All Episodes

November 19, 2025 17 mins

This week, Tony explains how all dogs slip a little in their skills when they go from training to hunting, but that's not just a reality we have to accept - it's a teachable moment for us as handlers.

Connect with Tony, Cal, and MeatEater

Cal on Instagram and Twitter

MeatEater on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, Youtube, and Youtube Clips

MeatEater Podcast Network on YouTube

Shop Cal's Merch

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:02):
Hey, everyone, Welcome to The Houndation's podcast. I'm your host,
Tony Peterson, and today's episode is all about dealing with
the attrition of hunting skills when we leave the training
grounds and head out into the fields and on the
water with our dogs. If you haven't yet gone through
what I'm going to talk about on this show, you're

(00:22):
either the best dog trainer on the planet, or you
have the best dog on the planet, or you're blissfully
aware of the reality when you actually hunt. All three
would be great, but only one is very likely. The
truth is, we train our dogs for a lot of
real world scenarios when it comes to hunting, but those skills,
as sharp as they can be off the field, will

(00:44):
often just dull up out of nowhere when the wild
birds start flying and the guns start going off. There
are some ways to nullify the atrophy of skills, though,
which is what I'm going to talk about right now.
You know that fellow who used to be a pretty
big deal in basketball. He goes by a name Michael Jordan.

(01:06):
Have you ever seen the video of his first dunk
attempt in the NBA way back in the mid eighties.
If you haven't, I'll give you a quick synopsis, but
first I want to break down a few things. Jordan
played in one thousand and seventy two games and scored
thirty two hundred and ninety two points in his career,
averaging just to shade over thirty per game, which, if

(01:28):
you don't know much about basketball, is a lot. His
shooting percentage was right at fifty percent, which means that
every time he put the ball up, it was a
coin toss on whether the scoreboard was going to change.
Maybe that doesn't sound that great, but it is considering
he was playing against all professional athletes, many of whom
were quite a bit taller than him. Jordan is known

(01:48):
for a lot of things, like being so fiercely competitive
that he will bet on just about anything and is
not a fan of losing, well anything. This mentality spawned
a work ethic, when mixed with the hell of a
lot of athleticism, led him to a pretty incredible career.
The high points are many, but most folks, at least

(02:08):
folks around my age, probably think of him during the
nineteen eighty eight Slam Dunk Contest the All Star Weekend,
where he went up against Dominique Wilkins to take the
title once again, but this time he did it by
leaping from the free throw line to solidify his reputation
as Air Jordan. That dunk led him to sell about

(02:30):
a trillion dollars worth of Nikes and helped him earn
enough to be considered a billionaire several times over. By
all accounts, Jordan had the mentality in the mindset to
be a champion, and he was. But his first dunk
attempt was a little less glamorous. In fact, he got
called for traveling but went up for it anyway, and
not only did he get stuffed by the rim hard,

(02:53):
he hit the court like a sack of wet concrete
and stayed there for quite a while. It's hard to
say how many practice shot he took in his life,
but hundreds of thousands is probably not much of a stretch.
He managed to miss thousands of shots in games and
turn the ball over plenty. He wasn't perfect, but he was,
by most accounts, the best there ever was. Now, think

(03:15):
about your dog. Your dog probably isn't the Michael Jordan
of dogs, even though in your heart you might suspect
that actually he is. He's not. Trust me, but that's
okay though, because if you're listening to a rando like
me talk about dogs, you're probably not the Michael Jordan
of hunters or of dog trainers. That's okay too. We
can all wallow in mediocrity together. We might not only

(03:38):
share average lives but also average skills. But for some reason,
it's easy to expect more out of our dogs than
we probably should. This is the first thing I want
to talk about when it comes to our dog skills
and how they translate to the field. The reality is
they're not perfect. While you can talk to hunters all
day who will claim their dogs recover one hundred percent

(03:59):
of the ripples and all that jazz, those hunters are
very likely to be suffering from selective memory. There may
be a few flawless performances each season, but more likely
than anything is that as soon as we get back
to the truck, our brains just clip out a lot
of the negative memories. But it's also true that we
often expect too much of our dogs. Young dogs, first

(04:21):
hunts of the year, different species of birds than usual dogs,
in different environments, changing weather conditions. There are a lot
of variables that come into play in the field and
They all affect our individual dogs' performances. The first thing
that we need to do is factor that stuff in
before we judge our dogs too harshly on his performance.

(04:42):
If you have an upland dog that is pretty solid
at flushing and retrieving birds and then you put him
in a duck blind for the first time, even after
training steadiness and blind marks and all that ducky stuff
throughout the summer, you know what's going to happen. That
dog is not going to deliver a perfect performance. It
doesn't work that way. There's going to be breaking or whining,
or miss marks or a whole host of things that

(05:04):
you just don't want to see. You can practice and
practice and practice, but it's never going to be exactly
the same as an actual hunt, just like how you
could run five thousand rounds a summer through your shotguns,
busting clays and still not shoot all that great on
wild quail or rough grouse the first couple times you
hunt them in the season. Giving our dogs some grace

(05:25):
is a good idea because if we don't, we instantly
make things worse. I had a situation last year with
Sadie where my buddy and I were bumping awful close
to our three bird limits here in Minnesota, when she
put up a rooster in front of me that swung
hard to my right over a frozen lake. Now, I'm
pretty deadly when they go straight away and somewhat deadly

(05:45):
when they go to the left. But a bird that
cuts hard to my right has made the best decision
he could. I still managed to knock that rooster down
on my first shot, and he hit the middle of
that lake, stood up and started running. Sadie, who's about
four feet shorter than me, didn't mark the bird because
the cattails are tall enough to block my view. So
I scrambled to the edge to point out the very

(06:06):
alive but wounded rooster pulling his best roadrunner moves on
the skating rink. I figured I was about to see
one of those oh so sweet moments when your dog
lays eyes on a rooster that's running real hard and
then takes off to tackle them, maybe fall over and
slip on the ice and all that cool jazz. What
I saw instead was a small black lab looking the
wrong way while I frantically yelled and screamed back, you know,

(06:30):
to her, in order to get her to look back
and run the way that she's been trained to run.
If you want to know how to communicate with your dog, stark,
raving lunatic isn't the best persona to adopt. In fact,
it was just a miracle that I saw exactly where
that rooster went into the cattails before I went ass
over apple cart and slid along on my face for
a while. When I finally got stood up and got

(06:52):
over there, Sadie had already taken my cue and was
well on her way to rounding up that bird from
a snowdrift. In the moment, I was like, well, I
have the dumbest dog in the world, But in reality
I had a dog that didn't know where the bird
was because she really couldn't, and instead of calmly getting
her attention and sending her in the right direction, I
did everything I shouldn't have. What looked like a lack

(07:14):
of skills on her end was entirely a mistake on
my part. Give them some grace because they are trying
and they might not know you know what you want
out of them or how to do something, but also
pay attention to what they absolutely should know that they
won't do anyway, For upland hunters, this tends to manifest
itself and recall issues a lot of the times. If

(07:37):
you haven't hunted with someone who has a dog that
doesn't understand anything about range, oh boy, just wait. There's
nothing more frustrating than a dog that just doesn't understand
any connection between it and the right distance to the hunter.
You know, some of this stuff can be excused away
through hunt jitters and excitement, but most of it is,

(07:57):
once again an issue on our part. Is where it
gets muddy though. If you deal with this, you have
to ask yourself how much you trained it in them.
If it was a ton and they disobey, you've got
to get them under control. You know, it might be
a one and done issue just from the excitement that
they'll shore up quickly throughout the first hunt, but if
it keeps happening, it's not actually an attrition of skills.

(08:20):
It's a light shining on what the skill level actually is.
This is a big deal, and it's something that every
bird dog trainer understands. You train for realistic scenarios, then
you go out and pay real close attention to the
dog's behavior in the field and on the water. This
will show you where the holes are in your game,
because they know that you can't show up everything in

(08:42):
the backyard no matter how many bumpers you toss. Now,
another issue that happens a lot is confusion over wounded birds.
Here's the thing about this. You can set up as
many hunt dead scenarios as you want with bumpers and

(09:04):
wings and whatever else you know in the yard and
the CRP field, in the woods wherever. The more you
do this, the better off your dog will understand the
job when that command comes out. But even Tom Docin,
who has made more realistic training dummies than anyone, has
yet to make a bumper that will run and hide
and possibly fly if a dog gets too close to it.

(09:26):
This is a skill issue that can only be resolved
by working real birds in the places real birds live.
But it's also true that we often don't do our
dogs any favors on this front. I think about this
a lot, and it's one of the many reasons I
rarely upland hunt with more than one other buddy, and
never more than two or possibly three, which usually ends

(09:49):
up feeling like one or two too many intends to
result in me finding a reason to go hunt solo
for a while. The more people and dogs we get involved,
the more some dogs will lose their abilities to perform
due to distraction. But where this gets untenable is when
a bird is down. Now, a couple of good, seasoned
dogs looking for a wounded bird is usually a gift

(10:11):
because that bird is generally in trouble when the smart
noses start to work it out. But what if you
aren't with a couple of seasoned pros, or what if
your dog's just never trained around other dogs. What if
it's just you and your dog and it's second season
and for whatever reason, the rooster you hit isn't where
he's supposed to beat. This is where patience and a
zen mindset comes into play, because it's very easy to

(10:33):
be frustrated with a dog that misses what looks like
a gimme retrieve in almost all situations, even a hell
of a lot of them that involve ducks, If the
dog doesn't have a good chance to use his nose,
he's not going to find the bird. When we send
a dog into the thick stuff or a down rooster
or rough or whatever and he doesn't find it right away,

(10:54):
our first instinct is to go in and look. I
see this every time someone new when we're in the
late season cattails, and every time it drives me crazy
because the odds of us spotting a down rooster about
as low as the odds of cow waking up one
day and just deciding he's going to shave his mustache off.
It's not gonna happen. So we think our dogs are

(11:15):
good at this stuff because in training they are successful,
but in the field they suddenly aren't. So we move
in and add a whole bunch of scent and urgency
to the scene, and that only makes it worse when
that dog's trying to nose up that down bird. Now,
as a deer hunter, I've started thinking about how bucks
really kind of just see with their noses, and I
try to equate that to our actual vision. It helps

(11:38):
me figure out where to hunt deer. But on the
dog front, thinking about them using their noses that way
just helps me visualize what they might need. So look
at it this way. Your dog needs the wind and
it needs time to work it. If you don't give
him both, he won't do very well. If you send
him in from the wrong direction, or you wade into

(11:58):
the exact spot you expect the sun to be. It
would be like trying to look for something that blends
in really well while someone else shines a bright flashlight
in your eyes every few seconds. Yeah, sure you might
find that thing, but it would be a hell of
a lot easier if someone wasn't shining a frickin light
in your eyes. But what if you don't screw that
part up? But your dog mostly stays where the grass

(12:19):
is short and it's easy to walk in and skirts
the thick stuff where that rooster hit the dirt, Then again,
that's not necessarily an atrophy of skills. It's a lack
of skills. Your dog hasn't learned that the thick stuff
is where the magic happens, and he's no dummy, so
he's staying where the living is easy. It's back to
training time there, but also time to encourage him in

(12:40):
the right direction while hopefully the wind feeds him just
enough to coax him into the morass again. Hunting with
our dogs is a great way to see in real
time the issues that need work during training, but it's
also a time for you to learn your dog and
for your dog to learn you. Scratch that your dog
already kind of knows how you operate, but not necessarily

(13:02):
how you operate in the field. You might be a
relaxed kind of fellow during summer time training sessions and
then be a keyed up lunatic when the ducks starts circling,
or the opening bell for the morning rings and it's
time to wade into the waist high grass for the day.
Your dog is used to you in one aspect but
maybe not the other, just like how you know exactly

(13:23):
how good your dog is during training, but suddenly it's
like having a whole different dog when you go out
into the field. That shit flows both ways, but we
rarely look at it from the dog's point of view.
It's kind of like how when you're married for a while,
it's pretty easy to see the flaws in your spouse,
while not so easy to see the good stuff that
they do. With our dogs, we actually see that positive

(13:45):
stuff during training because we can train to nearly one
hundred percent success, but that isn't possible while hunting and
hunting is a blood sport with prey animals that simply
don't want to die, it's a different beast from training altogether,
and it require of us and our dogs something that
we just don't bring to the table when we are training.
So let's break this down again. Even though hopefully by

(14:07):
this point of the season your dog has been in
the field more than a few times and it's starting
to get things figured out, you have to expect some
level of atrophy in their skills. It's hard to pin
down because it's just sort of this ethereal reality where
your dog's skills actually live. But you should know what
your dog has down really well when you get to

(14:27):
the field. If there is some confusion when those skills
come up, that's okay. How they react and how they
perform throughout the hunt or just the first few hunts
will tell you a lot. There's also the fact that
they sometimes just decide to blatantly ignore you when they
are having fun out there, which is a different issue altogether.
That's usually a dog that just needs more training and honestly,

(14:47):
probably more time in the field, so they aren't totally
willing to risk it for the feathered biscuit. Every time
you get out there. We owe it to them and
to ourselves to be brutally honest with their performance and
ours and to at least try to be fair to
them about the issues that crop up, because they are
there for a reason, and rarely is that reason because

(15:08):
the dog is throwing up a metaphorical middle finger to
you just because it can. They more often than not
just lose their minds a little and often don't know
exactly what you want, or worse, they know what you want,
but are totally perplexed in how to deliver that result
to you. Getting angry or ignoring these moments has a
snowball effect that won't work in your favor later on.

(15:30):
It's best to be aware of that stuff now and
except that you won't view a flawless performance, but we'll
have a chance to help your dog get better with
true on the job experience, And in that process we
also have a duty to view ourselves pretty much the
same light. What holes in our training game are blatantly
obvious now? Or how well do we handle going two

(15:52):
barrels deep a few times in a row without touching
a single feather while our buddies snicker and make Stevie
Wonder jokes. That's how it goes, and it's up to
us to take those lessons and reframe them for ourselves
and for our dogs. If we do, the atrophy and
skills on their part will become less and less, and
you'll get to that sweet sweet spot with your dog

(16:13):
where the mistakes are few and far between, and you'll
get to witness a peak dog doing what peak dogs do,
which is something I hope we all get to see
in our lives. So do that, Think about that, and
come back in two weeks to listen to more talk
about the dogs we love and how we can have
the best life with them. That's it for this week.

(16:34):
I'm Tony Peterson. This has been The Houndation's podcast. I
want to thank you so much for all of your support.
I have never worked at a place where we had
a better audience than we do here at meat Eater.
We truly appreciate you guys showing up for us. You
consume so much content and we love it. If you
want more content, or you're maybe missing something out of

(16:55):
your life, maybe you want to just watch some films
with the family at night, Maybe you need some new
podcasts listen to on your drive to work. Whatever. The
medeater dot com we drop new content every single day.
There's tons of good stuff on there go check it
out
Advertise With Us

Host

Cal Callaghan

Cal Callaghan

Popular Podcasts

Ruthie's Table 4

Ruthie's Table 4

For more than 30 years The River Cafe in London, has been the home-from-home of artists, architects, designers, actors, collectors, writers, activists, and politicians. Michael Caine, Glenn Close, JJ Abrams, Steve McQueen, Victoria and David Beckham, and Lily Allen, are just some of the people who love to call The River Cafe home. On River Cafe Table 4, Rogers sits down with her customers—who have become friends—to talk about food memories. Table 4 explores how food impacts every aspect of our lives. “Foods is politics, food is cultural, food is how you express love, food is about your heritage, it defines who you and who you want to be,” says Rogers. Each week, Rogers invites her guest to reminisce about family suppers and first dates, what they cook, how they eat when performing, the restaurants they choose, and what food they seek when they need comfort. And to punctuate each episode of Table 4, guests such as Ralph Fiennes, Emily Blunt, and Alfonso Cuarón, read their favourite recipe from one of the best-selling River Cafe cookbooks. Table 4 itself, is situated near The River Cafe’s open kitchen, close to the bright pink wood-fired oven and next to the glossy yellow pass, where Ruthie oversees the restaurant. You are invited to take a seat at this intimate table and join the conversation. For more information, recipes, and ingredients, go to https://shoptherivercafe.co.uk/ Web: https://rivercafe.co.uk/ Instagram: www.instagram.com/therivercafelondon/ Facebook: https://en-gb.facebook.com/therivercafelondon/ For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iheartradio app, apple podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows. Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com

Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC

Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.