November 21, 2024 • 9 mins
Things become curiously deadly on our tour through the Cabinet today.
Order the official Cabinet of Curiosities book by clicking here today, and get ready to enjoy some curious reading!
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:04):
Welcome to Aaron Menke's Cabinet of Curiosities, a production of
iHeartRadio and Grimm and Mild. Our world is full of
the unexplainable, and if history is an open book, all
of these amazing tales are right there on display, just
waiting for us to explore. Welcome to the Cabinet of Curiosities.
(00:36):
Tony Marino thought that he knew what frustration was. But
no matter how hard he worked or how carefully he schemed,
his plans just kept falling apart. It was supposed to
be simple, an easy way to get rid of a
nuisance and get rich in the process. But try as
Tony might, Michael Molloy simply would not die. The whole
thing started late one night in nineteen thirty three in
(00:59):
Tony Marine Knows Bronx Speakeasy. Tony was playing pe knuckle
with the boys. There was Red Murphy, Tony's bartender, Daniel Kriegsberg,
the fruit vendor, and Francis Pasqual the undertaker. As they
placed bets, they talked business, and business was bad. They
was the depths of the depression, and all of the
men were having trouble paying their bills. Wouldn't it be nice,
(01:22):
someone said, if they had a rich aunt or uncle
who died, or even a poor one with a big,
fat life insurance payout. Too bad. None of them had
such luck. And that's when Tony Marino first broached the idea.
Maybe he said they could make their own luck. Pick
someone expendable, someone who lived on the margins, someone nobody
would miss, someone like Michael molloy. Michael was a regular
(01:45):
at the speakeasy. In another life, he'd been a fireman
in Ireland, but now he just stumbled through the bronx
looking for his next drink. The way they saw it,
he was going to drink himself to death anyway, So
who would mind if Tony and the boys just sped
up the process. The gang quickly took an insurance policy
out on poor old Mike for eighteen hundred dollars, the
(02:05):
equivalent of nearly forty four thousand dollars today. They would
be plenty to settle their debts and help them through
the depression. All they had to do was make sure
that Mike died accidentally. The plan was simple. They would
tell old Mike that it was his lucky day. Tony
informed the man that he now had an unlimited tab.
He could drink as much liquor as his liver could handle,
(02:25):
and then some. Now all Tony had to do was
sit back, relax, and wait. But Tony quickly realized that
he would be waiting for a long time. Every night,
Michael drank himself into a stupor at the bar, and
every morning he would reappear ready for another drink. So
Tony and the gang decided to step it up. First,
they gave him bad alcohol. With prohibition in place, there
(02:48):
was plenty of dodgy spirits that Red couldn't serve the customers,
but Michael drank them like they were water. Next, Tony
tried anti freeze, then turpentine, rat poison, and finally ethanol,
the stuff that makes you go blind. The gang even
made Michael a special sandwich equal parts rotten sardines, poison,
and metal tax Michael's iron stomach prevailed. By this point,
(03:13):
they'd been trying to kill Michael for an entire month.
The next payment on the insurance policy was coming up,
and if they didn't kill him soon, the policy might lapse,
so they needed to try something completely different. The next
cold night, Tony waited until Michael drank himself unconscious. He
and the gang dragged Michael out to the park, stripped
him naked, and dumped him in a pile of fresh snow.
(03:35):
They poured water on him and left him to freeze
to death. Of course, Michael was back again in the
morning without even a shiver. A few days later, they
tried yet again. This time they enlisted the help of
a cab driver named Harry Green. They lured Michael out
into the street and had Harry run him down at
forty five miles an hour. Imagine their disappointment when Michael
(03:55):
showed up three weeks later with a couple of broken
bones and demand for more whiskey. Finally, Tony had had enough.
If they were going to kill Michael, they needed to
kill him right. So on February twenty second of nineteen
thirty three, they waited for Michael to drink himself silly.
Once he was out for the night, they brought him
upstairs to Red Murphy's room. They placed a hose in
(04:17):
his mouth, connected it to a gas jet, and turned
it on. An hour later, Michael Malloy was finally truly
and completely dead. Carbon monoxide had finally been the thing
to do him in. With all the attempts on Mike's life,
rumors of an unkillable Irishman were swirling around the Bronx,
so when he was finally declared dead, the police quickly
(04:39):
grew suspicious. Once they exhumed the body, it was easy
enough to spot evidence of foul play, and the culprits
were well known to the citizens of the Bronx with
how often they had tried to kill Mike. All five
were arrested for murder. The cab driver was given a
prison sentence, while Red, Daniel, Francis, and Tony were all
executed for their crimes. Tony and the boys probably thought
(05:01):
that Michael Molloy would be easy money. It turns out
killing Mike was a grave mistake. Sports are an incredibly
(05:22):
popular form of entertainment all around the world. As a result,
sports injuries are just a fact of life. Whether it's
Little league or the major leagues, athletes risk serious harm
to play the games they love. When it comes to baseball,
it's the fans who are the highest risk of injury.
Baseball stands seem like a safe place. The hot dogs,
(05:42):
the drinks, the cheering. Sure people get hurt by a
stray ball from time to time, but no one ever
dies right. Well, a look back at a very unique
baseball game from the early twentieth century might have you
reconsidering your season tickets. The game in question took place
in nineteen oh two in Morristown. Nineteen year old Stanton
Walker was a big baseball fan. There was a baseball
(06:05):
field directly behind his family home. A young sports enthusiast
couldn't ask for a better setup. He and his friends
Frank and Leroy would sit on a fence outside the diamond,
watching the local teams play. Once they were old enough,
they became the official scorekeepers, and with no physical scoreboard,
it fell to the three friends to track every inning.
(06:25):
Now they used old fashioned pencil and paper to accomplish
this task. The only problem was that occasionally that pencil
needed to be sharpened well. On October twenty fifth of
nineteen oh two, Stanton, Leroy, and Frank were all watching
a game from the fence. As usual, Stanton sat in
between Leroy and Frank, and for this game, Frank was
keeping score. When his pencil ran low, he asked lee
(06:48):
Roy if he could borrow his knife to sharpen it.
Leroy obliged, producing his knife and handing it to Stanton
to hand to Frank. Stanton took the knife, gripping the
handle so that the blade was pointed to his body.
Not the safest choice, and at that very moment they
heard the crack of a ball being hit by a
bat and looked up to see a ball flying right
(07:09):
at them. Before they could react, it hit Stanton in
the hand and drove the knife right into his chest.
The blade entered between his ribs, severing an artery below
his heart. He fell from the fence into the grass.
Frank and Leroy jumped down next to him, asking if
he was hurt, but by then it was too late.
(07:30):
He was already dead. Now, some listeners might hear this
tale of a foul ball and suspect foul play, but
Frank and Leroy had at least two full baseball teams
worth of witnesses to back up their story. Each and
every person on that field had their eye on the
ball as it sailed through the air and made fatal
contact with Stanton Walker's hand. It seems that in the
(07:52):
end he was just really unlucky, but luck aside death
in the stands around a baseball diamond are more common
than you might think. A September nineteen twenty eight game
in Ifaca, New York, saw another tragic death when a
player named Carlton Berger hit a foul ball. It went
directly into the stands, where it struck and killed his father.
(08:13):
But if these old school examples just seem like a
case of low safety standards, consider that games have only
gotten more dangerous since the nineteen seventies. This was when
many major league teams in the US began constructing the
massive stadiums that we're familiar with today, with some rising
as high as thirty feet into the air. Several fans
have taken fatal plunges when trying to catch a home run,
(08:35):
soaring above their heads. But even if you survive the fall,
don't look for anyone to pay your medical bills. Many
teams have what's now known in legal circles as the
Baseball Rule. It's printed on the back of your ticket
and it says that the park is not responsible for
any injury sustained from loose balls or bats. And look,
I know that the old song says, take me out
(08:56):
to the ballgame, but it seems like if we're not careful.
We might just get taken out at the ballgame. And
if that happens, I think we can call that curious.
I hope you've enjoyed today's guided tour of the Cabinet
of Curiosities. Subscribe for free on Apple Podcasts, or learn
(09:17):
more about the show by visiting Curiosities podcast dot com.
The show was created by me Aaron Mankey in partnership
with how Stuff Works. I make another award winning show
called Lore, which is a podcast, book series, and television show,
and you can learn all about it over at the
Worldolore dot com. And until next time, stay curious.
Welcome to Aaron Menke's Cabinet of Curiosities, a production of
iHeartRadio and Grimm and Mild. Our world is full of
the unexplainable, and if history is an open book, all
of these amazing tales are right there on display, just
waiting for us to explore. Welcome to the Cabinet of Curiosities.
(00:36):
Tony Marino thought that he knew what frustration was. But
no matter how hard he worked or how carefully he schemed,
his plans just kept falling apart. It was supposed to
be simple, an easy way to get rid of a
nuisance and get rich in the process. But try as
Tony might, Michael Molloy simply would not die. The whole
thing started late one night in nineteen thirty three in
(00:59):
Tony Marine Knows Bronx Speakeasy. Tony was playing pe knuckle
with the boys. There was Red Murphy, Tony's bartender, Daniel Kriegsberg,
the fruit vendor, and Francis Pasqual the undertaker. As they
placed bets, they talked business, and business was bad. They
was the depths of the depression, and all of the
men were having trouble paying their bills. Wouldn't it be nice,
(01:22):
someone said, if they had a rich aunt or uncle
who died, or even a poor one with a big,
fat life insurance payout. Too bad. None of them had
such luck. And that's when Tony Marino first broached the idea.
Maybe he said they could make their own luck. Pick
someone expendable, someone who lived on the margins, someone nobody
would miss, someone like Michael molloy. Michael was a regular
(01:45):
at the speakeasy. In another life, he'd been a fireman
in Ireland, but now he just stumbled through the bronx
looking for his next drink. The way they saw it,
he was going to drink himself to death anyway, So
who would mind if Tony and the boys just sped
up the process. The gang quickly took an insurance policy
out on poor old Mike for eighteen hundred dollars, the
(02:05):
equivalent of nearly forty four thousand dollars today. They would
be plenty to settle their debts and help them through
the depression. All they had to do was make sure
that Mike died accidentally. The plan was simple. They would
tell old Mike that it was his lucky day. Tony
informed the man that he now had an unlimited tab.
He could drink as much liquor as his liver could handle,
(02:25):
and then some. Now all Tony had to do was
sit back, relax, and wait. But Tony quickly realized that
he would be waiting for a long time. Every night,
Michael drank himself into a stupor at the bar, and
every morning he would reappear ready for another drink. So
Tony and the gang decided to step it up. First,
they gave him bad alcohol. With prohibition in place, there
(02:48):
was plenty of dodgy spirits that Red couldn't serve the customers,
but Michael drank them like they were water. Next, Tony
tried anti freeze, then turpentine, rat poison, and finally ethanol,
the stuff that makes you go blind. The gang even
made Michael a special sandwich equal parts rotten sardines, poison,
and metal tax Michael's iron stomach prevailed. By this point,
(03:13):
they'd been trying to kill Michael for an entire month.
The next payment on the insurance policy was coming up,
and if they didn't kill him soon, the policy might lapse,
so they needed to try something completely different. The next
cold night, Tony waited until Michael drank himself unconscious. He
and the gang dragged Michael out to the park, stripped
him naked, and dumped him in a pile of fresh snow.
(03:35):
They poured water on him and left him to freeze
to death. Of course, Michael was back again in the
morning without even a shiver. A few days later, they
tried yet again. This time they enlisted the help of
a cab driver named Harry Green. They lured Michael out
into the street and had Harry run him down at
forty five miles an hour. Imagine their disappointment when Michael
(03:55):
showed up three weeks later with a couple of broken
bones and demand for more whiskey. Finally, Tony had had enough.
If they were going to kill Michael, they needed to
kill him right. So on February twenty second of nineteen
thirty three, they waited for Michael to drink himself silly.
Once he was out for the night, they brought him
upstairs to Red Murphy's room. They placed a hose in
(04:17):
his mouth, connected it to a gas jet, and turned
it on. An hour later, Michael Malloy was finally truly
and completely dead. Carbon monoxide had finally been the thing
to do him in. With all the attempts on Mike's life,
rumors of an unkillable Irishman were swirling around the Bronx,
so when he was finally declared dead, the police quickly
(04:39):
grew suspicious. Once they exhumed the body, it was easy
enough to spot evidence of foul play, and the culprits
were well known to the citizens of the Bronx with
how often they had tried to kill Mike. All five
were arrested for murder. The cab driver was given a
prison sentence, while Red, Daniel, Francis, and Tony were all
executed for their crimes. Tony and the boys probably thought
(05:01):
that Michael Molloy would be easy money. It turns out
killing Mike was a grave mistake. Sports are an incredibly
(05:22):
popular form of entertainment all around the world. As a result,
sports injuries are just a fact of life. Whether it's
Little league or the major leagues, athletes risk serious harm
to play the games they love. When it comes to baseball,
it's the fans who are the highest risk of injury.
Baseball stands seem like a safe place. The hot dogs,
(05:42):
the drinks, the cheering. Sure people get hurt by a
stray ball from time to time, but no one ever
dies right. Well, a look back at a very unique
baseball game from the early twentieth century might have you
reconsidering your season tickets. The game in question took place
in nineteen oh two in Morristown. Nineteen year old Stanton
Walker was a big baseball fan. There was a baseball
(06:05):
field directly behind his family home. A young sports enthusiast
couldn't ask for a better setup. He and his friends
Frank and Leroy would sit on a fence outside the diamond,
watching the local teams play. Once they were old enough,
they became the official scorekeepers, and with no physical scoreboard,
it fell to the three friends to track every inning.
(06:25):
Now they used old fashioned pencil and paper to accomplish
this task. The only problem was that occasionally that pencil
needed to be sharpened well. On October twenty fifth of
nineteen oh two, Stanton, Leroy, and Frank were all watching
a game from the fence. As usual, Stanton sat in
between Leroy and Frank, and for this game, Frank was
keeping score. When his pencil ran low, he asked lee
(06:48):
Roy if he could borrow his knife to sharpen it.
Leroy obliged, producing his knife and handing it to Stanton
to hand to Frank. Stanton took the knife, gripping the
handle so that the blade was pointed to his body.
Not the safest choice, and at that very moment they
heard the crack of a ball being hit by a
bat and looked up to see a ball flying right
(07:09):
at them. Before they could react, it hit Stanton in
the hand and drove the knife right into his chest.
The blade entered between his ribs, severing an artery below
his heart. He fell from the fence into the grass.
Frank and Leroy jumped down next to him, asking if
he was hurt, but by then it was too late.
(07:30):
He was already dead. Now, some listeners might hear this
tale of a foul ball and suspect foul play, but
Frank and Leroy had at least two full baseball teams
worth of witnesses to back up their story. Each and
every person on that field had their eye on the
ball as it sailed through the air and made fatal
contact with Stanton Walker's hand. It seems that in the
(07:52):
end he was just really unlucky, but luck aside death
in the stands around a baseball diamond are more common
than you might think. A September nineteen twenty eight game
in Ifaca, New York, saw another tragic death when a
player named Carlton Berger hit a foul ball. It went
directly into the stands, where it struck and killed his father.
(08:13):
But if these old school examples just seem like a
case of low safety standards, consider that games have only
gotten more dangerous since the nineteen seventies. This was when
many major league teams in the US began constructing the
massive stadiums that we're familiar with today, with some rising
as high as thirty feet into the air. Several fans
have taken fatal plunges when trying to catch a home run,
(08:35):
soaring above their heads. But even if you survive the fall,
don't look for anyone to pay your medical bills. Many
teams have what's now known in legal circles as the
Baseball Rule. It's printed on the back of your ticket
and it says that the park is not responsible for
any injury sustained from loose balls or bats. And look,
I know that the old song says, take me out
(08:56):
to the ballgame, but it seems like if we're not careful.
We might just get taken out at the ballgame. And
if that happens, I think we can call that curious.
I hope you've enjoyed today's guided tour of the Cabinet
of Curiosities. Subscribe for free on Apple Podcasts, or learn
(09:17):
more about the show by visiting Curiosities podcast dot com.
The show was created by me Aaron Mankey in partnership
with how Stuff Works. I make another award winning show
called Lore, which is a podcast, book series, and television show,
and you can learn all about it over at the
Worldolore dot com. And until next time, stay curious.
Aaron Mahnke's Cabinet of Curiosities News
Host
Aaron Mahnke
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations.
The Clay Travis and Buck Sexton Show
The Clay Travis and Buck Sexton Show. Clay Travis and Buck Sexton tackle the biggest stories in news, politics and current events with intelligence and humor. From the border crisis, to the madness of cancel culture and far-left missteps, Clay and Buck guide listeners through the latest headlines and hot topics with fun and entertaining conversations and opinions.