OFF 2 BROADWAY
A podcast where we discuss everything musical theatre, from the comfort of the car. Hosted by Tara & Stefania
Episodes
This week, Tara and Stefania take a detour back in the archives to watch Schmigadoon! They break down Season 1 of the show, comparing their takes to news from the Broadway adaptation, discussing the target audience, classic musical theatre tropes, and potential for re-watchability.
Escape with us into the magic!
.
.
.
"Schmigadoon! " - Schmigadoon! (Apple TV+ Original Series Soundtrack)
"Tribulation" - Schmigadoo...
Tara and Stefania head back to the jazz-age prohibition era to unpack Some Like It Hot on its North American tour. From “boundary-pushing” claims to tap dancing tracks and the man-in-a-dress trope - join us as we dive into this Tony award winning musical!
.
.
.
"Let's Be Bad" - Some Like it Hot (Original Broadway Cast Recording)
"Fly, Mariposa, Fly" - Some Like it Hot (Original Broadway Cast Recording)
"...
The corn fields of the midwest have made their way to Toronto, as Tara and Stefania share their thoughts on Shucked! From contrasts to the Broadway production to the catchy country-inspired music, you butter believe we cover it all. Join us to chat about this a-maize-ing musical 🌽
.
.
.
"Independently Owned" - Shucked (Original Broadway Cast Recording)
"Somebody Will" - Shucked (Original Broadway Cast Recording)
...
We’re SO thrilled to host the founders and creative team behind Shifting Ground Collective! Joshua, Colette, and Shannon share their diverse paths into theatre, the Merrily inspiration behind their company’s name, and why producing musicals feels like the ultimate playground.
Theatre kids, this one's for you! 🎭
.
.
.
"Dress Your Way Up" - The Devil Wears Prada: A New Musical (Original West End Cast Recording)
"I ...
We are thrilled to finally have the impossibly charming George Krissa join us on the podcast! Tara and Stefania chat with our newest Shakespeare about his streak of successful shows, celebrating Canadian artistry and the benefits of settling into a long show run.
Hello, darling! This week, we're heading back to high school to talk about Kimberly Akimbo! Tara and Stefania discuss this both heartwarming and heartbreaking musical, highlighting changes from the New York production, actor-specific writing, and our favourite plot holes that are never addressed. Hop in, join us on this great adventure!
.
.
.
"Better" - Kimberly Akimbo (Original Broadway Cast Recording)
"Father Ti...
It’s 2026 which means it’s time for our way too early Tony nominations! 🏆 This year, we mean WAY TOO EARLY, as we only have 6 new musicals on the docket, and at the time of recording, plenty of casts still unannounced. Join Tara and Stefania for real time google searches and left field guesses we'll laugh at by June!
Join us on the journey!
The curtain falls on another year of theatre, and Tara and Stefania are here to highlight their favourite performances, cast albums and surprises of 2025.
As we look back on our 7th year Off 2 Broadway, we want to extend a heartfelt thank you to everyone who listens, comments and shares our podcast.
See you in 2026! 🎊
& Juliet, the Max Martin megamix musical, is back in Toronto ...one more time! Tara and Stefania were thrilled to sit down with Brandon Antonio and Matt Raffy to hear about epic dance auditions, "pinch me" moments, and making their Broadway debuts.
Join us!
After years in the making, Jon Chu's movie franchise comes to a close with Wicked: For Good released in theatres last month. Tara and Stefania give their thoughts on this emotional journey, speaking about pacing, world expansion and the new musical additions.
Join us one more time as we head down the yellow brick road!
.
.
.
"Thank Goodness/I Couldn't Be Happier" - Wicked: For Good - The Soundtrack
"No Place...
Tara and Stefania are delighted to welcome Fiona Sauder and Matt Pilipiak from Bad Hats Theatre to talk about their upcoming production, Narnia!
Fiona and Matt share the nuances of developing a new musical in Canada, the many hats they wear throughout the production process, and their efforts to make theatre more accessible to all audiences.
Join us on the other side of the wardrobe!
We're wrapping up this year's spooky season with Beetlejuice the musical, as it finds its final resting place back on Broadway. Tara and Stefania recap the whole 'being dead' thing -- from eviction histories to tour sets to their final Broadway run.
Join us one more time in the Netherworld!
.
.
.
"The Whole 'Being Dead' Thing" - Beetlejuice (Original Broadway Cast Recording)
"Main Titles (Beetl...
Let's start off this spooky season with a look back at Death Becomes Her, the new musical comedy! We love a well researched show, and this one gives us life with its spectacular book, special effects and perfectly timed humour.
We promise this show is not just for the gaze - listen now!
.
.
.
"If You Want Perfection" - Death Becomes Her (Original Broadway Cast Recording)
"For The Gaze" - Death Becomes Her (O...
This week's episode is a love letter to Canadian theatre, as we highlight Tell Tale Harbour, a new musical comedy set on the East coast. Tara and Stefania breakdown their use of the classic musical template, Alan Doyle's commitment to this show, and the importance of creating a cast recording to immortalize your work.
.
.
.
"Gotta Go Home" - The Songs of Tell Tale Harbour (Original Cast Recording)
"Real and T...
Tara and Stefania have your scoop on the highlights, drama, and predictions on what will transfer to Broadway this season.
It’s our annual tradition of keeping Sing Street alive, join us!
It looks like an exciting year ahead as Tara and Stefania walk us through the new seasons of theatre in Toronto. They're getting ready to repeat their favourites and expand their repertoire with shows just a road trip away -- join us for the drive!
.
.
.
"Rainbow High" - Evita West End
All music tracks used for educational and entertainment purposes only.
To celebrate their newly released cast recording, we’re bringing you back to NYC as we talk about Just in Time! Tara and Stefania recount the immersive experience of the one and only Jonathan Groff as Bobby Darin. Join us!
.
.
.
"Just in Time" - Just in Time (Original Broadway Cast)
"First Real Love" - Just in Time (Original Broadway Cast)
"Curtain Call Medley" - Just in Time (Original Broadway Cast...
Set sail with us this week as we dive into Shaw Festival's take on Anything Goes! Tara and Stefania had a de-lovely time at this timeless classic, join them for a chat about tap dancing, sets and casting!
.
.
.
"Anything Goes" - Anything Goes (2011 New Broadway Cast Recording)
"It's De-Lovely" - Anything Goes (2011 New Broadway Cast Recording)
"Diet Pepsi" - Live from 2025 Las Culturistas Culture Awards - Single
"Ultimate" - Freak Frida...
This week we're honoured to welcome one of our dream guests to the show -- Hailey Gillis! Hailey joins Tara and Stefania to chat about her history with The Great Comet as well as other Dave Malloy works, and shares what's most special about working in Canadian theatre.
.
.
.
Natasha, Pierre, and The Great Comet of 1812 Trailer | Youtube
All music tracks used for educational and entertainment purposes only.
It’s that time of year again! Tara and Stefania are off to Stratford to review Dirty Rotten Scoundrels and Annie, the two musicals of the season. Hop in and join us for the journey!
.
.
.
"Overture " - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels: Original Broadway Cast Recording
"If You Want Perfection" - Death Becomes Her (Original Broadway Cast Recording)
"Love is my Legs" - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels: Original Broadwa...
Popular Podcasts
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com
The World's Most Dangerous Morning Show, The Breakfast Club, With DJ Envy, Jess Hilarious, And Charlamagne Tha God!
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
The official podcast of comedian Joe Rogan.
The Clay Travis and Buck Sexton Show. Clay Travis and Buck Sexton tackle the biggest stories in news, politics and current events with intelligence and humor. From the border crisis, to the madness of cancel culture and far-left missteps, Clay and Buck guide listeners through the latest headlines and hot topics with fun and entertaining conversations and opinions.