April 4, 2024 • 25 mins
LA Times Reporter Paul Pringle starts to investigate what really happened at the Hotel Constance. But there’s a surprising lack of a police paper trail, and the Pasadena Police are stonewalling at every turn. So is USC. But Paul has investigated the university before, and he has his sources. Still, there’s one missing piece to the puzzle: the identity of the young woman found in the hotel room.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:02):
Every university has a scandal every now and then, we
just have the flavor of the week.
Speaker 2 (00:10):
That's William Tierney, Professor Emeritus at the University of Southern California.
He's been at USC for almost three decades and he's
seen the place get caught up in scandal, and not
just every now and then.
Speaker 1 (00:22):
What is it about USC that has created a non
ending bit of scandalmania for the institution?
Speaker 2 (00:29):
I've asked myself that same question many times, what is
it with USC and its scandals? My colleagues and I
have exposed a number of them over the years, and
it's not that we go looking for them, they find us.
My name is Paul Pringle. I'm an investigative reporter for
the La Times. This is Fallen Angels. This story is
(00:54):
about power and money and how they can eat away
at a place, corrupt it and destroy people lives in
the process. It's the story of an investigation that starts
in a hotel room in Pasadena, California, and reaches all
the way to the top of two of the most
powerful institutions in the city of Los Angeles. This is
(01:16):
episode two The Trojan Wall. Devon Khan was working at
the hotel Constance in Pasadena. He'd been there when a
young woman overdosed on drugs. The man she was with
was questioned by the police, but was allowed to just
(01:37):
walk away. It turned out that the man was the
dean of USC's medical school. His name is Carmen Puliaffido.
The cops had done nothing, and USC itself had just
ignored Devon's call. He'd been trying to get a tip
to the La Times when he met a Times photographer
named Ricardo de'r atonia.
Speaker 3 (01:56):
Boy, do I have a tip for you? And he's like, well,
I'm just a photographer, but what's the story. So I
laid it out for him and he's like, yeah, that's
a story. He goes like, I said, I'm a photographer,
but I can get the tip to the right person.
Speaker 2 (02:12):
Ricardo and the editors bring the tip to me since
I have some history investigating USC, so I called Devon Khan.
Speaker 3 (02:21):
I get a call from Paul. He says, yeah, I
understand that you know you have a tip. Would you
mind explaining to me what happened.
Speaker 2 (02:29):
Dev On's story is detailed and thorough. He seems like
a credible source, but he does have one important condition.
Speaker 3 (02:36):
Does the Tip understand that I need to remain anonymous.
Can't have this jeopardizing my job at all. He assured
me that I would remain anonymous. He says, Okay, I'm
going to start looking into this. He goes, I'm definitely
going to have to give you a call back from
time to time. Is that okay?
Speaker 4 (02:54):
I say, sure, whatever you need.
Speaker 2 (02:57):
The Times has strict guidelines for granting anonymity to sources.
They need to have a compelling reason to go unnamed,
like the fact that they would get fired if they
were identified. Devon makes that case to me convincingly. But
before I could even think about building a story around
an anonymous Tip, I have to check out, nail down
every detail of Devon's account. This is the starting point
(03:21):
of the investigation. First, I checked to see if there
has been any recent news about Puliafido.
Speaker 4 (03:31):
And yeah.
Speaker 2 (03:31):
It turns out that eleven days earlier, he had quote
stepped down as dean of the medical school. The press
release gives no reason for his sudden resignation, and it's
in the middle of the school term, which seems like
strange timing. I scrub public records for more on Puliaffido.
I find a recent divorce petition filed by his wife.
At the same time, I reach out to the coroner's
(03:53):
office to see if there's been a death of a
young woman in the past few weeks who matches the
description Devona had given me. And I head over to
the Passing A Police department to get a copy of
the police report from the incident. The Pasadena A Police
say there is no police report, just a heavily redacted document,
a log that shows the police accompanied paramedics on a call.
(04:16):
Considering what Devon has told me about what he witnessed
in the hotel room, the fact that there's no police
report strikes me as very odd.
Speaker 5 (04:25):
Any situation where somebody is seriously injured or likely to
die or is dead, those are the cases that would
be an automatic complaint report.
Speaker 2 (04:34):
Joseph Jackalone had a long career as an NYPD detective
with a specialty in forensic investigations. He's one of the
experts I contact for law enforcement stories.
Speaker 5 (04:44):
If you find lots of paraphernalia at the scene, or
guns and drugs or whatever you might find, those will
have to have a report because there's nothing on paper.
There's nothing to investigate, there's nothing to charge, and that's
why documentation becomes its real important and any attorney in
the world will tell you that if it wasn't document
that it wasn't done.
Speaker 2 (05:06):
And the fact that there was a camera potentially filming
everything in the room that raises all kinds of questions.
Speaker 5 (05:13):
What were they filming? There's lots of evidence that could
be found on that video, including the illegal user narcotics,
who was using them, and how they were being administered.
Speaker 2 (05:26):
But when I asked the police spokesperson about the lack
of a report, I'm told the incident had been viewed
as a quote, medical emergency, not a crime. I also
contact US's executive offices several times, trying to reach USC
president Max Tikias to ask him why the dean is
a medical school has suddenly stepped down. No response whatsoever,
(05:49):
and then I get an email from Pulliafido himself.
Speaker 4 (05:59):
Pull Fido right quote.
Speaker 2 (06:00):
I understand from my colleagues here at USC that you've
been inquiring about my stepping down as dean of the
medical school. I wanted to reach out to you directly
and let you know that my decision was entirely my
own The timing of my decision was related to a unique,
time limited opportunity in the biotech industry, something which I
am looking forward to sharing with others soon. US was
(06:21):
nice enough to grant me a sabbatical to explore this opportunity.
I got that email from him on April twenty of
twenty sixteen, a couple of weeks into my investigation. Naturally,
I write him back saying I have questions, and I
call I tell him I'm aware of the events occurred
on March fourth at the Hotel Constance, and I intend
(06:41):
to pursue the story.
Speaker 4 (06:45):
No reply.
Speaker 2 (06:48):
I have the same luck with the Kias and the
people close to him silence. I'm not surprised, but a
lack of response from USC's leaders. Silence had become their
typical way of dealing with me. I've investigated USC more
than once a colleague, and I discovered that USC's athletic
(07:09):
director was paying himself and his family members from a
scholarship fund for low income students. I investigated a cheating
scandal involving the coach of the USC football team, the Trojans,
And then there was our reporting on the deal that
gave US control of the publicly owned LA Coliseum.
Speaker 6 (07:28):
The coliseum was built to honor World War One veterans.
Speaker 4 (07:32):
That's been our Parks. Most people call him Bernie.
Speaker 6 (07:35):
It's the only place in the world that's had the
kinds of major events, the first Super Bowl, multiple Olympics,
a visit of the Pope. It's basically one of the
most recognized facilities in the world.
Speaker 2 (07:53):
Bernie Parks was chief of the LAPD from nineteen ninety
seven to two thousand and two. For the next twelve
he served as a member of the La City Council,
representing the eighth district in South LA. He's also a
USC alum. The coliseum part of his district is very
important to him and his constituents.
Speaker 6 (08:13):
This house sc football for decades because it's right across
the street. It's not a modern football facility as we
see on TV, whether it's NFL or other college stadium.
Sc it always hinted at they not only wanted to
have more upgrades of the facility, they also hinted strongly
(08:33):
that if these things couldn't be done, they would like
take over the facility.
Speaker 2 (08:40):
In twenty eleven, USC launched an aggressive campaign to take
control of the coliseum to a master lease that would
extend for nearly a century. The decision on whether to
accept US's proposal was up to the commission that managed
the coliseum parks.
Speaker 4 (08:55):
Was on that commission.
Speaker 6 (08:56):
They actually sent a proposal to the Colisseum Commission and
unanimously the commission rejected it. Members of the Colisim Commission
actually laughed at the deal because it was so preposterous.
It was like, give us the colissem and let us
run it, and community was not even part of the equation.
And so a letter was sent with unanimous signatures from
(09:19):
every member of the college in commission saying no, thank you,
we don't want to participate. This is not a deal
for the city. But s He did what it does.
Speaker 2 (09:29):
And what s He does is deploy its powerful trustees
and other allies to lean on the commission.
Speaker 6 (09:36):
The amount of money that they have is significant, the
amount of influence they have as far as their graduates
and their alumni, the amount of exposure they get from
their athletic program. They don't have any problem pushing their
weight around as it relates things that they want. They
went to Schwarzenegger as the state and they insisted that
(09:59):
with his three of appointments, could he make one of
them a member of SC's management or their board, and
so he agreed to that.
Speaker 2 (10:11):
Parks believe that after Governor Schwarzenegger made those appointments to
the Coliseum Commission, resistance to a USC takeover started to
crumble for some reasons.
Speaker 6 (10:21):
When Schwarzenegger got convinced that this was a good deal,
all of a sudden, the state begin to send messages
quietly that they were in support of this. And so
this process continues, and the Coliseum Commission approves this deal
and it moves forward. You're basically giving away a facility
(10:43):
that was built for military veterans, and you're giving it
to a private entity with the ability for them to
do with it as they please and keep all the money.
There is absolutely no benefit to the city, County.
Speaker 4 (10:56):
And state.
Speaker 2 (10:58):
Bernie says the proach in playbook. Whenever it faces resistance,
USC calls on its network of power brokers to neutralize
the opposition.
Speaker 6 (11:07):
I think what it shows when people fall in line,
they fall in line.
Speaker 2 (11:13):
It's now June, three months since the overdose at the
hotel Constance. Two months into my reporting, I learned from
a person within USC that President, Nikias is hosting a
celebration for Puliafido in honor of all he has done
for the medical school. The reception will be held at
the Kech School of Medicine on the Law and outside
of building name for Eli and Edith Broade, the La
(11:35):
billionaire couple who's thirty million dollar gift paid for it.
They made the gift three years into Puliafido's tenure esteem
perhaps a testament to his fundraising skills. My source shows
me the invitation they foresee for the event. It's Emboston
gold on heavy stock. Very nice. I'm definitely not invited,
but I show up anyway. I'm out the city US.
(11:59):
He's a private cool but the campus clearly invites entry
by the public just in case. Though I'm careful not
to break any trespassing rules. I make sure to stay
on the sidewalk and off the university's lawn. It's a
little hard to hear from where I'm standing, but here's
the gist. Nikias is extolling Puliafito's many accomplishments as Dean Pulliafido.
Speaker 4 (12:19):
Thanks his wife.
Speaker 2 (12:22):
I'll have to check the status of that divorce file.
This is the first time I've seen Pulliafido in person.
I'm struck by his confidence. He appears as if he
has nothing to worry about. My investigation included why would
(12:43):
the president of USC put on such a public show
of appreciation for Puliaffido, especially if he knew that the
La Times is investigating him. It might have something to
do with the priorities that drove Max Nichias. Professor William
Tierney had been at Penn State before coming to US
in nineteen ninety four.
Speaker 1 (13:02):
When I went to SC, a lot of my friends said, Geez,
SC is not of the same caliber as Penn State.
Why would you be moving to USC. There's an association
called the AAU, the Association of American Universities, and that's
the elite institutions. At the time, SC was at the
(13:23):
bottom of the AAU and trying to move up. Steve
Sample came in with a great deal of energy and
really wanted to transform the institution.
Speaker 2 (13:32):
Steve Sample was president of USC from nineteen ninety one
to twenty ten. Tierney saw what he was trying to do,
and he believed Sample could pull it off.
Speaker 1 (13:41):
For a university to be the best, it's not that
we've got a winning football team. It's that you've got
a faculty that are the best and you are listening
to what they say they need. And that also meant
that we needed to bring in enormous amounts of money
in a capital campaign.
Speaker 2 (14:00):
Ample devoted himself to fundraising NonStop, and when he retired,
Max to Kia seemed like the perfect choice to continue
that pursuit.
Speaker 1 (14:08):
Max was someone who if you called from New York
and said, I've got Joe and he's willing to have
breakfast with you tomorrow and he might give us big money,
but you need to be here for breakfast. Max would
take the Red Eye and if he knew that he
needed to be back in Los Angeles that night for
some type of dinner, he'd do it.
Speaker 2 (14:29):
Yikias's drive is understandable when you consider his background as
an immigrant who came to this country intent on making
something of himself.
Speaker 1 (14:37):
Max came from a very poor family in Cyprus. His
father was a carpenter. His father said to him at
one point, you're a smart, smart boy. I might send
you to high school and if you work hard, you
can graduate, then become a carpenter. For Max to graduate,
go to the United States, to go to a Sunni
Buffalo to get his doctorate, comes to USC, rises through
(14:59):
the ranks and become a president.
Speaker 2 (15:00):
I'm agazing, and his rise brought him into the same
room with a lot of rich, powerful, famous people.
Speaker 1 (15:07):
When you're having dinner with Steven Spielberg, that's a different
sort of undertaking. I do think that created a disconnect
between the world of the faculty and the world of
la At Max's inauguration, he said, USC, we have to
(15:30):
work so hard that we have to run a marathon
at a ten k speed. I went up to him
afterwards and I said, Max, you can't do that, and
you shouldn't tell people to do that, and he said, oh,
but we have to.
Speaker 2 (15:44):
When he was recruited to USC to run the medical school,
Holdieffido understood perfectly that the mandate was to bring in money,
and he delivered.
Speaker 1 (15:53):
Fundraising in the United States is sort of an odd thing.
If you're at Columbia or Harvard, there's a lot of
old money and foundations that will give you money. The West,
especially Los Angeles, is the opposite of that. It's a
lot of new money and you need to be charismatic
in a way that maxim Carmen had they knew how
(16:16):
to court donors successfully, and they did it.
Speaker 2 (16:21):
By the time he quote steps down as dean, Pulldiofido
has become the public face of the medical school. If
the dean were to get caught up in a scandal,
it would be bad for USC. This backslapping ceremony at
the Kech School of Medicine might be a face saving
gesture for Pulliffido, but maybe it's one for USC as well.
Speaker 7 (16:45):
This was a story that had the potential to hold
a powerful institution and a powerful person accountable for misconduct.
Speaker 2 (16:54):
Matt Lay was my editor at this time. Throughout his career,
he's seen his share of corruption and cover up.
Speaker 7 (17:00):
I was at the La Times for about twenty eight years.
I always tried to focus on investigative reporting, both as
a reporter and an editor. I worked with reporters who
uncovered corruption at city hall, abuses, in the La County jails.
I worked on investigations about dirty doctors, and prior to
(17:21):
the USC investigation, I was working on one about Purdue
pharmat These are tough.
Speaker 3 (17:25):
Stories to do.
Speaker 7 (17:26):
They can be controversial, they can have an impact.
Speaker 1 (17:29):
On the paper's reputation.
Speaker 7 (17:31):
The paper's finances, the paper's legal standing. They are all
issues that need to be considered when taking on powerful institutions.
But my feeling is that these are good stories.
Speaker 4 (17:42):
They should be.
Speaker 2 (17:43):
Published with Matt's support. I keep digging. I find Pullio
Fido's home address. It's a mansion in Pasadena. Of course,
it sits behind a high security gate. No way to
knock on his door. I leave my business card with
a note on his mail, urging him to get in touch.
He doesn't. Finally I get a break. I've made multiple
(18:12):
public records requests to opacitying of police, including for the
information redacted on the call log from the incident. I
need a way to verify what Devon has told me,
and the best way to do that is through police records.
So I've been chasing them constantly with no response. But
then the police chief writes that the records are requested
are exempt from disclosure because they're part of a criminal investigation.
Speaker 4 (18:36):
Wait a minute, what investigation?
Speaker 2 (18:38):
How could you have an investigation without a police report?
The chief set a trap for himself and walk right
into it. Now the city will have to cough up
a report.
Speaker 7 (18:48):
This story, like a lot of investigative reporting to me
is like detective work. You're out knocking on doors and
chasing leads and gathering them from me and filing public
records requests. There's a couple of different thoughts in journalism,
and the one I think Paul was favoring and I
was supportive of it was, let's go with what we know,
(19:10):
shake the tree and unearth other details that we didn't know.
Speaker 2 (19:16):
And finally, shaking that tree actually gets me something. The
passing a police department admits they made a mistake. After
months of saying there's no police report because there is
no need for one because this was a medical emergency,
not a crime, the department creates one retroactively three months
after the incident. The police spokesperson tells me they dropped
(19:36):
the ball because of a quote training issue. I've never
seen anything like it in my career. Neither has former
detective Joseph jackalone.
Speaker 5 (19:44):
Police departments have policies and procedures and protocols. For a reason,
we had a saying and said, went in doubt, fill
it out. So if you didn't know you had to
fill out a report, just fill it out. The worst
thing that could happen is that the supervisor, who has
to sign off on it, says, you know what, this
isn't necessary, so we're just going.
Speaker 3 (19:59):
To get rid of it.
Speaker 2 (20:01):
Finally I get access to not just the very tardy
police report, but also recordings of the nine one one
calls made.
Speaker 4 (20:07):
From the hotel.
Speaker 2 (20:09):
At first, I'm only given the recording of the call
that Devon made.
Speaker 5 (20:13):
Are you able to transfer me to that room?
Speaker 1 (20:14):
Or?
Speaker 2 (20:17):
But it cuts out when the dispatcher asks to be
transferred to room three oh four. Then the Pasadena City
manager sends me a second recording that he says the
city was quote able to obtain, and it's quote a
better version of the nine to one one call, and
it continues longer than the original file. Good does make
me wonder why wouldn't the city release the second recording immediately?
Speaker 4 (20:40):
Why hold it back?
Speaker 2 (20:41):
I finally get to hear from myself while the second
recording is quote better, did.
Speaker 3 (20:46):
She wake now?
Speaker 7 (20:47):
No, she's sort of very bride.
Speaker 5 (20:50):
You know.
Speaker 7 (20:50):
Do you know how much she drinks a.
Speaker 8 (20:52):
B I mean I came in the room and.
Speaker 3 (20:55):
There were lots of didn't you take any deals with it?
Speaker 7 (20:57):
Or just the alcohol?
Speaker 2 (20:59):
I think just the alpha the call places pull your
feto at the scene. We know from the report there's
meth in the room, and here he is present at
the overdose of a young woman, and you can hear
that he lies. He doesn't mention the drugs that, according
to Devon and the police report were found in a room.
So far, everything Devon con has told me has checked out.
(21:20):
I have plenty to run my story. My editor, Matt Laatee, agrees.
Speaker 7 (21:24):
The first draft was well documented, based on police reports,
nine to one one recordings, interviews with key people. It
was a solid story.
Speaker 2 (21:34):
There might be more to report in follow up stories,
but the details we have are bulletproof.
Speaker 4 (21:39):
The hot shot, Din.
Speaker 2 (21:39):
Of USC's medical school has caught up in an incident
where a young woman has overdosed on drugs and he
lies to the police.
Speaker 4 (21:46):
Then he mysteriously steps down. It looks bad and it's essence.
Speaker 7 (21:51):
This is the story about a powerful man abusing his
position and authority, and then on top of that you
have an institution that is essentially covering up before this man.
Speaker 2 (22:05):
It's Friday, the end of the day. I'm on my
way out the door. I stop and talk to my
friend Jack Leonard.
Speaker 8 (22:12):
I've been at the Los Angeles Times for more than
twenty five years. I started as an intern there in
nineteen eighty seven, and I've covered many different beats, police, crime,
county government. I've done a lot of investigative work. Paul
is excited about every really good story.
Speaker 4 (22:29):
That he works on.
Speaker 8 (22:30):
When he finds some wrongdoing, when he finds something that
authorities or powerful people are trying to keep him, he
gets very excited about it. And that's contagious, and he
likes sharing that.
Speaker 4 (22:42):
Like many of us do.
Speaker 8 (22:43):
So he comes over to my desk and he starts
telling me about the story.
Speaker 2 (22:48):
I tell him about Puliafido and USC, the stone walling
from the cops, the retroactive police report.
Speaker 8 (22:54):
I remember him talking about Pasadena police and how they
were not providing him with the requids that they were
supposed to be providing.
Speaker 4 (23:03):
But Jack's reaction is not what I expect.
Speaker 8 (23:06):
I said something to the defects of what makes you
think they could have publish that?
Speaker 2 (23:13):
And that's when I start to think, how far does
USC's influence actually go? Is it possible that it could
extend all the way into my own newsroom? Next time
on Fallen Angels as.
Speaker 8 (23:28):
An investigative reporter. Every story could be your lost.
Speaker 2 (23:32):
Matt and I face an uphill battle trying to get
our Pullia Fido story in the paper.
Speaker 7 (23:36):
I was in this defiant mode and kind of clung
to the idea that Dagon City wasn't closing the door
to more reporting.
Speaker 4 (23:44):
So we decide to force the issue.
Speaker 3 (23:46):
I remember being in the conference room and Matt had said, like, look,
we're going to do this thing.
Speaker 4 (23:52):
We're just going to keep it on the downlow. We're
going to make it so they have to publish Paul story.
That's next time. On Angels.
Speaker 2 (24:03):
Fallen Angels, The Story of California Corruption is a production
of iHeart Podcasts in partnership with Best Case Studios. I'm
Paul Pringle. This show is based on my book Bad City,
Peril and Power in the City of Angels. Fallen Angels
was written by Isabel Evans, Adam Pinks, and Brent Katz.
Isabel Evans is our producer, Brent Katz is co producer.
(24:27):
Associate producers are Hanna Leebowitz, Lockhart and On Pajo Locke.
Executive producers are Me, Paul Pringle, Joe Picarello, and Adam Pinkus.
For Best Case Studios. Original music is by James Newberry.
This episode was edited by Max Michael Miller with assistants
from Nisha Venkat. Additional editings, sound design, and additional music
(24:49):
by Dean White. Harriet Ryan, Matt Hamilton, Sarah Parvini and
Adam Almarik are consulting producers. Our iHeart team is Ali
Perry and Carl Ketel. Following eight Fallen Angels Wherever you
get your Podcasts, m
Every university has a scandal every now and then, we
just have the flavor of the week.
Speaker 2 (00:10):
That's William Tierney, Professor Emeritus at the University of Southern California.
He's been at USC for almost three decades and he's
seen the place get caught up in scandal, and not
just every now and then.
Speaker 1 (00:22):
What is it about USC that has created a non
ending bit of scandalmania for the institution?
Speaker 2 (00:29):
I've asked myself that same question many times, what is
it with USC and its scandals? My colleagues and I
have exposed a number of them over the years, and
it's not that we go looking for them, they find us.
My name is Paul Pringle. I'm an investigative reporter for
the La Times. This is Fallen Angels. This story is
(00:54):
about power and money and how they can eat away
at a place, corrupt it and destroy people lives in
the process. It's the story of an investigation that starts
in a hotel room in Pasadena, California, and reaches all
the way to the top of two of the most
powerful institutions in the city of Los Angeles. This is
(01:16):
episode two The Trojan Wall. Devon Khan was working at
the hotel Constance in Pasadena. He'd been there when a
young woman overdosed on drugs. The man she was with
was questioned by the police, but was allowed to just
(01:37):
walk away. It turned out that the man was the
dean of USC's medical school. His name is Carmen Puliaffido.
The cops had done nothing, and USC itself had just
ignored Devon's call. He'd been trying to get a tip
to the La Times when he met a Times photographer
named Ricardo de'r atonia.
Speaker 3 (01:56):
Boy, do I have a tip for you? And he's like, well,
I'm just a photographer, but what's the story. So I
laid it out for him and he's like, yeah, that's
a story. He goes like, I said, I'm a photographer,
but I can get the tip to the right person.
Speaker 2 (02:12):
Ricardo and the editors bring the tip to me since
I have some history investigating USC, so I called Devon Khan.
Speaker 3 (02:21):
I get a call from Paul. He says, yeah, I
understand that you know you have a tip. Would you
mind explaining to me what happened.
Speaker 2 (02:29):
Dev On's story is detailed and thorough. He seems like
a credible source, but he does have one important condition.
Speaker 3 (02:36):
Does the Tip understand that I need to remain anonymous.
Can't have this jeopardizing my job at all. He assured
me that I would remain anonymous. He says, Okay, I'm
going to start looking into this. He goes, I'm definitely
going to have to give you a call back from
time to time. Is that okay?
Speaker 4 (02:54):
I say, sure, whatever you need.
Speaker 2 (02:57):
The Times has strict guidelines for granting anonymity to sources.
They need to have a compelling reason to go unnamed,
like the fact that they would get fired if they
were identified. Devon makes that case to me convincingly. But
before I could even think about building a story around
an anonymous Tip, I have to check out, nail down
every detail of Devon's account. This is the starting point
(03:21):
of the investigation. First, I checked to see if there
has been any recent news about Puliafido.
Speaker 4 (03:31):
And yeah.
Speaker 2 (03:31):
It turns out that eleven days earlier, he had quote
stepped down as dean of the medical school. The press
release gives no reason for his sudden resignation, and it's
in the middle of the school term, which seems like
strange timing. I scrub public records for more on Puliaffido.
I find a recent divorce petition filed by his wife.
At the same time, I reach out to the coroner's
(03:53):
office to see if there's been a death of a
young woman in the past few weeks who matches the
description Devona had given me. And I head over to
the Passing A Police department to get a copy of
the police report from the incident. The Pasadena A Police
say there is no police report, just a heavily redacted document,
a log that shows the police accompanied paramedics on a call.
(04:16):
Considering what Devon has told me about what he witnessed
in the hotel room, the fact that there's no police
report strikes me as very odd.
Speaker 5 (04:25):
Any situation where somebody is seriously injured or likely to
die or is dead, those are the cases that would
be an automatic complaint report.
Speaker 2 (04:34):
Joseph Jackalone had a long career as an NYPD detective
with a specialty in forensic investigations. He's one of the
experts I contact for law enforcement stories.
Speaker 5 (04:44):
If you find lots of paraphernalia at the scene, or
guns and drugs or whatever you might find, those will
have to have a report because there's nothing on paper.
There's nothing to investigate, there's nothing to charge, and that's
why documentation becomes its real important and any attorney in
the world will tell you that if it wasn't document
that it wasn't done.
Speaker 2 (05:06):
And the fact that there was a camera potentially filming
everything in the room that raises all kinds of questions.
Speaker 5 (05:13):
What were they filming? There's lots of evidence that could
be found on that video, including the illegal user narcotics,
who was using them, and how they were being administered.
Speaker 2 (05:26):
But when I asked the police spokesperson about the lack
of a report, I'm told the incident had been viewed
as a quote, medical emergency, not a crime. I also
contact US's executive offices several times, trying to reach USC
president Max Tikias to ask him why the dean is
a medical school has suddenly stepped down. No response whatsoever,
(05:49):
and then I get an email from Pulliafido himself.
Speaker 4 (05:59):
Pull Fido right quote.
Speaker 2 (06:00):
I understand from my colleagues here at USC that you've
been inquiring about my stepping down as dean of the
medical school. I wanted to reach out to you directly
and let you know that my decision was entirely my
own The timing of my decision was related to a unique,
time limited opportunity in the biotech industry, something which I
am looking forward to sharing with others soon. US was
(06:21):
nice enough to grant me a sabbatical to explore this opportunity.
I got that email from him on April twenty of
twenty sixteen, a couple of weeks into my investigation. Naturally,
I write him back saying I have questions, and I
call I tell him I'm aware of the events occurred
on March fourth at the Hotel Constance, and I intend
(06:41):
to pursue the story.
Speaker 4 (06:45):
No reply.
Speaker 2 (06:48):
I have the same luck with the Kias and the
people close to him silence. I'm not surprised, but a
lack of response from USC's leaders. Silence had become their
typical way of dealing with me. I've investigated USC more
than once a colleague, and I discovered that USC's athletic
(07:09):
director was paying himself and his family members from a
scholarship fund for low income students. I investigated a cheating
scandal involving the coach of the USC football team, the Trojans,
And then there was our reporting on the deal that
gave US control of the publicly owned LA Coliseum.
Speaker 6 (07:28):
The coliseum was built to honor World War One veterans.
Speaker 4 (07:32):
That's been our Parks. Most people call him Bernie.
Speaker 6 (07:35):
It's the only place in the world that's had the
kinds of major events, the first Super Bowl, multiple Olympics,
a visit of the Pope. It's basically one of the
most recognized facilities in the world.
Speaker 2 (07:53):
Bernie Parks was chief of the LAPD from nineteen ninety
seven to two thousand and two. For the next twelve
he served as a member of the La City Council,
representing the eighth district in South LA. He's also a
USC alum. The coliseum part of his district is very
important to him and his constituents.
Speaker 6 (08:13):
This house sc football for decades because it's right across
the street. It's not a modern football facility as we
see on TV, whether it's NFL or other college stadium.
Sc it always hinted at they not only wanted to
have more upgrades of the facility, they also hinted strongly
(08:33):
that if these things couldn't be done, they would like
take over the facility.
Speaker 2 (08:40):
In twenty eleven, USC launched an aggressive campaign to take
control of the coliseum to a master lease that would
extend for nearly a century. The decision on whether to
accept US's proposal was up to the commission that managed
the coliseum parks.
Speaker 4 (08:55):
Was on that commission.
Speaker 6 (08:56):
They actually sent a proposal to the Colisseum Commission and
unanimously the commission rejected it. Members of the Colisim Commission
actually laughed at the deal because it was so preposterous.
It was like, give us the colissem and let us
run it, and community was not even part of the equation.
And so a letter was sent with unanimous signatures from
(09:19):
every member of the college in commission saying no, thank you,
we don't want to participate. This is not a deal
for the city. But s He did what it does.
Speaker 2 (09:29):
And what s He does is deploy its powerful trustees
and other allies to lean on the commission.
Speaker 6 (09:36):
The amount of money that they have is significant, the
amount of influence they have as far as their graduates
and their alumni, the amount of exposure they get from
their athletic program. They don't have any problem pushing their
weight around as it relates things that they want. They
went to Schwarzenegger as the state and they insisted that
(09:59):
with his three of appointments, could he make one of
them a member of SC's management or their board, and
so he agreed to that.
Speaker 2 (10:11):
Parks believe that after Governor Schwarzenegger made those appointments to
the Coliseum Commission, resistance to a USC takeover started to
crumble for some reasons.
Speaker 6 (10:21):
When Schwarzenegger got convinced that this was a good deal,
all of a sudden, the state begin to send messages
quietly that they were in support of this. And so
this process continues, and the Coliseum Commission approves this deal
and it moves forward. You're basically giving away a facility
(10:43):
that was built for military veterans, and you're giving it
to a private entity with the ability for them to
do with it as they please and keep all the money.
There is absolutely no benefit to the city, County.
Speaker 4 (10:56):
And state.
Speaker 2 (10:58):
Bernie says the proach in playbook. Whenever it faces resistance,
USC calls on its network of power brokers to neutralize
the opposition.
Speaker 6 (11:07):
I think what it shows when people fall in line,
they fall in line.
Speaker 2 (11:13):
It's now June, three months since the overdose at the
hotel Constance. Two months into my reporting, I learned from
a person within USC that President, Nikias is hosting a
celebration for Puliafido in honor of all he has done
for the medical school. The reception will be held at
the Kech School of Medicine on the Law and outside
of building name for Eli and Edith Broade, the La
(11:35):
billionaire couple who's thirty million dollar gift paid for it.
They made the gift three years into Puliafido's tenure esteem
perhaps a testament to his fundraising skills. My source shows
me the invitation they foresee for the event. It's Emboston
gold on heavy stock. Very nice. I'm definitely not invited,
but I show up anyway. I'm out the city US.
(11:59):
He's a private cool but the campus clearly invites entry
by the public just in case. Though I'm careful not
to break any trespassing rules. I make sure to stay
on the sidewalk and off the university's lawn. It's a
little hard to hear from where I'm standing, but here's
the gist. Nikias is extolling Puliafito's many accomplishments as Dean Pulliafido.
Speaker 4 (12:19):
Thanks his wife.
Speaker 2 (12:22):
I'll have to check the status of that divorce file.
This is the first time I've seen Pulliafido in person.
I'm struck by his confidence. He appears as if he
has nothing to worry about. My investigation included why would
(12:43):
the president of USC put on such a public show
of appreciation for Puliaffido, especially if he knew that the
La Times is investigating him. It might have something to
do with the priorities that drove Max Nichias. Professor William
Tierney had been at Penn State before coming to US
in nineteen ninety four.
Speaker 1 (13:02):
When I went to SC, a lot of my friends said, Geez,
SC is not of the same caliber as Penn State.
Why would you be moving to USC. There's an association
called the AAU, the Association of American Universities, and that's
the elite institutions. At the time, SC was at the
(13:23):
bottom of the AAU and trying to move up. Steve
Sample came in with a great deal of energy and
really wanted to transform the institution.
Speaker 2 (13:32):
Steve Sample was president of USC from nineteen ninety one
to twenty ten. Tierney saw what he was trying to do,
and he believed Sample could pull it off.
Speaker 1 (13:41):
For a university to be the best, it's not that
we've got a winning football team. It's that you've got
a faculty that are the best and you are listening
to what they say they need. And that also meant
that we needed to bring in enormous amounts of money
in a capital campaign.
Speaker 2 (14:00):
Ample devoted himself to fundraising NonStop, and when he retired,
Max to Kia seemed like the perfect choice to continue
that pursuit.
Speaker 1 (14:08):
Max was someone who if you called from New York
and said, I've got Joe and he's willing to have
breakfast with you tomorrow and he might give us big money,
but you need to be here for breakfast. Max would
take the Red Eye and if he knew that he
needed to be back in Los Angeles that night for
some type of dinner, he'd do it.
Speaker 2 (14:29):
Yikias's drive is understandable when you consider his background as
an immigrant who came to this country intent on making
something of himself.
Speaker 1 (14:37):
Max came from a very poor family in Cyprus. His
father was a carpenter. His father said to him at
one point, you're a smart, smart boy. I might send
you to high school and if you work hard, you
can graduate, then become a carpenter. For Max to graduate,
go to the United States, to go to a Sunni
Buffalo to get his doctorate, comes to USC, rises through
(14:59):
the ranks and become a president.
Speaker 2 (15:00):
I'm agazing, and his rise brought him into the same
room with a lot of rich, powerful, famous people.
Speaker 1 (15:07):
When you're having dinner with Steven Spielberg, that's a different
sort of undertaking. I do think that created a disconnect
between the world of the faculty and the world of
la At Max's inauguration, he said, USC, we have to
(15:30):
work so hard that we have to run a marathon
at a ten k speed. I went up to him
afterwards and I said, Max, you can't do that, and
you shouldn't tell people to do that, and he said, oh,
but we have to.
Speaker 2 (15:44):
When he was recruited to USC to run the medical school,
Holdieffido understood perfectly that the mandate was to bring in money,
and he delivered.
Speaker 1 (15:53):
Fundraising in the United States is sort of an odd thing.
If you're at Columbia or Harvard, there's a lot of
old money and foundations that will give you money. The West,
especially Los Angeles, is the opposite of that. It's a
lot of new money and you need to be charismatic
in a way that maxim Carmen had they knew how
(16:16):
to court donors successfully, and they did it.
Speaker 2 (16:21):
By the time he quote steps down as dean, Pulldiofido
has become the public face of the medical school. If
the dean were to get caught up in a scandal,
it would be bad for USC. This backslapping ceremony at
the Kech School of Medicine might be a face saving
gesture for Pulliffido, but maybe it's one for USC as well.
Speaker 7 (16:45):
This was a story that had the potential to hold
a powerful institution and a powerful person accountable for misconduct.
Speaker 2 (16:54):
Matt Lay was my editor at this time. Throughout his career,
he's seen his share of corruption and cover up.
Speaker 7 (17:00):
I was at the La Times for about twenty eight years.
I always tried to focus on investigative reporting, both as
a reporter and an editor. I worked with reporters who
uncovered corruption at city hall, abuses, in the La County jails.
I worked on investigations about dirty doctors, and prior to
(17:21):
the USC investigation, I was working on one about Purdue
pharmat These are tough.
Speaker 3 (17:25):
Stories to do.
Speaker 7 (17:26):
They can be controversial, they can have an impact.
Speaker 1 (17:29):
On the paper's reputation.
Speaker 7 (17:31):
The paper's finances, the paper's legal standing. They are all
issues that need to be considered when taking on powerful institutions.
But my feeling is that these are good stories.
Speaker 4 (17:42):
They should be.
Speaker 2 (17:43):
Published with Matt's support. I keep digging. I find Pullio
Fido's home address. It's a mansion in Pasadena. Of course,
it sits behind a high security gate. No way to
knock on his door. I leave my business card with
a note on his mail, urging him to get in touch.
He doesn't. Finally I get a break. I've made multiple
(18:12):
public records requests to opacitying of police, including for the
information redacted on the call log from the incident. I
need a way to verify what Devon has told me,
and the best way to do that is through police records.
So I've been chasing them constantly with no response. But
then the police chief writes that the records are requested
are exempt from disclosure because they're part of a criminal investigation.
Speaker 4 (18:36):
Wait a minute, what investigation?
Speaker 2 (18:38):
How could you have an investigation without a police report?
The chief set a trap for himself and walk right
into it. Now the city will have to cough up
a report.
Speaker 7 (18:48):
This story, like a lot of investigative reporting to me
is like detective work. You're out knocking on doors and
chasing leads and gathering them from me and filing public
records requests. There's a couple of different thoughts in journalism,
and the one I think Paul was favoring and I
was supportive of it was, let's go with what we know,
(19:10):
shake the tree and unearth other details that we didn't know.
Speaker 2 (19:16):
And finally, shaking that tree actually gets me something. The
passing a police department admits they made a mistake. After
months of saying there's no police report because there is
no need for one because this was a medical emergency,
not a crime, the department creates one retroactively three months
after the incident. The police spokesperson tells me they dropped
(19:36):
the ball because of a quote training issue. I've never
seen anything like it in my career. Neither has former
detective Joseph jackalone.
Speaker 5 (19:44):
Police departments have policies and procedures and protocols. For a reason,
we had a saying and said, went in doubt, fill
it out. So if you didn't know you had to
fill out a report, just fill it out. The worst
thing that could happen is that the supervisor, who has
to sign off on it, says, you know what, this
isn't necessary, so we're just going.
Speaker 3 (19:59):
To get rid of it.
Speaker 2 (20:01):
Finally I get access to not just the very tardy
police report, but also recordings of the nine one one
calls made.
Speaker 4 (20:07):
From the hotel.
Speaker 2 (20:09):
At first, I'm only given the recording of the call
that Devon made.
Speaker 5 (20:13):
Are you able to transfer me to that room?
Speaker 1 (20:14):
Or?
Speaker 2 (20:17):
But it cuts out when the dispatcher asks to be
transferred to room three oh four. Then the Pasadena City
manager sends me a second recording that he says the
city was quote able to obtain, and it's quote a
better version of the nine to one one call, and
it continues longer than the original file. Good does make
me wonder why wouldn't the city release the second recording immediately?
Speaker 4 (20:40):
Why hold it back?
Speaker 2 (20:41):
I finally get to hear from myself while the second
recording is quote better, did.
Speaker 3 (20:46):
She wake now?
Speaker 7 (20:47):
No, she's sort of very bride.
Speaker 5 (20:50):
You know.
Speaker 7 (20:50):
Do you know how much she drinks a.
Speaker 8 (20:52):
B I mean I came in the room and.
Speaker 3 (20:55):
There were lots of didn't you take any deals with it?
Speaker 7 (20:57):
Or just the alcohol?
Speaker 2 (20:59):
I think just the alpha the call places pull your
feto at the scene. We know from the report there's
meth in the room, and here he is present at
the overdose of a young woman, and you can hear
that he lies. He doesn't mention the drugs that, according
to Devon and the police report were found in a room.
So far, everything Devon con has told me has checked out.
(21:20):
I have plenty to run my story. My editor, Matt Laatee, agrees.
Speaker 7 (21:24):
The first draft was well documented, based on police reports,
nine to one one recordings, interviews with key people. It
was a solid story.
Speaker 2 (21:34):
There might be more to report in follow up stories,
but the details we have are bulletproof.
Speaker 4 (21:39):
The hot shot, Din.
Speaker 2 (21:39):
Of USC's medical school has caught up in an incident
where a young woman has overdosed on drugs and he
lies to the police.
Speaker 4 (21:46):
Then he mysteriously steps down. It looks bad and it's essence.
Speaker 7 (21:51):
This is the story about a powerful man abusing his
position and authority, and then on top of that you
have an institution that is essentially covering up before this man.
Speaker 2 (22:05):
It's Friday, the end of the day. I'm on my
way out the door. I stop and talk to my
friend Jack Leonard.
Speaker 8 (22:12):
I've been at the Los Angeles Times for more than
twenty five years. I started as an intern there in
nineteen eighty seven, and I've covered many different beats, police, crime,
county government. I've done a lot of investigative work. Paul
is excited about every really good story.
Speaker 4 (22:29):
That he works on.
Speaker 8 (22:30):
When he finds some wrongdoing, when he finds something that
authorities or powerful people are trying to keep him, he
gets very excited about it. And that's contagious, and he
likes sharing that.
Speaker 4 (22:42):
Like many of us do.
Speaker 8 (22:43):
So he comes over to my desk and he starts
telling me about the story.
Speaker 2 (22:48):
I tell him about Puliafido and USC, the stone walling
from the cops, the retroactive police report.
Speaker 8 (22:54):
I remember him talking about Pasadena police and how they
were not providing him with the requids that they were
supposed to be providing.
Speaker 4 (23:03):
But Jack's reaction is not what I expect.
Speaker 8 (23:06):
I said something to the defects of what makes you
think they could have publish that?
Speaker 2 (23:13):
And that's when I start to think, how far does
USC's influence actually go? Is it possible that it could
extend all the way into my own newsroom? Next time
on Fallen Angels as.
Speaker 8 (23:28):
An investigative reporter. Every story could be your lost.
Speaker 2 (23:32):
Matt and I face an uphill battle trying to get
our Pullia Fido story in the paper.
Speaker 7 (23:36):
I was in this defiant mode and kind of clung
to the idea that Dagon City wasn't closing the door
to more reporting.
Speaker 4 (23:44):
So we decide to force the issue.
Speaker 3 (23:46):
I remember being in the conference room and Matt had said, like, look,
we're going to do this thing.
Speaker 4 (23:52):
We're just going to keep it on the downlow. We're
going to make it so they have to publish Paul story.
That's next time. On Angels.
Speaker 2 (24:03):
Fallen Angels, The Story of California Corruption is a production
of iHeart Podcasts in partnership with Best Case Studios. I'm
Paul Pringle. This show is based on my book Bad City,
Peril and Power in the City of Angels. Fallen Angels
was written by Isabel Evans, Adam Pinks, and Brent Katz.
Isabel Evans is our producer, Brent Katz is co producer.
(24:27):
Associate producers are Hanna Leebowitz, Lockhart and On Pajo Locke.
Executive producers are Me, Paul Pringle, Joe Picarello, and Adam Pinkus.
For Best Case Studios. Original music is by James Newberry.
This episode was edited by Max Michael Miller with assistants
from Nisha Venkat. Additional editings, sound design, and additional music
(24:49):
by Dean White. Harriet Ryan, Matt Hamilton, Sarah Parvini and
Adam Almarik are consulting producers. Our iHeart team is Ali
Perry and Carl Ketel. Following eight Fallen Angels Wherever you
get your Podcasts, m
Popular Podcasts
1. The Podium
The Podium: An NBC Olympic and Paralympic podcast. Join us for insider coverage during the intense competition at the 2024 Paris Olympic and Paralympic Games. In the run-up to the Opening Ceremony, we’ll bring you deep into the stories and events that have you know and those you'll be hard-pressed to forget.
2. In The Village
In The Village will take you into the most exclusive areas of the 2024 Paris Olympic Games to explore the daily life of athletes, complete with all the funny, mundane and unexpected things you learn off the field of play. Join Elizabeth Beisel as she sits down with Olympians each day in Paris.
3. iHeartOlympics: The Latest
Listen to the latest news from the 2024 Olympics.