March 16, 2021 • 29 mins
Adele Hugo (1830-1915) was the youngest child of Victor Hugo, a major French writer of the Romantic era. She also was known for stalking a British officer known as Lieutenant Albert Pinson in the mid-1800s.
The lieutenant at one time asked for Adele’s hand in marriage, but Adele declined the proposal. As Pinson moved on however, Hugo’s daughter displayed obsessive behaviors, from wearing disguises, to renting rooms near where he would stay.
Though tragic, Adele’s tale displays a good breakdown of the characteristics of Erotomania.
Executive Producers: Maria Trimarchi and Holly Frey
Producer & Editor: Casby Bias
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:02):
Welcome to Criminalia, a production of Shonda Land Audio in
partnership with I Heart Radio. Hello, and welcome to another
episode of Criminalia. This season, we're exploring the lives and
motivations of some of the most notorious stalkers throughout history.
I'm Maria Tremarking and I'm Holly Fry and today we
(00:26):
are talking about Adele Hugo. That's Adele Hugo in the
americanized version, which is what we're going to be using. Right,
that's how you'll be hearing me said. Right. So, Adele
was born in in Paris. She was the fifth and
the youngest child of the French poet, novelist and dramatist
Victor Hugo and his wife Adele Fouchet. And you'll recognize
(00:50):
her father's name from those famous novels that he has written.
We all probably had to read one in high school
if you grew up in a US city. So we're
talking about things like The Hunchback of No Trade Dome
and Lemis rob and her family, as you might suspect,
was comfortably affluent. And Adele, her sister Leopoldine, and her
brother's sharrows and Francois Victor, grew up surrounded by music
(01:15):
and the arts, and her father's famous friends and their
intellectual and literary conversations. She did have another brother, Leopold,
who was born in eight three. However, he had died
as an infant, and Leopoldine would also die tragically later
in her life in a boating accident during her honeymoon.
So by all accounts, though Adele was a bit of
(01:38):
a sullen child who spent most of her day at
the piano, she grew up to be an accomplished musician,
and she was an intelligent and ambitious young woman. She
was known for her beauty and her long dark hair,
and she sat for portraits by several well known Parisian artists.
In fact, one of them is possibly maybe it's still
(01:59):
being investigated attributed to the Impressionist painter Eduard Money since
two thousand and four. Apparently someone bought the painting and
suspected it was her and they're looking into it, which
is kind of cool. Um. Her life, though, becomes a
tragic story of mental illness and romantic obsession with a
British military officer. So the Hugos, though did not raise
(02:24):
their family in France. Victor Hugo was not only a writer,
he was also a statesman and a human rights activist,
and he was a fierce opponent of the Second Empire
of Napoleon the Third and he wrote outspoken pamphlets opposing,
among many other things, napoleon the third seizure of power. So,
in protest to the anti parliamentary and constitution of eighteen
(02:46):
fifty one, Hugo took his family and left France. Others
would put this a different way, to say that he
was actually banished. Most I think that I read in
my research suggested it was more banishment. It was a
muchel yes, I'm leaving, well, good, you should go. We
don't want you anywhere um. So, first, after they were
(03:10):
not banished, the family lived in Belgium um and then
they eventually landed on the island of Jersey, which is
the largest of the Channel Islands. The Channel Islands are
an archipelago in the English Channel, which is off the
coast of Normandy, and the family's relocation to the island
happened at about the time in Adele's life, when she
(03:30):
was in her early twenties, so she was very likely
expecting her life to be focused on establishing her position
in Parisian society. She may have been expecting to marry
soon um, but none of those things really played out. Instead,
the family stayed among the Channel Islands until eighteen seventy.
But it's on those islands where Adele first met a
(03:53):
man named Albert Pinson, and a lot of what we
know about Adele can be found in biography is written
about her father. So in late eighteen fifty five, the
family arrived at Hauteville House at Guernsey, that's another island
in the Channel Islands, again seeking refuge. And it's around
this time when Adele also started writing a diary, a
(04:15):
coded diary which I love. I do too. I want
to know exactly I didn't. I haven't seen it, and
I got to look it up. This diary was titled
Journald de Lexile or Diary of the Exile, and she
was twenty two years old when she started keeping it.
Adele was a prolific writer, and she recorded pretty much
everything in her life, from her thoughts about horse racing
(04:39):
to love affairs. I gotta tell you, reading the horse
racing entries were really funny, actually, like you wouldn't expect it,
but they were funny. She was a funny lady, I
believe it. And she kept this diary throughout the time
that she lived on the islands of Jersey and Guernsey.
Adele and Albert met on the island of Jersey actually
in June of eight before and for Adele, who was
(05:02):
in her early twenties at the time, the affair began
as a summer romance, and she wrote about their meeting
in her diary. Of course right, and now we know
um and we quote her because these diaries are public.
He saw me for the first time on a bench
on the terrace in Jersey. She said, I was sitting
down reading. I was absorbed in my book and I
(05:22):
didn't see him, but he saw me, and from that
day he loved me so. Albert, who went by Bertie Pinson,
was a lieutenant in the British Army. He was an
aristocratic man and he was considerably older than Adele. He
and we actually have a quote describing him, was of
average height, rather handsome, and decidedly stylish in appearance. He
(05:45):
wore long mustaches and took great pains to appear in
most an exquisite mode. So he was fancy. He was
fancy every time I hear the description of him and
his long mustache desire. That's the part that gets new,
right uh. Pinson was also, though described as ill tempered
and ill mannered and untrustworthy. So he might have looked fancy,
(06:08):
but he wasn't apparently very delightful, and he also had
a bad reputation of being both a womanizer and a gambler.
Yet Pinson and Adele became close, and he also became
close to the Hugo family, reportedly visiting for dinner several
times a week. Pinson proposed to Adele, which was probably
(06:30):
the biggest surprise in research that I found. Um he
did actually propose to her, and she refused him, but
she would later on regret that refusal. She would sincerely
believe in months after this that she had taken the
alternate path and that she was married to the lieutenant.
(06:52):
By September, Pinson left Jersey for England, and upon leaving Adele,
Pinson promised her, we quote, with every token of sincerity
and honor, that she should join him in England, and
in fact she did at least a few times, and
he also continued to visit with the Hugo family and
this cordial, seemingly mutual adoration or affection went on from
(07:16):
about eighteen fifty four to eighteen sixty one. So that's
a significant relationship, exactly. Those are that many years. So
because her father was in political exile slash banished, slash
moved away. The family did move again in eighteen fifty five,
and this time they went from one island to another.
(07:38):
They went from Jersey to Guernsey and they stayed there
until eighteen seventy. So at this point Adele's feelings for
prison were, as we said, reciprocated, but circumstances would change.
And we're going to take a quick break here, but
when we returned, we will start talking about how Adele
was likely beginning to succumb to mental illness. Welcome back
(08:09):
to Criminalia. Let's now talk about what happened when Adele
followed Lieutenant Pinson to Nova Scotia. So by eighteen fifty six,
Adele was falling into a depression that continued to deepen,
and by this time in her life, it is believed
(08:31):
she was very likely showing signs of a mental illness.
She seemed to be beginning to lose contact with reality,
and she was exhibiting symptoms such as delusions and hallucinations,
but her symptoms were mostly overlooked, or at least nothing
was done about them. In a letter to Victor written
in eighteen fifty six, Adele's mother expressed her increasing concern
(08:55):
over her daughter's mental state, and we can quote her
because this letter is also public. She is forced in
upon herself. She thinks a great deal and her ideas
often erroneous since nothing flows in from the outside to
modify them, become like burning lava, which is sort of
a poetic way to describe a depression. I have to say,
(09:17):
like you are trapped in your own mind. And her
mother saw that much of it, but couldn't really address it.
So in eighteen sixty one, several years later, Pinson's regiment,
which was the sixteenth, move from where it had been
stationed in Ireland to alder Shop, which is a town
in southeast England famous for being the home of the
(09:38):
British Army. So this meant that geographically he was actually
quite near the Hugo family, and with Pinson so close,
Adele told a lie about going to see her mother,
who had gone to Paris for temporary stay, and instead
Adele went to see Pinson on the Isle of Right,
and she brought her maid Rosalie with her for this,
(10:00):
which Holly and I have talked about. There was really
no particular reason for Rosalie to go with her, except
perhaps they were her friends. Adele had traveled solo prior
to this, right, I mean, who among us hasn't been like,
I'm going to go on a road trip and had
a friend go, can I go? Exactly right. It wasn't
like protection or I don't know how to do this
or anything like that. I think they were just friendly.
In December of that year, Pinson spent Christmas with the
(10:24):
Hugo family at Guernsey, and Adele urged her father to
let her marry the Lieutenant and victor. Though he was
agreeable to a marriage between the two, he didn't really
think that Pinson had made a commitment to his daughter,
and frankly he was right after her initial rejection of
the marriage proposal. Pinson never formally courted Adele, and he
(10:45):
never asked her parents for permission to marry her. Yeah,
so they had actually kind of been just friends for
a bit at this point for like a decade now,
but by the year's end, Pinson's regiment was ordered to
Nova Scotia. Adele's obsession, though, did not dim with his absence,
and though she had previously turned down his proposal, she
(11:08):
began insisting that they were going to get married, and
she even ran away from home to join him in Halifax,
referring to herself as Mrs Pinson. Adele's family, believing that
there was an arrangement between her and Pinson, actually shipped
her her clothing in care of a Mr. And Mrs Saunders. Right,
I mean, why why I think that she's lying? They've
(11:29):
known each other for such a long time. I can
see why they would. Adele continued to write daily letters
to Pinson when she wasn't around him. She tried to
meet with him, but Pinson had lost interest in her
and he soon started to ignore her and her romantic advances.
But Adele was undaunted. She began disguising herself as a
man while pursuing him, which she would do both day
(11:52):
and night, and though Pinson insisted he did not want
to be with her, Adele continued to follow him around.
She would peer through his windows and rent rooms in
his vicinity, and she journaled all of her activities and
her feelings in her diary. In eighteen sixty two, when
all of this was happening, Adele actually refused a different
(12:14):
marriage proposal from another man who was an Italian poet.
And we should mention that Pinson was not Adele's first love.
Remember we talked about how she was considered quite beautiful.
She had this long, dark hair. There were a lot
of people interested in her, and when she was sixteen,
she fell madly in love with a man named August Vacquerie,
who was ten years her senior, and that was also
(12:37):
her brother in law through her sister Leopoldine's marriage, and
the two actually planned to marry, although the family agreed
to the marriage, but they felt that Adele was too
young at that time, so while they were waiting for
her to age up, over the next four years, she
kind of fell out of love with a goost and
they did not marry. She also had many many crushes,
(12:59):
most of whom were men that her parents did not
care for, such as French sculptor and painter Jean Baptiste Pleasangie.
He has his own story, which is that her parents
were right about him. By the way, he ended up
married to George Song's daughter and eventually caused a huge
rupture between her and her mother. Uh. Just he's a
(13:22):
problematic figure. There we go, that's how to describe him.
So the Hugoes were correct in thinking this was not
a good person for their daughter to fixate on. Yes,
and and you know what I mean. Victor was pretty
right on with Pinson too, where he's like, I'm not
so sure that you're committed. So the Hugo seemed to
be aware, at least when their daughter is interested in
(13:44):
and and likes so Adele she received many marriage proposals,
but here's what's interesting about her is that she refused
them all. It was Pinson or nothing. While in Halifax, Pinson,
unknown to Adele, became engaged to a woman named Agnes Johnson,
and that engagement was called off because Ms. Johnson's parents
(14:07):
decided that Pinson was not what they wanted in the family.
I hear he's no manner, right. He looks fancy, but
he's crabby and unpleasant. Yeah, personality goes a long way.
So a few years later, which puts us in eighteen
sixty six, now, Pinson moved with his unit from Nova
(14:30):
Scotia to Barbados. Uh, there's a big weather change. Adele,
still obsessed by him, also traveled to Barbados, and once
she arrived, she moved into a room at a Mrs
Chatterton's residence and she spent her days exploring the streets
in search of Pinson. So throughout all of this she
(14:52):
continued to call herself Mrs Pinson, and that includes when
she went to Barbados. She also started to refuse to eat.
She was taking very poor care of herself, and her
overall physical and mental health continued to decline. There was
actually a study by the American Journal of Psychiatry that
found that over a ten year period, people living with
(15:13):
schizophrenia had measurable cognitive declines in memory, verbal learning, and vocabulary.
And Adele, of course, during this time, was still not diagnosed.
And what started to happen was she was spending her
nights pacing in her room, just talking to herself. By
the time she had followed Pinsent to Barbados, Adele had
(15:34):
spent almost all of her money and regardless, she was
still following him, and she was still hoping and maybe
we should say, expecting that the two would marry, and
perhaps in some moments, believing they already had. Here is
the deep tragedy Here. What she did not know was
that shortly after arriving in Barbados, Pinson actually left Barbados.
(15:58):
He soon traveled to England and out married to a
woman named Katherine Edith Roxburgh. Yes, this is all while
Adele was still in Barbados roaming the streets looking for
him or sad girl. So we're gonna take a quick
break for a word from our sponsor, and when we're back,
let's talk about what obsessive love is. Welcome back to Criminalia.
(16:35):
Let's talk about how undiagnosed mental illness was likely fueling
Adele's stalker behavior. Right, so, but first let's be very clear.
We're not saying that having a crush on someone means
that you have a mental illness. But when there's an
obsessive part to it, when it's obsessive love, there are
some problematic behaviors that mental health professionals um will tell
(16:58):
you go along with it, and those include making repeated
calls or texts or letters, giving unwanted and intense attention
towards the object. Of your affection and even making unexpected,
unannounced visits at their work or home. Um, and that's
those are the examples of when we moved into what's
(17:19):
considered stalk or behavior. And there's no list of criteria
that can solidly distinguish what's real love from what's become
obsessive love. Right if my husband turned around and said
I'm not into you, I would look super stalkery, wouldn't
we all, I'm very attached to that gent. But we
(17:42):
do know that obsessive love is considered delusional jealousy, and
both real love and obsessive love have some addictive qualities
to them, and there can be a few things going
on in what differentiates this being something abnormal and not
healthy versus something that you know is part of just
(18:03):
an intense and deeply held relationship. Yes, I'm defending myself.
I know I'm obsessed with my husband. You just have
a lot of dopamine when you're around him. It's fine,
just hitting it off like a rato maze. So much
so I don't mean to laugh about this is his
mental health issues. So I'm going to talk now about
(18:23):
a condition called eroto mania, And we have talked about
this before on this show, but we'll we'll do a
quick overview because we've talked a lot of things before,
so let's just refresh um. This is a condition when
a person believes that another person loves them, whether or
not that person does or not. They're convinced. The individual
(18:46):
often believes that they're being sent messages from their admirer,
and that could be anything from like license plate numbers
to wearing a certain color sweater. It's it's very odd
and very specific. Arotomania has been considered different things depending
on which decade you're in. So in Adele's time in
(19:06):
the early nineteenth century to about the beginning of the
twentieth century, the mental health condition was believed to be
caused by unrequited love. It wasn't until the early twentieth century, though,
when it began to be considered a subtype of a
delusional disorder. Yeah, it's an interesting thing that the cause
and effect there was believed to be someone else not
(19:29):
loving you back, rather than there being something going on
with your brain chemistry that was making you perceive the
situation in quickly. So Arotomania has two forms, primary and secondary,
and the primary form is a condition that exists alone.
The onset is sudden and there's no identifiable cause. The
(19:50):
second form is diagnosed along with other mental illnesses, including schizophrenia,
which Adele likely lived with. And the secondary form often
includes symptoms like persecutory delusions, hallucinations, and grandiose ideas, and
it has a more gradual onset than the primary form,
though this can turn into Stoker behavior, and we have
(20:12):
told many of those stories. Now, this description of erotomania,
at least to us non medical professionals, it doesn't really
feel quite like the right fit for Adell. Right. There
is also a condition that is known as obsessive love disorder,
and that's when you become obsessed with one person that
you think you may be in love with. The distinction
(20:35):
here is that with erotomania, you think they love you. This, however,
obsessive love disorder was first called fittingly Adele syndrome, and
it's still not widely recognized as its own mental health condition.
It's usually tied to other things. And this is an expression, right, um,
But there's another thing. There's Adele's undiagnosed mental illness and
(20:56):
her symptoms of mental illness. They were likely the fuel
for her fire of irrational and obsessive behavior. And we're
gonna focus on because aprenia, because that's kind of what
everyone is assuming was happening with the doll's five. So,
schizophrenia is a mental illness that can be disabling. It's
generally characterized by a variety of things like thought related
(21:17):
and behavior related symptoms. Um, it could come in the
form of delusions, hallucinations, or just a general unusual way
of thinking. So by the time she was in Barbados,
it had become really quite obvious to those around Adele
that she was exhibiting some delusional, if not other odd behaviors,
(21:40):
and though not diagnosed, people who knew her recognized that
she was clearly unwell. So as we talk about all
of this, you know, we have to acknowledge it is always, really,
really a tricky proposition to diagnose someone post mortem when
they are not around to be assessed by a mental
health professional. But this, this association with schizophrenia on the
(22:02):
part of Adele, is something that modern biographers and historians
have pieced together multiple times. Like all of the evidence
indicates something along these lines. Um, there is also a
very good likelihood that she inherited it because it is
known to run in families, and her father's brother Eugene,
is also said to have lived with it. So those
(22:23):
living with this particular mental illness often experience psychosis, which
happens when you lose your connection with reality. You might
not know it, but people around you will notice this.
And delusions are are false beliefs that aren't based in reality,
and most people with schizophrenia will experience these as well.
(22:44):
And delusions could manifest in a few ways. Um you
might think you have special abilities, or you might believe
that you're being harassed by anyone from your neighbor to
the cia Um. Delusions could also leads you to believe
you have that another person is in love with you,
and those false beliefs often lead to paranoia. So there
(23:07):
are a few different stories of exactly how Adele was
extracted from Barbados and brought home to her family, but
most historians believe that she was actually accompanied back to
Paris by a woman named missus Celine Alvarez Ba in
February of eighty two. Ultimately, in the tragic story of Adele,
(23:27):
her father committed her to a mental institution when she
was home from Barbados, and she lived there from when
she was about forty or forty two years old until
her death at eighty five years old. Um and we
have an excerpt in a letter from one of his visits.
It's not too long, I'm gonna quote it. I saw
her again in the mental institution. She recognized me, I
(23:50):
embraced her. I spoke words of tenderness and hope to her.
She was calm and seemed sometimes to be asleep. It
was just one year ago today that I left for
Bordeaux with Charles, who would not return alive. Today I
see Adele again, what sorrow. And Victor Hugo bequeathed his manuscripts,
which include a significant part of Adele's exile diary as
(24:13):
well as her signed scores, to the National Library of France.
It's really easy to forget that she was a prolific
writer and musician, because her symptoms and her travels around
the world really seemed to cloud that. And I like
that we have various points that we can look at.
We can look at her father's manuscripts, which we can
(24:34):
look at her I suppose it took a little while,
but we could look in her code to diary there. Yeah,
there's a few places to get things from her. And
so interestingly, in looking at Victor Hugo's manuscripts, we know
that this episode was it was a downer. It was
downer for everyone. So to end a bit less somber,
I'm gonna share a little anecote about Victor Hugo that
(24:57):
that turned up during our research. And so Victor knew everyone,
and he was known for having large dinner parties, which
he would have almost every night of the week. There
were at least twenty or thirty people present, and he
had really one heck of a party trick that he
would pull out and just buris yourselves for a moment.
(25:17):
He would shove an entire orange in his mouth, and
then he would fill his cheeks with as many lumps
of sugar as would fit, and he would kind of
then like churn it all up in there. I can't
imagine he could have shut very well because of that
whole orange um and then he would he would swallow
it down with two glasses of gearch. So let's hope
(25:39):
that Holly is not making us all swallow a whole
orange in this episodes Chasers, But maybe she is. No,
doesn't not sound miserable and orange? You know, I keep
thinking him like, you know, a little like cute E's
or mandarins. This whole well, and I always think of
you know, when you take too big of a mouthful
(25:59):
of some very sugary and the sugar goes down the
wrong way, like that is one of the worst relatively
harmless pains. I can. No, there's no whole orange, but
I thought it would be fun to do something orange flavored.
And so I am calling this cocktail Victor's party trick,
(26:24):
because you're also creating something that tastes like something else delicious, Yes,
and not everyone could fit the whole orange in their
mactic And why would you want to, Victor, you fool.
He was loaded with vitamin C, so that's great. But
so for the party trick, into a shaker, you will
pour two ounces of triple sec two ounces of whipped
(26:47):
to vodka. You'll also see it like as whipped cream vodka.
There are a few different brands. One ounce of simple
syrup or vanilla syrup if you have it, and then
you're gonna shake that with ice, give it a good
heart shake, and then pour it into a martini glass
and then top it with three ounces of a hard seltzer.
If you want a hard seltzer that has a flavor
(27:09):
to it, that's fine. Like a citrus or even something
like a pineapple works here because when you take a sip,
it tastes like a creamsicles. That's the party trick. It
turns into a yummy dessert. The first version of the
party trick, I doubt tasted like a creamsicle. I don't
think it did, know, but I like things a little
(27:31):
more delicious than that. Yes, the point of yours is
to be a drink. The point of his was look
what I can fit in my mouth? Like I'm right.
No one else wanted to do that, but everyone will
want to drink if they are in fact a drinker.
This is also one if you wanted to do a
uh like a variation on it. If you're not a drinker,
I bet you could do, like, you know, a few
(27:53):
ounces of an orange soda and yeah, it is some
vanilla syrup with that and then like a a not
hard seltzer, and you would get something closesh. You wouldn't
quite be right. It's one of those things. Orange juice
is the natural tendency to want to go for when
you're recreating it. But usually in my experiments it's very yummy.
(28:14):
I love an orange juice with a vanilla vodka, but
it's a little too acidic, whereas like the orange soda
or an orange liquor is not as acidic. Usually you
don't have that bite of citrus. So I love that
she did a citrus drink this week, because I know
how you feel about citrus. It's not my favorite, it's mine,
(28:36):
but then it grows on me because I'll turn up
something like this. And even the sixteen sixties French lemonade
that we did give a season one was really quite yummy,
but also had a half pound that may have been
yunny because of the half a bag of sugarage. Yeah,
so I mean, at that point, what are you actually
(28:59):
tasting sugar? Just put some water on some sugar, just
drink it. So Victor's party trick, triple sack whipped vodka,
vanilla stare up in a little hard seltzer and you're
off to the races. Uh. It was so delicious. So
we hope that you have enjoyed not only a delicious
sip of something delightful but also spending this time with us,
and we hope to see you back next week right
(29:20):
here in Criminalia. Criminalia is a production of Shonda land
Audio in partnership with I Heart Radio. For more podcasts
from Shonda land Audio, please visit the I Heart Radio app,
Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
Welcome to Criminalia, a production of Shonda Land Audio in
partnership with I Heart Radio. Hello, and welcome to another
episode of Criminalia. This season, we're exploring the lives and
motivations of some of the most notorious stalkers throughout history.
I'm Maria Tremarking and I'm Holly Fry and today we
(00:26):
are talking about Adele Hugo. That's Adele Hugo in the
americanized version, which is what we're going to be using. Right,
that's how you'll be hearing me said. Right. So, Adele
was born in in Paris. She was the fifth and
the youngest child of the French poet, novelist and dramatist
Victor Hugo and his wife Adele Fouchet. And you'll recognize
(00:50):
her father's name from those famous novels that he has written.
We all probably had to read one in high school
if you grew up in a US city. So we're
talking about things like The Hunchback of No Trade Dome
and Lemis rob and her family, as you might suspect,
was comfortably affluent. And Adele, her sister Leopoldine, and her
brother's sharrows and Francois Victor, grew up surrounded by music
(01:15):
and the arts, and her father's famous friends and their
intellectual and literary conversations. She did have another brother, Leopold,
who was born in eight three. However, he had died
as an infant, and Leopoldine would also die tragically later
in her life in a boating accident during her honeymoon.
So by all accounts, though Adele was a bit of
(01:38):
a sullen child who spent most of her day at
the piano, she grew up to be an accomplished musician,
and she was an intelligent and ambitious young woman. She
was known for her beauty and her long dark hair,
and she sat for portraits by several well known Parisian artists.
In fact, one of them is possibly maybe it's still
(01:59):
being investigated attributed to the Impressionist painter Eduard Money since
two thousand and four. Apparently someone bought the painting and
suspected it was her and they're looking into it, which
is kind of cool. Um. Her life, though, becomes a
tragic story of mental illness and romantic obsession with a
British military officer. So the Hugos, though did not raise
(02:24):
their family in France. Victor Hugo was not only a writer,
he was also a statesman and a human rights activist,
and he was a fierce opponent of the Second Empire
of Napoleon the Third and he wrote outspoken pamphlets opposing,
among many other things, napoleon the third seizure of power. So,
in protest to the anti parliamentary and constitution of eighteen
(02:46):
fifty one, Hugo took his family and left France. Others
would put this a different way, to say that he
was actually banished. Most I think that I read in
my research suggested it was more banishment. It was a
muchel yes, I'm leaving, well, good, you should go. We
don't want you anywhere um. So, first, after they were
(03:10):
not banished, the family lived in Belgium um and then
they eventually landed on the island of Jersey, which is
the largest of the Channel Islands. The Channel Islands are
an archipelago in the English Channel, which is off the
coast of Normandy, and the family's relocation to the island
happened at about the time in Adele's life, when she
(03:30):
was in her early twenties, so she was very likely
expecting her life to be focused on establishing her position
in Parisian society. She may have been expecting to marry
soon um, but none of those things really played out. Instead,
the family stayed among the Channel Islands until eighteen seventy.
But it's on those islands where Adele first met a
(03:53):
man named Albert Pinson, and a lot of what we
know about Adele can be found in biography is written
about her father. So in late eighteen fifty five, the
family arrived at Hauteville House at Guernsey, that's another island
in the Channel Islands, again seeking refuge. And it's around
this time when Adele also started writing a diary, a
(04:15):
coded diary which I love. I do too. I want
to know exactly I didn't. I haven't seen it, and
I got to look it up. This diary was titled
Journald de Lexile or Diary of the Exile, and she
was twenty two years old when she started keeping it.
Adele was a prolific writer, and she recorded pretty much
everything in her life, from her thoughts about horse racing
(04:39):
to love affairs. I gotta tell you, reading the horse
racing entries were really funny, actually, like you wouldn't expect it,
but they were funny. She was a funny lady, I
believe it. And she kept this diary throughout the time
that she lived on the islands of Jersey and Guernsey.
Adele and Albert met on the island of Jersey actually
in June of eight before and for Adele, who was
(05:02):
in her early twenties at the time, the affair began
as a summer romance, and she wrote about their meeting
in her diary. Of course right, and now we know
um and we quote her because these diaries are public.
He saw me for the first time on a bench
on the terrace in Jersey. She said, I was sitting
down reading. I was absorbed in my book and I
(05:22):
didn't see him, but he saw me, and from that
day he loved me so. Albert, who went by Bertie Pinson,
was a lieutenant in the British Army. He was an
aristocratic man and he was considerably older than Adele. He
and we actually have a quote describing him, was of
average height, rather handsome, and decidedly stylish in appearance. He
(05:45):
wore long mustaches and took great pains to appear in
most an exquisite mode. So he was fancy. He was
fancy every time I hear the description of him and
his long mustache desire. That's the part that gets new,
right uh. Pinson was also, though described as ill tempered
and ill mannered and untrustworthy. So he might have looked fancy,
(06:08):
but he wasn't apparently very delightful, and he also had
a bad reputation of being both a womanizer and a gambler.
Yet Pinson and Adele became close, and he also became
close to the Hugo family, reportedly visiting for dinner several
times a week. Pinson proposed to Adele, which was probably
(06:30):
the biggest surprise in research that I found. Um he
did actually propose to her, and she refused him, but
she would later on regret that refusal. She would sincerely
believe in months after this that she had taken the
alternate path and that she was married to the lieutenant.
(06:52):
By September, Pinson left Jersey for England, and upon leaving Adele,
Pinson promised her, we quote, with every token of sincerity
and honor, that she should join him in England, and
in fact she did at least a few times, and
he also continued to visit with the Hugo family and
this cordial, seemingly mutual adoration or affection went on from
(07:16):
about eighteen fifty four to eighteen sixty one. So that's
a significant relationship, exactly. Those are that many years. So
because her father was in political exile slash banished, slash
moved away. The family did move again in eighteen fifty five,
and this time they went from one island to another.
(07:38):
They went from Jersey to Guernsey and they stayed there
until eighteen seventy. So at this point Adele's feelings for
prison were, as we said, reciprocated, but circumstances would change.
And we're going to take a quick break here, but
when we returned, we will start talking about how Adele
was likely beginning to succumb to mental illness. Welcome back
(08:09):
to Criminalia. Let's now talk about what happened when Adele
followed Lieutenant Pinson to Nova Scotia. So by eighteen fifty six,
Adele was falling into a depression that continued to deepen,
and by this time in her life, it is believed
(08:31):
she was very likely showing signs of a mental illness.
She seemed to be beginning to lose contact with reality,
and she was exhibiting symptoms such as delusions and hallucinations,
but her symptoms were mostly overlooked, or at least nothing
was done about them. In a letter to Victor written
in eighteen fifty six, Adele's mother expressed her increasing concern
(08:55):
over her daughter's mental state, and we can quote her
because this letter is also public. She is forced in
upon herself. She thinks a great deal and her ideas
often erroneous since nothing flows in from the outside to
modify them, become like burning lava, which is sort of
a poetic way to describe a depression. I have to say,
(09:17):
like you are trapped in your own mind. And her
mother saw that much of it, but couldn't really address it.
So in eighteen sixty one, several years later, Pinson's regiment,
which was the sixteenth, move from where it had been
stationed in Ireland to alder Shop, which is a town
in southeast England famous for being the home of the
(09:38):
British Army. So this meant that geographically he was actually
quite near the Hugo family, and with Pinson so close,
Adele told a lie about going to see her mother,
who had gone to Paris for temporary stay, and instead
Adele went to see Pinson on the Isle of Right,
and she brought her maid Rosalie with her for this,
(10:00):
which Holly and I have talked about. There was really
no particular reason for Rosalie to go with her, except
perhaps they were her friends. Adele had traveled solo prior
to this, right, I mean, who among us hasn't been like,
I'm going to go on a road trip and had
a friend go, can I go? Exactly right. It wasn't
like protection or I don't know how to do this
or anything like that. I think they were just friendly.
In December of that year, Pinson spent Christmas with the
(10:24):
Hugo family at Guernsey, and Adele urged her father to
let her marry the Lieutenant and victor. Though he was
agreeable to a marriage between the two, he didn't really
think that Pinson had made a commitment to his daughter,
and frankly he was right after her initial rejection of
the marriage proposal. Pinson never formally courted Adele, and he
(10:45):
never asked her parents for permission to marry her. Yeah,
so they had actually kind of been just friends for
a bit at this point for like a decade now,
but by the year's end, Pinson's regiment was ordered to
Nova Scotia. Adele's obsession, though, did not dim with his absence,
and though she had previously turned down his proposal, she
(11:08):
began insisting that they were going to get married, and
she even ran away from home to join him in Halifax,
referring to herself as Mrs Pinson. Adele's family, believing that
there was an arrangement between her and Pinson, actually shipped
her her clothing in care of a Mr. And Mrs Saunders. Right,
I mean, why why I think that she's lying? They've
(11:29):
known each other for such a long time. I can
see why they would. Adele continued to write daily letters
to Pinson when she wasn't around him. She tried to
meet with him, but Pinson had lost interest in her
and he soon started to ignore her and her romantic advances.
But Adele was undaunted. She began disguising herself as a
man while pursuing him, which she would do both day
(11:52):
and night, and though Pinson insisted he did not want
to be with her, Adele continued to follow him around.
She would peer through his windows and rent rooms in
his vicinity, and she journaled all of her activities and
her feelings in her diary. In eighteen sixty two, when
all of this was happening, Adele actually refused a different
(12:14):
marriage proposal from another man who was an Italian poet.
And we should mention that Pinson was not Adele's first love.
Remember we talked about how she was considered quite beautiful.
She had this long, dark hair. There were a lot
of people interested in her, and when she was sixteen,
she fell madly in love with a man named August Vacquerie,
who was ten years her senior, and that was also
(12:37):
her brother in law through her sister Leopoldine's marriage, and
the two actually planned to marry, although the family agreed
to the marriage, but they felt that Adele was too
young at that time, so while they were waiting for
her to age up, over the next four years, she
kind of fell out of love with a goost and
they did not marry. She also had many many crushes,
(12:59):
most of whom were men that her parents did not
care for, such as French sculptor and painter Jean Baptiste Pleasangie.
He has his own story, which is that her parents
were right about him. By the way, he ended up
married to George Song's daughter and eventually caused a huge
rupture between her and her mother. Uh. Just he's a
(13:22):
problematic figure. There we go, that's how to describe him.
So the Hugoes were correct in thinking this was not
a good person for their daughter to fixate on. Yes,
and and you know what I mean. Victor was pretty
right on with Pinson too, where he's like, I'm not
so sure that you're committed. So the Hugo seemed to
be aware, at least when their daughter is interested in
(13:44):
and and likes so Adele she received many marriage proposals,
but here's what's interesting about her is that she refused
them all. It was Pinson or nothing. While in Halifax, Pinson,
unknown to Adele, became engaged to a woman named Agnes Johnson,
and that engagement was called off because Ms. Johnson's parents
(14:07):
decided that Pinson was not what they wanted in the family.
I hear he's no manner, right. He looks fancy, but
he's crabby and unpleasant. Yeah, personality goes a long way.
So a few years later, which puts us in eighteen
sixty six, now, Pinson moved with his unit from Nova
(14:30):
Scotia to Barbados. Uh, there's a big weather change. Adele,
still obsessed by him, also traveled to Barbados, and once
she arrived, she moved into a room at a Mrs
Chatterton's residence and she spent her days exploring the streets
in search of Pinson. So throughout all of this she
(14:52):
continued to call herself Mrs Pinson, and that includes when
she went to Barbados. She also started to refuse to eat.
She was taking very poor care of herself, and her
overall physical and mental health continued to decline. There was
actually a study by the American Journal of Psychiatry that
found that over a ten year period, people living with
(15:13):
schizophrenia had measurable cognitive declines in memory, verbal learning, and vocabulary.
And Adele, of course, during this time, was still not diagnosed.
And what started to happen was she was spending her
nights pacing in her room, just talking to herself. By
the time she had followed Pinsent to Barbados, Adele had
(15:34):
spent almost all of her money and regardless, she was
still following him, and she was still hoping and maybe
we should say, expecting that the two would marry, and
perhaps in some moments, believing they already had. Here is
the deep tragedy Here. What she did not know was
that shortly after arriving in Barbados, Pinson actually left Barbados.
(15:58):
He soon traveled to England and out married to a
woman named Katherine Edith Roxburgh. Yes, this is all while
Adele was still in Barbados roaming the streets looking for
him or sad girl. So we're gonna take a quick
break for a word from our sponsor, and when we're back,
let's talk about what obsessive love is. Welcome back to Criminalia.
(16:35):
Let's talk about how undiagnosed mental illness was likely fueling
Adele's stalker behavior. Right, so, but first let's be very clear.
We're not saying that having a crush on someone means
that you have a mental illness. But when there's an
obsessive part to it, when it's obsessive love, there are
some problematic behaviors that mental health professionals um will tell
(16:58):
you go along with it, and those include making repeated
calls or texts or letters, giving unwanted and intense attention
towards the object. Of your affection and even making unexpected,
unannounced visits at their work or home. Um, and that's
those are the examples of when we moved into what's
(17:19):
considered stalk or behavior. And there's no list of criteria
that can solidly distinguish what's real love from what's become
obsessive love. Right if my husband turned around and said
I'm not into you, I would look super stalkery, wouldn't
we all, I'm very attached to that gent. But we
(17:42):
do know that obsessive love is considered delusional jealousy, and
both real love and obsessive love have some addictive qualities
to them, and there can be a few things going
on in what differentiates this being something abnormal and not
healthy versus something that you know is part of just
(18:03):
an intense and deeply held relationship. Yes, I'm defending myself.
I know I'm obsessed with my husband. You just have
a lot of dopamine when you're around him. It's fine,
just hitting it off like a rato maze. So much
so I don't mean to laugh about this is his
mental health issues. So I'm going to talk now about
(18:23):
a condition called eroto mania, And we have talked about
this before on this show, but we'll we'll do a
quick overview because we've talked a lot of things before,
so let's just refresh um. This is a condition when
a person believes that another person loves them, whether or
not that person does or not. They're convinced. The individual
(18:46):
often believes that they're being sent messages from their admirer,
and that could be anything from like license plate numbers
to wearing a certain color sweater. It's it's very odd
and very specific. Arotomania has been considered different things depending
on which decade you're in. So in Adele's time in
(19:06):
the early nineteenth century to about the beginning of the
twentieth century, the mental health condition was believed to be
caused by unrequited love. It wasn't until the early twentieth century, though,
when it began to be considered a subtype of a
delusional disorder. Yeah, it's an interesting thing that the cause
and effect there was believed to be someone else not
(19:29):
loving you back, rather than there being something going on
with your brain chemistry that was making you perceive the
situation in quickly. So Arotomania has two forms, primary and secondary,
and the primary form is a condition that exists alone.
The onset is sudden and there's no identifiable cause. The
(19:50):
second form is diagnosed along with other mental illnesses, including schizophrenia,
which Adele likely lived with. And the secondary form often
includes symptoms like persecutory delusions, hallucinations, and grandiose ideas, and
it has a more gradual onset than the primary form,
though this can turn into Stoker behavior, and we have
(20:12):
told many of those stories. Now, this description of erotomania,
at least to us non medical professionals, it doesn't really
feel quite like the right fit for Adell. Right. There
is also a condition that is known as obsessive love disorder,
and that's when you become obsessed with one person that
you think you may be in love with. The distinction
(20:35):
here is that with erotomania, you think they love you. This, however,
obsessive love disorder was first called fittingly Adele syndrome, and
it's still not widely recognized as its own mental health condition.
It's usually tied to other things. And this is an expression, right, um,
But there's another thing. There's Adele's undiagnosed mental illness and
(20:56):
her symptoms of mental illness. They were likely the fuel
for her fire of irrational and obsessive behavior. And we're
gonna focus on because aprenia, because that's kind of what
everyone is assuming was happening with the doll's five. So,
schizophrenia is a mental illness that can be disabling. It's
generally characterized by a variety of things like thought related
(21:17):
and behavior related symptoms. Um, it could come in the
form of delusions, hallucinations, or just a general unusual way
of thinking. So by the time she was in Barbados,
it had become really quite obvious to those around Adele
that she was exhibiting some delusional, if not other odd behaviors,
(21:40):
and though not diagnosed, people who knew her recognized that
she was clearly unwell. So as we talk about all
of this, you know, we have to acknowledge it is always, really,
really a tricky proposition to diagnose someone post mortem when
they are not around to be assessed by a mental
health professional. But this, this association with schizophrenia on the
(22:02):
part of Adele, is something that modern biographers and historians
have pieced together multiple times. Like all of the evidence
indicates something along these lines. Um, there is also a
very good likelihood that she inherited it because it is
known to run in families, and her father's brother Eugene,
is also said to have lived with it. So those
(22:23):
living with this particular mental illness often experience psychosis, which
happens when you lose your connection with reality. You might
not know it, but people around you will notice this.
And delusions are are false beliefs that aren't based in reality,
and most people with schizophrenia will experience these as well.
(22:44):
And delusions could manifest in a few ways. Um you
might think you have special abilities, or you might believe
that you're being harassed by anyone from your neighbor to
the cia Um. Delusions could also leads you to believe
you have that another person is in love with you,
and those false beliefs often lead to paranoia. So there
(23:07):
are a few different stories of exactly how Adele was
extracted from Barbados and brought home to her family, but
most historians believe that she was actually accompanied back to
Paris by a woman named missus Celine Alvarez Ba in
February of eighty two. Ultimately, in the tragic story of Adele,
(23:27):
her father committed her to a mental institution when she
was home from Barbados, and she lived there from when
she was about forty or forty two years old until
her death at eighty five years old. Um and we
have an excerpt in a letter from one of his visits.
It's not too long, I'm gonna quote it. I saw
her again in the mental institution. She recognized me, I
(23:50):
embraced her. I spoke words of tenderness and hope to her.
She was calm and seemed sometimes to be asleep. It
was just one year ago today that I left for
Bordeaux with Charles, who would not return alive. Today I
see Adele again, what sorrow. And Victor Hugo bequeathed his manuscripts,
which include a significant part of Adele's exile diary as
(24:13):
well as her signed scores, to the National Library of France.
It's really easy to forget that she was a prolific
writer and musician, because her symptoms and her travels around
the world really seemed to cloud that. And I like
that we have various points that we can look at.
We can look at her father's manuscripts, which we can
(24:34):
look at her I suppose it took a little while,
but we could look in her code to diary there. Yeah,
there's a few places to get things from her. And
so interestingly, in looking at Victor Hugo's manuscripts, we know
that this episode was it was a downer. It was
downer for everyone. So to end a bit less somber,
I'm gonna share a little anecote about Victor Hugo that
(24:57):
that turned up during our research. And so Victor knew everyone,
and he was known for having large dinner parties, which
he would have almost every night of the week. There
were at least twenty or thirty people present, and he
had really one heck of a party trick that he
would pull out and just buris yourselves for a moment.
(25:17):
He would shove an entire orange in his mouth, and
then he would fill his cheeks with as many lumps
of sugar as would fit, and he would kind of
then like churn it all up in there. I can't
imagine he could have shut very well because of that
whole orange um and then he would he would swallow
it down with two glasses of gearch. So let's hope
(25:39):
that Holly is not making us all swallow a whole
orange in this episodes Chasers, But maybe she is. No,
doesn't not sound miserable and orange? You know, I keep
thinking him like, you know, a little like cute E's
or mandarins. This whole well, and I always think of
you know, when you take too big of a mouthful
(25:59):
of some very sugary and the sugar goes down the
wrong way, like that is one of the worst relatively
harmless pains. I can. No, there's no whole orange, but
I thought it would be fun to do something orange flavored.
And so I am calling this cocktail Victor's party trick,
(26:24):
because you're also creating something that tastes like something else delicious, Yes,
and not everyone could fit the whole orange in their
mactic And why would you want to, Victor, you fool.
He was loaded with vitamin C, so that's great. But
so for the party trick, into a shaker, you will
pour two ounces of triple sec two ounces of whipped
(26:47):
to vodka. You'll also see it like as whipped cream vodka.
There are a few different brands. One ounce of simple
syrup or vanilla syrup if you have it, and then
you're gonna shake that with ice, give it a good
heart shake, and then pour it into a martini glass
and then top it with three ounces of a hard seltzer.
If you want a hard seltzer that has a flavor
(27:09):
to it, that's fine. Like a citrus or even something
like a pineapple works here because when you take a sip,
it tastes like a creamsicles. That's the party trick. It
turns into a yummy dessert. The first version of the
party trick, I doubt tasted like a creamsicle. I don't
think it did, know, but I like things a little
(27:31):
more delicious than that. Yes, the point of yours is
to be a drink. The point of his was look
what I can fit in my mouth? Like I'm right.
No one else wanted to do that, but everyone will
want to drink if they are in fact a drinker.
This is also one if you wanted to do a
uh like a variation on it. If you're not a drinker,
I bet you could do, like, you know, a few
(27:53):
ounces of an orange soda and yeah, it is some
vanilla syrup with that and then like a a not
hard seltzer, and you would get something closesh. You wouldn't
quite be right. It's one of those things. Orange juice
is the natural tendency to want to go for when
you're recreating it. But usually in my experiments it's very yummy.
(28:14):
I love an orange juice with a vanilla vodka, but
it's a little too acidic, whereas like the orange soda
or an orange liquor is not as acidic. Usually you
don't have that bite of citrus. So I love that
she did a citrus drink this week, because I know
how you feel about citrus. It's not my favorite, it's mine,
(28:36):
but then it grows on me because I'll turn up
something like this. And even the sixteen sixties French lemonade
that we did give a season one was really quite yummy,
but also had a half pound that may have been
yunny because of the half a bag of sugarage. Yeah,
so I mean, at that point, what are you actually
(28:59):
tasting sugar? Just put some water on some sugar, just
drink it. So Victor's party trick, triple sack whipped vodka,
vanilla stare up in a little hard seltzer and you're
off to the races. Uh. It was so delicious. So
we hope that you have enjoyed not only a delicious
sip of something delightful but also spending this time with us,
and we hope to see you back next week right
(29:20):
here in Criminalia. Criminalia is a production of Shonda land
Audio in partnership with I Heart Radio. For more podcasts
from Shonda land Audio, please visit the I Heart Radio app,
Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
Hosts And Creators
Holly Frey
Maria Trimarchi
Popular Podcasts
Crime Junkie
Does hearing about a true crime case always leave you scouring the internet for the truth behind the story? Dive into your next mystery with Crime Junkie. Every Monday, join your host Ashley Flowers as she unravels all the details of infamous and underreported true crime cases with her best friend Brit Prawat. From cold cases to missing persons and heroes in our community who seek justice, Crime Junkie is your destination for theories and stories you won’t hear anywhere else. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or new to the genre, you'll find yourself on the edge of your seat awaiting a new episode every Monday. If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people. Follow to join a community of Crime Junkies! Crime Junkie is presented by audiochuck Media Company.
24/7 News: The Latest
The latest news in 4 minutes updated every hour, every day.
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.