All Episodes

June 6, 2022 • 50 mins

This week, Jamie heads to the only spiritualist library in the American south -- open two hours a week -- to try and trace the legend of Cassadaga's founding to its root, as land taken from indigenous Americans. Writer Olivia Woodward stops by to discuss spiritual traditions of the Caddo Nation, thoughts on spiritualism's appropriation of Native culture, and questions George Colby's spirit guide.


Follow Olivia's work here: https://twitter.com/LivNative93


More on the Seneca Nation: https://sni.org/

More on the Mascogo: https://about.proquest.com/en/blog/2019/what-juneteenth-means-to-the-mascogo-tribe/

More on the Timucua: https://read.dukeupress.edu/hahr/article/77/3/502/144849/The-History-of-the-Timucua-Indians-and-Missions

More on the Miccosukee: https://www.miccosukee.com/history 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:02):
I've finally made it to the Cassadeca Library, but as
with everything in this place, they did not make it easy.
It's a Tuesday night and the sun is setting. For
my entire time here, I don't ever feel afraid or
threatened when night falls near the Ghost Church. And I
mean that. I mean. One of the first things I
was told by Pastor deb when I was planning my

(00:24):
trip to Cassadeca was that there was this energy vortex
in the area, a spirit vortex. It sounds a little scary,
but all it means is that this is a place
where contact with the dead is more possible than almost
anywhere else in the country. Other areas that have vortexes
include Arizona, New Mexico, the Midwest in many places, New England,

(00:50):
and of course of State, New York, basically anywhere spiritualism
popped off. The b and Game in Memorial Library is
on Stephens Street in Cassadakeh, right by where I did
my session with the Reverend Doctor Louis Gates and the
Ferry Trail where tourists leave those little trinkets and remembrances
of themselves and they're dead. And Gaiman herself was trained

(01:13):
as a medium in Cassadega, beginning as a teenager and
served as a medium to lobbyists and congress people in
the DC area for decades. Make of that what you will.
The library itself doubles as an educational building where classes
take place and as another example of a property in
Cassadega that could definitely use a renovation. Lawn is a

(01:36):
little bit barren. There's some detritus close to one of
the exits, and there don't seem to be any lights
on inside on the street where most of the houses
have soft lights from the interior, telling you that at
least someone is home, either making dinner or possibly helping
someone connect with the dead mother they never got closure with.

(01:57):
I crossed the lawn and try one of the entry
says it's a lucky guess, And suddenly I'm standing in
what appears to just look like someone's house with the
lights off. There's a voice coming from down the hallway.
It sounds like there's a man talking to himself, or actually,
the longer I listened, I realize he's talking to a dog.

(02:17):
I call the number I was given for the librarian
who works here, and feel deeply paranoid because if I
miscalculated this, There's virtually no other time to see whatever
is going on in this building. The library is open
exactly two hours per week Tuesday night, seven pm to
nine pm, and has run by someone who has what

(02:40):
I feel is the most noble profession in the entire world,
a volunteer librarian. As I'm trying to get my nerve
up to follow this voice down the hall, a couple
enters the building behind me. I've actually met the woman
before at a class called Healing one oh one at
the Andrew Jackson Davis building around the corner. She had

(03:00):
been excited to learn that I was a reporter. Did
I want to read the children's books she self published
not too long ago. It's on Amazon. The two are
also volunteer librarians here. I learned she and her husband
are Rhode Islanders who moved to Cassadega sometime in the
middle of the pandemic. They had retired they were sick

(03:22):
of mask mandates, yet another common feeling here in Cassadega
that seems to go against the traditional, assumed progressivism of
the religion. She had taken an interest in spiritualism and
is training as a medium. Herself, so at this point
the couple had been involved at the camp intimately for months, volunteering,

(03:43):
taking classes, and attending services for the full year that
it's necessary to before one can qualify to rent land
from the camp to live on. As we've discussed in
past episodes, becoming a medium at Cassadega takes at least
four years, and she'll have to find a mentor to
approve and keep track of her training and volunteer hours,

(04:05):
and seems to have found the person she's looking for
via the librarian, who as we get to the end
of the hall, is there with a little wheezing dog.
He asks, am I, Jamie. I say yes and apologize
for all the calls. I'm just worried that I'll miss
it when there's so few hours available. He's a total sweetheart,
a man in his seventies with this low musical voice

(04:28):
named Richard Russell. It is recognized that everything in the
universe's energy and vibration. As an extension of that knowledge,
we in accord our energy and are affected by the
vibrations around us. He's been at Cassadega for twenty five
years and the library is sort of his side project.

(04:49):
You could say, he tells me. It started in seventeen
with a donation of eighteen hundred books from Endgame in
herself and has since ballooned to a collect of over
six thousand books and texts. Every Tuesday, he and a
few volunteers continue the work of organizing the titles into
an infinity Google spreadsheet. Six thousand volumes is pretty impressive,

(05:14):
But what I'm most curious about on this night is
what kind of texts we're talking. For the most part,
I find the same history is reported over and over
over a century of spiritualists working out their ideas, working
out their inviting some texts that reference more Eastern religion,
self help, idealism, American individualism. It's a fascinating collection, but

(05:40):
it feels like there's a lot missing. So over the
next two weeks, we're going to take a look at
the corners of spiritualism that are even less discussed than
the religion itself. Will take a look at the cultures
that spiritualism appropriates in order to distance itself from traditional Christianity.
How a supposedly russ of religion managed to lose the

(06:02):
vast majority of their Black American believers in the offshoot
of spiritualism that enmeshed with the beliefs of enslaved people
who had been moved to Imperial Land and created a
religious movement that is far more popular and practiced than
spiritualism in America itself. Let's create a corner of the
library that doesn't exist. Meet me at the energy vortex

(06:25):
down at Seneca Pond. Wait o, Seneca Wait. Let's do
the theme song first? Is that Vera so Richard shows

(07:28):
me into this library that's being organized as a volunteer
project by medium slash librarians. Some of the materials are
primary sources and pamphlets that have been hanging around the camp,
semi organized for decades, and other texts were inherited by
retired or passed into spirit mediums, still to be arranged

(07:50):
and determined what their use in the camp might be.
The two rooms that compose the library have these low
ceilings and are lit with fluorescent lights. Most of the
shelves are full, others are semi organized arranged. Categories so
far include biographies of mediums, metaphysical topics, women's books, self
help books. I can't account for this, but there's a

(08:12):
pile of books on the ground that seemed to have
to do with the history of Nazis between the late
nineteen twenties and World War Two. It's not pro Nazi rhetoric,
but I don't understand why it's there. Richard is kind
of talking me through these categories as he walks me around.
He says, we try to be inclusive, but he gestures

(08:33):
around a little helplessly before earnestly begging me to please
put books back where I found them. They don't have
the infrastructure to organize them. Again, he says, our system
is not the best and if we get books out
of whack. He trails off, just completely overwhelmed by the
idea of books out of whack, and he leaves me

(08:54):
to it. So where to start. I'm trying not to
trip over the random stacks of books and paper that
have yet to be categorized, and decided that I'll try
and start by seeking out something I've been looking for
since I got here, any record or context for the
spiritualists preoccupation with generalized indigenous history. But for all the

(09:16):
books that I can find, just a sampling of titles.
They've got a copy of Women who Love Too Much,
They've got shelves dedicated to natural law and angels and
aura color and astral projection, and even a copy of
that book by Dr Phil that everybody's auntie has that
book called Self Matters? Why do they have that? What
there's none of is anything that concerns spiritual practices outside

(09:41):
of American spiritualism, for questions what cultural influences they took
in order to build their own religion. In the several
volumes that exist on Cassadega's history, one story always features prominently,
the Cassadega Founding story. I find it in a number
of titles throughout the library, and it's been repeated pretty

(10:03):
often online as well, and I think it's high time
that we take a closer look at it. On Ghost Church,
that's the show you're listening to. By the way, mm,
the myth goes a little bit like this. The Fox Sisters,

(10:26):
who had first heard the spirit rappings in Hydesville, New
York in eighty eight as kids, were dead and gone
by the mid eighteen nineties, after decades of prosperity, struggle, destitution,
and establishing themselves as some of the premier female religious
leaders of their time. While the Sisters Maggie and Kate
Fox in particular, died in relative poverty and obscurity. The

(10:50):
legacy they left behind was enormous. Spiritualism had managed to
cross lines of fashionality, of gender, of race, of class.
It now belonged to the whole world, and communities were
forming to continue the observance and development of this Christian
influenced religion with no heaven or Hell that emphasized spirit

(11:13):
communication and mediumship entered George Colby, born just weeks before
the Fox sisters made a splash in upstate New York.
Colby grew up in Pike, New York, an hour outside
of Rochester, before the family moved to Minnesota, and Colby
developed an interest in spiritualism as a teenager, beginning to

(11:34):
work as a medium in the eighteen sixties and formally
leaving his Baptist upbringing in eighteen sixty seven after the
conclusion of the Civil War. Legend has it that one
of the main messages Colby received during this time was
that it was his destiny to start a spiritualist camp
in the US. But with all due respect, George Colby

(11:58):
said a lot of things, and so did his primary
spirit guide, an indigenous man named Seneca, which we've been
beating around the bush on Seneca long enough. I've mentioned
before that Seneca is a prominent name here at the
Cassadega Camp. One of the main parks that one I
was telling you about with the energy Vortex is named

(12:21):
for Seneca, and another meditation garden, refers to Native American
spiritual practices in this very Anglo centric, vagueified way. It's
called Medicine Wheel Park, right around the corner from the library.
The camp's relationship to Indigenous culture is at best dissonant
and bizarre. The majority white religion is sprinkled with references

(12:45):
to Indigenous people and culture, but without any specificity or
acknowledgement of these specific tribes whose land they are living
and worshiping on. Instead, you'll often find them leaning into
popular tropes around indigenous people as a monoculture with unified
spiritual practices, characterizing more indigenous spirit guides acting in the

(13:10):
interests of the white religion than actual people who had
lived and died and had their land taken from them.
So to begin, I want to present the story of
George Colby and his spirit guide Seneca's journey to Cassadeca
with some annotations. Look, I'm down to respect a religious

(13:31):
legend just as much as the next girl is, but
this one is regularly presented as fact in and outside
of spiritualist circles, while failing to acknowledge with all due respect,
actual facts, actual people, and actual human atrocities that made
it possible for Cassadeca to exist in the first place. So, okay,

(13:56):
George and Seneca, let's see what's going on. It's eighteen
seventy five and the twenty something George Colby is living
in Wisconsin making his living as a medium, frequently flanked
by his spirit guide, Seneca. Seneca's name is the first
reference to Native American culture that rings a little weird.

(14:19):
The Seneca were and our an indigenous tribe, not one
guy who live in upstate New York. This is very
likely something George Colby would have known from his childhood. However, Seneca,
his spirit guide, leaned heavily into what is now commonly
referred to in media as the magical Native American trope,

(14:41):
defined as stating that their power comes from innate spirituality
or closeness to nature that civilized races don't have. Usually
involves influence over nature or animals or other spirit powers.
Quite often the native in question will be dressed very traditionally,
even in modern setting. But the Seneca people have a

(15:02):
unique and relevant history that took place adjacent to George
Colby's life. Holby likely learned the term in his hometown
of Pike, New York, where the Seneca tribe had lived.
Pike was a town that was only incorporated by colonizers
thirty years before Colby was born. Most significantly, Cassadega is

(15:24):
a Seneca word one that means water beneath the rocks,
originally named for Cassadega Lake in the area now known
as the Lily Deale Spiritual Association or Cassadega's Sister Camp.
As of the late two thousands, the Seneca language was
considered to be endangered, with less than fifty remaining speakers,

(15:44):
a clear and direct result of colonizers often government enabled
methods of forced relocation, forced cultural assimilation, and ethnic cleansing.
Here's a clip of what the Seneca language does sound
like from a recent Seneca language audio newsletter on how
to say grandfather's and uncle's on Glass Saint Ka East.

(16:13):
Now today, around eight thousand Seneca are enrolled in the
Seneca nation of Indians, who refer to themselves as quote,
the keepers of the Western Door. A link to some
resources where you can learn more in the description of
this episode. Unfortunately, for George Colby's credibility promise and being

(16:34):
sarcastic there, his spirit guide Seneca and the Seneca people
had very little in common. As presented in the spiritualist legend,
the spirit guide Seneca primarily served as a conduit by
which George Colby was able to justify moving to Florida
from Wisconsin. There he would acquire the plot of land

(16:56):
where the Southern Cassadega Spiritualist Association would be low caated
beginning in the eighteen nineties. After meeting another medium in
Wisconsin in eighteen seventy five, Holby said that Seneca guided
the two of them down to the Jacksonville area by railroad.
Seneca was seeking out a very specific plot of land.

(17:18):
They arrived at the end of the railroad line, but
Seneca instructed them to continue on foot, seeking out land
described by the most current Cassadega history book available called
Cassadega the South's oldest spiritual community as quote, a great
spiritual center where thousands of believers could congregate a promised

(17:40):
land of lakes and high bluffs. Behold the land where
Cassadega exists now, the legend continues. Having satisfied Seneca, Wilby
filed a homestead grant in eighteen eighty, an act that
was passed by Abraham Lincoln during the Civil War in
eighteen sixty two. They gave plots of land of around

(18:01):
one hundred sixty acres to applicants, the vast, vast majority
of whom were white people, except wait, who did those
acres belong to Originally? Cassadega was made possible with a
land grant that was intentionally redistributing indigenous land to white people.

(18:22):
Made plausible in Florida after the US had acquired heavy
air quotes used there the land from fellow colonizers Spain
back in eighteen nineteen, soon after, in humane policies like
the eighteen thirty Indian Removal Act Forcibly relocated many Cherokees, Creeks,

(18:43):
and other people indigenous to the eastern US. They were
forced to go to the west of the Mississippi River
to make room for more white colonizers. This led to
the trail of tears, a brutal government sanctioned ethnic cleansing
carried out between a teen thirty and eighteen fifty that
demanded that over one hundred thousand Indigenous people relocate, with

(19:07):
some historians estimating as many as fifteen thousand people died
on the way in unlivable conditions. Add this to the
fallout of the Seminole Wars, there is no doubt that
Cassadega would not have been possible without the exploitation of
Indigenous people whose religion and culture were being criminalized and erased.

(19:27):
While movements like Spiritualism were given the space both culturally
and literally to evolve and thrive. While the abolitionist politics
of most early spiritualists were emphasized, there's not much to
indicate that the religion had meaningful solidarity with Indigenous people
during these periods of massive violence. Another conflict that was

(19:50):
very relevant to this area was the Seminal Wars, a
still undertaught series of three wars between the Seminal tribe
and Florida and white colonialists. The first war went from
eighteen seventeen to eighteen, the second from eighteen thirty five
to forty two, and the third and final Seminal War

(20:12):
went from eighteen fifty five to fifty eight, just under
a quarter century before George Colby was said to have
shown up with his spirit guide Seneca. The latter two
wars related to Cassadega directly. The second Seminal War had
erupted over the Indian Removal Act. Many seminals refused to

(20:34):
vacate to Oklahoma when it was demanded by the U. S. Military,
and we're effectively using guerrilla war tactics before US generals
began to play extremely dirty, doing things like abducting seminal
leaders under the guise of proposed treaties. The Third Seminal
War was intended by the U. S Military to remove

(20:56):
or murder the remaining seminal from Florida, those who had
survived the first two conflicts. The plan was to burn
their plantations and starve them until they agreed to relocate,
although it said that between two hundred and five hundred
Seminole people moved deep into the Everglades instead of abandoning
their land in Colby was granted one hundred acres of

(21:22):
land central Floridian, land that had previously been the home
of tribes like the Muscogo, a group of majority black
Seminoles who had faced extreme marginalization for their skin color
and their status as indigenous in both the US and
in Mexico. Their history is a fascinating one, a result

(21:44):
of the Seminole tribe of Florida welcoming escaped slaves and
being open to blending their cultures and customs. During the
years that Florida was under the control of Spain, escaped
slaves could live freely here, and this resulted in a
strong ally ship between the cultures formed prior to the

(22:05):
colonial musical chairs between Spain and the US the land
that belonged to neither of them in the first place,
followed by the Indian Removal Act of eighteen thirty by
President Andrew Jackson, who, it must be said, is one
of history's greatest pieces of ship from any country at
any time. It should be mentioned, though the Muskogo were

(22:28):
forced out of the area during the Trail of Tears years,
seminal leaders did have black slaves, and often black seminal slaves.
When seminal leaders changed their policies to endorse chattel slavery
during the Second Seminal War, the better aligned themselves with
the practices of the Creek tribe. This shift and enslavement

(22:49):
led to many Muskogo retreating to Mexico, where some of
their descendants continue to live today. The relationships between the
cultures was certainly not actionless, but both were being aggressively
exploited and abused by the colonizers. An interesting factor between
Seminoles and Black Seminoles descendants of this blended culture, was

(23:13):
an evolving spiritual tradition. Most escaped slaves practiced some form
of Christianity during the nineteenth century, leading to Christian elements
being blended into seminal spiritual traditions. Sound familiar. Another tribe
in central Florida was the Micosuki, who had lived in

(23:33):
southern Georgia and northern Florida before being forcibly relocated to
the Everglades during the Indian Removal Act, at which point
most allied with the Seminole. I can't stress this enough,
and we'll be addressing it through this episode. There is
no Indigenous American monoculture. Every group has their own spiritual traditions,

(23:55):
has their own ideas, has their own practices, and so
this ally ship came with a lot of cultural adjustment
for both groups. Mikosuki is the englishization of the word Mikosuki,
a mixed heech Zook word from Mexico that means leader
of the civilized people. Many Mikosuki fought in the Seminole Wars,

(24:18):
only to be displaced and targeted by the US government
again during the years of the Trail of Tears. After
refusing to have their culture considered as one and the
same as the Seminoles culture by the US, the ally
ship between the Seminole and the Mikosuki soured, and the
Mikosuki tribe is currently represented mainly in southern Florida, where

(24:41):
their tribal dialect remains endangered, with only about five hundred
speakers remaining. Here is a Mikosuki school teacher and tribe
member named William Popeye Osceola, talking about how he tries
to preserve the language and culture of the Mikosuki in
the classroom in an interview the Creative Lab at McClatchy.

(25:06):
When you go to school in America, you learn all
about American history, but a big part of American history,
I guess left those Native history, so I always look
back to what was missing in my education. This generation
is like heads and shoulders above my group. The future
they have and we're they're going to take this tribe.
I can't wait to see if we want them to
be empowered. We want them to come back and want

(25:27):
them to help take over and they can run this
and then we can also all under leadership. Their unique
religious beliefs include the idea that men are transformed into
angels after an attempt to visit the quote unquote great Spirit. Finally,
the Tumukua tribe was represented in the Cassadeca region, a
tribe that was all but wiped out by eighteen hundred,

(25:50):
with a population that is said to have once included
as many as two hundred thousand people. Their spiritual traditions
included community shamans that were able to contact the spirit
realm with powers that ranged from the belief that they
controlled the weather to sometimes serving as herbalists that used
natural remedies to ease the pain of childbirth. This culture

(26:14):
was destroyed by colonial violence and illness, with the remainder
of the Tumukua ingratiating into the Seminole and many others
taken to Cuba. But it's important to note the majority
of what's known about their history, and it's not that
much are still taken from the records of European colonizers,
not that the legend of Cassadega references well virtually any

(26:39):
of these people or any of the history of the
land they're using. It is possible that I missed references
to indigenous culture during my time at Cassadega that was
more specific, particularly at a library where I was only
entitled to two hours of time. But any reference to
any specific native group is ex dreamly hard to come

(27:01):
by unless you're sharp enough to know what Seminole Street
is referencing. In the unincorporated community where crystal shops sell
their wares to tourists. If you're lucky, maybe you'll find
one of those tourist dream catchers that are emblematic of
the ways in which modern Americans erased the cultures of
what was once around six hundred unique tribes whose land

(27:22):
was stolen and then formed into this monocultural image by colonizers.
If Seneca the Spirit Guide had any interest in this history,
these lost lives and stolen land of the tribes in
Central Florida, I've never seen any reference to it. For
the legend of Cassadega's founding, Seneca only seemed to have

(27:42):
a vested interest in being George Colby's sidekick, not just
giving him permission to found Cassadega, but as the legend goes,
it was his idea. The fallout of all of these conflicts,
the Trail of Tears, the Indian Removal Act, the Seminole
Wars had turned Florida into an area that was under

(28:04):
constant change throughout the nineteenth century due to the massive
loss of life that took place during the Seminole War years.
By eighteen sixty, the census indicated that only about twelve
hundred people were living in Valusia County, where Cassadega still
is now, and that very little activity took place there
throughout the Civil War years. According to Cassadega, the South's

(28:28):
oldest spiritualist community, Belusia County was more popular during these
years as a place to hide from conscription into the
Confederate Army. Only beginning to be developed by colonizers in
the eighteen seventies, when You're George Colby's began to show up.
White industrialists began working on areas that bear their names
to this day. An Ohio entrepreneur named Matthias Day incorporated Daytona, Florida,

(28:55):
in eighteen seventy six, and Henry Addison the Land founded
the community that still bears his last name. Around this
same time, by the nine cents is, the population of
the area had increased to around people, bolstered by the
end of the Civil War and expanding train accessibility in
the central Florida area. In the land that Colby had

(29:19):
acquired via the Homestead Act stealing indigenous land was now
accessible and was developed to make it accessible to the
people he wanted to court, majority white spiritualists from upstate
New York looking for a place to worship when it
got too cold at the camps in the north. So
this legend is present everywhere in the library. I feel

(29:41):
a little weird poking so many holes in it out
of respect to the spiritualists, But for a religion that
constantly references indigenous culture and seems to have a vested
interest in the illusion of paying respect, it sounds like
a bunch of colonial free form jazz by a guy
who just wanted to set up a religious camp in

(30:02):
a colonial culture that was and should have been grappling
with their relation to Native American culture. From this vantage point,
Seneca can be seen either as a well intentioned attempt
to incorporate Native culture into spiritualism, or, as it's been suggested,
this weird and offensive caricature that absolved a white landowner

(30:25):
of the guilt of thinking anyone could truly own land
that has been stolen with violence and cruelty. Quite recently,
I was lucky enough to speak with the amazing Olivia

(30:47):
Woodward about this legend, the precise reasons that it crosses
from the weird into the harmful, and the conversation that
surrounds indigenous culture in the United States to this day,
this gelatinous monoculture, and the erasure of all these traditions, histories,
and stories that are unique around six hundred tribes that
exists or existed across the mainland US for centuries. Olivia

(31:12):
writes about movies, media and Native issues and has previously
appeared on My movie podcast with Caitlin Durante, the Bechtel Cast.
I'm so thrilled I got to talk with her, and
here's a little bit of our conversation. All right, Well, Kombuchia,
my name is Olivia Woodward. I am a citizen of
the Catto nation Um. I'm also a writer for a

(31:34):
tribe called Geek and currently my day job is working
in tourism. So I was actually first raised pagan. I
have never followed Christianity. I've never never been a part
of that. My my parents, I'm the youngest of three,
and so by the time I was born, I think
they experimented experimented with Christianity with my siblings. But by

(31:57):
the time I was born, my mom, my mom and
dad like, now, Paganism makes sense to us, We're going
to do that. Then, when I was about nine years old,
my mother started reconnecting with her native identity and that's
how we first started with the Cato nation Um. And yeah,
so since I was nine years old, that's when I
was introduced to our kind of Cato spirituality and as

(32:21):
an adult, Unfortunately, modern day paganism does appropriate a lot
from Data spirituality, but they have a lot of the
same principles and tenants, so I still in my adulthood,
kind of combined the two of them. In general, though,
uh Catos do believe in Creator. Creator is a genderless
being that created everything. So before we started discussing a
story that George Coleby told about indigenous people. I was

(32:45):
curious about the spiritual origins of Olivia's people, the Katam.
I think a fun place to start, if you don't mind,
is if I kind of share our creation story. Um.
Every nation has a creation story. They're all pretty different
from each other. There is a through line among all
of them. There is some commonality, but we all are different.

(33:05):
So Icado's creation story. It is believed that a very
long time ago, Um humans and animals lived under the earth,
like within the earth, and they lived there for forever.
Then one day their leader, whose name translates to Moon,
received a message from Creator Um and through that message,

(33:27):
discovered a tunnel that led up Uh. So they followed
the tunnel and realized it led to a cave which
led to a different realm essentially. So with this message
from Creator, Moon gathered his people and the animals and
led them out of the cave. However, great Or told

(33:48):
Moon to not look back. You're moving forward, don't look back.
So they get almost all the way out of the cave,
and it's also said that Moon is carried I believe
drum and tobacco and his wife is carrying corn and
pumpkin something else you can't remember right now. They're carrying
these things though, that are essentially the foundation too for
the Cattos um. And they get almost like almost all

(34:11):
the way out, and Wolf gets too curious and turns
around and looks back, and that's when the cave collapse
and half of the people and half the animals are
left behind, and the other half make it to earth,
the other realm, and they cry and cry and cry,
and that's what forms the Mississippi River um and also
that's where the Cattos eventually made their land and their home.

(34:37):
And I think what's interesting to know about our creation
story and a lot of indigenous creation stories, is that
we are of the earth. We come from the earth,
which to me um indicates our that we have a relationship.
We're guests on the earth, and so we have to
maintain a relationship with the earth. So with that in

(34:57):
mind too, that also means we a lot of animals
as relative as well. That's not an exaggeration, that's not
like spiritual that that is a big belief is that
we have a relationship with the animals, so away we
do that way we honor the animals is through dance.
A lot of your spirituality is kind of through your

(35:18):
everyday things as well, so it's a a big part
of it is being aware of what's around you and
being appreciative of what's around you, and also helping out
when it makes sense as well. Well. I'd probably give
more context to this later. A lot of our practices
and our understandings have been lost on purpose by outside courses,

(35:42):
so this might not be like a super fun answer.
So right now, for my understanding, I was not raised
in the cabination to believe in really an afterlife, because
we are of the earth. Once we die, we return
to the earth. Um. And that's kind of where it
stops now. I have done some research and I believe
before colonization there is a whole different subset of believes

(36:03):
when it came to that. But because so much of
vis a bit lost, uh, that's kind of where it
stands now. So a difficulty I had in interacting with
white mediums around the ideas of indigenous culture, as well
as looking at past writings of Cassadaga mediums, was that
the way that they were presenting indigenous culture was too

(36:24):
vague and self serving to be the kind of show
of respect that it was said to be. Olivia breaks
down her frustration on this issue brilliantly here. I think
in general, a question I start pushing on people who
who believe in things like that is um. Specifically, I'll
ask like, well, what nation do you think that's from? Like,
what's what tribe are you referencing? And I do that

(36:47):
because we tend to get like all put in the
same group. And just to put it out there right now,
there is no Native American religion. There are over five
hundred nations across the continental United States. We can't all
it doesn't make sense for all of us to have
the same religion. Now, there is a Native American church

(37:07):
in Oklahoma that I believe is still functioning, but that
is a result of laws imposed by the US government
that criminalized our religion. So we had to go underground
and build these churches to continue to as a facade
to practice some of our Native religion. UM. But in general,
whenever I come across people who think like that, I

(37:28):
will just push them and ask what which nation are
you pulling that from? Which tribe are you're pulling that from?
And they'll get frustrated, double down on whatever. But that's
the only way I can see to combat it. But
it's it's frustrating. It's very frustrating because they do see
this as all one entity. We all believe the same things,
we all have the same practices um like especially and

(37:50):
also to I will say some Native people will follow
to this because we have been purposely disconnected from our
religion and our identity for in things. I know a
lot of Natives who have dream catchers, and that's not
necessarily a bad thing. But dream catchers are not from
my tribe. They were not created out of the southeastern tribes.

(38:11):
They were created from the northeastern the Canadian tribes I
want to say Jibre or a Nishinabe. They created dream
catchers as a way to help their children not be
so scared of colonists, which I don't think a lot
of people understand that. Like whatever columnists started invading the
nations and murdering them. A lot of children were having nightmares.

(38:34):
So alders created these dream catchers to help them capture
their nightmares. And so that's the other frustrating part too,
is that they will take one thing and literally when
I say take I do mean literally, they take it,
they redo the definition, give no recognition to where they
took it from, and then oftentimes profit off of it.

(38:57):
So that's that's the other really frustrating thing is that
not only do they just see us as one entity, um,
they don't even want to recognize the beautiful differences between
all of us. It's it's really frustrating when non natives,
and oftentimes only white people say well, we're doing this
to honor you, We're doing this to honor you, but

(39:17):
you don't. You have to let the people tell you
how they want to be honored. And so if if
it's out of ignorance, understand that's understanding. But whenever you're
presented the opportunity to learn about that nation, so many
non natives will just double down because they're embarrassed or
because they don't like being wrong. They will double down

(39:39):
on what they're doing and saying, no, we do this
because we're honoring you, and we have we come back
and say, well, this is not honoring us, so this
is just for you then, And I think that's where
a lot of disconnect comes from, is that these other
cultures religions, people don't want to accept when they're wrong.
This all begs the question, what are the issues that

(40:00):
spiritualists could and should be acknowledging to actually meaningfully move
the needle on how Native culture is viewed. Where they
currently live on Seminole Land in Florida, I asked Olivia
and she shared a few pieces of history in particular
to be aware of. And that's why I feel it's
really important to get the context as to why so
many of us have this quote unquote attitude in regards

(40:24):
to white people, non natives appropriating our culture and like
where that frustration, that deep seated frustration comes from. So UM, first,
I'd like to talk about the establishments of boarding schools.
UM Boarding schools began in the United States and Canada,
but the United States around eighteen sixty and they were
government funded but oftentimes run by Christian and Catholic churches.

(40:51):
The motto of the founder of these schools, General Richard
Henry Pratt, he thought he was a righteous man and
he could quote unquote see the humanity and the savages.
So the goal of these schools was to kill the Indian,
save the man. That was a literal motto of the school.

(41:11):
They did that by taking children from families and forcing
them to be Christian, uh, taking away their native names,
punishing them when they spoke their language, cutting their hair,
and making them dress like white people, and essentially trying
to assimilate them into the white culture. So that's happening
in eighteen sixties. Um, there are technically still residential schools now,

(41:37):
but there they functioned very differently. Now there there's not
as much like religious trauma involved now. But um, as
far as this this model, I think I don't have
the exact date on me right now, but I think
they were eliminated the seventies, maybe even the nineties, so
like nineteen nineties. So the bit around for a really

(41:59):
long line. Then in eighteen eighty three, the Code of
Indian Offenses was passed by the Department of Interior, and
these codes were only applied to Native Americans. And these
codes and summary criminalized our religion. Um, if you were

(42:19):
because also at this point in eighteen eighty three, a
lot of the Native nations have been forced onto reservations. Um,
so either you were, you were forced on a reservation, uh,
taken away from your food resources. And because our re
our religion and relationship is tied so closely to the earth.
They were being forced away from their land that was
so connected to their religion. Um, so there are forces

(42:43):
of these reservations. The children were being taken away from them.
And now the government has said, if you were caught
practicing your dances and your ceremony, you will either be
imprisoned or we will withhold food from you for a month.
And that's important because these nations were forced onto servations
because they were their land essentially stolen from them. The

(43:04):
government said, well, in return, we will provide resources from
you since we were taking a work, since you're being
pushed away from the resources. So it was a big deal.
Aside from imprisonment, you wouldn't get food if you were
caught practicing your religion. And then if any religious leaders
were caught, they were automatically sent to prison for like
ten days or longer. That's like date my mother, but

(43:28):
she was born in nineteen sixty four, right, so even
as a child, she legally wasn't allowed to do even
if she even if she was raised with our native religion,
which because of everything I have listed, she wasn't. But
even if she was, she wouldn't be allowed to do
a lot of the practices we wanted to do to be.
That's also important because it's a big reason why my

(43:50):
mom raised me pagan for the first nine years of
my life, and then we were able to switch to
or transition a little bit to our native religion, like
be as of these laws. My grandmother wasn't raised with
her religion, so how could she raise my mom with
her religion. So that's why this is important. Everyone likes
to act like this happened so long ago and that
Natives are complaining for no reason, but we're not. Like

(44:15):
laws were still in practice when my grandma was alive,
Like this wasn't that long ago. So Olivia was not
aware that the majority white religion of American spiritualism was
appropriating from indigenous culture without really any accurate information prior
to listening to Ghost Church to prepare for this interview,
But she was not surprised. You know, before I listened

(44:40):
to the series, I didn't know that they were using
Native natives as their avatar essentially. Uh. Sure, that is
a very weird feeling, especially because during the time of
I feel like spiritualism reaching its popularity, Natives were fighting
for their fucking lives to just exist and no in
that these people were starting to use us to give

(45:04):
them strength but not but not supporting us in any
material way is uh disupporting? So what does Olivia make
of the story of George and Spirit Seneca? Okay, this
is my genuine like first time hearing the story, I
purposely didn't look it up so that I could have

(45:26):
a more genuine reaction. Um. So caught a lot of thoughts, Um,
why would a native spirit guide tell you to go
own land for your benefit rather than tell you to
go help the natives get their land back? That makes

(45:47):
no sense. That makes absolutely good sense. I think. The
other frustration is, Um, a lot of this just feels
like they are using us as a to mask her
greediness to be frank, so that I feel a lot
all that I think it's funny is that expensed to

(46:08):
be does it really aligned with any native spirituality? Like
at all? Um? And really just using us as a
reason to say it's okay that we own this land.
I hope that a big takeaway people will have from
this is that it's okay to be curious and it's
okay to want to participate, but you have to let

(46:32):
us lead, and you have to let us do it.
And also for reconnecting natives, It's okay that you're not
actively participating in your nation's religion. It's not your fault. Um.
We've had laws in place for over a century to
prevent us, and honestly, on a darker side, we've had

(46:52):
a lot of laws try to humanely genocide us. And
we're still here, and you are still valid for being here.
Like the fact that you're here is a miracle. Um.
So yeah, I think those are probably my party words.
Thank you so much to Olivia Woodward again, and I'll
be linking to some of her work in the description.

(47:13):
And I want to say personally, I mean, look, most
of this history of the Cassadeca area was not known
to me prior to working on this episode, and most
Native history remains untaught, unacknowledged, and unpreserved in American schools.
Characters like Seneca the Spirit Guide really don't serve to
do much more than to perpetuate existing stereotypes an attempt

(47:37):
to fill this void of non history. So by Seneca
the Spirit Guide and George Colby decide, Hey, it's time
to get this camp up and running. To do so,
he enlisted the help of two women who had been
responsible for a considerable amount of success at the lily
Dale Assembly, the camp that was originally called Old Cassadega

(48:01):
in upstate New York. This is the camp where the
Central Floridian Spiritualists would borrow its name. The best information
isn't always contained in the library. The beliefs of the
Spiritualists are fascinating and widely applicable, but there are areas
of their own history that are completely forgotten or obscured

(48:24):
among the few left practicing in their major hubs. This
is done in the expected way, by pushing already marginalized
communities to the side and replacing areas of their own
histories with versions that make them less uncomfortable. And that's
where I'll leave you this week, as Cassadega continued to
build on its own legacy on its House of Cards

(48:46):
origin story. Next week we're going to learn about a
spirit tisma which uses spiritism as its foundation, and how
many black spiritualists grew disillusioned with spiritualism and flocked instead
to independently run spiritual churches. That's next week on Ghost Church.

(49:06):
Ghost Church is a Cruise On Media production, created, written
and hosted by me Jamie Loftus. The show is produced
by Sophie Lichtman, edited by Ian Johnson. Our theme song
is by Speedy Ortiz. That's Sadie Dupley, Andy Moholt, Audrey C.
Whitesides and Joey Dubeck. Music is by Zoe Blade. Special

(49:27):
thanks to Olivia Woodward for speaking with me for this episode.
Please check out her work. It's linked in the description.
Special shout out to Ian Johnson and Sophie Lichterman Ghost
Church Cannon for lending their voices to this episode. And
I really tried my best pronunciation on this. I in

(49:47):
my defense, I did grow up in a region where
the worst accent on the planet exists. Um so I
am open to corrections. Deep
Advertise With Us

Host

Jamie Loftus

Jamie Loftus

Popular Podcasts

Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC

Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

On Purpose with Jay Shetty

On Purpose with Jay Shetty

I’m Jay Shetty host of On Purpose the worlds #1 Mental Health podcast and I’m so grateful you found us. I started this podcast 5 years ago to invite you into conversations and workshops that are designed to help make you happier, healthier and more healed. I believe that when you (yes you) feel seen, heard and understood you’re able to deal with relationship struggles, work challenges and life’s ups and downs with more ease and grace. I interview experts, celebrities, thought leaders and athletes so that we can grow our mindset, build better habits and uncover a side of them we’ve never seen before. New episodes every Monday and Friday. Your support means the world to me and I don’t take it for granted — click the follow button and leave a review to help us spread the love with On Purpose. I can’t wait for you to listen to your first or 500th episode!

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2025 iHeartMedia, Inc.