants poured ashore hungry
and exhausted, and theanti-Catholic sentiment simmered
(10:57):
openly in the streets.
Hughes just didn't join them,though, he became their
defender.
He founded schools, establishedparishes, and fought
relentlessly for a community thecity often wished would
disappear.
His fiery temperament andrefusal to yield earned him the
nickname Dagger John, areference to the cross-shaped
slash that cut through hissignature like a blade.
(11:19):
In 1842, Hughes was named thefirst Archbishop of New York.
From that moment on, hecommitted himself to a single
unyielding vision, a cathedralthat would stand in plain sight,
permanent, visible, immovable,within a city openly hostile to
its presence.
For more than twenty years heendured skepticism, financial
(11:41):
strain, and the slow agony ofconstruction, all ministering to
a population shaped by famine,poverty, riots, and war.
When Hughes died in January in1864, the Civil War still raged.
The walls of St.
Patrick stood unfinished.
He never saw Christmas lightsalong Fifth Avenue, never heard
(12:02):
midnight mass echo through themarble vaults.
What he knew instead werefamine ships heavy with grief,
draft riots fueled by hatred,and a city unsure whether
Catholics or their churchestruly belonged.
He was laid to rest beneath thehigh altar of the cathedral
that existed more in faith thanin stone.
(12:22):
What rose above Fifth Avenueafter his death was not simply a
cathedral, but a convictionmade permanent, when buried with
him beneath its walls.
If Hughes was fire, JohnMcCulski was endurance.
Born in Brooklyn in 1810 toIrish immigrant parents,
McCulski grew up in a hardshipso complete that there was no
(12:42):
Catholic Church in his boroughat all, as the boy he rode
across the East River just toattend Mass in Manhattan, a
small but stubborn act thatwould define the rest of his
life.
A near fatal accident on hisfamily farm later left him frail
and temporarily blind.
It was a quiet brush withmorality that lingered, shaping
his restraint and caution longafter his strength returned.
(13:05):
He studied at Mount St.
Mary's in Emmitsburg, where hebecame known for being measured,
thoughtful, and disciplined.
Ordained in 1834, McCulskiserved wherever he was needed.
Old St.
Patrick's Cathedral, BellevueHospital, St.
Joseph's Seminary.
When he traveled to Rome, hereturned not with ambition, but
with perspective, and thepatience to wait.
(13:27):
In 1847, he was named the firstbishop of Albany, charged with
shepherding a vast andimpoverished diocese of
immigrants.
He built what was necessary: churches, schools, orphanages, (13:35):
undefined
seminaries.
Among them rose the Cathedralof the Immaculate Conception.
Foundations laid not forspectacle but for survival.
After Hugh's death, Mikulskyreluctantly took on leadership
of the New York Archdiocese.
Under his quiet stewardship,construction of the new St.
(13:56):
Patrick's resumed after theCivil War.
In 1875, he became the firstAmerican cardinal, a recognition
not just of one man, but of afaith that endured long enough
to be acknowledged.
His health though was fragile.
Illness returned again andagain.
Still Mikulski pressed on,expanding the archdiocese,
(14:17):
establishing 88 new parishes,and guiding New York's Catholics
through a city that remainedwary of them.
When he died in 1885, he leftbehind institutions meant to
outlast him.
Today he rests beneath the mainaltar, a quiet custodian of the
Marvel Knave and soaring towershe helped bring into being.
When McCulski governed gently,Michael Augustine Corrigan
(14:40):
governed firmly.
Born in Newark in 1839, thefifth of nine children of Irish
immigrants, Corrigan was shapedby discipline and education.
His father's successfulbusiness afforded him
opportunities rare for immigrantfamilies.
Studies in Wilmington,Emmitsburg, and Europe,
cultivating in the ordation atthe Basilica of St.
(15:00):
John Lateran in Rome in 1863.
Corrigan returned to America asa scholar and administrator.
He taught theology, led SeatonHall, and at just 34 became the
youngest Catholic bishop in theUnited States.
In 1880, he was namedcoadjunctor to McCloskey, and
five years later Archbishop ofNew York.
(15:21):
His tenure, though, was markedby tension, a committed
conservative at Corganchampioned parochial schools and
national parishes, oftenclashing with clergy who
flavored more of an Americanizedchurch.
His conflict with Father EdwardMcGlynn, whose labor activism
led to removal and temporaryexcommunication, divided the
city and exposed fault lineswithin the Catholic leadership.
(15:44):
Corrigan's treatment of Italianimmigrants drew criticism as
well, relegating many debasementchapels apart from Irish
congregations.
Yet even he bented times.
In 1889, he welcomed MotherFrances Xavier Cabrini and her
sisters at the Pope'sinsistence.
Setting in motion one of themost transformative missions in
(16:05):
American Catholic history,Gorrigan oversaw the
construction of St.
Joseph's Seminary at Dunwoodyand strengthened the diocese
structures across a rapidlychanging city.
When he died in 1902, he leftbehind an archdiocese reshaped
by authority, conflict, andinstitutional strength.
He remains though a complicatedpresence in the crypt, a
(16:27):
reminder that faith is notpracticed outside of power, but
within it.
Beneath the high altar, thecrypt becomes a ledger, not only
of faith, but of influence.
Here lie the men who shapedCatholic life in New York as the
city grew louder, richer, moredivided, and more visible to the
world.
John Murphy Farley entered acathedral finally risen from
(16:49):
decades of struggle, and anarchdiocese still learning how
to stand.
Born in Ireland in 1842, heimmigrated to the United States
as a child.
He studied for priesthood inFrance and Rome, gaining a
perspective that stretched farbeyond New York City's streets.
Ordained in 1870, he movedsteadily through the church's
hierarchy, eventually becomingArchbishop of New York in 1902
(17:13):
following Corrigan's death.
Farley's most enduring act wasconsecration.
On October 5, 1910, more than50 years after the cornerstone
was first laid, he formallyconsecrated St.
Patrick's Cathedral.
At last, he whose vision wasrealized, a cathedral complete,
a church present, permanent, andrespected in the heart of the
(17:35):
city.
He guided the archdiocesethrough ways of immigration,
labor unrest, and the openingyears of World War I.
He expanded charitableinstitutions and new parishes,
balancing growth with diplomacy,never seeking spectacle, but
always insisting on steadiness.
When he died in 1918, the citymourned quietly.
(17:55):
He rests out beneath thecathedral he helped finish, a
figure whose legacy is notmeasured in stone but in
completion, and the final act ofbringing a decades-long dream
to rest.
After Farley, Patrick JosephHayes took office in the shadow
of war and pandemic.
Born in Manhattan in 1867,Hayes was New York bred, shaped
(18:17):
by its neighborhoods and itsstreets.
Ordained in Rome, he returnedto serve as Chancellor of the
Archdiocese and later Bishop ofPittsburgh before becoming
Archbishop of New York in 1919.
He guided the church throughthe roaring twenties and the
Great Depression, years ofaccess and collapse.
He expanded Catholic education,strengthened relief efforts,
(18:40):
and cautiously supported laborrights.
Hayes valued order anddiscipline, and in a world
teetering on chaos, he providedit.
His mark of the skyline wastangible.
The seminary of the ImmaculateConception in Huntington, and
the Catholic Center near St.
Patrick's, buildings thatdeclared permanence in uncertain
times.
When he died in 1938, the cityteetered on another brink of
(19:04):
global war.
He rest beneath a cathedralthat became more than a church,
a civic gathering place in timesof fear.
No figure in the crypt thoughcast a longer shadow than
Spellman.
Born in Massachusetts in 1889,Spellman rose with remarkable
speed.
Educated in Rome, fluent inVatican politics, he became an
(19:25):
Archbishop of New York in 1939and a cardinal shortly after.
He inherited an archdiocese onthe brink of World War II and
transformed it into a globalcenter of Catholic influence.
Spellman was not a quietshepherd, he was a power broker,
a commandant of presidents, anda constant presence at the
White House.
(19:45):
Roosevelt, Eisenhower, Kennedy.
His relationships tied thechurch to national life itself.
During World War II and theKorean War, he traveled
extensively to visit Americantroops, earning the nickname the
G.I.'s Cardinal.
Anti-communist, he later drewcriticism for supporting the
Vietnam War.
Under Spellman, schools,hospitals, and universities
(20:08):
multiplied.
Authority was centralized,dissent often contained.
Admirers saw strength, criticssaw secrecy.
When he died in 1967, he leftan empire, vast, efficient, and
deeply influential.
Beneath the altar, he rests asa reminder of how closely faith
and power once walked together,and how difficult they are to
(20:30):
separate.
After the G.
I's Cardinal Terence James Cookcouldn't have been a more
different figurehead of thechurch.
Born in New York City in 1921,Cook came of age in the church
in transition.
Ordained in 1945, he roseduring the era of the Vatican
II, embracing reform, humility,and pastoral outreach.
(20:51):
When he became Archbishop ofNew York in 1968, he inherited a
church unsettled by war, civicrights struggles, and internal
fracture.
Cook rejected spectacles andfavored presence.
Under his guidance, theArchdiocese expanded ministries
to prisoners, immigrants, andthe chronically ill.
The long-standing Flower FifthAvenue Hospital was renamed the
(21:13):
Terrence Cardinal CookHealthcare Center, gearing his
name into the city's mission ofcare for the vulnerable.
More than a brick or policy,his work was about attention,
compassion, and steady guidance.
Yet gentleness didn't shieldhim from controversy.
His firm adherence to churchteachings on sexuality and
authority sometimes put him atodds with the progressive clergy
(21:36):
and those pressing for rapidchange.
He governed quietly butdecisively, earning both loyalty
and criticism.
Cook died of leukemia in 1983.
Devotion to his memory grewquickly.
In 1992, the Catholic Churchformally opened his cause for
sainthood, recognizing him as aservant of God, a steadfore
(21:57):
decantonization that honors theholiness many saw in his life.
Beneath the cathedral he restsas a figure shaped as much by
restraint as resolve.
A shepherd's legacy is aboutpresence, care, and conscience.
Quietly watching over a city,he served.
But the next voice's risewithin the Archdiocese would
sound very different.
(22:18):
John Joseph O'Connor arrived inNew York not as a diplomat or
shepherd, but as a commander.
Born in Philadelphia in 1920,O'Connor served as a naval
chaplain during World War II andlater as chief of chaplains in
the U.S.
Navy.
The discipline of the militarylife never left him.
Appointed Archbishop of NewYork in 1984, he brought a
(22:40):
direct, uncompromising publicvoice.
To a church navigating moraluncertainty, O'Connor became one
of the most visible Catholicleaders in America.
He spoke forcefully againstabortion, euthanasia, and
capital punishment, challengingpolitical orthodoxies on both
sides.
During the AIDS crisis, heexpanded care for the sick even
(23:00):
as his moral positions provokedanger and protests beyond these
walls.
He was also among the firstprominent church leaders to
confront clergy's sexual abusepublicly, calling for reform
before the full scope of thecrisis wasn't even known.
His response was imperfect andshaped by institutional limits,
but his refusal to remain silentmarked a shift toward
(23:22):
accountability to the church.
O'Connor died in 2000, closingout the century.
He was buried beneath St.
Patrick's as a man who believedthe moral authority demanded
voice, and that silence, in thepresence of suffering, carried
its own weight.
But the next legacy beneath thecathedral would be defined not
by voice, but by reckoning.
(23:42):
Edward Egan's tenure was briefand burdened.
A scholar and Vatican diplomat,Egan became archbishop at a
dawn of a century already markedby fracture.
During his leadership, theclergy abuse crisis erupted in a
public view, testing thechurch's credibility, its
compassion, and its capacity fortruth.
His responses drew sharpcriticism.
(24:05):
In later years, Eganacknowledged failures in how the
crisis was first handled, anadmission that came too late for
many who had already beenharmed.
He retired in 2009 and died in2015.
His presence in the cryptstands as a reminder that not
all legacies grow gentler withtime, and that institutions,
(24:25):
like cathedrals, cast longshadows over those who lead
them.
And yet not every voiceconnected to this place spoke
from the altar.
Some spoke from the airwaves.
Fulton Sheen didn't need stonewalls to be heard.
His voice traveled throughwires and waves into living
rooms and late night silence,even as he remained at times
alone in the presence of power.
(24:46):
Born Peter John Sheen in 1895in El Paso, Illinois, he took
the name Fulton from his mother.
From an early age he showedbrilliance and devotion,
surviving childhoodtuberculosis, excelling in
school, and answering the callto priesthood.
By the 1920s, he was already acelebrated theologian, earning
the Cardinal Mercer Prize inPhilosophy and teaching at the
(25:09):
Catholic University of America.
Sheen's voice would eventuallyreach far beyond the classroom.
For two decades, he captivatedthe nation on radio and then on
television with Life is WorthLiving and the Fulton Sheen
program.
His golden voice in charismadrew audiences of millions, many
non-Catholics, and won him EmmyAwards.
(25:30):
He converted prominent figures,challenged world leaders, and
wielded words like a sword,reading Shakespeare to rally
against Stalin, calling the Axispowers agents of evil, and
insisting that holiness mustconfront sin directly.
Yet for all his fame, Sheen wasno stranger to conflict.
Within the church hisbrilliance clashed with
(25:51):
authority, Cardinal FrancisSpelman, then head of the
Archdiocese of New York,pressured Sheen over funds
donated to missions, leading toSheen's removal from television
and the eventual reassignment asBishop of Rochester.
Sheen accepted the movequietly, referring only vaguely
to trials inside and outside thechurch.
But his independence and moralinsistence left a mark on those
(26:15):
who knew the truth.
As Bishop of Rochester, Sheencontinued to challenge injustice
and champion ecumenicaldialogue, but not without
friction.
His attempts to use parishproperty for affordable housing
for black residents were metwith protest and disagreement, a
rare instance where hisidealism collided with both
buiocracy and public opinion.
(26:35):
Sheen's final years weredevoted to writing, prayer, and
teaching.
He authored more than 70 booksand countless articles,
remaining faithful to his beliefthat truth could be
communicated to the hearts ofordinary people, whether in
living rooms across America orquiet study halls.
He died in 1979 praying beforethe Blessed Sacrament in his
(26:56):
private chapel, originallyinterred in St.
Patrick's Cathedral near theArchbishops of New York.
His remains were latertransferred to his home diocese
of Peoria, Illinois.
After a long legal andestolastical dispute, Sheen's
wrote to Sainthood continues tothis day.
He's now styled venerable,recognized for heroic virtue,
through his debates about hislife and decisions, particularly
(27:19):
the moments of church politics.
Here lies a man who met themodern world without fear, who
spoke to millions, and whononetheless knew the solitude of
conscious.
Together these men lie beneathSaint Patrick's, visionaries,
administrators, shepherds, andpower brokers.
Above them, sunlight poursthrough stained glass, painting
the stone in colors of devotion.
(27:41):
Below them, history murmursrestless and unresolved for
some.
And yet as you pause before onename in the crypt, something
immediately feels different.
There's no title carved besideit, no bishop, no archbishop, no
cardinal, only a man who livedhis faith in action, whose quiet
charity opened doors and heartsalike.
(28:03):
Pierre Toussaint is the onlylayperson buried beneath the
high altar of St.
Patrick's Cathedral.
A quiet disruption in a spacelong reserved for power.
He was born into slavery in1766 in Saint Domingue, now
modern-day Haiti.
His great grandmother was takenfrom Africa and sold into
bondage.
His grandmother and his motherfollowed.
(28:25):
Raised Catholic on theplantation along the Artibanite
River, Pierre learned faithearly, not as comfort but as
endurance.
When revolution swept Haiti, hewas carried north with his
enslavers, arriving in New YorkCity at the end of the 18th
century, a city that condemnedslavery in theory while
practicing it in life.
Harry was apprenticed as ahairdresser, styling the
(28:48):
powdered wigs and careful curlsof Manhattan's elite.
He dressed the wealthy whileliving without freedom.
Pierre was not freed bypurchase or petition.
In 1807, as the woman whoenslaved him lay dying, she made
her husband promise that Pierrewould be free.
After her death, that promisewas kept.
Toussaint walked into freedomnot by Law's generosity, but
(29:11):
from a vow made at the edge of agrave.
What followed was notbitterness, but resolve.
Toussaint became one of NewYork's most sought-after
hairdressers, serving Protestantwomen who admired his
gentleness, discipline, andunfailing charity.
Many called him Saint Pierre,long before Rome ever considered
the name.
With his earnings, he purchasedhis sister's freedom.
(29:33):
He then later secured thefreedom of the woman he loved,
Juliette Noel, and the two builta life together, bound by love
and devotion.
Together they turned to theirhome into a refuge.
They sheltered orphans,educated foster children, fed
the hungry, cared for yellowfever victims when others fled
the city.
Pierre attended daily mass formore than sixty years, not here,
(29:56):
but at St.
Peter's, because segregationand custom often push black
Catholics to the margins ofparish life.
And here is the quietcontradiction that follows him
into the crypt.
Pierre Toussaint helped fundCatholic institutions that would
not admit children of his ownrace.
He raised money for orphansthat excluded black children.
He supported schools thatbarred black students.
(30:19):
He gave away, not because thesystem was just, but because the
need was real.
His charity didn't wait forpermission to be righteous.
He helped finance old St.
Patrick's Cathedral on MulberryStreet.
He organized informal creditnetworks, found work and housing
for Haitian refugees.
Long before Catholic charitieshad a name, Pierre Saint was
(30:42):
doing its work withoutauthority, without security,
without recognition.
When he died in 1853, at theage of 87, his funeral filled
the church.
The poor stood behind thepowerful, like mourners beside
New York's elite.
He was buried quietly besidehis wife and adopted daughter.
More than a century later,though, his body was exhumed.
(31:03):
As the church opened his causefor sainthood, Pierre Toussaint
was interred here, beneath themain altar of St.
Patrick's Cathedral, the firstand only lay person ever granted
that honor.
Not because he commanded, notbecause he governed, but because
he served.
In a crypt filled with men whowielded authority, Pierre
Toussaint represents somethingrarer.
(31:24):
Holiness without office, faithwithout recognition, charity
practice inside an unjust worldwithout pretending it was fair.
Above him, the cathedral risesin marble and light.
Around him lie the princes ofthe church, yet it's Pierre
Toussaint, once enslaved, onceexcluded, who rests the closest
(31:44):
to the altar.
In 1997 he was declaredvenerable by Pope John Paul II,
a milestone on the path towardssainthood for a man many
believed already lived in.
His grave reminds us that thegift of giving, even after
enduring human cruelty, ismeasured not in wealth or title,
but in deeds.
Despite its hauntinglybeautiful grounds, St.
(32:06):
Patrick's Cathedral is notknown for restless spirits or
wandering shades.
That may disappoint some, butfor those hoping to wed within
its walls, perhaps it's ablessing.
For many, St.
Patrick's means midnight mass,a tourist stop or gothic
masterpiece.
Yet for the cardinals whoserved within its soaring nave,
(32:27):
it has become a place of eternalrest, beneath its spires,
tucked into the quiet shadows ofits crypt.
For now the stories of St.
Patrick slid back into thegleaming gothic marble, and the
dead return to their uneasyrest.
Yet they're never silent forlong.
Thank you for walking with usthrough the veil into the crypt
in St.
Patrick's Cathedral, descendingonce more into the hauntings of
(32:50):
history.
The gate is sealed, the veildrawn, yet death keeps no
calendar, and so we shallreturn, as we always do, on the
grim.
Grim morning and welcome to the Grim.
I'm your host, Kristin.
On today's episode, we'll beopening the gate and entering
the crypt in St.
Patrick's Cathedral, located inNew York City, New York.
The aroma of coffee mingles inthe air.
The gates stand open.
Step carefully.
It's starting to descend intothe hauntings of history.
(00:34):
It's the week of Christmas,dear listeners, if you
celebrate.
As the season settles in, manymake their way to the Big Apple,
drawn by a city that knows howto dress itself in life.
New York gleams in December,its streets draped in garland
and tinsel reflections, alivewith anticipation, and the cold
air curling like smoke aroundhurried footsteps.
(00:57):
Rockefeller Center is often thefirst pilgrimage.
Central Park follows, hushedbeneath winter's weight, and
then their St.
Patrick's Cathedral, risingpale and unyielding along Fifth
Avenue.
Its gothic spires cuttingthrough the glow of storefronts
and traffic, like somethingolder, steadier, and indifferent
to the season's spectacle.
(01:18):
Some of you might be among theparishioners who often return
year after year, quietlysecuring your place at midnight
mass as part of a traditionpassed down through family and
faith.
Others may watch from home, thesoft glow of Christmas trees
reflecting in your screen,listening as bells echo into the
cold night.
However, you arrive, throughbronze doors or by the way of
(01:40):
live stream, the cathedralwelcomes millions each year,
drawn not only by its beauty butby the quiet promise of
belonging.
But tonight we're not here forits beauty, nor its midnight
mass.
We're here for what liesbeneath.
More than twenty archbishopsand cardinals are buried below
St.
Patrick's Cathedral.
Their remains sealed withinbrick-lined crypts and marble
(02:02):
tombs.
Names once spoken withauthority and reverence now
survive only in engraved stone.
Hughes, Farley, Spellden, andCoop.
There were shepherds of a cityswollen with immigrants and
grief, men who presided overChristmas masses, while
influenza crept through itstenements, while telegrams
delivered news of lost soulsoverseas, while hunger lingered
(02:24):
and fires devoured entireblocks, and death they remained
where they served, directlybelow the altar.
Before we descend into thecrypts, we must first understand
the story of the cathedralabove them, its ambition, its
trials, and the hands that builtit.
The Diocese of New York wasfounded in 1808 by Pope Pius
VII, and soon after St.
(02:46):
Patrick's was established toserve the city's small but
growing Catholic population.
The original St.
Patrick's, what's now calledthe Old Cathedral, was dedicated
in 1850 on Mulberry Street,accommodating just 15,000
Catholics at the time, but bythe mid-19th century the
Catholic community had swelledto more than 200,000, many of
(03:08):
them Irish immigrants fleeingfamine and hardship.
The Old Cathedral, though,could no longer hold them.
In 1810, a parcel of land onFifth Avenue, between 50th and
51st Street, was purchased bythe Reverend Anthony Coleman.
At the time it lay far north ofthe city proper, a quiet rocky
stretch of ground whereManhattan thinned into the
(03:29):
countryside.
A Jesuit college rose there,along with a small chapel
dedicated to St.
Ignatius.
Its presence modest butdeliberate.
By 1840, the diocese repurposedthe property, transforming it
into a parish church andorphanage.
Trappist monks fleeingpersecution in France care for
the children until their returnhome in 1815.
(03:51):
Around them, the neighborhoodremained sparse, early streets
sketched into stone and dirt,hinting at a future not yet
imagined.
By 1850, Archbishop John JosephHughes understood the growing
Catholic population could nolonger be contained by its
downtown cathedral.
He envisioned something bolder,a Gothic monument rising along
(04:12):
Fifth Avenue, a dedication offaith and permanence in a city
where Catholics were still metwith suspicion and hostility.
In 1853, Hughes commissionedthe architectural firm of
Renwick and Rodrigue, entrustingthe project to James Renwick
Jr., a young architect deeplyinfluenced by the great
cathedrals of Europe, includingCologne.
(04:33):
Renwick's original plans weregrand with soaring spires,
flying buttresses, and anelaborate ambulatory, yet
ambitions soon met with reality.
Hughes requested modifications,scaling the design to make room
for clergy residences, andremoving several buttresses and
chapels.
Even so, when the cornerstonewas laid on August 15, 1858,
(04:56):
more than 100,000 peoplegathered.
A crowd drawn not just byceremony, but to the promise of
what this building would become.
But such ambition came at acost.
Money was always a problem.
From the beginning, thiscathedral was built in defiance
of scarcity.
James Renwick insisted on whitemarble, stone quarried from
Pleasantville, New York.
(05:17):
Beautiful, durable, andruinously expensive.
Fronton blocks were hauled intoplace as foundations were
carved into shallow bedrock.
Progress though was slow,painfully slow, and then came
the setbacks.
A stonecutter's strike broughtthe work to a standstill, and
then the Civil War erupted.
Construction stoppedaltogether.
(05:38):
Archbishop John Hughes, thecathedral's great champion,
would never see its completion.
When he died, the burden passedto those who followed.
Men like John McCulski, whoinherited not just an unfinished
church, but an unfinishedpromise.
They raised money where theycould, negotiated contracts, and
refused to let the projectcollapse under its own weight.
(05:59):
By the late 1860s, the wallsfinally began to rise again.
Marble climbed skyward alongFifth Avenue.
Stained glass, some of it oncedisplayed at the World's Fair,
was set into place.
Washing the nave in muted reds,blues, and golds.
The roof was then laid down.
Scaffolding filled the interiorlike a skeleton waiting for its
(06:19):
flesh.
And then on November 29, 1877,the doors opened, unfinished,
unpolished, but standing.
Fundraisers in the year thatfollowed drew crowds by the
hundreds of thousands, and in1879, St.
Patrick's Cathedral wasformally dedicated, not as a
monument to wealth or ease, butas a testament to endurance,
(06:42):
faith, and survival.
Every stone, every pane ofglass, every detail, from the
vaulted ceilings above to thecrypts below, tells a story of
ambition and struggle.
This is a cathedral shaped byhands hardened by labor and by
hearts hardened throughprejudice, loss, and
persistence.
It's in this context that thespaces beneath the cathedral
(07:04):
take on their full meaning.
The new St.
Patrick's Cathedral officiallyopened on May 25, 1879, attended
by 35 bishops and sixarchbishops.
The reaction was swift anddivided.
Some newspapers were openlyadmiring.
The Baltimore Sun called St.
Patrick's the finest churchedifice on the American
(07:24):
continent.
Others, though, were far lessgenerous.
Journalist Clarence Cookdismissed the facade as
repetitive, the interior aspaltry.
Criticisms that years later,architectural historian Robert
A.
M.
Stern would argue were rootedless in design and more in
religious and ethnic prejudice.
But praise or protests thecathedral endured.
(07:45):
Alongside Temple and Manuel,St.
Patrick's claimed a place onMidtown Fifth Avenue, making it
one of the first non-Protestanthouses of worship to rise there,
at a time when the neighborhooditself was still on the city's
margins.
It was not being merely justjudged, it was being allowed, or
not, to belong.
James Renwick Jr.
(08:05):
continued shaping thecathedral's world beyond its
walls.
He designed the Archbishop'shouse and rectory on Madison
Avenue.
Buildings meant to anchor thechurch's presence nearby.
Even these drew criticism.
Their dormant windows weremocked as absurd, reminders that
scrutiny followed the cathedralin every form it took.
Money once again slowedeverything.
(08:28):
The spires, those unmistakabletwin towers, were delayed for
years.
Only in 1885 were the fundsfinally secured.
Three years later, in Octoberof 1888, they rose at last,
towering over Fifth Avenue,briefly becoming the tall
structures in New York City, adeclaration at last, that the
(08:48):
cathedral was not temporary, itwas here to stay.
Inside, however, the workremained unfinished, a ceiling
of plaster and wood, but only asa placeholder was never
replaced.
Shortages persisted.
Completion was always just outof reach.
The bells then came next,tested in 1889, then replaced by
(09:09):
a French set blessed in 1897.
Their number eventually grew to19, more than any other church
in the city.
The cathedral might have beenincomplete, but it would no
longer be quiet.
At the turn of the century, onefinal promise remained
unfulfilled.
In 1899, Margaret A.
Kelly left $200,000 for theconstruction of Lady Chapel,
(09:32):
stipulating it be built onlyafter her death.
It was an act of faithdeferred, a gift meant for the
future she would never see.
Architect Charles T.
Matthews was chosen to bringthe chapel to life.
He traveled through Europe,studying shrines and sanctuaries
shaped by his centuries ofdevotion.
When construction began in1901, it was with the
(09:53):
understanding that this wouldnot merely be an addition, but a
cultimation.
On Christmas Day in 1906, thefirst Mass was celebrated within
the Lady Chapel.
By 1908, its interior wascomplete, at a cost far
exceeding its original bequest.
And at last, in 1910, thecathedral's long-standing debt
(10:14):
was cleared.
After decades of delay,interruption, and unfinished
work, St.
Patrick's Cathedral was finallyready.
On October 5, 1910, it wasformally consecrated.
And yet for all those years oflabor and longing, the cathedral
began with loss.
The first man laid to restbeneath St.
Patrick's never lived to see itfinished.
(10:35):
John Joseph Hughes, New York'sfirst archbishop, was born in
Ireland in 1797 and ordained atMaynooth College in 1817.
He arrived in New York in 1826as a young priest in a city raw
with prejudice, where Irishimmigrants poured ashore hungry
and exhausted, and theanti-Catholic sentiment simmered
(10:57):
openly in the streets.
Hughes just didn't join them,though, he became their
defender.
He founded schools, establishedparishes, and fought
relentlessly for a community thecity often wished would
disappear.
His fiery temperament andrefusal to yield earned him the
nickname Dagger John, areference to the cross-shaped
slash that cut through hissignature like a blade.
(11:19):
In 1842, Hughes was named thefirst Archbishop of New York.
From that moment on, hecommitted himself to a single
unyielding vision, a cathedralthat would stand in plain sight,
permanent, visible, immovable,within a city openly hostile to
its presence.
For more than twenty years heendured skepticism, financial
(11:41):
strain, and the slow agony ofconstruction, all ministering to
a population shaped by famine,poverty, riots, and war.
When Hughes died in January in1864, the Civil War still raged.
The walls of St.
Patrick stood unfinished.
He never saw Christmas lightsalong Fifth Avenue, never heard
(12:02):
midnight mass echo through themarble vaults.
What he knew instead werefamine ships heavy with grief,
draft riots fueled by hatred,and a city unsure whether
Catholics or their churchestruly belonged.
He was laid to rest beneath thehigh altar of the cathedral
that existed more in faith thanin stone.
(12:22):
What rose above Fifth Avenueafter his death was not simply a
cathedral, but a convictionmade permanent, when buried with
him beneath its walls.
If Hughes was fire, JohnMcCulski was endurance.
Born in Brooklyn in 1810 toIrish immigrant parents,
McCulski grew up in a hardshipso complete that there was no
(12:42):
Catholic Church in his boroughat all, as the boy he rode
across the East River just toattend Mass in Manhattan, a
small but stubborn act thatwould define the rest of his
life.
A near fatal accident on hisfamily farm later left him frail
and temporarily blind.
It was a quiet brush withmorality that lingered, shaping
his restraint and caution longafter his strength returned.
(13:05):
He studied at Mount St.
Mary's in Emmitsburg, where hebecame known for being measured,
thoughtful, and disciplined.
Ordained in 1834, McCulskiserved wherever he was needed.
Old St.
Patrick's Cathedral, BellevueHospital, St.
Joseph's Seminary.
When he traveled to Rome, hereturned not with ambition, but
with perspective, and thepatience to wait.
(13:27):
In 1847, he was named the firstbishop of Albany, charged with
shepherding a vast andimpoverished diocese of
immigrants.
He built what was necessary: churches, schools, orphanages, (13:35):
undefined
seminaries.
Among them rose the Cathedralof the Immaculate Conception.
Foundations laid not forspectacle but for survival.
After Hugh's death, Mikulskyreluctantly took on leadership
of the New York Archdiocese.
Under his quiet stewardship,construction of the new St.
(13:56):
Patrick's resumed after theCivil War.
In 1875, he became the firstAmerican cardinal, a recognition
not just of one man, but of afaith that endured long enough
to be acknowledged.
His health though was fragile.
Illness returned again andagain.
Still Mikulski pressed on,expanding the archdiocese,
(14:17):
establishing 88 new parishes,and guiding New York's Catholics
through a city that remainedwary of them.
When he died in 1885, he leftbehind institutions meant to
outlast him.
Today he rests beneath the mainaltar, a quiet custodian of the
Marvel Knave and soaring towershe helped bring into being.
When McCulski governed gently,Michael Augustine Corrigan
(14:40):
governed firmly.
Born in Newark in 1839, thefifth of nine children of Irish
immigrants, Corrigan was shapedby discipline and education.
His father's successfulbusiness afforded him
opportunities rare for immigrantfamilies.
Studies in Wilmington,Emmitsburg, and Europe,
cultivating in the ordation atthe Basilica of St.
(15:00):
John Lateran in Rome in 1863.
Corrigan returned to America asa scholar and administrator.
He taught theology, led SeatonHall, and at just 34 became the
youngest Catholic bishop in theUnited States.
In 1880, he was namedcoadjunctor to McCloskey, and
five years later Archbishop ofNew York.
(15:21):
His tenure, though, was markedby tension, a committed
conservative at Corganchampioned parochial schools and
national parishes, oftenclashing with clergy who
flavored more of an Americanizedchurch.
His conflict with Father EdwardMcGlynn, whose labor activism
led to removal and temporaryexcommunication, divided the
city and exposed fault lineswithin the Catholic leadership.
(15:44):
Corrigan's treatment of Italianimmigrants drew criticism as
well, relegating many debasementchapels apart from Irish
congregations.
Yet even he bented times.
In 1889, he welcomed MotherFrances Xavier Cabrini and her
sisters at the Pope'sinsistence.
Setting in motion one of themost transformative missions in
(16:05):
American Catholic history,Gorrigan oversaw the
construction of St.
Joseph's Seminary at Dunwoodyand strengthened the diocese
structures across a rapidlychanging city.
When he died in 1902, he leftbehind an archdiocese reshaped
by authority, conflict, andinstitutional strength.
He remains though a complicatedpresence in the crypt, a
(16:27):
reminder that faith is notpracticed outside of power, but
within it.
Beneath the high altar, thecrypt becomes a ledger, not only
of faith, but of influence.
Here lie the men who shapedCatholic life in New York as the
city grew louder, richer, moredivided, and more visible to the
world.
John Murphy Farley entered acathedral finally risen from
(16:49):
decades of struggle, and anarchdiocese still learning how
to stand.
Born in Ireland in 1842, heimmigrated to the United States
as a child.
He studied for priesthood inFrance and Rome, gaining a
perspective that stretched farbeyond New York City's streets.
Ordained in 1870, he movedsteadily through the church's
hierarchy, eventually becomingArchbishop of New York in 1902
(17:13):
following Corrigan's death.
Farley's most enduring act wasconsecration.
On October 5, 1910, more than50 years after the cornerstone
was first laid, he formallyconsecrated St.
Patrick's Cathedral.
At last, he whose vision wasrealized, a cathedral complete,
a church present, permanent, andrespected in the heart of the
(17:35):
city.
He guided the archdiocesethrough ways of immigration,
labor unrest, and the openingyears of World War I.
He expanded charitableinstitutions and new parishes,
balancing growth with diplomacy,never seeking spectacle, but
always insisting on steadiness.
When he died in 1918, the citymourned quietly.
(17:55):
He rests out beneath thecathedral he helped finish, a
figure whose legacy is notmeasured in stone but in
completion, and the final act ofbringing a decades-long dream
to rest.
After Farley, Patrick JosephHayes took office in the shadow
of war and pandemic.
Born in Manhattan in 1867,Hayes was New York bred, shaped
(18:17):
by its neighborhoods and itsstreets.
Ordained in Rome, he returnedto serve as Chancellor of the
Archdiocese and later Bishop ofPittsburgh before becoming
Archbishop of New York in 1919.
He guided the church throughthe roaring twenties and the
Great Depression, years ofaccess and collapse.
He expanded Catholic education,strengthened relief efforts,
(18:40):
and cautiously supported laborrights.
Hayes valued order anddiscipline, and in a world
teetering on chaos, he providedit.
His mark of the skyline wastangible.
The seminary of the ImmaculateConception in Huntington, and
the Catholic Center near St.
Patrick's, buildings thatdeclared permanence in uncertain
times.
When he died in 1938, the cityteetered on another brink of
(19:04):
global war.
He rest beneath a cathedralthat became more than a church,
a civic gathering place in timesof fear.
No figure in the crypt thoughcast a longer shadow than
Spellman.
Born in Massachusetts in 1889,Spellman rose with remarkable
speed.
Educated in Rome, fluent inVatican politics, he became an
(19:25):
Archbishop of New York in 1939and a cardinal shortly after.
He inherited an archdiocese onthe brink of World War II and
transformed it into a globalcenter of Catholic influence.
Spellman was not a quietshepherd, he was a power broker,
a commandant of presidents, anda constant presence at the
White House.
(19:45):
Roosevelt, Eisenhower, Kennedy.
His relationships tied thechurch to national life itself.
During World War II and theKorean War, he traveled
extensively to visit Americantroops, earning the nickname the
G.I.'s Cardinal.
Anti-communist, he later drewcriticism for supporting the
Vietnam War.
Under Spellman, schools,hospitals, and universities
(20:08):
multiplied.
Authority was centralized,dissent often contained.
Admirers saw strength, criticssaw secrecy.
When he died in 1967, he leftan empire, vast, efficient, and
deeply influential.
Beneath the altar, he rests asa reminder of how closely faith
and power once walked together,and how difficult they are to
(20:30):
separate.
After the G.
I's Cardinal Terence James Cookcouldn't have been a more
different figurehead of thechurch.
Born in New York City in 1921,Cook came of age in the church
in transition.
Ordained in 1945, he roseduring the era of the Vatican
II, embracing reform, humility,and pastoral outreach.
(20:51):
When he became Archbishop ofNew York in 1968, he inherited a
church unsettled by war, civicrights struggles, and internal
fracture.
Cook rejected spectacles andfavored presence.
Under his guidance, theArchdiocese expanded ministries
to prisoners, immigrants, andthe chronically ill.
The long-standing Flower FifthAvenue Hospital was renamed the
(21:13):
Terrence Cardinal CookHealthcare Center, gearing his
name into the city's mission ofcare for the vulnerable.
More than a brick or policy,his work was about attention,
compassion, and steady guidance.
Yet gentleness didn't shieldhim from controversy.
His firm adherence to churchteachings on sexuality and
authority sometimes put him atodds with the progressive clergy
(21:36):
and those pressing for rapidchange.
He governed quietly butdecisively, earning both loyalty
and criticism.
Cook died of leukemia in 1983.
Devotion to his memory grewquickly.
In 1992, the Catholic Churchformally opened his cause for
sainthood, recognizing him as aservant of God, a steadfore
(21:57):
decantonization that honors theholiness many saw in his life.
Beneath the cathedral he restsas a figure shaped as much by
restraint as resolve.
A shepherd's legacy is aboutpresence, care, and conscience.
Quietly watching over a city,he served.
But the next voice's risewithin the Archdiocese would
sound very different.
(22:18):
John Joseph O'Connor arrived inNew York not as a diplomat or
shepherd, but as a commander.
Born in Philadelphia in 1920,O'Connor served as a naval
chaplain during World War II andlater as chief of chaplains in
the U.S.
Navy.
The discipline of the militarylife never left him.
Appointed Archbishop of NewYork in 1984, he brought a
(22:40):
direct, uncompromising publicvoice.
To a church navigating moraluncertainty, O'Connor became one
of the most visible Catholicleaders in America.
He spoke forcefully againstabortion, euthanasia, and
capital punishment, challengingpolitical orthodoxies on both
sides.
During the AIDS crisis, heexpanded care for the sick even
(23:00):
as his moral positions provokedanger and protests beyond these
walls.
He was also among the firstprominent church leaders to
confront clergy's sexual abusepublicly, calling for reform
before the full scope of thecrisis wasn't even known.
His response was imperfect andshaped by institutional limits,
but his refusal to remain silentmarked a shift toward
(23:22):
accountability to the church.
O'Connor died in 2000, closingout the century.
He was buried beneath St.
Patrick's as a man who believedthe moral authority demanded
voice, and that silence, in thepresence of suffering, carried
its own weight.
But the next legacy beneath thecathedral would be defined not
by voice, but by reckoning.
(23:42):
Edward Egan's tenure was briefand burdened.
A scholar and Vatican diplomat,Egan became archbishop at a
dawn of a century already markedby fracture.
During his leadership, theclergy abuse crisis erupted in a
public view, testing thechurch's credibility, its
compassion, and its capacity fortruth.
His responses drew sharpcriticism.
(24:05):
In later years, Eganacknowledged failures in how the
crisis was first handled, anadmission that came too late for
many who had already beenharmed.
He retired in 2009 and died in2015.
His presence in the cryptstands as a reminder that not
all legacies grow gentler withtime, and that institutions,
(24:25):
like cathedrals, cast longshadows over those who lead
them.
And yet not every voiceconnected to this place spoke
from the altar.
Some spoke from the airwaves.
Fulton Sheen didn't need stonewalls to be heard.
His voice traveled throughwires and waves into living
rooms and late night silence,even as he remained at times
alone in the presence of power.
(24:46):
Born Peter John Sheen in 1895in El Paso, Illinois, he took
the name Fulton from his mother.
From an early age he showedbrilliance and devotion,
surviving childhoodtuberculosis, excelling in
school, and answering the callto priesthood.
By the 1920s, he was already acelebrated theologian, earning
the Cardinal Mercer Prize inPhilosophy and teaching at the
(25:09):
Catholic University of America.
Sheen's voice would eventuallyreach far beyond the classroom.
For two decades, he captivatedthe nation on radio and then on
television with Life is WorthLiving and the Fulton Sheen
program.
His golden voice in charismadrew audiences of millions, many
non-Catholics, and won him EmmyAwards.
(25:30):
He converted prominent figures,challenged world leaders, and
wielded words like a sword,reading Shakespeare to rally
against Stalin, calling the Axispowers agents of evil, and
insisting that holiness mustconfront sin directly.
Yet for all his fame, Sheen wasno stranger to conflict.
Within the church hisbrilliance clashed with
(25:51):
authority, Cardinal FrancisSpelman, then head of the
Archdiocese of New York,pressured Sheen over funds
donated to missions, leading toSheen's removal from television
and the eventual reassignment asBishop of Rochester.
Sheen accepted the movequietly, referring only vaguely
to trials inside and outside thechurch.
But his independence and moralinsistence left a mark on those
(26:15):
who knew the truth.
As Bishop of Rochester, Sheencontinued to challenge injustice
and champion ecumenicaldialogue, but not without
friction.
His attempts to use parishproperty for affordable housing
for black residents were metwith protest and disagreement, a
rare instance where hisidealism collided with both
buiocracy and public opinion.
(26:35):
Sheen's final years weredevoted to writing, prayer, and
teaching.
He authored more than 70 booksand countless articles,
remaining faithful to his beliefthat truth could be
communicated to the hearts ofordinary people, whether in
living rooms across America orquiet study halls.
He died in 1979 praying beforethe Blessed Sacrament in his
(26:56):
private chapel, originallyinterred in St.
Patrick's Cathedral near theArchbishops of New York.
His remains were latertransferred to his home diocese
of Peoria, Illinois.
After a long legal andestolastical dispute, Sheen's
wrote to Sainthood continues tothis day.
He's now styled venerable,recognized for heroic virtue,
through his debates about hislife and decisions, particularly
(27:19):
the moments of church politics.
Here lies a man who met themodern world without fear, who
spoke to millions, and whononetheless knew the solitude of
conscious.
Together these men lie beneathSaint Patrick's, visionaries,
administrators, shepherds, andpower brokers.
Above them, sunlight poursthrough stained glass, painting
the stone in colors of devotion.
(27:41):
Below them, history murmursrestless and unresolved for
some.
And yet as you pause before onename in the crypt, something
immediately feels different.
There's no title carved besideit, no bishop, no archbishop, no
cardinal, only a man who livedhis faith in action, whose quiet
charity opened doors and heartsalike.
(28:03):
Pierre Toussaint is the onlylayperson buried beneath the
high altar of St.
Patrick's Cathedral.
A quiet disruption in a spacelong reserved for power.
He was born into slavery in1766 in Saint Domingue, now
modern-day Haiti.
His great grandmother was takenfrom Africa and sold into
bondage.
His grandmother and his motherfollowed.
(28:25):
Raised Catholic on theplantation along the Artibanite
River, Pierre learned faithearly, not as comfort but as
endurance.
When revolution swept Haiti, hewas carried north with his
enslavers, arriving in New YorkCity at the end of the 18th
century, a city that condemnedslavery in theory while
practicing it in life.
Harry was apprenticed as ahairdresser, styling the
(28:48):
powdered wigs and careful curlsof Manhattan's elite.
He dressed the wealthy whileliving without freedom.
Pierre was not freed bypurchase or petition.
In 1807, as the woman whoenslaved him lay dying, she made
her husband promise that Pierrewould be free.
After her death, that promisewas kept.
Toussaint walked into freedomnot by Law's generosity, but
(29:11):
from a vow made at the edge of agrave.
What followed was notbitterness, but resolve.
Toussaint became one of NewYork's most sought-after
hairdressers, serving Protestantwomen who admired his
gentleness, discipline, andunfailing charity.
Many called him Saint Pierre,long before Rome ever considered
the name.
With his earnings, he purchasedhis sister's freedom.
(29:33):
He then later secured thefreedom of the woman he loved,
Juliette Noel, and the two builta life together, bound by love
and devotion.
Together they turned to theirhome into a refuge.
They sheltered orphans,educated foster children, fed
the hungry, cared for yellowfever victims when others fled
the city.
Pierre attended daily mass formore than sixty years, not here,
(29:56):
but at St.
Peter's, because segregationand custom often push black
Catholics to the margins ofparish life.
And here is the quietcontradiction that follows him
into the crypt.
Pierre Toussaint helped fundCatholic institutions that would
not admit children of his ownrace.
He raised money for orphansthat excluded black children.
He supported schools thatbarred black students.
(30:19):
He gave away, not because thesystem was just, but because the
need was real.
His charity didn't wait forpermission to be righteous.
He helped finance old St.
Patrick's Cathedral on MulberryStreet.
He organized informal creditnetworks, found work and housing
for Haitian refugees.
Long before Catholic charitieshad a name, Pierre Saint was
(30:42):
doing its work withoutauthority, without security,
without recognition.
When he died in 1853, at theage of 87, his funeral filled
the church.
The poor stood behind thepowerful, like mourners beside
New York's elite.
He was buried quietly besidehis wife and adopted daughter.
More than a century later,though, his body was exhumed.
(31:03):
As the church opened his causefor sainthood, Pierre Toussaint
was interred here, beneath themain altar of St.
Patrick's Cathedral, the firstand only lay person ever granted
that honor.
Not because he commanded, notbecause he governed, but because
he served.
In a crypt filled with men whowielded authority, Pierre
Toussaint represents somethingrarer.
(31:24):
Holiness without office, faithwithout recognition, charity
practice inside an unjust worldwithout pretending it was fair.
Above him, the cathedral risesin marble and light.
Around him lie the princes ofthe church, yet it's Pierre
Toussaint, once enslaved, onceexcluded, who rests the closest
(31:44):
to the altar.
In 1997 he was declaredvenerable by Pope John Paul II,
a milestone on the path towardssainthood for a man many
believed already lived in.
His grave reminds us that thegift of giving, even after
enduring human cruelty, ismeasured not in wealth or title,
but in deeds.
Despite its hauntinglybeautiful grounds, St.
(32:06):
Patrick's Cathedral is notknown for restless spirits or
wandering shades.
That may disappoint some, butfor those hoping to wed within
its walls, perhaps it's ablessing.
For many, St.
Patrick's means midnight mass,a tourist stop or gothic
masterpiece.
Yet for the cardinals whoserved within its soaring nave,
(32:27):
it has become a place of eternalrest, beneath its spires,
tucked into the quiet shadows ofits crypt.
For now the stories of St.
Patrick slid back into thegleaming gothic marble, and the
dead return to their uneasyrest.
Yet they're never silent forlong.
Thank you for walking with usthrough the veil into the crypt
in St.
Patrick's Cathedral, descendingonce more into the hauntings of
(32:50):
history.
The gate is sealed, the veildrawn, yet death keeps no
calendar, and so we shallreturn, as we always do, on the
grim.
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
The Joe Rogan Experience
The official podcast of comedian Joe Rogan.
Two Guys, Five Rings: Matt, Bowen & The Olympics
Two Guys (Bowen Yang and Matt Rogers). Five Rings (you know, from the Olympics logo). One essential podcast for the 2026 Milan-Cortina Winter Olympics. Bowen Yang (SNL, Wicked) and Matt Rogers (Palm Royale, No Good Deed) of Las Culturistas are back for a second season of Two Guys, Five Rings, a collaboration with NBC Sports and iHeartRadio. In this 15-episode event, Bowen and Matt discuss the top storylines, obsess over Italian culture, and find out what really goes on in the Olympic Village.