November 4, 2025 • 16 mins
This week, Tony explains how to develop a rut hunting plan and then actually see it through until you get a crack at the right buck.
Connect with Tony Peterson and MeatEater
Tony Peterson on Instagram and Facebook
MeatEater on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, Youtube, and Youtube Clips
MeatEater Podcast Network on YouTube
Shop MeatEater Merch
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:01):
Welcome to the Wired to Hunt Foundations podcast, your guide
to the fundamentals of better deer hunting, presented by first Light,
creating proven versatile hunting apparel for the stand, saddle or blind.
First Light Go Farther, Stay Longer, and now your host
Tony Peterson.
Speaker 2 (00:20):
Hey everyone, welcome to the Wire to Hunt Foundation's podcast,
which is brought to you by first Light. I'm your host,
Tony Peterson. In today's episode is all about how to
approach the rut with a plan and then to see
that plan through. Well, if you've been bitching about hot
weather or rainy, foggy, stupid weather, or no daytime movement
(00:40):
or whatever, you know, when it comes to the deer,
you can stop now. At least much of the country
is writ smack dab in the best damn time of
the year to be a white tail hunter, and that
means a lot of folks are going to have amazing
hunts this week, but.
Speaker 3 (00:52):
A lot of folks won't.
Speaker 2 (00:53):
You don't want to be in that ladder category, and
to help you avoid it, I'm going to talk about
developing a rut hunting plan and actually it through. So
buckle up, because it's time to get serious about the
best time of the year to be a deer hunter.
Here in Minnesota, we have a thing called m EA,
which stands for Minnesota Educator Academy, and every year in
(01:16):
October they hold a conference with teachers, and since they
are all tied up all day, the kids get a
nice little.
Speaker 3 (01:21):
Break of a couple days off of school.
Speaker 2 (01:23):
I figured that was the perfect opportunity to take one
of my daughters back to that stupid wasteland with no
deer that is northern Wisconsin and try to get her
to arrow anything. I didn't have a great plan, but
I had a sort of plan, given that the wind
was going to be out of the south for two
days and then out of the north for our remaining
two days. Well, we saw grouse, squirrels, a hell of
(01:43):
a lot of songbirds, and we never saw a single deer,
not in seven sits, which, if you think about it,
sucks a whole lot. I realized about halfway through that
I was bumping up against a couple of things. The
first was that my daughter is certainly capable of hunting
long hours and being patient, but she can't hunt out
of a tree stand with a crossbow. At least a
(02:03):
stand that isn't a ladder stand, and I'm just not
much of a ladder stand guy, although I guess I
probably should be now that my daughters could hunt them.
That was mistake number one. Anyway, I should have put
up some ladder stands. Second, because the crossbow she uses
is heavy, like they generally are, she needs a solid rest,
which comes in the form of a heavy bog pot.
(02:24):
That's a limiting factor for many reasons, but it is
what it is until they are strong enough and confident
enough to shoot a vertical bow.
Speaker 3 (02:30):
Anyway.
Speaker 2 (02:31):
Now, we hunted private land, and we hunted public We
hunted alfalfa, we hunted acorns, we hunted the limited amount
of scrapes we found, We hunted pinch points. And what
we saw was that whatever decision I made was clearly
the wrong one. It was frustrating, but it also reminded
me of how my dad and I used to hunt. Now,
instead of trying to input as many variables as possible
(02:51):
into the old brain algorithm and then make a decision
based on that plus fresh sign, I said, well, the
wind is from the north, so I have these four options.
I thought her extremely low standards in the reality that
we'd spend probably twenty eight hours or so in those
seven sits out actually hunting that it would just be
a matter of time, but it wasn't, and the highlight
(03:11):
of the whole trip was taking the pop out for
some midday ducks and then woodcock and grouse. A few
wood ducks can make up for some shitty deer hunting,
but didn't quite smooth the whole thing. Over the last
night of the trip, my daughter and I sat watching
a beautiful small alfalfa field on a piece of private
and listened to wolves howl in the distance, which was
a good reminder that it might not just be my
poor decision making that had the deer on edge or
(03:34):
totally gone. I recently heard someone on a podcast say
something like, when it comes to business, hope is not
a strategy, and I was running off of hope out there.
That last part of that statement stuck with me, and
it rattled around my smooth brain on the drive home
from our ill fated hunt, because it just kind of
perfectly summed up a lot of life and definitely summed
(03:56):
up deer hunting at that time and right now during
the rut. This is the thing, though, there's like no
better time during the season to have that warm and
fuzzy feeling that this is just going to be our
sit or this is just going to be our week,
because after all, when all the bucks in the neighborhood
are on the move, the odds of one of them
walking by at twenty yards will never be higher than
(04:18):
right now. That's the good news. But the bad news
is that the rut doesn't erase a lot of the
things that we think it does. Let me give you
an example here. During late September, my daughters and I
sat over in Wisconsin and saw a big old dough
multiple times one day. She was a frequent flyer on
my cameras in that spot, and she had no fawns,
so I figured her days were definitely numbered, and boy
(04:41):
did she flirt with death.
Speaker 3 (04:43):
But she beat us, and.
Speaker 2 (04:44):
Eventually she got close enough to our blind where she
could be down wind and figure it out.
Speaker 3 (04:49):
Now.
Speaker 2 (04:49):
When I heard her spook, I wondered how long it
would take for her to get back to normal. Well,
as of the last week of October, I never had
another daylight pick of her, but I had plenty of
nighttime picks. We never saw her again either, and we
hunted specifically for that deer a few times. That dough
an old, no bullshit kind of dough. She's still around,
(05:11):
but I can promise you the odds of her running
by that blind in daylight at some point or way
less than they would have been if we didn't spook
her there. She knows where we like to hide, and
she's not the kind of deer to take those chances.
Does that sound like I'm putting too much mental horsepower
in between her ears? Maybe, but I don't think so.
Does that mean a buck won't go by that blind?
(05:31):
Absolutely not. But I also think that dough in particular,
even if she was getting chased like crazy, would be
more likely to head off somewhere else where she feels
a little safer. I think it's often that simple, and
that stuff doesn't work in our favor. Now I can
somewhat confidently say that because I can keep tabs on
individual deer in that place where there just aren't very
many deer. But you might think, well, I always have
(05:54):
lots of does and fawns around my old favorite stand
site or my favorite box blind, and that's great off.
And do those dos go by and range? Are they
onto you at all. What if, for some reason, you
go out for a couple of days of your rut
cation and they don't come by, at least they don't
drag a buck by you. I remember Randy Nuberg telling
me one time about once in a lifetime tags or
(06:16):
at least super premium, you know, tags that you might
never draw, and if you do, you got real lucky.
Speaker 3 (06:21):
He said.
Speaker 2 (06:22):
People draw them and they think the hunt is going
to be easy, but you still have to put in
the effort commensurate to the tag and the animal. This
is where people get the rut wrong. A lot of times,
we like it for a lot of reasons, but the
main one we don't talk about is that the rut
is an excuse to be kind of lazy. And I'm
just going to say this and take the heat if
I have to. Lazy saves more bucks than anything else.
(06:44):
My dad just recently texted me that he put up
a blind on a farm in southeastern Minnesota for deer,
where you know there's a lot of deer in general.
But he went in there and sat a couple of times,
and that blind wasn't giving him good vibes. He knew
he needed to move it, and he was almost willing
to do that, but then he said he would just
open up a different window on the blind where there
(07:06):
are more trails on that side than the spot he'd
originally faced that. Now I had many thoughts there, none
of which I shared with him because he won't follow
my advice anyway, But I'll share them with you. That
decision was based purely on not wanting to do the
work to find new deer and set up something different.
Worse yet, I'm sure he believes his reasoning.
Speaker 3 (07:25):
Now.
Speaker 2 (07:25):
I don't want to pick on Papa too hard, because
we all do shit like that. It's in our nature
to figure out ways to shortcut every process and to
try to put in as little effort as possible for
the highest reward. If the deer have taught me anything,
it's that if you don't have an unbelievable spot to hunt,
you aren't going to get away with little effort. They're
too good at not getting killed for that kind of approach.
(07:47):
So I guess this leads me to the point where
I have to tell you how to make a plan.
I'm going to tell you what I do, and then
tell you why that's wrong, and then go in circles
for a while until I wrap this thing up. The
weather forecast is your friend, first and foremost. Wind direction
(08:12):
is what I care about the most because it will
tell me an awful lot about what I can and
can't do on any given day. So if I have,
let's say five days to hunt the rut, I want
to pull up the forecast for each day and make
no to the predicted wind direction. Now, I know that
this isn't an exact science, but it's a hell of
a lot more reliable than it used to be. So
start there where you can reasonably expect whatever wind directions
(08:34):
are predicted. Then you have to use that infotocross reference
it with the best weather conditions you have, because that's
when you want to hunt your best stuff. So let's
say you have one pinch point you scout of the
spring and you believe with your heart that it's going
to be on fire during the rut. Now you need
a west or a north wind for it, and that
isn't going to come until day three of your five
day hunt. Do you talk yourself into sitting there because
(08:56):
you think it's your best spot, or do you stay
out and hunt backups to until the weather gets right,
especially if the weather is going to get cold and
maybe a little rainy and oh so special for the rut.
Here's what probably half of the hunters will do. They'll say, well,
it's a southwest wind, but it won't be blowing very hard,
and I think I can get away with it, so
they'll hunt that pinch anyway. This is especially true if
(09:18):
they have a camera there, which they will, and that
camera will show them some daylight movement with big ones.
That siren song is loud, it's beautiful, and it'll talk
you into crashing your ship right into the rocks. My friends,
I feel like at least half of the time I haunt,
especially during the rut, I find myself sitting somewhere that's
good enough, but not where I really want to beat.
(09:41):
But if you can't cheat the wind in any meaningful
way when you're bowhunting, you just have to live by this.
You need backups that you believe in. Let's say you
decide I'm not going to that sweet pinch point till
the wind and the weather break my way. But you
also don't want to sandbag the first couple days of
your rut hunt. Where can you put in some time
and not mess up the deer that should be going
through that pinch. That's what you need to answer. So again,
(10:03):
take into account to wind in the conditions. Maybe it's
going to be ten or fifteen degrees warmer than it
should be during the rut. So on that first day
you know you're going to have the wind out of
the south. Probably do you have water to hunt or
a funnel that allows you to sit over it where
maybe they might pass through on their way to the
drinking fountain somewhere. What if you think your water spot
(10:23):
is just a nursery of little bucks and you don't
want to waste your time there. Again, probably because what
your cameras show. I look at this different and I
try to ignore my trail camera data when it comes
to the rut. If I am where I believe the
general deer population might want to go, I'm not without confidence,
even if I haven't had tons of pictures of one
to fifties in that spot. Plus, it's better than blowing
(10:46):
out your best stuff by a long shot. Now, maybe
that's not it, and maybe the south wind will allow
for a hanging hunt in an area that usually has
a whole bunch of bucks sign anything is better than
settling for good enough. And the more you lay out
your plan and your brain before you start hunting, the
more you can see it through until at least the
deer show you something different. This is where things get squirrely.
(11:09):
The best plans just generally meet our deer realities, and
if we force them too hard, when the bucks show
us something else, we lose again. You want that rough
plan in place, that day by day plan, so you
can follow through something with confidence. But if at any
point the deer really show you something but where they
(11:29):
want to be, you know, somewhere else, then you've got
to factor that in. But here's where it gets a
little worse. The way deer usually show us that is
through trail cameras. Look, that's good intel and might talk
you into calling an audible, But in person rut observations
are much more valuable. If you see a buck doing
something anything, pay attention. I don't care if it's a
spiker at two hundred injury. If you see two bucks
(11:52):
do something, you have an answer to an important question.
Where should I be sitting right now? Uh?
Speaker 3 (11:58):
Right there?
Speaker 2 (12:00):
So develop a good plan and then toss it into
the garbage. The minute the deer show you anything outside
of that plan, right, kind of, without the original plan
in place, you're going to probably settle without taking into
account what the deer actually show you. You won't be
taking full advantage of the rut. Instead, you'll be far
(12:20):
more likely to sit in a place you want to
hunt and try to call or decoy one in. Look,
this is supposed to be fun if that's how you
want to play it, so go ahead.
Speaker 3 (12:30):
That's okay.
Speaker 2 (12:30):
But if you generally don't kill big ones in November
and you want to and that's your go to strategy,
maybe hope alone isn't going to cut it. But you're
not done with your plan yet. I didn't know this
until I actually did it. But do you know why
alcoholics and addicts often tell their friends and family that
they are quitting for good. It's called a social contract,
and it's weirdly helpful because we don't want to look
(12:52):
like failures, so we try to see our promises through.
We do this with ourselves as well in the deer world.
Where I found this to be the most helpful is
that I don't just decide on where I'm most likely
to sit on any given day of the rut, but
I also make a pact with myself to sit either
until a certain time and then move or just sit
all day. It's not like I couldn't break that pack
(13:14):
you know in my head and go in for some
pancakes at ten in the morning, but for some reason
I usually don't anymore. It's kind of like when you
work out a lot, you say tonight, I'm gonna go
run the seven miles instead of just lacing up your
old on clouds and heading out for a run without
any distance or route in mind. Because the minute you
do that, you give yourself an out, because your brain
will decide that three miles is good enough. When it
(13:36):
comes to killing a buck during the rut, you can't
do better than putting in as much time as possible.
In high confidence locations, it's the way to kill deer.
And if you don't hold yourself accountable to sit until
noon or to go dark to dark, the second guessing
can talk you into heading out for a midday nap.
Not only does that take you out of the game
because you can't shoot them. When you're dreaming, you know
(13:57):
that Margot Robbie is your new coworker, or I guess
in Mark's case, a new butterfly species was just discovered
in southern Michigan. But also it puts more disturbance in
the woods just by your comings and going. This is
also the way that most of your competition's going to hunt.
And if you tend to hunt pressure ground and you
do not sit during the midday hours during the rut,
you're just missing out. I promise you that pressure deer
(14:20):
are tuned into us in major ways, and that timeframe
when most hunters can't hack it because they don't believe,
you know, in any real midday deer movement and they
don't have a plan, is some of the most important
time you can spend in the woods. But it takes
a strategy, takes a plan. It takes a willingness to
look at every opportunity you have to be out there
and decide how to play it against the predicted wind
(14:42):
and weather and all of the variables that you might
bump into. As the bucks get a little silly with
lust and they start to cover some serious ground, you know,
pair that with a willingness to go mobile or accept
that what you thought was going to happen didn't and
that you're going to have to let the deer decide
what to do if their movements are just persuasive enough.
And now you have the framework for a successful rut hunt.
(15:06):
The last piece of that puzzle is just putting in
the time, which, when you do and have a few
years show you that it was the right call, gets
a hell of a lot easier to do over time.
So remember this when it comes to rut hunting. Hope
is not a strategy. It's just a nice little boost
that will help you stick out a well thought out plant.
So get out there and get your buck and come
(15:27):
back next week because I'm going to talk about certain
situations during the rut where I will dig into my
bag of get rich quick products and really try to
make something happen.
Speaker 3 (15:35):
That's it for this week. I'm Tony Peterson.
Speaker 2 (15:38):
This has been the Wirre to Hunt Foundation's episode, which
is brought to you by First Light. As always, thank
you so much for listening for all your support. I
know you're spending a lot of time in tree stands
right now, but you might also be driving somewhere to
go do an over the road trip. You might kill
a buck and want to know I don't know how
to do a ural amount with it, or maybe cook
it up.
Speaker 3 (15:57):
So it's super tasty.
Speaker 2 (15:59):
Whatever, you can probably find the answers to a lot
of your questions, and I know you can find a
hell of a lot of entertainment at the medeater dot com,
where we drop new content every single day.
Speaker 3 (16:08):
Go check it out.
Welcome to the Wired to Hunt Foundations podcast, your guide
to the fundamentals of better deer hunting, presented by first Light,
creating proven versatile hunting apparel for the stand, saddle or blind.
First Light Go Farther, Stay Longer, and now your host
Tony Peterson.
Speaker 2 (00:20):
Hey everyone, welcome to the Wire to Hunt Foundation's podcast,
which is brought to you by first Light. I'm your host,
Tony Peterson. In today's episode is all about how to
approach the rut with a plan and then to see
that plan through. Well, if you've been bitching about hot
weather or rainy, foggy, stupid weather, or no daytime movement
(00:40):
or whatever, you know, when it comes to the deer,
you can stop now. At least much of the country
is writ smack dab in the best damn time of
the year to be a white tail hunter, and that
means a lot of folks are going to have amazing
hunts this week, but.
Speaker 3 (00:52):
A lot of folks won't.
Speaker 2 (00:53):
You don't want to be in that ladder category, and
to help you avoid it, I'm going to talk about
developing a rut hunting plan and actually it through. So
buckle up, because it's time to get serious about the
best time of the year to be a deer hunter.
Here in Minnesota, we have a thing called m EA,
which stands for Minnesota Educator Academy, and every year in
(01:16):
October they hold a conference with teachers, and since they
are all tied up all day, the kids get a
nice little.
Speaker 3 (01:21):
Break of a couple days off of school.
Speaker 2 (01:23):
I figured that was the perfect opportunity to take one
of my daughters back to that stupid wasteland with no
deer that is northern Wisconsin and try to get her
to arrow anything. I didn't have a great plan, but
I had a sort of plan, given that the wind
was going to be out of the south for two
days and then out of the north for our remaining
two days. Well, we saw grouse, squirrels, a hell of
(01:43):
a lot of songbirds, and we never saw a single deer,
not in seven sits, which, if you think about it,
sucks a whole lot. I realized about halfway through that
I was bumping up against a couple of things. The
first was that my daughter is certainly capable of hunting
long hours and being patient, but she can't hunt out
of a tree stand with a crossbow. At least a
(02:03):
stand that isn't a ladder stand, and I'm just not
much of a ladder stand guy, although I guess I
probably should be now that my daughters could hunt them.
That was mistake number one. Anyway, I should have put
up some ladder stands. Second, because the crossbow she uses
is heavy, like they generally are, she needs a solid rest,
which comes in the form of a heavy bog pot.
(02:24):
That's a limiting factor for many reasons, but it is
what it is until they are strong enough and confident
enough to shoot a vertical bow.
Speaker 3 (02:30):
Anyway.
Speaker 2 (02:31):
Now, we hunted private land, and we hunted public We
hunted alfalfa, we hunted acorns, we hunted the limited amount
of scrapes we found, We hunted pinch points. And what
we saw was that whatever decision I made was clearly
the wrong one. It was frustrating, but it also reminded
me of how my dad and I used to hunt. Now,
instead of trying to input as many variables as possible
(02:51):
into the old brain algorithm and then make a decision
based on that plus fresh sign, I said, well, the
wind is from the north, so I have these four options.
I thought her extremely low standards in the reality that
we'd spend probably twenty eight hours or so in those
seven sits out actually hunting that it would just be
a matter of time, but it wasn't, and the highlight
(03:11):
of the whole trip was taking the pop out for
some midday ducks and then woodcock and grouse. A few
wood ducks can make up for some shitty deer hunting,
but didn't quite smooth the whole thing. Over the last
night of the trip, my daughter and I sat watching
a beautiful small alfalfa field on a piece of private
and listened to wolves howl in the distance, which was
a good reminder that it might not just be my
poor decision making that had the deer on edge or
(03:34):
totally gone. I recently heard someone on a podcast say
something like, when it comes to business, hope is not
a strategy, and I was running off of hope out there.
That last part of that statement stuck with me, and
it rattled around my smooth brain on the drive home
from our ill fated hunt, because it just kind of
perfectly summed up a lot of life and definitely summed
(03:56):
up deer hunting at that time and right now during
the rut. This is the thing, though, there's like no
better time during the season to have that warm and
fuzzy feeling that this is just going to be our
sit or this is just going to be our week,
because after all, when all the bucks in the neighborhood
are on the move, the odds of one of them
walking by at twenty yards will never be higher than
(04:18):
right now. That's the good news. But the bad news
is that the rut doesn't erase a lot of the
things that we think it does. Let me give you
an example here. During late September, my daughters and I
sat over in Wisconsin and saw a big old dough
multiple times one day. She was a frequent flyer on
my cameras in that spot, and she had no fawns,
so I figured her days were definitely numbered, and boy
(04:41):
did she flirt with death.
Speaker 3 (04:43):
But she beat us, and.
Speaker 2 (04:44):
Eventually she got close enough to our blind where she
could be down wind and figure it out.
Speaker 3 (04:49):
Now.
Speaker 2 (04:49):
When I heard her spook, I wondered how long it
would take for her to get back to normal. Well,
as of the last week of October, I never had
another daylight pick of her, but I had plenty of
nighttime picks. We never saw her again either, and we
hunted specifically for that deer a few times. That dough
an old, no bullshit kind of dough. She's still around,
(05:11):
but I can promise you the odds of her running
by that blind in daylight at some point or way
less than they would have been if we didn't spook
her there. She knows where we like to hide, and
she's not the kind of deer to take those chances.
Does that sound like I'm putting too much mental horsepower
in between her ears? Maybe, but I don't think so.
Does that mean a buck won't go by that blind?
(05:31):
Absolutely not. But I also think that dough in particular,
even if she was getting chased like crazy, would be
more likely to head off somewhere else where she feels
a little safer. I think it's often that simple, and
that stuff doesn't work in our favor. Now I can
somewhat confidently say that because I can keep tabs on
individual deer in that place where there just aren't very
many deer. But you might think, well, I always have
(05:54):
lots of does and fawns around my old favorite stand
site or my favorite box blind, and that's great off.
And do those dos go by and range? Are they
onto you at all. What if, for some reason, you
go out for a couple of days of your rut
cation and they don't come by, at least they don't
drag a buck by you. I remember Randy Nuberg telling
me one time about once in a lifetime tags or
(06:16):
at least super premium, you know, tags that you might
never draw, and if you do, you got real lucky.
Speaker 3 (06:21):
He said.
Speaker 2 (06:22):
People draw them and they think the hunt is going
to be easy, but you still have to put in
the effort commensurate to the tag and the animal. This
is where people get the rut wrong. A lot of times,
we like it for a lot of reasons, but the
main one we don't talk about is that the rut
is an excuse to be kind of lazy. And I'm
just going to say this and take the heat if
I have to. Lazy saves more bucks than anything else.
(06:44):
My dad just recently texted me that he put up
a blind on a farm in southeastern Minnesota for deer,
where you know there's a lot of deer in general.
But he went in there and sat a couple of times,
and that blind wasn't giving him good vibes. He knew
he needed to move it, and he was almost willing
to do that, but then he said he would just
open up a different window on the blind where there
(07:06):
are more trails on that side than the spot he'd
originally faced that. Now I had many thoughts there, none
of which I shared with him because he won't follow
my advice anyway, But I'll share them with you. That
decision was based purely on not wanting to do the
work to find new deer and set up something different.
Worse yet, I'm sure he believes his reasoning.
Speaker 3 (07:25):
Now.
Speaker 2 (07:25):
I don't want to pick on Papa too hard, because
we all do shit like that. It's in our nature
to figure out ways to shortcut every process and to
try to put in as little effort as possible for
the highest reward. If the deer have taught me anything,
it's that if you don't have an unbelievable spot to hunt,
you aren't going to get away with little effort. They're
too good at not getting killed for that kind of approach.
(07:47):
So I guess this leads me to the point where
I have to tell you how to make a plan.
I'm going to tell you what I do, and then
tell you why that's wrong, and then go in circles
for a while until I wrap this thing up. The
weather forecast is your friend, first and foremost. Wind direction
(08:12):
is what I care about the most because it will
tell me an awful lot about what I can and
can't do on any given day. So if I have,
let's say five days to hunt the rut, I want
to pull up the forecast for each day and make
no to the predicted wind direction. Now, I know that
this isn't an exact science, but it's a hell of
a lot more reliable than it used to be. So
start there where you can reasonably expect whatever wind directions
(08:34):
are predicted. Then you have to use that infotocross reference
it with the best weather conditions you have, because that's
when you want to hunt your best stuff. So let's
say you have one pinch point you scout of the
spring and you believe with your heart that it's going
to be on fire during the rut. Now you need
a west or a north wind for it, and that
isn't going to come until day three of your five
day hunt. Do you talk yourself into sitting there because
(08:56):
you think it's your best spot, or do you stay
out and hunt backups to until the weather gets right,
especially if the weather is going to get cold and
maybe a little rainy and oh so special for the rut.
Here's what probably half of the hunters will do. They'll say, well,
it's a southwest wind, but it won't be blowing very hard,
and I think I can get away with it, so
they'll hunt that pinch anyway. This is especially true if
(09:18):
they have a camera there, which they will, and that
camera will show them some daylight movement with big ones.
That siren song is loud, it's beautiful, and it'll talk
you into crashing your ship right into the rocks. My friends,
I feel like at least half of the time I haunt,
especially during the rut, I find myself sitting somewhere that's
good enough, but not where I really want to beat.
(09:41):
But if you can't cheat the wind in any meaningful
way when you're bowhunting, you just have to live by this.
You need backups that you believe in. Let's say you
decide I'm not going to that sweet pinch point till
the wind and the weather break my way. But you
also don't want to sandbag the first couple days of
your rut hunt. Where can you put in some time
and not mess up the deer that should be going
through that pinch. That's what you need to answer. So again,
(10:03):
take into account to wind in the conditions. Maybe it's
going to be ten or fifteen degrees warmer than it
should be during the rut. So on that first day
you know you're going to have the wind out of
the south. Probably do you have water to hunt or
a funnel that allows you to sit over it where
maybe they might pass through on their way to the
drinking fountain somewhere. What if you think your water spot
(10:23):
is just a nursery of little bucks and you don't
want to waste your time there. Again, probably because what
your cameras show. I look at this different and I
try to ignore my trail camera data when it comes
to the rut. If I am where I believe the
general deer population might want to go, I'm not without confidence,
even if I haven't had tons of pictures of one
to fifties in that spot. Plus, it's better than blowing
(10:46):
out your best stuff by a long shot. Now, maybe
that's not it, and maybe the south wind will allow
for a hanging hunt in an area that usually has
a whole bunch of bucks sign anything is better than
settling for good enough. And the more you lay out
your plan and your brain before you start hunting, the
more you can see it through until at least the
deer show you something different. This is where things get squirrely.
(11:09):
The best plans just generally meet our deer realities, and
if we force them too hard, when the bucks show
us something else, we lose again. You want that rough
plan in place, that day by day plan, so you
can follow through something with confidence. But if at any
point the deer really show you something but where they
(11:29):
want to be, you know, somewhere else, then you've got
to factor that in. But here's where it gets a
little worse. The way deer usually show us that is
through trail cameras. Look, that's good intel and might talk
you into calling an audible, But in person rut observations
are much more valuable. If you see a buck doing
something anything, pay attention. I don't care if it's a
spiker at two hundred injury. If you see two bucks
(11:52):
do something, you have an answer to an important question.
Where should I be sitting right now? Uh?
Speaker 3 (11:58):
Right there?
Speaker 2 (12:00):
So develop a good plan and then toss it into
the garbage. The minute the deer show you anything outside
of that plan, right, kind of, without the original plan
in place, you're going to probably settle without taking into
account what the deer actually show you. You won't be
taking full advantage of the rut. Instead, you'll be far
(12:20):
more likely to sit in a place you want to
hunt and try to call or decoy one in. Look,
this is supposed to be fun if that's how you
want to play it, so go ahead.
Speaker 3 (12:30):
That's okay.
Speaker 2 (12:30):
But if you generally don't kill big ones in November
and you want to and that's your go to strategy,
maybe hope alone isn't going to cut it. But you're
not done with your plan yet. I didn't know this
until I actually did it. But do you know why
alcoholics and addicts often tell their friends and family that
they are quitting for good. It's called a social contract,
and it's weirdly helpful because we don't want to look
(12:52):
like failures, so we try to see our promises through.
We do this with ourselves as well in the deer world.
Where I found this to be the most helpful is
that I don't just decide on where I'm most likely
to sit on any given day of the rut, but
I also make a pact with myself to sit either
until a certain time and then move or just sit
all day. It's not like I couldn't break that pack
(13:14):
you know in my head and go in for some
pancakes at ten in the morning, but for some reason
I usually don't anymore. It's kind of like when you
work out a lot, you say tonight, I'm gonna go
run the seven miles instead of just lacing up your
old on clouds and heading out for a run without
any distance or route in mind. Because the minute you
do that, you give yourself an out, because your brain
will decide that three miles is good enough. When it
(13:36):
comes to killing a buck during the rut, you can't
do better than putting in as much time as possible.
In high confidence locations, it's the way to kill deer.
And if you don't hold yourself accountable to sit until
noon or to go dark to dark, the second guessing
can talk you into heading out for a midday nap.
Not only does that take you out of the game
because you can't shoot them. When you're dreaming, you know
(13:57):
that Margot Robbie is your new coworker, or I guess
in Mark's case, a new butterfly species was just discovered
in southern Michigan. But also it puts more disturbance in
the woods just by your comings and going. This is
also the way that most of your competition's going to hunt.
And if you tend to hunt pressure ground and you
do not sit during the midday hours during the rut,
you're just missing out. I promise you that pressure deer
(14:20):
are tuned into us in major ways, and that timeframe
when most hunters can't hack it because they don't believe,
you know, in any real midday deer movement and they
don't have a plan, is some of the most important
time you can spend in the woods. But it takes
a strategy, takes a plan. It takes a willingness to
look at every opportunity you have to be out there
and decide how to play it against the predicted wind
(14:42):
and weather and all of the variables that you might
bump into. As the bucks get a little silly with
lust and they start to cover some serious ground, you know,
pair that with a willingness to go mobile or accept
that what you thought was going to happen didn't and
that you're going to have to let the deer decide
what to do if their movements are just persuasive enough.
And now you have the framework for a successful rut hunt.
(15:06):
The last piece of that puzzle is just putting in
the time, which, when you do and have a few
years show you that it was the right call, gets
a hell of a lot easier to do over time.
So remember this when it comes to rut hunting. Hope
is not a strategy. It's just a nice little boost
that will help you stick out a well thought out plant.
So get out there and get your buck and come
(15:27):
back next week because I'm going to talk about certain
situations during the rut where I will dig into my
bag of get rich quick products and really try to
make something happen.
Speaker 3 (15:35):
That's it for this week. I'm Tony Peterson.
Speaker 2 (15:38):
This has been the Wirre to Hunt Foundation's episode, which
is brought to you by First Light. As always, thank
you so much for listening for all your support. I
know you're spending a lot of time in tree stands
right now, but you might also be driving somewhere to
go do an over the road trip. You might kill
a buck and want to know I don't know how
to do a ural amount with it, or maybe cook
it up.
Speaker 3 (15:57):
So it's super tasty.
Speaker 2 (15:59):
Whatever, you can probably find the answers to a lot
of your questions, and I know you can find a
hell of a lot of entertainment at the medeater dot com,
where we drop new content every single day.
Speaker 3 (16:08):
Go check it out.
Host
Mark Kenyon
Popular Podcasts
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
Ruthie's Table 4
For more than 30 years The River Cafe in London, has been the home-from-home of artists, architects, designers, actors, collectors, writers, activists, and politicians. Michael Caine, Glenn Close, JJ Abrams, Steve McQueen, Victoria and David Beckham, and Lily Allen, are just some of the people who love to call The River Cafe home. On River Cafe Table 4, Rogers sits down with her customers—who have become friends—to talk about food memories. Table 4 explores how food impacts every aspect of our lives. “Foods is politics, food is cultural, food is how you express love, food is about your heritage, it defines who you and who you want to be,” says Rogers. Each week, Rogers invites her guest to reminisce about family suppers and first dates, what they cook, how they eat when performing, the restaurants they choose, and what food they seek when they need comfort. And to punctuate each episode of Table 4, guests such as Ralph Fiennes, Emily Blunt, and Alfonso Cuarón, read their favourite recipe from one of the best-selling River Cafe cookbooks. Table 4 itself, is situated near The River Cafe’s open kitchen, close to the bright pink wood-fired oven and next to the glossy yellow pass, where Ruthie oversees the restaurant. You are invited to take a seat at this intimate table and join the conversation. For more information, recipes, and ingredients, go to https://shoptherivercafe.co.uk/ Web: https://rivercafe.co.uk/ Instagram: www.instagram.com/therivercafelondon/ Facebook: https://en-gb.facebook.com/therivercafelondon/ For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iheartradio app, apple podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows. Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
Dateline NBC
Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com