It seems like the drama from Peter Weber's season of The Bachelor is never ending. Since the show ended a few months ago, Peter has broken up with two of the contestants—Hannah Ann Sluss, who he proposed to in the finale, and Madison Prewett, he reunited with on After the Final Rose—and is now believed to have gotten back together with Kelley Flanagan. Both Madison and Hannah Ann have spilled some tea about Peter since their season of The Bachelor wrapped, as well. According to an Us Weekly source, they've been seeing a "completely different side" of their ex.
"The girls from Peter’s season are seeing a completely different side of Peter now from who they knew on the show,” the source explained. “He’s much more laid-back, relaxed and chill. On the show, he was guarded and seemed to be putting on a front.”
While Hannah Ann and Madison aren't fans of this new side, Kelley enjoys this "chill" version of Peter much more than the version of himself he was on the show. Kelley and Peter met at a hotel before season 24 of The Bachelor began filming. “During the show, Kelley noticed Peter was different from what she had remembered when they first met in real life,” the source continued. “Now he’s back to the person she first knew and that’s why she is hanging out with him again.”
Kelley and Peter are now self-isolating together at her apartment in Chicago. This development was upsetting to Madison, who then dished about it on a Bachelor Nation podcast. “I told him kind of what I’m saying,” she recalled in a recent episode. "What I’m confused about, Peter, is two days ago you were telling me how much you loved me and wanted to get back together and now you’re with the one person that was my best friend."
Peter responded to Madison's comments on a fan's Instagram page when they shared Madison's quote. "You’d think you’d have a little more respect for this situation given we both know there’s more to the story," he wrote, tagging Madison in his comment.
We'll just have to wait and see if these contestants from season 24 end up spilling any more tea.
Photo: Getty