September 11, 2025 • 39 mins
On the night of February 4, 2011, Avalisa Morris was shot and killed at a birthday party in the basement of a two-family home in Queens, NY. The fatal gunshots were fired from outside the party, through the closed door of the entrance to the basement. Even though no eyewitnesses placed Allen at the door with a weapon, he was tried under an acting-in-concert theory, and convicted of second‑degree manslaughter and related firearms charges. He was sentenced to 15 years in prison.
To learn more and get involved, please visit:
https://www.instagram.com/brukky_freewise/
https://ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/politics/2024/09/18/tim-pearson-investigation
https://jacobin.com/2024/10/timothy-pearson-nyc-asylum-seekers
https://www.netflix.com/title/80187052
Wrongful Conviction is a production of Lava for Good™ Podcasts in association with Signal Co. No1.
We have worked hard to ensure that all facts reported in this show are accurate. The views and opinions expressed by the individuals featured in this show are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of Lava for Good.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:02):
On February sixth, twenty eleven, a party in a queen's
New York basement turned violent, and when those involved were
forced out into the exit stairwell, two gunshots were fired
into the door, fatally striking twenty six year old Avalisa Morris.
The police were soon directed toward a couple Felicia Douglas
(00:25):
and O'Neill Mayers, whose argument allegedly ignited the fray. Even
though O'Neill claims to have left before the gunshots and
didn't match the initial descriptions of the likely shooter, he
was arrested and tried, along with his friend Nicholas Allen,
who had left the party hours before the shooting. This
(00:46):
is wrongful Conviction. You're listening to Wrongful Conviction. You can
listen to this and all the Lava for Good podcasts
one week early and ad free subscribing to Lava for
Good Plus on Apple Podcasts. Welcome back to Ronfuel Conviction,
(01:13):
where our guest is calling in from the country of
Jamaica to tell us about a case that happened near
Jamaica Queens and started with an absolutely senseless act of
violence which was then compounded by convicting at least one,
if not two innocent men, one of them being Nicholas Brucky. Allen, welcome,
Thank you, all right. So tell us about growing up
(01:34):
in Jamaica and coming to the US.
Speaker 2 (01:37):
I was born in Kingston, Jamaica. I got four sisters
and three brothers. Two of them was like babies, and
one of them was born while I was in the States,
so I didn't really actually grew up with those three.
I came to the stage when I was like twelve.
So I just remember where I used to live in Jamaica.
It was like a soccer field next.
Speaker 3 (01:56):
To my home. Soccer was just my love.
Speaker 2 (02:00):
If my friend's playing on the street bearfooted, I will
go out there and also play bearfooted.
Speaker 1 (02:06):
So where did the nickname Brockie come from?
Speaker 2 (02:09):
In Jamaican culture, we call dribble brooke when you cross
somebody that's basically you brooking everybody. Basically Brookie is somebody
that does just love to dribble and don't like the past.
Speaker 3 (02:24):
And it's funny because when I.
Speaker 2 (02:26):
Got to the States, my first team, Cambria Heights, it
was a lady that first called me Brookie.
Speaker 3 (02:32):
I never told her that was my nickname. In Jamaica.
I never told her that. She just watched me. She
was like, yo, you was a Brookie and.
Speaker 2 (02:38):
I'm like, oh, that's what they called me in Jamaica.
Speaker 3 (02:41):
That's my name.
Speaker 1 (02:42):
But it wasn't soccer that brought him to New York.
Speaker 2 (02:44):
At the age of eleven, I was diagnosed with you
and star a coma. It was a form of cancer.
This was like around two thousand. I started off getting
treatment in Jamaica, but my auntie came into the States
and on the teaching program. She went to the courts
with my dad and my mom did the legal guardianship.
Speaker 3 (03:05):
So the lawyer told.
Speaker 2 (03:06):
Her when you're in the States and you get your
green card, he's going to get his. When you become
a citizen, he will become citizen. So she had took
me into the States. I did chemoturpy. I had no hair,
so I used to wear a lot of door rags
a lot of time. When I used to play soccer,
it was like I was the sick on. Everybody was
just looking at me. But that never stopped me. I
(03:27):
play hard. I went to Automotive High School. My own
was a teacher at the school. But yo, they never
seen the playoff until I came. When I came, took
them the playoff the whole four years.
Speaker 3 (03:38):
That I was there. I graduated.
Speaker 2 (03:41):
Then from there I got in a soccer scholarship to
Globe College. Went for a year and a half and
that's when I got arrested.
Speaker 1 (03:50):
And he was arrested along with another young Jamaican man
named O'Neill Mayers.
Speaker 2 (03:55):
I met Mayors through guys from my soccer team. They
were quit mars at Walmart. When I first met him,
I never get any bad vibes. I see that he
always works to take care of his son. You know,
I'm on college and stuff, so I used to love parties,
so you know, me and Mirors sometimes will go to parties.
Speaker 1 (04:18):
And that's what was happening at the time of this
tragic shooting. O'Neill's supervisor at Walmart, Damian Skurvin, had planned
a party for his wife Nikki at their friend Mary
Johnson's apartment on February fifth, twenty eleven, even though there
was a competing party nearby at Nicholas's friend named Pouchi
Poochie's house. Both O'Neill and Nicholas were drawn to the
(04:38):
Skurvans party to see two girls who they had met
the night before, one of whom Britney Goodrich later testified.
Now this previous night, February fourth, they were up really late,
leading to a midday nap for O'Neil that nearly lasted
through both parties on February fifth. But Nicholas was close
with Poochie's boyfriend Gabby Francis, so he made sure he
(04:59):
was at Pooci's.
Speaker 2 (05:00):
So when I got there, I was pretty much helping
him decoration, helping, cooking the food, stuff like that. So
around twelve midnight, I pull up my friends Cafarri, Samuel,
Dwayne Right, Gabby Francis, and Dennis Cunningham, and I told him, oh, listen,
Damien is having a birthday party for his wife tonight.
Y'all want to go support, and they agreed. They call
(05:23):
a cab. I got there around twelve ish and I
left like early one. When we got there, I saw
Brittany dancing under the light. The only spot in the
basement had light was where the DJ booth was at,
So I went right up to Brittany. I asked her
how she's doing. I told her I'm not staying. My
people have a party, so I'm leaving. She put her
number with my phone and I never seen mirrors at
(05:46):
that party. Never Me and Mirrs was not together. It
was my four friends and we left in a cab
back to Pucci party. For the rest of the night,
we drink, dance, we took pictures. One of the girls
over there took a picture with me and around the
same time as.
Speaker 1 (06:01):
The incident, it was just about eight minutes after the
shooting when Nicholas took a picture with Vanessa Bunton on
a digital camera. Now remember this was twenty eleven when
folks were still transitioning from flip phones, iPods and cameras
to the all in one smartphone that's now ubiquitous. But anyway,
we'll get back to Vanessa Bunton and this picture in
a bit. So let's rewind to about three o'clock in
(06:23):
the morning.
Speaker 2 (06:24):
Around three on he called me saying, yo, you just
got up. He's gonna go to Damien wife's Porty Nikki
on his block because the party actually kept on his block.
So I said, oh yeah, I was there earlier.
Speaker 3 (06:36):
And I got Brittany number. That was it. Around a
little bit before five.
Speaker 2 (06:41):
He called me back again, saying the party got shoot up,
asked if I was still at Pucci I said yes,
and he said I'm coming right now. When he came,
he sat in the car and he told me the
girl that he was talking to the day before. He
was talking to her and his girlfriend came over slapped him,
and out of a reflex, he slapped her back and
(07:02):
she went outside crying and stuff. He also said he
noticed the commotions at the door. He said the DJ
got into it with somebody and he just pushed through
the commotions and left. While he got to the front
of the house, he said he heard gunshots and he
just ran home, jump in his car, called me and
came to me at Pouci's.
Speaker 1 (07:20):
To exit the basement, O'Neill left through the back door
to a covered stairwall that led to the backyard, where
his girlfriend Felicia Douglass and her friend Vanessa Edwards claimed
to have seen him, which he doesn't deny. What he
does deny is going back down the stairwell and shooting
at the door. Now. According to the initial police reports,
also known as DV five's, the guest of honor, Nicki
(07:41):
Scurvin the host Mary Johnson, as well as the victim
of Alisa Morris, pushed a group of three or four
young men out into the back stairwell and slammed the door,
and the group tried to force their way back in.
Speaker 2 (07:53):
I heard that she used her back to prevent the
guys from coming back and said and shot fired and
mis Kelly hit her in their head. When the cops
had just came Mary Johnson's she identified a tall, light
skin with braids in his.
Speaker 1 (08:07):
Thirties, which doesn't describe O'Neill or Nicholas.
Speaker 2 (08:12):
Also, NICKI Scurvin the morning off the crime. When the
cops came in our DD five, she never mentioned O'Neill.
Mayers never mentioned me at all.
Speaker 1 (08:19):
But both of those statements would change by the time
of the grand jury and trial, as would pretty much
everyone else's statements, including O'Neill's girlfriend Felicia Douglas and her
friend Vanessa Edwards. Now. In their first statements, they said
that they had seen O'Neill emerge from the coupvered stairwell,
which is undisputed, but was it before or after the
(08:40):
gunshots well? Either way, Felicia texted O'Neill after giving her statement.
Speaker 2 (08:46):
So we were still in the car, he got a
text from his girlfriend saying that such and such a
diet and you and your friend Brookie did it. So
he showed me the texts. I'm like, what the hell
is she talking about?
Speaker 3 (08:57):
You know?
Speaker 2 (08:58):
But I looked at Mayer's face. I could see like
a worried look. So he tried to call her. She
answered on the fifth call, and she was just crying.
He said, Yo, what's going on? Why you send me
that text? So she was like, they made me do it,
They made me do it. So he said, why would
you tell the police?
Speaker 3 (09:16):
I did nothing? Why do you tell the police? Go
tell the police. I didn't do nothing.
Speaker 2 (09:20):
We had found out later on that basically the friends
of the victim tell her, yo, listen, you and your
man came here and mess up my party, so you
better go tell the cops that he did that. That's
when she had gave the police on ill number.
Speaker 1 (09:33):
But with no views through the stairwells covering the basement
door or any meaningful ballistics evidence, no witnesses or experts
could claim to know who pulled the trigger, and without
the ever important timing aspect had O'Neil been seen before
or after the gunshots, and with no other names being
mentioned besides O'Neil, he became the target.
Speaker 3 (09:54):
So we were still in the car. He looked distressed.
Speaker 2 (09:58):
A few minutes later, a detective by the name of
Pearson called him saying that he's a person of interest
and they would like to speak with him. So he said,
all right, no doubt, I'm coming in right now. So
I stayed and I waited for him to come back,
and he never came back.
Speaker 1 (10:13):
O'Neill was arrested, and since no one could actually see
the shooting, they used the circumstances. Someone had to place
a gun in his hand in the stairwell at the
time of the crime. So by the grand jury, Vanessa
Edwards testified that when O'Neill first emerged from the stairwell,
he had a gun in his hand. Then the group
went back down the covered stairwell and shots were fired. However,
(10:37):
Felicia's story changed in a different way.
Speaker 2 (10:40):
The two statements that she gave to the cops. She
was saying that she saw Onneila ran up the steps.
The other statement she had said that she just said
this because she was mad, because Onlyla had slapped her.
She also made a statement to one's lawyer saying that
she was mad and was also forced by the victim
(11:02):
friends tell the cops that she saw on it ran
up the steps, and she also made a statement to
my attorney saying that she never even seen me that
whole night.
Speaker 1 (11:13):
And at this point, neither Vanessa Edwards, Nicki Scurvin, nor
Mary Johnson had mentioned Nicholas, only Felicia had done so
in that text that she now just disavowed. Vanessa Edwards
also maintained that she hadn't seen Nicholas since earlier in
the evening. But Nicholas becomes involved because during the month
(11:34):
following the shooting, O'Neil had let Nicholas his car.
Speaker 2 (11:37):
So a month later I noticed an unmarked car following me.
They passed me, came in front of me, made a
sound stop, forcing me to stop. Then they jumped up
and it was just police everywhere, guns everywhere.
Speaker 3 (11:52):
Move Move, motherfuckers. I could shoot you. Move. So I'm like,
I'm not moving. I'm not moving.
Speaker 2 (11:56):
They dragged me out of car, put my face on
the ground with the knee in my face. Detective Pearson
came in, got me and brought me to one thirteen.
Speaker 1 (12:04):
Percent, and this detective Timothy Pearson, recently served as a
top aid to New York City Mayor Eric Adams. Apparently
they go way back, and he has faced or is
currently facing allegations ranging from corruption, pay the play schemes,
as well as rape and other sexual misconduct. But there's
no known history of wrongful convictions, that is until now.
Speaker 2 (12:26):
So when I got to one thirteen percint, they asked me,
do you know why I'm here? I'm like, maybe because
I was driving my friend's car and he was charged
for murder. They said yes, but there is more. The
car was seen leaving the scene that waitness saw me
and O'Neill together that night, So I said, no, that
can't be true. So he said, O'Neill said I was
with him that.
Speaker 1 (12:45):
Night, which yes, they were together, but only after the
shooting when they met up at Pucci's house. Now, always
remember it is legal for the police to lie or mislead.
I'm hoping that'll change someday, but that's the way it is.
And the reality here was that Nicholas and O'Neill had
been calling each other before they actually met up.
Speaker 3 (13:07):
So I'm like, I have.
Speaker 2 (13:08):
Proof in my phone that we was actually calling each other.
If you check my call log, you could see recent
call and only called me at three, and he called
me also at five. It was like a tow way phone.
It was a Walmart phone. So the only thing that
phone could prove is the recent call. So I don't
know if they did check or not, but my phone
(13:28):
end up disappearing, right. I told my lawyer about the phone,
and they told my lawyer in evidence.
Speaker 3 (13:35):
Right days past, my lawyer tried.
Speaker 2 (13:37):
To get the phone back again and they said the
phone disappeared. The phone can be found.
Speaker 1 (13:43):
I mean, why let perfectly good exculpatory evidence get in
the way of what appears to be manufactured evidence. This
came in the form of another alleged partygoer, the upstairs neighbor,
a guy named Richard Bennett. For the first time, he
claimed to have seen the alleged sailants being pushed out
of the basement back door. Never mind that from where
(14:04):
he said he was standing, he couldn't have seen that door.
Then he said he ran upstairs to his apartment. This
is a two family home, so he had to go
out Mary Johnson's front door outside to access his own
front door, and he claimed that this is when he
saw three alleged assailants. And now he was at the
precinct of view a lineup featuring Nicholas.
Speaker 2 (14:27):
He was seeing a Facebook photo off me minutes before
the lineup. This same guy testified at a grandjury that
I have a tattoo on the right side of my neck.
This same guy said that when me and Oni got
to the front of the house, he said a point
a gun in his face. He said, I said to him,
what's you're looking at, motherfucker? And while he was looking
(14:48):
at me, he saw a tattoo on my neck, with words,
I don't have no tattoo, never have a tattoo on me.
Speaker 1 (14:54):
Ever, nevertheless, now Panessa Edwards and Richard Bennett both placed
O'Neill and the at the scene with guns in their hands.
Speaker 2 (15:02):
They charged us with acting in concert.
Speaker 3 (15:05):
I was arraigned.
Speaker 2 (15:06):
I had a bunch of people in court that was
there with me at Pucci house. It looked like the
judge were considering to give me a bill until the
district attorney jumped up and said, judge, the victim family
scared for their life, and the judge was like, no bill,
you know, so I was sent to rakas Allen. It
was a new experience for me, so I had to
(15:28):
adapt fast.
Speaker 3 (15:30):
I was young. I was like in the jungle.
Speaker 2 (15:32):
I was like around some wild kids that's probably been
to jail more than my fingers, you know.
Speaker 1 (15:53):
Nicholas spent three long, miserable years in pre trial detention
on the Notori Complex, not as Riker's Island, which is
just fucking wild. I mean, from March twenty eleven to
November twenty fourteen, not convicted of a freaking thing. This
was around the same time that Khalif Browder, by the
(16:15):
Way Rest in Peace was there for three years pre
trial as well. We're going to link to the Kaliff
Browder documentary in the episode description. Well, luckily Nicholas was
able to survive this ordeal, unlike Khalif. But meanwhile, on
the outside, O'Neil and Nicholas's attorneys had three years to
prepare for cross examinations, and despite Nicholas's phone just magically disappearing,
(16:38):
he still had his alibi, witnesses and the picture with
Vanessa Punton, placing him a fifteen minute drive away from
Mary Johnson's just about eight minutes after the shooting. The
only issue was that in the digital cameras settings AM
had been flipped with PM.
Speaker 2 (16:54):
Well, my lawyer was telling me that even though the
time stamp it's saying PM instead of M. When it's
time for trial, he would get Vanessa to come and
testify for.
Speaker 1 (17:04):
The grand jury. Only the photo was entered into evidence.
In addition, his friend Gabby Francis testified that he was
with Nicholas all night, including when they had gone to
the Scurvins party and back to Poocies, but Britney Goodrich,
the girl that had traded phone numbers with him, She
claimed that Nicholas had returned later on in the morning.
Speaker 2 (17:22):
There was a weakness go by the name of Larissa White.
She also wrote a statement the morning of the crime.
She also testified in a grand jury, and her testimony
was that when the shot rang out, she was upstairs
with Britney Goodrich looking for their coats to leave. So
she contradicts Brittany because Brittany said she was down in
(17:43):
the basement when the shots rang out and that's the
last time she saw me.
Speaker 1 (17:47):
Vanessa Edwards also testified that the last time she saw
Nicholas was earlier in the night, which also impeached Brittany,
as well as Nicki Skurvin and Mary Johnson's new statements,
which now aligned with the state's narrative.
Speaker 3 (18:00):
D five statement.
Speaker 2 (18:01):
As Mary Johnson, she gave to the cops she identified
a tall, light skin with braids in his thirties. That
was just disregarded. So my lawyer let her know that
he's not tall, he's not light skin, and you know
what I'm saying.
Speaker 3 (18:16):
So her thing was that it was me. I was there.
Speaker 2 (18:19):
Also, Nicki Scurvin, minutes after the situation, she never mentioned
ONeill Mayors. She never mentioned me at all. It was
at the Grand Jewelry when she mentioned O'Neill and me.
Then in the first trial, Mary Johnson she said, my
hair was basically braided up with rubber bands at the tip,
wearing a jeans jacket with a gray shirt. That's was
not my appearance that night. The picture that I took
(18:42):
showed a different appearance. Everybody put me into a different clothing, earstyle.
Everybody description was just off, but hers was funny and ridiculous.
Speaker 1 (18:52):
So despite photographic evidence of the contrary, Mary Johnson and
Nicki Scurvin supported the state's trial narrative, which was that
after O'Neill and Felicia traded slaps, that O'Neill, Nicholas, and
two others were forced to leave the party by the victim,
as well as Mary Johnson and Nicki Scurvin.
Speaker 3 (19:11):
Nicki's Curvin.
Speaker 2 (19:12):
She testified that she went to you gotta go because
you and your girl messed up my party.
Speaker 3 (19:17):
And she said.
Speaker 2 (19:18):
One'll tell her leave me alone. And while she grabbed him,
she said, he like swring her hands off him. And
as he did that, she said she saw something that
appears to be a gun in his waist. When she
saw the gun, she said, ONeill said, yo, leave me alone.
You want to mess with badman. Don't mess with badman.
That's the Jamaican term saying that, don't mess with the gangster.
Speaker 3 (19:39):
So she said.
Speaker 2 (19:40):
Other people came in shove shove him out. So they
asked her what I was doing. She said, I was
just there. She said, she got us out, closed the door.
As we're trying to bang the door to come back in,
the door cracked open and she saw my face, so
she put.
Speaker 3 (19:55):
Me on the scene.
Speaker 1 (19:56):
Then Vanessa Edwards stuck with her initial statement about O'Neil
emerging from the stairwell, but this time she added a
gun and more.
Speaker 2 (20:04):
She testified that she saw one ran up the steps
with a gun in his hand with about four guys,
and the four guys ran back down the steps. She
heard the shots, and then the guys walked back up
and ran down the driveway. So Maloya asked her, did
she ever saw my face before? She said yes, she
saw me that night talking to Brittany. Did you see
(20:27):
him run up the steps with those group of guys?
Speaker 3 (20:29):
She said no.
Speaker 2 (20:30):
Last time she saw me was the time that I
was talking to Brittany, and she never saw me back that.
Speaker 1 (20:34):
Night, which contradicts Mary Johnson and Nikki Scurvin, who claimed
to have seen Nicholas's face when Ava Lisa Morris slammed
the door shut on the four men before two gun
shots were fired through the door.
Speaker 2 (20:46):
There was a hole that's higher and there's another lower hole.
The ballistic detective he was trying to say, I fired
the lower hole and because one was taller, he fired
the higher hole. So like this is just your speculations
or this is a fact. He said, no, it's just
(21:06):
in speculating. So Maloya ax him.
Speaker 3 (21:09):
Was it one gun? Was it two gun?
Speaker 2 (21:11):
Did they fire one gun and gave it to the
other one and the other one fired?
Speaker 3 (21:14):
What was it?
Speaker 2 (21:15):
So he couldn't answer, So it was just based off
of his speculations.
Speaker 1 (21:19):
And what appears to be wishful thinking to nab two
gunmen for the price of one, when in actuality, what
they had were two forty five caliber shell cases believed
to have been fired from a semi automatic weapon, which
simply could have been fired from different angles. But they
continued right along with the two shooter theory, putting Richard
Bennett on the stand, and he proceeded to impeach himself twice,
(21:43):
first claiming that he was at the front side of
the basement about to head up the stairs when he'd
seen o, Neil and Nicholas being forced out the back door,
but there was a structure, a bathroom that had been
built between those two points and it was blocking his
view of the back door. And then came self sabotage
number two, when he claimed to have gone upstairs and
out the front door.
Speaker 2 (22:03):
So he said, while he was outside opening the door,
he said he saw me and Onneil. He said, I
said to him, what's you looking at motherfucker pointing the
gun in his face. And he was asked, did you say, mister,
and you saw a tattoo on his neck?
Speaker 3 (22:16):
Yes, he got a tattoo on his neck.
Speaker 2 (22:18):
So when I took the stand, my lawyer asked me
to show my neck, and I don't have no tattoo,
never have a tattoo on me ever, But Bennett was
certain that he saw a tattoo and it was in words.
Speaker 1 (22:30):
Then Gabby Francis teestified that Nicholas had been with him
all night and therefore unavailable for this crime. The picture
with Vanessa Bunden was also presented, which not only impeached
all the hair and clothing descriptions, but also corroborated his alibi,
placing him a fifteen minute drive away right about eight
minutes after the shooting. And instead of attacking the incorrect
(22:52):
AMPM setting up the timestamp, the district attorney, Denise Tarini,
took a different tact.
Speaker 2 (22:58):
She was trying to say that I did the crime
and a rush to Puccios. So her argument was like, yes, judge,
he knew what he was doing. He did that, and
then he rushed over there and say, let me take
a picture to show that I was here.
Speaker 1 (23:12):
So let's recap. Vanessa Edwards contradicted Scurvin, Johnson and Bennett,
while Bennett proceeded to impeach himself even more. And then
there was the worthless ballistics speculation, followed by Ada Denise
Terini's own worthless speculation about the photo. But still some
(23:34):
jurors they just wanted to believe in their guilt.
Speaker 2 (23:37):
We went for deliberation and we was in the bullpen
and it was just a wall separating us from the
deliberation room, so we could actually hear the juries like
raising their voice cursing like I.
Speaker 3 (23:52):
Don't give a fuck.
Speaker 2 (23:53):
He did not do it, he caunnot see, he cannot
see through the bathroom.
Speaker 3 (23:58):
I don't give a fuck.
Speaker 2 (23:59):
So me and Oni like we got elated because we
were like damn people in there fighting for us. The
verdict came back, they said, judge, we can't decide, and
it was a hang jury. The child would have to
go over again.
Speaker 3 (24:13):
And it was like mixed.
Speaker 2 (24:15):
Feeling because like I was happy and I was said
because I was sent back to rack as Allen, and
also I felt like all right, no, we know what
was said.
Speaker 3 (24:25):
So next time it would be better.
Speaker 1 (24:27):
But the district attorney also observed what worked and what
clearly did not. So eight months later, at the second trial,
Vanessa Edwards needed to not contradict half the state's witnesses,
most of whom had previously testified about how dark it
had been in the basement, thereby making it difficult to see,
so that part of the narrative needed to change. And
(24:50):
then Richard Bennett needed to try to somehow deflect from
his previous self sabotage and focus solely on identifying Nicholas.
Speaker 2 (25:00):
My second trial started and Richard Bennon he was the
first witness call to the stand, right, so eight months
later he trying to say that, you don't remember saying
no tattoo.
Speaker 3 (25:11):
You don't remember saying that.
Speaker 2 (25:13):
So you know, we did read backs from the first
trial and grand jury acting him, do you remember saying, yeah,
witness point of gun in my face had a tattoo
on his right side of his neck. And then that's
when he was like, yeah, I remember saying that. But
he came back in the second trial trying to say,
you don't remember saying it. District attorney disregard that old tattoo.
She said, first of all, Richard Bennon was not identifying
(25:36):
a tattoo. He was identifying my face. And she was like,
so what what if he thought he saw a tattoo.
So she disregarded that whole thing, and she asked him
about the lighting.
Speaker 3 (25:48):
He said it was dark. It was dark.
Speaker 2 (25:50):
It was dark, and she become frustrated. Now you know,
in the first trial that was like a big thing
for my side, were trying to prove, like, yo, is
a party, it's pretty much dark.
Speaker 3 (26:03):
Like, yeah, the DJ have light.
Speaker 2 (26:05):
In the second trial, the district attorney.
Speaker 3 (26:07):
She lit up the whole place. It was so bright.
Speaker 2 (26:11):
She was like Christmas lights was in the basement. Light
was shining from outside coming into the basement.
Speaker 3 (26:16):
She was lit up the whole place.
Speaker 2 (26:18):
That's why the ballistic detective came back and started testifying
about lights. So Monmoy was like, Yo, you supposed to
be testifying about ballistic evidence. Why are you coming here
testifying about lights? You never said that in your first child.
Why are you coming here talking about the light.
Speaker 1 (26:33):
So it appears that testifying about the lights was a
better use of this expert than his speculations. In addition,
Mary Johnson and Nicki Scurvin steered away from the erroneous
hair and clothing descriptions and focused instead on making the
IDs and placing a gun on O'Neill.
Speaker 2 (26:50):
In the second trial, Nickiy Scurvy she was more sturdy.
Her husband actually came also in the second trial and
testify on RBA testify and said she was drunk. He
said one time he was trying to talk to her,
she couldn't even recognize him.
Speaker 3 (27:05):
She was up in his face. So he testified that
she was actually drunk.
Speaker 1 (27:10):
But that impeachment mattered a little less when Vanessa Edwards
took the stand to place o'neel at the scene with
a gun and was careful not to clear Nicholas again,
thereby impeaching the other state's witnesses.
Speaker 2 (27:22):
My lawyer asked her the same thing again. Was I
in the group? She said she don't know, because she
wasn't looking at face and she was just looking at
the gun that Meares had in his hand. You could
tell that she was coached by the district attorney. My
lawyer picked that up throughout the whole trial because they
was like button heads.
Speaker 3 (27:40):
They was literally arguing.
Speaker 2 (27:42):
I remember incident my girlfriend came in and told me, oh,
mister Mitchell just cursed out mister Reno. He told her
that you're trying to set up my client. You're trying
to send my client to jail, not over my dead body.
And it was a big argument in the elevator. It
was just so crazy because you sit down in your
first child here thing, and then when it comes to
the second child, the whole testimony just changed and flips.
Speaker 1 (28:05):
But there were at least two witnesses in addition to
Gabby Francis that could have helped the defense. One was
the girl from the picture, Vanessa Bunten, the second child.
Speaker 2 (28:14):
She said she was coming to testify. She was supposed
to go to work and sign out and come in court.
So we was in court waiting for her to come,
so my lawyer called her. She told my lawyer that
she's sorry, she cannot come anymore because when she got
to work, she had a surprise promotional party for her,
so she never came in testify.
Speaker 1 (28:36):
Another defense witness could have been Felicia Douglas, because not
only had she admitted to making the statement out of
anger at O'Neill and feeling pressure from the victim's friends,
but also she had denied seeing Nicholas at the time
of the shooting, and she was standing right next to
Vanessa Edwards.
Speaker 2 (28:52):
She came to the court ready to testify, but only
lawyer pulled back. He said, listen, we're not going to
put her on this because with the four statement that
she made, the district attorney will eat her up. So
he decided not to put her on the stand.
Speaker 1 (29:08):
And let's face it, separate trials had a singularly focused
strategy probably would have made a difference for Nicholas, but
unfortunately he was deprived of that. And then the district
attorney had one more tactic.
Speaker 3 (29:22):
She put the mom on.
Speaker 2 (29:23):
The stand, and the mom testified above for half an hour,
and she cried the whole alf an hour. You know
what I mean, I cried, I'm sitting over there, she cried,
I can't remember that.
Speaker 3 (29:36):
This deliberation, this.
Speaker 2 (29:38):
One took three days, not like the first one that
took almost two weeks. This one took three days.
Speaker 3 (29:45):
And the verdict came in. They started O'Neill.
Speaker 2 (29:48):
First, murder her in the second degree not guilty, so I.
Speaker 3 (29:52):
Was like, oh whooa.
Speaker 2 (29:54):
But then manslaughter guilty, criminal position of a weapon guilty,
recklessly guilty, so now.
Speaker 3 (30:01):
It was my term. They read a murder not guilty,
so no o, so they read out manslaughter.
Speaker 2 (30:09):
I was guilty, criminal position guilty, reckless endigierment guilty.
Speaker 3 (30:14):
So we got the same charges. We had to go
back like.
Speaker 2 (30:18):
Three months for sentence, and I gave my condolences to
the family. I told the mom, listen, your daughter blood
is not on my hand. I don't know what happened,
but I give you my deepest condolence. O'Neill did the
same thing. I asked the judge for sympathy, but it
(30:40):
was gotten. The mac sentence and all charges five to
fifteen on the Manto fifteen flat for the criminal position
of a weapon and three to seven on the reckless engagement.
The fifteen flat overrides the five to fifteen. If it
wasn't the fifteen flat, I think would have been home
long time ago. But because fifteen flat, we had to
(31:01):
do the whole fifteen years. When I got to five points,
(31:23):
he was a double bunk jail, so I was like,
oh my gosh, I gotta share this small space with someone.
But the guy that I was bunk with, he was
pretty cool.
Speaker 3 (31:37):
You know, so we become close. Then he left.
Speaker 2 (31:41):
Then no, I was worrying again and be like, oh
my god, I hope I don't get a nasty bunky,
you know, But I got somebody pretty decent. He was
like older. He's also good in the law. His name
is Paul Thompson. Actually he's also innocent in his case.
Somebody had shot him and the person that shot him
(32:02):
died later, so they're trying to say he was the
one that did it. So they paid a crackhead, put
him up in the hotel, make him live in luxury
to testify against him that he saw him that day
that shoot the guy that shot him.
Speaker 3 (32:15):
So he's good with the laws. He's still fighting right now.
Speaker 1 (32:19):
Paul Thompson, all right, we'll try to make contact somehow.
Speaker 2 (32:22):
He got twenty five to life and I got fifteen years.
I saw I could never complain. I'm gonna go back out.
Speaker 3 (32:29):
He might not.
Speaker 1 (32:30):
And what's wild about Nicholas's appeal process was that since
three years went by pre trial, a lot of the
information that we talked about today was discovered and used
by the defense, so new evidence couldn't get him the
relief that he needed and deserved. At least not yet. Now.
The issues that were raised on direct appeal and in
(32:51):
his habeas related to insufficiency of evidence, as well as
potentially prejudicial comments and conduct by the prosecution. Unfortunately, the
time that was denied, it was already twenty twenty two,
eleven long years into a maximum sentence of fifteen years.
Speaker 2 (33:08):
Because you know, when you get fifteen years, you have
good time, so you don't actually do the whole fifteen years.
Speaker 3 (33:15):
You know.
Speaker 2 (33:15):
I wasn't giving no trouble inside, so I still had
my good time, you know, So I actually did twelve
years and ten months. My release date was January seventh,
twenty twenty four, right before I came home. You know,
they have a saint say in the streets talk, you know,
(33:35):
so I waited the years to see if someone my
anti prayed like, oh, the real person was going to
come forward one day, and right before I came home,
I called my cousin one day and she told me
that she heard who did it.
Speaker 1 (33:53):
He knows the alternative suspect's name, but that would still
need to be verified. And we're not going to name
names here if it's not confirmed, but that could be
a very promising starting point for an interested attorney who
hopefully is listening right now, who might want to take
up the cause of clearing Nicholas's name once and for all.
It also seems that there's an ineffective council claim here
(34:16):
for not having severed the trials.
Speaker 2 (34:19):
When I did my appeal, that was a big thing.
My lawyer, Alan Feleck, he was saying, listen, you could
have easily walk away from this if the child was separated.
But at the time my lawyer it felt like it
was best for him to team up, so you have
two lawyers against one district attorney. But he was wrong
because every other lawyer looked at my case they said, yeah,
(34:42):
y'all should have been separated.
Speaker 1 (34:43):
So we'll be linking the contact information for Nicholas Brucky
Allen in the episode description for any interested attorney or
anyone who has it pertinent information, including the actual shooter
or one of the men in the stairwell morning. But
back to his release. Since his immigration status was impacted
(35:05):
by this roundful conviction, he was sent to immigration detention.
Speaker 2 (35:10):
So I was in the immigration facility. I was deciding
to fight the case, you know, But then I'm like,
why would I stay any longer in prison, when I
could just be free and just go back to Jamaica.
I just want to live my life now. Thank God
for my freedom, and that's it. But always in the
(35:32):
back of my head saying that one day I want
to clear my name, you know. And when I got
to Jamaica walked out, that's when I firstly first experience freedom.
On the twenty fifth January in twenty twenty four, my
family here head keep a big party for me, like
a welcome home party meals.
Speaker 3 (35:53):
When I came home that I was eating, it was
like just delicious. It was. It was like a breath
of fresh air. You know.
Speaker 2 (36:00):
It was like the actra real, authentic Jamaican taste.
Speaker 3 (36:05):
You know.
Speaker 1 (36:06):
Since Nicholas Bucky Allen has been home, he's written a
book called The State of New York Versus Nicholas Allen.
We're going to link to that as well. I'm going
to order a copy myself. But Brucky has also connected
with an old friend who has been visiting him in
Jamaica and they're expecting a baby really soon. So we
wish them all the best. And with that, we're going
(36:26):
to go to closing arguments, where first of all, I
thank you for sharing this incredible true story. Closing arguments,
of course, is a part of the show that I
really look forward to, where I'm going to turn off
my microphone, leave my headphones on, just close my eyes
and listen to any other thoughts you want to share.
Speaker 2 (36:45):
When it comes to like the criminals system, you know,
they always say it's unjust, but as every here goes by,
people becoming more aware, so a lot of laws change
in and eventually, hopefully one day there will be no
more wrongfully convicted person behind bars. You know, I thank
(37:10):
people like you for just keep bringing awareness, keep doing
what you're doing. The work that you're doing is not
going unseen or unheard, because you got to understand a
lot of the dudes in there, they don't really have
a voice. So with yeah being the voice for them
out here, they trust me. They would really appreciate that.
(37:32):
Because when I used to be in jail, and I
used to be in prison and I heard oh, this
law is coming, this law is coming soon, that law
is coming soon, I'm like, ah, it was because the
people like you, like protests, people fight, people bring awareness.
So I just cannot do nothing else but show y'all
(37:56):
my gratitude like I thank y'all so much.
Speaker 1 (37:58):
Man, all of y'all, thank you for listening to Wrongful Conviction.
You can listen to this and all the Lava for
Good podcasts one week early and ad free by subscribing
to Lava for Good Plus on Apple Podcasts. I want
(38:20):
to thank our production team, Connor Hall and Kathleen Fink,
as well as my fellow executive producers Jeff Kempler, Kevin Wartis,
and Jeff Kleiber. The music in this production was supplied
by three time OSCAR nominated composer Jay Ralph. Be sure
to follow us across all social media platforms at Lava
for Good and at Wrongful Conviction. You can also follow
me on Instagram at It's Jason Flamm. Wrongful Conviction is
(38:41):
a production of Lava for Good Podcasts and association with
Signal Company Number One. We've worked hard to ensure that
all facts reported in this show are accurate.
Speaker 2 (38:49):
The views and opinions expressed by the individuals featured in
this show are their own and do not necessarily reflect
those of Lava for Good.
On February sixth, twenty eleven, a party in a queen's
New York basement turned violent, and when those involved were
forced out into the exit stairwell, two gunshots were fired
into the door, fatally striking twenty six year old Avalisa Morris.
The police were soon directed toward a couple Felicia Douglas
(00:25):
and O'Neill Mayers, whose argument allegedly ignited the fray. Even
though O'Neill claims to have left before the gunshots and
didn't match the initial descriptions of the likely shooter, he
was arrested and tried, along with his friend Nicholas Allen,
who had left the party hours before the shooting. This
(00:46):
is wrongful Conviction. You're listening to Wrongful Conviction. You can
listen to this and all the Lava for Good podcasts
one week early and ad free subscribing to Lava for
Good Plus on Apple Podcasts. Welcome back to Ronfuel Conviction,
(01:13):
where our guest is calling in from the country of
Jamaica to tell us about a case that happened near
Jamaica Queens and started with an absolutely senseless act of
violence which was then compounded by convicting at least one,
if not two innocent men, one of them being Nicholas Brucky. Allen, welcome,
Thank you, all right. So tell us about growing up
(01:34):
in Jamaica and coming to the US.
Speaker 2 (01:37):
I was born in Kingston, Jamaica. I got four sisters
and three brothers. Two of them was like babies, and
one of them was born while I was in the States,
so I didn't really actually grew up with those three.
I came to the stage when I was like twelve.
So I just remember where I used to live in Jamaica.
It was like a soccer field next.
Speaker 3 (01:56):
To my home. Soccer was just my love.
Speaker 2 (02:00):
If my friend's playing on the street bearfooted, I will
go out there and also play bearfooted.
Speaker 1 (02:06):
So where did the nickname Brockie come from?
Speaker 2 (02:09):
In Jamaican culture, we call dribble brooke when you cross
somebody that's basically you brooking everybody. Basically Brookie is somebody
that does just love to dribble and don't like the past.
Speaker 3 (02:24):
And it's funny because when I.
Speaker 2 (02:26):
Got to the States, my first team, Cambria Heights, it
was a lady that first called me Brookie.
Speaker 3 (02:32):
I never told her that was my nickname. In Jamaica.
I never told her that. She just watched me. She
was like, yo, you was a Brookie and.
Speaker 2 (02:38):
I'm like, oh, that's what they called me in Jamaica.
Speaker 3 (02:41):
That's my name.
Speaker 1 (02:42):
But it wasn't soccer that brought him to New York.
Speaker 2 (02:44):
At the age of eleven, I was diagnosed with you
and star a coma. It was a form of cancer.
This was like around two thousand. I started off getting
treatment in Jamaica, but my auntie came into the States
and on the teaching program. She went to the courts
with my dad and my mom did the legal guardianship.
Speaker 3 (03:05):
So the lawyer told.
Speaker 2 (03:06):
Her when you're in the States and you get your
green card, he's going to get his. When you become
a citizen, he will become citizen. So she had took
me into the States. I did chemoturpy. I had no hair,
so I used to wear a lot of door rags
a lot of time. When I used to play soccer,
it was like I was the sick on. Everybody was
just looking at me. But that never stopped me. I
(03:27):
play hard. I went to Automotive High School. My own
was a teacher at the school. But yo, they never
seen the playoff until I came. When I came, took
them the playoff the whole four years.
Speaker 3 (03:38):
That I was there. I graduated.
Speaker 2 (03:41):
Then from there I got in a soccer scholarship to
Globe College. Went for a year and a half and
that's when I got arrested.
Speaker 1 (03:50):
And he was arrested along with another young Jamaican man
named O'Neill Mayers.
Speaker 2 (03:55):
I met Mayors through guys from my soccer team. They
were quit mars at Walmart. When I first met him,
I never get any bad vibes. I see that he
always works to take care of his son. You know,
I'm on college and stuff, so I used to love parties,
so you know, me and Mirors sometimes will go to parties.
Speaker 1 (04:18):
And that's what was happening at the time of this
tragic shooting. O'Neill's supervisor at Walmart, Damian Skurvin, had planned
a party for his wife Nikki at their friend Mary
Johnson's apartment on February fifth, twenty eleven, even though there
was a competing party nearby at Nicholas's friend named Pouchi
Poochie's house. Both O'Neill and Nicholas were drawn to the
(04:38):
Skurvans party to see two girls who they had met
the night before, one of whom Britney Goodrich later testified.
Now this previous night, February fourth, they were up really late,
leading to a midday nap for O'Neil that nearly lasted
through both parties on February fifth. But Nicholas was close
with Poochie's boyfriend Gabby Francis, so he made sure he
(04:59):
was at Pooci's.
Speaker 2 (05:00):
So when I got there, I was pretty much helping
him decoration, helping, cooking the food, stuff like that. So
around twelve midnight, I pull up my friends Cafarri, Samuel,
Dwayne Right, Gabby Francis, and Dennis Cunningham, and I told him, oh, listen,
Damien is having a birthday party for his wife tonight.
Y'all want to go support, and they agreed. They call
(05:23):
a cab. I got there around twelve ish and I
left like early one. When we got there, I saw
Brittany dancing under the light. The only spot in the
basement had light was where the DJ booth was at,
So I went right up to Brittany. I asked her
how she's doing. I told her I'm not staying. My
people have a party, so I'm leaving. She put her
number with my phone and I never seen mirrors at
(05:46):
that party. Never Me and Mirrs was not together. It
was my four friends and we left in a cab
back to Pucci party. For the rest of the night,
we drink, dance, we took pictures. One of the girls
over there took a picture with me and around the
same time as.
Speaker 1 (06:01):
The incident, it was just about eight minutes after the
shooting when Nicholas took a picture with Vanessa Bunton on
a digital camera. Now remember this was twenty eleven when
folks were still transitioning from flip phones, iPods and cameras
to the all in one smartphone that's now ubiquitous. But anyway,
we'll get back to Vanessa Bunton and this picture in
a bit. So let's rewind to about three o'clock in
(06:23):
the morning.
Speaker 2 (06:24):
Around three on he called me saying, yo, you just
got up. He's gonna go to Damien wife's Porty Nikki
on his block because the party actually kept on his block.
So I said, oh yeah, I was there earlier.
Speaker 3 (06:36):
And I got Brittany number. That was it. Around a
little bit before five.
Speaker 2 (06:41):
He called me back again, saying the party got shoot up,
asked if I was still at Pucci I said yes,
and he said I'm coming right now. When he came,
he sat in the car and he told me the
girl that he was talking to the day before. He
was talking to her and his girlfriend came over slapped him,
and out of a reflex, he slapped her back and
(07:02):
she went outside crying and stuff. He also said he
noticed the commotions at the door. He said the DJ
got into it with somebody and he just pushed through
the commotions and left. While he got to the front
of the house, he said he heard gunshots and he
just ran home, jump in his car, called me and
came to me at Pouci's.
Speaker 1 (07:20):
To exit the basement, O'Neill left through the back door
to a covered stairwall that led to the backyard, where
his girlfriend Felicia Douglass and her friend Vanessa Edwards claimed
to have seen him, which he doesn't deny. What he
does deny is going back down the stairwell and shooting
at the door. Now. According to the initial police reports,
also known as DV five's, the guest of honor, Nicki
(07:41):
Scurvin the host Mary Johnson, as well as the victim
of Alisa Morris, pushed a group of three or four
young men out into the back stairwell and slammed the door,
and the group tried to force their way back in.
Speaker 2 (07:53):
I heard that she used her back to prevent the
guys from coming back and said and shot fired and
mis Kelly hit her in their head. When the cops
had just came Mary Johnson's she identified a tall, light
skin with braids in his.
Speaker 1 (08:07):
Thirties, which doesn't describe O'Neill or Nicholas.
Speaker 2 (08:12):
Also, NICKI Scurvin the morning off the crime. When the
cops came in our DD five, she never mentioned O'Neill.
Mayers never mentioned me at all.
Speaker 1 (08:19):
But both of those statements would change by the time
of the grand jury and trial, as would pretty much
everyone else's statements, including O'Neill's girlfriend Felicia Douglas and her
friend Vanessa Edwards. Now. In their first statements, they said
that they had seen O'Neill emerge from the coupvered stairwell,
which is undisputed, but was it before or after the
(08:40):
gunshots well? Either way, Felicia texted O'Neill after giving her statement.
Speaker 2 (08:46):
So we were still in the car, he got a
text from his girlfriend saying that such and such a
diet and you and your friend Brookie did it. So
he showed me the texts. I'm like, what the hell
is she talking about?
Speaker 3 (08:57):
You know?
Speaker 2 (08:58):
But I looked at Mayer's face. I could see like
a worried look. So he tried to call her. She
answered on the fifth call, and she was just crying.
He said, Yo, what's going on? Why you send me
that text? So she was like, they made me do it,
They made me do it. So he said, why would
you tell the police?
Speaker 3 (09:16):
I did nothing? Why do you tell the police? Go
tell the police. I didn't do nothing.
Speaker 2 (09:20):
We had found out later on that basically the friends
of the victim tell her, yo, listen, you and your
man came here and mess up my party, so you
better go tell the cops that he did that. That's
when she had gave the police on ill number.
Speaker 1 (09:33):
But with no views through the stairwells covering the basement
door or any meaningful ballistics evidence, no witnesses or experts
could claim to know who pulled the trigger, and without
the ever important timing aspect had O'Neil been seen before
or after the gunshots, and with no other names being
mentioned besides O'Neil, he became the target.
Speaker 3 (09:54):
So we were still in the car. He looked distressed.
Speaker 2 (09:58):
A few minutes later, a detective by the name of
Pearson called him saying that he's a person of interest
and they would like to speak with him. So he said,
all right, no doubt, I'm coming in right now. So
I stayed and I waited for him to come back,
and he never came back.
Speaker 1 (10:13):
O'Neill was arrested, and since no one could actually see
the shooting, they used the circumstances. Someone had to place
a gun in his hand in the stairwell at the
time of the crime. So by the grand jury, Vanessa
Edwards testified that when O'Neill first emerged from the stairwell,
he had a gun in his hand. Then the group
went back down the covered stairwell and shots were fired. However,
(10:37):
Felicia's story changed in a different way.
Speaker 2 (10:40):
The two statements that she gave to the cops. She
was saying that she saw Onneila ran up the steps.
The other statement she had said that she just said
this because she was mad, because Onlyla had slapped her.
She also made a statement to one's lawyer saying that
she was mad and was also forced by the victim
(11:02):
friends tell the cops that she saw on it ran
up the steps, and she also made a statement to
my attorney saying that she never even seen me that
whole night.
Speaker 1 (11:13):
And at this point, neither Vanessa Edwards, Nicki Scurvin, nor
Mary Johnson had mentioned Nicholas, only Felicia had done so
in that text that she now just disavowed. Vanessa Edwards
also maintained that she hadn't seen Nicholas since earlier in
the evening. But Nicholas becomes involved because during the month
(11:34):
following the shooting, O'Neil had let Nicholas his car.
Speaker 2 (11:37):
So a month later I noticed an unmarked car following me.
They passed me, came in front of me, made a
sound stop, forcing me to stop. Then they jumped up
and it was just police everywhere, guns everywhere.
Speaker 3 (11:52):
Move Move, motherfuckers. I could shoot you. Move. So I'm like,
I'm not moving. I'm not moving.
Speaker 2 (11:56):
They dragged me out of car, put my face on
the ground with the knee in my face. Detective Pearson
came in, got me and brought me to one thirteen.
Speaker 1 (12:04):
Percent, and this detective Timothy Pearson, recently served as a
top aid to New York City Mayor Eric Adams. Apparently
they go way back, and he has faced or is
currently facing allegations ranging from corruption, pay the play schemes,
as well as rape and other sexual misconduct. But there's
no known history of wrongful convictions, that is until now.
Speaker 2 (12:26):
So when I got to one thirteen percint, they asked me,
do you know why I'm here? I'm like, maybe because
I was driving my friend's car and he was charged
for murder. They said yes, but there is more. The
car was seen leaving the scene that waitness saw me
and O'Neill together that night, So I said, no, that
can't be true. So he said, O'Neill said I was
with him that.
Speaker 1 (12:45):
Night, which yes, they were together, but only after the
shooting when they met up at Pucci's house. Now, always
remember it is legal for the police to lie or mislead.
I'm hoping that'll change someday, but that's the way it is.
And the reality here was that Nicholas and O'Neill had
been calling each other before they actually met up.
Speaker 3 (13:07):
So I'm like, I have.
Speaker 2 (13:08):
Proof in my phone that we was actually calling each other.
If you check my call log, you could see recent
call and only called me at three, and he called
me also at five. It was like a tow way phone.
It was a Walmart phone. So the only thing that
phone could prove is the recent call. So I don't
know if they did check or not, but my phone
(13:28):
end up disappearing, right. I told my lawyer about the phone,
and they told my lawyer in evidence.
Speaker 3 (13:35):
Right days past, my lawyer tried.
Speaker 2 (13:37):
To get the phone back again and they said the
phone disappeared. The phone can be found.
Speaker 1 (13:43):
I mean, why let perfectly good exculpatory evidence get in
the way of what appears to be manufactured evidence. This
came in the form of another alleged partygoer, the upstairs neighbor,
a guy named Richard Bennett. For the first time, he
claimed to have seen the alleged sailants being pushed out
of the basement back door. Never mind that from where
(14:04):
he said he was standing, he couldn't have seen that door.
Then he said he ran upstairs to his apartment. This
is a two family home, so he had to go
out Mary Johnson's front door outside to access his own
front door, and he claimed that this is when he
saw three alleged assailants. And now he was at the
precinct of view a lineup featuring Nicholas.
Speaker 2 (14:27):
He was seeing a Facebook photo off me minutes before
the lineup. This same guy testified at a grandjury that
I have a tattoo on the right side of my neck.
This same guy said that when me and Oni got
to the front of the house, he said a point
a gun in his face. He said, I said to him,
what's you're looking at, motherfucker? And while he was looking
(14:48):
at me, he saw a tattoo on my neck, with words,
I don't have no tattoo, never have a tattoo on me.
Speaker 1 (14:54):
Ever, nevertheless, now Panessa Edwards and Richard Bennett both placed
O'Neill and the at the scene with guns in their hands.
Speaker 2 (15:02):
They charged us with acting in concert.
Speaker 3 (15:05):
I was arraigned.
Speaker 2 (15:06):
I had a bunch of people in court that was
there with me at Pucci house. It looked like the
judge were considering to give me a bill until the
district attorney jumped up and said, judge, the victim family
scared for their life, and the judge was like, no bill,
you know, so I was sent to rakas Allen. It
was a new experience for me, so I had to
(15:28):
adapt fast.
Speaker 3 (15:30):
I was young. I was like in the jungle.
Speaker 2 (15:32):
I was like around some wild kids that's probably been
to jail more than my fingers, you know.
Speaker 1 (15:53):
Nicholas spent three long, miserable years in pre trial detention
on the Notori Complex, not as Riker's Island, which is
just fucking wild. I mean, from March twenty eleven to
November twenty fourteen, not convicted of a freaking thing. This
was around the same time that Khalif Browder, by the
(16:15):
Way Rest in Peace was there for three years pre
trial as well. We're going to link to the Kaliff
Browder documentary in the episode description. Well, luckily Nicholas was
able to survive this ordeal, unlike Khalif. But meanwhile, on
the outside, O'Neil and Nicholas's attorneys had three years to
prepare for cross examinations, and despite Nicholas's phone just magically disappearing,
(16:38):
he still had his alibi, witnesses and the picture with
Vanessa Punton, placing him a fifteen minute drive away from
Mary Johnson's just about eight minutes after the shooting. The
only issue was that in the digital cameras settings AM
had been flipped with PM.
Speaker 2 (16:54):
Well, my lawyer was telling me that even though the
time stamp it's saying PM instead of M. When it's
time for trial, he would get Vanessa to come and
testify for.
Speaker 1 (17:04):
The grand jury. Only the photo was entered into evidence.
In addition, his friend Gabby Francis testified that he was
with Nicholas all night, including when they had gone to
the Scurvins party and back to Poocies, but Britney Goodrich,
the girl that had traded phone numbers with him, She
claimed that Nicholas had returned later on in the morning.
Speaker 2 (17:22):
There was a weakness go by the name of Larissa White.
She also wrote a statement the morning of the crime.
She also testified in a grand jury, and her testimony
was that when the shot rang out, she was upstairs
with Britney Goodrich looking for their coats to leave. So
she contradicts Brittany because Brittany said she was down in
(17:43):
the basement when the shots rang out and that's the
last time she saw me.
Speaker 1 (17:47):
Vanessa Edwards also testified that the last time she saw
Nicholas was earlier in the night, which also impeached Brittany,
as well as Nicki Skurvin and Mary Johnson's new statements,
which now aligned with the state's narrative.
Speaker 3 (18:00):
D five statement.
Speaker 2 (18:01):
As Mary Johnson, she gave to the cops she identified
a tall, light skin with braids in his thirties. That
was just disregarded. So my lawyer let her know that
he's not tall, he's not light skin, and you know
what I'm saying.
Speaker 3 (18:16):
So her thing was that it was me. I was there.
Speaker 2 (18:19):
Also, Nicki Scurvin, minutes after the situation, she never mentioned
ONeill Mayors. She never mentioned me at all. It was
at the Grand Jewelry when she mentioned O'Neill and me.
Then in the first trial, Mary Johnson she said, my
hair was basically braided up with rubber bands at the tip,
wearing a jeans jacket with a gray shirt. That's was
not my appearance that night. The picture that I took
(18:42):
showed a different appearance. Everybody put me into a different clothing, earstyle.
Everybody description was just off, but hers was funny and ridiculous.
Speaker 1 (18:52):
So despite photographic evidence of the contrary, Mary Johnson and
Nicki Scurvin supported the state's trial narrative, which was that
after O'Neill and Felicia traded slaps, that O'Neill, Nicholas, and
two others were forced to leave the party by the victim,
as well as Mary Johnson and Nicki Scurvin.
Speaker 3 (19:11):
Nicki's Curvin.
Speaker 2 (19:12):
She testified that she went to you gotta go because
you and your girl messed up my party.
Speaker 3 (19:17):
And she said.
Speaker 2 (19:18):
One'll tell her leave me alone. And while she grabbed him,
she said, he like swring her hands off him. And
as he did that, she said she saw something that
appears to be a gun in his waist. When she
saw the gun, she said, ONeill said, yo, leave me alone.
You want to mess with badman. Don't mess with badman.
That's the Jamaican term saying that, don't mess with the gangster.
Speaker 3 (19:39):
So she said.
Speaker 2 (19:40):
Other people came in shove shove him out. So they
asked her what I was doing. She said, I was
just there. She said, she got us out, closed the door.
As we're trying to bang the door to come back in,
the door cracked open and she saw my face, so
she put.
Speaker 3 (19:55):
Me on the scene.
Speaker 1 (19:56):
Then Vanessa Edwards stuck with her initial statement about O'Neil
emerging from the stairwell, but this time she added a
gun and more.
Speaker 2 (20:04):
She testified that she saw one ran up the steps
with a gun in his hand with about four guys,
and the four guys ran back down the steps. She
heard the shots, and then the guys walked back up
and ran down the driveway. So Maloya asked her, did
she ever saw my face before? She said yes, she
saw me that night talking to Brittany. Did you see
(20:27):
him run up the steps with those group of guys?
Speaker 3 (20:29):
She said no.
Speaker 2 (20:30):
Last time she saw me was the time that I
was talking to Brittany, and she never saw me back that.
Speaker 1 (20:34):
Night, which contradicts Mary Johnson and Nikki Scurvin, who claimed
to have seen Nicholas's face when Ava Lisa Morris slammed
the door shut on the four men before two gun
shots were fired through the door.
Speaker 2 (20:46):
There was a hole that's higher and there's another lower hole.
The ballistic detective he was trying to say, I fired
the lower hole and because one was taller, he fired
the higher hole. So like this is just your speculations
or this is a fact. He said, no, it's just
(21:06):
in speculating. So Maloya ax him.
Speaker 3 (21:09):
Was it one gun? Was it two gun?
Speaker 2 (21:11):
Did they fire one gun and gave it to the
other one and the other one fired?
Speaker 3 (21:14):
What was it?
Speaker 2 (21:15):
So he couldn't answer, So it was just based off
of his speculations.
Speaker 1 (21:19):
And what appears to be wishful thinking to nab two
gunmen for the price of one, when in actuality, what
they had were two forty five caliber shell cases believed
to have been fired from a semi automatic weapon, which
simply could have been fired from different angles. But they
continued right along with the two shooter theory, putting Richard
Bennett on the stand, and he proceeded to impeach himself twice,
(21:43):
first claiming that he was at the front side of
the basement about to head up the stairs when he'd
seen o, Neil and Nicholas being forced out the back door,
but there was a structure, a bathroom that had been
built between those two points and it was blocking his
view of the back door. And then came self sabotage
number two, when he claimed to have gone upstairs and
out the front door.
Speaker 2 (22:03):
So he said, while he was outside opening the door,
he said he saw me and Onneil. He said, I
said to him, what's you looking at motherfucker pointing the
gun in his face. And he was asked, did you say, mister,
and you saw a tattoo on his neck?
Speaker 3 (22:16):
Yes, he got a tattoo on his neck.
Speaker 2 (22:18):
So when I took the stand, my lawyer asked me
to show my neck, and I don't have no tattoo,
never have a tattoo on me ever, But Bennett was
certain that he saw a tattoo and it was in words.
Speaker 1 (22:30):
Then Gabby Francis teestified that Nicholas had been with him
all night and therefore unavailable for this crime. The picture
with Vanessa Bunden was also presented, which not only impeached
all the hair and clothing descriptions, but also corroborated his alibi,
placing him a fifteen minute drive away right about eight
minutes after the shooting. And instead of attacking the incorrect
(22:52):
AMPM setting up the timestamp, the district attorney, Denise Tarini,
took a different tact.
Speaker 2 (22:58):
She was trying to say that I did the crime
and a rush to Puccios. So her argument was like, yes, judge,
he knew what he was doing. He did that, and
then he rushed over there and say, let me take
a picture to show that I was here.
Speaker 1 (23:12):
So let's recap. Vanessa Edwards contradicted Scurvin, Johnson and Bennett,
while Bennett proceeded to impeach himself even more. And then
there was the worthless ballistics speculation, followed by Ada Denise
Terini's own worthless speculation about the photo. But still some
(23:34):
jurors they just wanted to believe in their guilt.
Speaker 2 (23:37):
We went for deliberation and we was in the bullpen
and it was just a wall separating us from the
deliberation room, so we could actually hear the juries like
raising their voice cursing like I.
Speaker 3 (23:52):
Don't give a fuck.
Speaker 2 (23:53):
He did not do it, he caunnot see, he cannot
see through the bathroom.
Speaker 3 (23:58):
I don't give a fuck.
Speaker 2 (23:59):
So me and Oni like we got elated because we
were like damn people in there fighting for us. The
verdict came back, they said, judge, we can't decide, and
it was a hang jury. The child would have to
go over again.
Speaker 3 (24:13):
And it was like mixed.
Speaker 2 (24:15):
Feeling because like I was happy and I was said
because I was sent back to rack as Allen, and
also I felt like all right, no, we know what
was said.
Speaker 3 (24:25):
So next time it would be better.
Speaker 1 (24:27):
But the district attorney also observed what worked and what
clearly did not. So eight months later, at the second trial,
Vanessa Edwards needed to not contradict half the state's witnesses,
most of whom had previously testified about how dark it
had been in the basement, thereby making it difficult to see,
so that part of the narrative needed to change. And
(24:50):
then Richard Bennett needed to try to somehow deflect from
his previous self sabotage and focus solely on identifying Nicholas.
Speaker 2 (25:00):
My second trial started and Richard Bennon he was the
first witness call to the stand, right, so eight months
later he trying to say that, you don't remember saying
no tattoo.
Speaker 3 (25:11):
You don't remember saying that.
Speaker 2 (25:13):
So you know, we did read backs from the first
trial and grand jury acting him, do you remember saying, yeah,
witness point of gun in my face had a tattoo
on his right side of his neck. And then that's
when he was like, yeah, I remember saying that. But
he came back in the second trial trying to say,
you don't remember saying it. District attorney disregard that old tattoo.
She said, first of all, Richard Bennon was not identifying
(25:36):
a tattoo. He was identifying my face. And she was like,
so what what if he thought he saw a tattoo.
So she disregarded that whole thing, and she asked him
about the lighting.
Speaker 3 (25:48):
He said it was dark. It was dark.
Speaker 2 (25:50):
It was dark, and she become frustrated. Now you know,
in the first trial that was like a big thing
for my side, were trying to prove, like, yo, is
a party, it's pretty much dark.
Speaker 3 (26:03):
Like, yeah, the DJ have light.
Speaker 2 (26:05):
In the second trial, the district attorney.
Speaker 3 (26:07):
She lit up the whole place. It was so bright.
Speaker 2 (26:11):
She was like Christmas lights was in the basement. Light
was shining from outside coming into the basement.
Speaker 3 (26:16):
She was lit up the whole place.
Speaker 2 (26:18):
That's why the ballistic detective came back and started testifying
about lights. So Monmoy was like, Yo, you supposed to
be testifying about ballistic evidence. Why are you coming here
testifying about lights? You never said that in your first child.
Why are you coming here talking about the light.
Speaker 1 (26:33):
So it appears that testifying about the lights was a
better use of this expert than his speculations. In addition,
Mary Johnson and Nicki Scurvin steered away from the erroneous
hair and clothing descriptions and focused instead on making the
IDs and placing a gun on O'Neill.
Speaker 2 (26:50):
In the second trial, Nickiy Scurvy she was more sturdy.
Her husband actually came also in the second trial and
testify on RBA testify and said she was drunk. He
said one time he was trying to talk to her,
she couldn't even recognize him.
Speaker 3 (27:05):
She was up in his face. So he testified that
she was actually drunk.
Speaker 1 (27:10):
But that impeachment mattered a little less when Vanessa Edwards
took the stand to place o'neel at the scene with
a gun and was careful not to clear Nicholas again,
thereby impeaching the other state's witnesses.
Speaker 2 (27:22):
My lawyer asked her the same thing again. Was I
in the group? She said she don't know, because she
wasn't looking at face and she was just looking at
the gun that Meares had in his hand. You could
tell that she was coached by the district attorney. My
lawyer picked that up throughout the whole trial because they
was like button heads.
Speaker 3 (27:40):
They was literally arguing.
Speaker 2 (27:42):
I remember incident my girlfriend came in and told me, oh,
mister Mitchell just cursed out mister Reno. He told her
that you're trying to set up my client. You're trying
to send my client to jail, not over my dead body.
And it was a big argument in the elevator. It
was just so crazy because you sit down in your
first child here thing, and then when it comes to
the second child, the whole testimony just changed and flips.
Speaker 1 (28:05):
But there were at least two witnesses in addition to
Gabby Francis that could have helped the defense. One was
the girl from the picture, Vanessa Bunten, the second child.
Speaker 2 (28:14):
She said she was coming to testify. She was supposed
to go to work and sign out and come in court.
So we was in court waiting for her to come,
so my lawyer called her. She told my lawyer that
she's sorry, she cannot come anymore because when she got
to work, she had a surprise promotional party for her,
so she never came in testify.
Speaker 1 (28:36):
Another defense witness could have been Felicia Douglas, because not
only had she admitted to making the statement out of
anger at O'Neill and feeling pressure from the victim's friends,
but also she had denied seeing Nicholas at the time
of the shooting, and she was standing right next to
Vanessa Edwards.
Speaker 2 (28:52):
She came to the court ready to testify, but only
lawyer pulled back. He said, listen, we're not going to
put her on this because with the four statement that
she made, the district attorney will eat her up. So
he decided not to put her on the stand.
Speaker 1 (29:08):
And let's face it, separate trials had a singularly focused
strategy probably would have made a difference for Nicholas, but
unfortunately he was deprived of that. And then the district
attorney had one more tactic.
Speaker 3 (29:22):
She put the mom on.
Speaker 2 (29:23):
The stand, and the mom testified above for half an hour,
and she cried the whole alf an hour. You know
what I mean, I cried, I'm sitting over there, she cried,
I can't remember that.
Speaker 3 (29:36):
This deliberation, this.
Speaker 2 (29:38):
One took three days, not like the first one that
took almost two weeks. This one took three days.
Speaker 3 (29:45):
And the verdict came in. They started O'Neill.
Speaker 2 (29:48):
First, murder her in the second degree not guilty, so I.
Speaker 3 (29:52):
Was like, oh whooa.
Speaker 2 (29:54):
But then manslaughter guilty, criminal position of a weapon guilty,
recklessly guilty, so now.
Speaker 3 (30:01):
It was my term. They read a murder not guilty,
so no o, so they read out manslaughter.
Speaker 2 (30:09):
I was guilty, criminal position guilty, reckless endigierment guilty.
Speaker 3 (30:14):
So we got the same charges. We had to go
back like.
Speaker 2 (30:18):
Three months for sentence, and I gave my condolences to
the family. I told the mom, listen, your daughter blood
is not on my hand. I don't know what happened,
but I give you my deepest condolence. O'Neill did the
same thing. I asked the judge for sympathy, but it
(30:40):
was gotten. The mac sentence and all charges five to
fifteen on the Manto fifteen flat for the criminal position
of a weapon and three to seven on the reckless engagement.
The fifteen flat overrides the five to fifteen. If it
wasn't the fifteen flat, I think would have been home
long time ago. But because fifteen flat, we had to
(31:01):
do the whole fifteen years. When I got to five points,
(31:23):
he was a double bunk jail, so I was like,
oh my gosh, I gotta share this small space with someone.
But the guy that I was bunk with, he was
pretty cool.
Speaker 3 (31:37):
You know, so we become close. Then he left.
Speaker 2 (31:41):
Then no, I was worrying again and be like, oh
my god, I hope I don't get a nasty bunky,
you know, But I got somebody pretty decent. He was
like older. He's also good in the law. His name
is Paul Thompson. Actually he's also innocent in his case.
Somebody had shot him and the person that shot him
(32:02):
died later, so they're trying to say he was the
one that did it. So they paid a crackhead, put
him up in the hotel, make him live in luxury
to testify against him that he saw him that day
that shoot the guy that shot him.
Speaker 3 (32:15):
So he's good with the laws. He's still fighting right now.
Speaker 1 (32:19):
Paul Thompson, all right, we'll try to make contact somehow.
Speaker 2 (32:22):
He got twenty five to life and I got fifteen years.
I saw I could never complain. I'm gonna go back out.
Speaker 3 (32:29):
He might not.
Speaker 1 (32:30):
And what's wild about Nicholas's appeal process was that since
three years went by pre trial, a lot of the
information that we talked about today was discovered and used
by the defense, so new evidence couldn't get him the
relief that he needed and deserved. At least not yet. Now.
The issues that were raised on direct appeal and in
(32:51):
his habeas related to insufficiency of evidence, as well as
potentially prejudicial comments and conduct by the prosecution. Unfortunately, the
time that was denied, it was already twenty twenty two,
eleven long years into a maximum sentence of fifteen years.
Speaker 2 (33:08):
Because you know, when you get fifteen years, you have
good time, so you don't actually do the whole fifteen years.
Speaker 3 (33:15):
You know.
Speaker 2 (33:15):
I wasn't giving no trouble inside, so I still had
my good time, you know, So I actually did twelve
years and ten months. My release date was January seventh,
twenty twenty four, right before I came home. You know,
they have a saint say in the streets talk, you know,
(33:35):
so I waited the years to see if someone my
anti prayed like, oh, the real person was going to
come forward one day, and right before I came home,
I called my cousin one day and she told me
that she heard who did it.
Speaker 1 (33:53):
He knows the alternative suspect's name, but that would still
need to be verified. And we're not going to name
names here if it's not confirmed, but that could be
a very promising starting point for an interested attorney who
hopefully is listening right now, who might want to take
up the cause of clearing Nicholas's name once and for all.
It also seems that there's an ineffective council claim here
(34:16):
for not having severed the trials.
Speaker 2 (34:19):
When I did my appeal, that was a big thing.
My lawyer, Alan Feleck, he was saying, listen, you could
have easily walk away from this if the child was separated.
But at the time my lawyer it felt like it
was best for him to team up, so you have
two lawyers against one district attorney. But he was wrong
because every other lawyer looked at my case they said, yeah,
(34:42):
y'all should have been separated.
Speaker 1 (34:43):
So we'll be linking the contact information for Nicholas Brucky
Allen in the episode description for any interested attorney or
anyone who has it pertinent information, including the actual shooter
or one of the men in the stairwell morning. But
back to his release. Since his immigration status was impacted
(35:05):
by this roundful conviction, he was sent to immigration detention.
Speaker 2 (35:10):
So I was in the immigration facility. I was deciding
to fight the case, you know, But then I'm like,
why would I stay any longer in prison, when I
could just be free and just go back to Jamaica.
I just want to live my life now. Thank God
for my freedom, and that's it. But always in the
(35:32):
back of my head saying that one day I want
to clear my name, you know. And when I got
to Jamaica walked out, that's when I firstly first experience freedom.
On the twenty fifth January in twenty twenty four, my
family here head keep a big party for me, like
a welcome home party meals.
Speaker 3 (35:53):
When I came home that I was eating, it was
like just delicious. It was. It was like a breath
of fresh air. You know.
Speaker 2 (36:00):
It was like the actra real, authentic Jamaican taste.
Speaker 3 (36:05):
You know.
Speaker 1 (36:06):
Since Nicholas Bucky Allen has been home, he's written a
book called The State of New York Versus Nicholas Allen.
We're going to link to that as well. I'm going
to order a copy myself. But Brucky has also connected
with an old friend who has been visiting him in
Jamaica and they're expecting a baby really soon. So we
wish them all the best. And with that, we're going
(36:26):
to go to closing arguments, where first of all, I
thank you for sharing this incredible true story. Closing arguments,
of course, is a part of the show that I
really look forward to, where I'm going to turn off
my microphone, leave my headphones on, just close my eyes
and listen to any other thoughts you want to share.
Speaker 2 (36:45):
When it comes to like the criminals system, you know,
they always say it's unjust, but as every here goes by,
people becoming more aware, so a lot of laws change
in and eventually, hopefully one day there will be no
more wrongfully convicted person behind bars. You know, I thank
(37:10):
people like you for just keep bringing awareness, keep doing
what you're doing. The work that you're doing is not
going unseen or unheard, because you got to understand a
lot of the dudes in there, they don't really have
a voice. So with yeah being the voice for them
out here, they trust me. They would really appreciate that.
(37:32):
Because when I used to be in jail, and I
used to be in prison and I heard oh, this
law is coming, this law is coming soon, that law
is coming soon, I'm like, ah, it was because the
people like you, like protests, people fight, people bring awareness.
So I just cannot do nothing else but show y'all
(37:56):
my gratitude like I thank y'all so much.
Speaker 1 (37:58):
Man, all of y'all, thank you for listening to Wrongful Conviction.
You can listen to this and all the Lava for
Good podcasts one week early and ad free by subscribing
to Lava for Good Plus on Apple Podcasts. I want
(38:20):
to thank our production team, Connor Hall and Kathleen Fink,
as well as my fellow executive producers Jeff Kempler, Kevin Wartis,
and Jeff Kleiber. The music in this production was supplied
by three time OSCAR nominated composer Jay Ralph. Be sure
to follow us across all social media platforms at Lava
for Good and at Wrongful Conviction. You can also follow
me on Instagram at It's Jason Flamm. Wrongful Conviction is
(38:41):
a production of Lava for Good Podcasts and association with
Signal Company Number One. We've worked hard to ensure that
all facts reported in this show are accurate.
Speaker 2 (38:49):
The views and opinions expressed by the individuals featured in
this show are their own and do not necessarily reflect
those of Lava for Good.
Hosts And Creators
Lauren Bright Pacheco
Maggie Freleng
Jason Flom
Popular Podcasts
On Purpose with Jay Shetty
I’m Jay Shetty host of On Purpose the worlds #1 Mental Health podcast and I’m so grateful you found us. I started this podcast 5 years ago to invite you into conversations and workshops that are designed to help make you happier, healthier and more healed. I believe that when you (yes you) feel seen, heard and understood you’re able to deal with relationship struggles, work challenges and life’s ups and downs with more ease and grace. I interview experts, celebrities, thought leaders and athletes so that we can grow our mindset, build better habits and uncover a side of them we’ve never seen before. New episodes every Monday and Friday. Your support means the world to me and I don’t take it for granted — click the follow button and leave a review to help us spread the love with On Purpose. I can’t wait for you to listen to your first or 500th episode!
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.
The Joe Rogan Experience
The official podcast of comedian Joe Rogan.