All Episodes

March 3, 2023 19 mins

Last month marked the one-year anniversary of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, which has had a devastating impact on Ukraine's economy, people and landmarks. In this episode, we consider the nuanced role that crypto has played so far in the conflict. 

Plus, a review of what's happening with Bitcoin miner Marathon Digital: The company was supposed to report earnings this week, but instead announced it’s restating financials from previous quarters. We’ll explain what, if anything, accounting and the price of Bitcoin have to do with prospects for the sector. 

The show also has the latest on an FTX lieutenant who recently pleaded guilty to various crimes in a New York court. 

 Bloomberg senior editor Dave Liedtka and reporter Emily Nicolle join this episode to discuss.

Subscribe to the Bloomberg Crypto Newsletter at https://bloom.bg/cryptonewsletter 

This podcast is produced by the Bloomberg Crypto Podcast team: Supervising producer: Vicki Vergolina, Senior Producer: Janet Babin, Producers: Sharon Beriro and Muhammad Farouk, Associate Producers: Mo Andam and Ty Butler. Sound Design/Engineer:  Desta Wondirad.

 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Mark as Played
Transcript

Episode Transcript

Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:03):
I'm Stacy mrie Ishmael, Managing editor of Crypto for Bloomberg News,
and this is Bloomberg Crypto, a daily Bloomberg I Hood podcast.
It's Friday, March third. It's Friday, which, as always means

(00:26):
it's time for another episode of This Week in Crypto.
Happy as always, to be joined by Bloomberg Senior editor
Dave Litka and by Emmeline Nicole. Dave is based with
me here in New York and Emily is in London.
On this episode, we're going to talk a little bit
about a pretty somber anniversary, the one year anniversary of
Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and what, in addition to all

(00:47):
of the devastation that that has meant for Ukraine's economy,
people and landmarks, has to do with crypto. We'll talk
about Nashad Singh, an FTX lieutenant who pleaded guilty to
various crimes in court in New York this week, and
we'll talk a little bit about what's happening with Marathon,
a bitcoin miner, and what if anything, accounting and the
rising price of bitcoin have to do with the prospects

(01:10):
for the sector. Emily, Dave, welcome back. To the podcast.
Great to be here. Before we go into what's been
happening in Ukraine's Emily's point, Dave, I want to ask
you about what has become one of our favorite topics
on this podcast, which is the state of bitcoin mining. Yes,

(01:31):
which varies from like very precarious to precarious. I think
very precarious right now. This week we had a bit
of news. Marathon Digital, one of the biggest miners out there,
was supposed to report earnings this week and at the
last minute they said, we're not. We have to restate
a bunch of our financials from prior quarters. Now that

(01:55):
seems unusual and or bad, it could be on it.
So it's the whole bitcoin industry, including the better known
micro Strategy, have had an issue with how gains and
losses are accounted for on their financials, and basically, the
way the rules are set up, they can't account for

(02:19):
any gains, but they have to write down losses their holdings.
So it brings a lot of volatility to their numbers.
And there are proposals out there to make this a
little more workable, but until then it kind of distorts
the numbers a bit in terms of gains and losses

(02:39):
that they have to report. But in the case of Marathon,
it's how they recognized these adjustments and also revenue in
regard to a mining pool. Even just as interesting in
one aspect of this market is the stocks have taken
off this year. They've been some of the best performers
out there, which has helped the distressed ones to buy

(03:00):
or time for themselves, right because they're kind of the
perception is that they're going to be able to get
out of this particular crypto winter and survive that. And
they have huge obligations they the lenders. For a while
there they were giving back machines and if nobody wants
to buy or mine or buy bitcoin, why do you

(03:20):
want to mind it? But in this case they're able
to now have negotiating point with the equity steaks. So
if we can give you a steak when the stocks rising,
then you feel a little better about it. And so
Dave to that point, you know you've had this appreciation
in the share price. How much of that has to
do with the fact that crypto prices themselves have been
rallying a lot, and that does make there is the

(03:44):
inner relationship there where if the price of bitcoin is
going up, you're going to feel better about a minor.
But some people have also characterized these companies as narrative
stocks on it. So if you're selling that narrative of
that bitcoin is back, then you're gonna buy them. But
in the end, these guys have to pay their bills

(04:05):
in their public companies, and it's a little more complicated
than just riding the highs and lows of bitcoin. At
this point, I just want to share one of my
favorite random facts about bitcoin miners, which is that there's
a company called taro Wolf which has four reasons that
would never entirely clear to me. Two celebrities among its baccas,
and they are Gwyneth Paltrow and Mindy Kaling. That is

(04:26):
your random fact of the crypto day. Anybody know who's
if Gwyneth Paltrow and Minnie Healing have buyos, remorse about
taro Wolf, Like crypto at Bloomberg dot net's very interested
in in that follow up. Now, we just talked about
two celebrities, But for a lot of people who are
paying close attention to crypto, and even people who aren't
paying that close attention to crypto, there are a few

(04:48):
more names that now come to the four when we
talk about the events of twenty twenty two, And obviously
Sam Bankman, Freed and FTX were among the biggest. But
certainly one of the developments we've been paying close attention
to is what's been happening to the other members of
the so called FTX inner circle. And one of the
folks on that list is Nishad Singh. He was the

(05:11):
director of engineering at FTX. He was one of the
folks who lived in the famous, infamous, depending on your perspective,
Bahamas compound. And what happened this week is that he
in a New York court, agreed to plead guilty to
various allegations against him. And that's a criminal court. And

(05:32):
at the same time he was hit by, you know,
effectively like lawsuits from the Securities and Exchange Commission and
the sec Emily. What are the numbers that we're talking
about here when it relates to Nishad Singh. So to
put this into perspective, you've got like FTX owing its
customers roughly eight billion dollars in total, and we're not

(05:52):
too sure you know how much SPF Funny made away with,
but his bail, for example, was two hundred and fifty
million dollars. That's what that was set up. Nis Sings
bail is said at one one thousandth of that amount,
closer to you know, the tens of thousands rather than
the millions of dollars. And the lawsuits against him accused
saying of taking about six million dollars for personal use

(06:17):
from FTX, and that's to pay for things like houses,
to do things like donate to charity, and his top
donations to charity actually went to a charity run by
Sam Backmanfried's mum. And also there was a little bit
of insight into exactly where he was spending some of
the money that was coming from FTX as well. For example,
he donated about nine point three million dollars to Democratic

(06:41):
candidates and committees since twenty twenty eight million of that
was just in the last election cycle. And so you know,
he knew about these things going on at Alameda and
FTX for months. Supposedly, that's what he said in his
own statements. He says he was aware of everything that
was happening and just turned a blind eye, willfully misstated
revenue figures to auditors and all because that was the

(07:03):
only way they could see FTX continuing to stay afloat.
And to your point about the willfulness statement, he also
said he apologized right. He quote said, I'm unbelievably sorry
for my rule in this and the harm it caused,
and giving some specifics and then you know, saying I
knew my conduct was wrong, which is of course a

(07:27):
clear you know, he's admissing guilty, he's pleading guilty. Sam
bankmun Freed has denied all of the charges and the
accusations against him and has not pleaded guilty and is
currently out on bail. This marks the third member of
the FTX SPF in a circle to plead guilty in
an apparent cooperation agreement with prosecutors, the first two being

(07:48):
Caroline Ellison, who was first the co CEO and then
the CEO of Alimta Trading, and Gary Wang, who was,
in addition to being a childhood friend of Sam bankmun Freed,
was the chief technology officer at FTX. Yeah, it's pretty
obvious that the reason why US authorities are agreeing to
do these plea deals with the likes of Nischad Singh

(08:10):
and Gary Wang and Kyla Allison. It's because not only
did FTX not really keep track of anything, so you
really do only have the words of people to go
on when trying to figure out what happened here. There's
no paper trail to look at. With SPF pleading not
guilty and denying everything that's been thrown against him, it's

(08:30):
going to take a very strong case to be able
to carry out some of the lawsuits that have been
put against Sam and put against the criminal charges that
he's facing, and so basically getting all of his friends
and closest employees to flip on him is the strongest
tool in the SEC's wheelhouse at the minute. After Russia

(08:51):
invaded Ukraine, you had two conversations about crypto happening simultaneously.
This idea that the philanthropic community in crypto could be
rallied to donate funds not just too ordinary people in Ukraine,
but also to the government, and the fear from various

(09:11):
regulators and central banks that crypto could be used as
a means for Russians who were facing sanctions to avoid
those sanctions. At the same time, so it's now twelve
months on, we can do a little bit of a
retrospective about how the year went. You know, how successful
were crypto exchanges that limiting the access of sanctioned Russian
individuals to trade on their exchanges. How successful were the

(09:35):
attempts to help support the effort in Ukraine by crypto
companies wanting to be on the other side of the equation,
And some of the data that's comeback hasn't necessarily been
all that positive for the overall impact. But at the
same time, efforts to stop Russian exchanges from being able
to trade with international exchanges, to stop Russian individuals from

(09:58):
being able to trade on international exchange, those weren't as successful.
There was some data coming out at the end of
February from the US based research group TRM Labs which
said that Russian based exchange Grand Texts more than doubled
its volumes between February twenty twenty two and February twenty
twenty three. And that's with it being sanctioned by the
US in April, so, you know, ten out of the

(10:20):
twelve months it was a sanctioned entity, and yet it's
still more than doubled its volumes. While other crypto exchanges,
as we know, have based a pretty dour environment over
the last year. A lot of demand has fallen off
a cliff, so it's a pretty different picture. And overall
as well, the amount of crypto that was going towards
elicit activity in the last year, according to chain Analysis,
another analytics company, rose for the first time since twenty nineteen,

(10:44):
so it's more than doubled in the last year to
zero point two four percent. Obviously, that's still a tiny
percentage if we think about the entire crypto market, but
the fact that it's going up shows that Russia definitely
still had access to what it needed to access in
crypto when being cut off from the rest of the
international payment system. And there was even another report. Crypto

(11:06):
companies love reports, but there was another report that also
came out in February from an analytics room called Inca Digital,
alleging that non Russian exchanges allowed people who had debit
cards issued by sanctioned Russian banks to still participate in
transactions on those exchanges. Yeah, it's worth noting that some

(11:27):
of those exchanges, like Quobe, like Coucoin, like Finance, most
of them have denied those reports. If not, they didn't respond,
but most of them said, you know, this isn't true.
We don't accept users from Russia. We don't accept users
with bank cards from those sanctioned banks. That reports are reports,
and they usually based on data, And if it is
true that these things have been going on, then it

(11:49):
obviously provides more insight to just how much it is
really a difficult job for regulators to be able to
see what's going on at crypto exchanges. That they are
already concerns even before the war, that crypto exchanges can
often be like a black box the regulators just don't
get to see into. And so if this is still
going on even with most of the world is shrink
sanctions against Russia, it definitely proves their point. We'll be

(12:12):
right back with more from Bloomberg's Dave Litka and Emmeline Nicole. Dave,
there's something I want your perspective on. As you know,
a person who has been paying close attention to this
asset class for such a long time, it still blows

(12:34):
my mind how this industry is trying to simultaneously argue
it is against government control, it is for freedom, it
is for the ability of people to do their thing individually.
But also they're like, but also we definitely don't allow
people on government lists to participate in this ecosystem whatsoever, Like,

(12:55):
how are folks trying to walk that line between not
getting completely shut down by the US government while appearing
to espouse the libertarian ideals of bitcoin and the blockchain.
That's the fine line that these exchanges and companies have
been walking since roll at the beginning of this industry
on it. I think you're seeing the consequences of that

(13:15):
now in the broader crackdown, whether it's sanctions here or
just the regulation of products that people should or shouldn't
be offered according to the government, which is basically there
to serve the people. Yeah, and the point about, you know,
the difficulty of knowing who someone is. For some people,

(13:38):
that's a feature, right, Like they don't want you to
know who they are because they don't trust their governments,
or they don't trust those banks, or they don't trust
that exchange necessarily. But of course, if you are a
government or a regulator, you're just going to look at
that and say, well, exchange, then you're not being compliant
with know your Customer rules. I mean it's literally in
the name know your customer. You're not being compliance with

(13:59):
anti money launder and you know, for some folks, that's
the argument for them for why they're like, well, okay,
like let's do let's go to defy, Let's go to
the really decentralized places where I don't have to tell
somebody what my name is or provide my passport or
my county dantity or whatever those things are. Emily, are
you seeing real evidence that's like a sustainable proposition for

(14:23):
people to move to something that's much more technically complicated
if they want to avoid more onerous data provision requirements.
It's been a difficult thing to monitor over the last
year because with crypto being down everywhere, it's hard to
know whether decentralized exchanges are getting hit better or worse
than those that are centralized exchanges. And ultimately a lot

(14:43):
of people do move their funds between lots of different
exchanges at once, so you can't even necessarily say, Okay,
you prefer this or you prefer that, because traders who
are native to crypto will use multiple exchanges for one journey.
What we do know, however, those that decentralized is becoming
a much harder ideal for firms to achieve, and in
some ways it does look like companies are starting to think, well,

(15:07):
maybe perhaps it's not possible to true decentralization, and perhaps
there's like a level that we can be comfortable with. So,
for example, in the end of February, we saw a
decentralized lending protocol called Oasis comply with a court order
to use a backdoor in its code that would allow

(15:28):
it to seize some funds that were stolen from a
platform last year called Wormhole, and Oasis was very clear
in the way that it spoke about it, because it
wanted to make sure that users didn't think that it
already knew about that backdoor and its code that would
allow to do that, because that's the opposite of decentralization, right,
let alone complying with a court order. But there's an

(15:48):
element now of like, well, surely it's a good thing,
right that you were able to get funds back from
a hacker, and surely it's a good thing that we
were able to comply with regulations where we're able to.
And so now is more of a debate about, you know,
what level are we comfortable with, how much decentralization is
truly possible, and what will that look like going forward.

(16:09):
Dave just as a kind of a closing thought, because
you know, it's this week in crypto. As we look
forward into the last month of the first quarter of
the year, are there any big top line numbers kind
of metrics that people are looking at to try to
see if they should be happy or sad about where
we are sure it's it's an interesting time for the market.

(16:29):
You had the January rally which crypto bounced almost forty
percent and got everybody saying or enough people saying, Crypto's back,
and that kind of stalled in February. As going to
the March period, now it's the big question is where
we go. And we're looking at actually some of the

(16:49):
positioning in the open interest options market on it, and
the big number that stood out was thirty thousand, which
this market loves around numbers. It's a good target. It's
an easy target to put up there when you're trading
blow around twenty five thousand. But interesting we saw also
that the to get technical, something called applied volatilities down

(17:13):
for these options, which means that people are kind of
losing interest on it. And what that means for the
people who actually bought those call options is that the
value of the options have dropped since they purchased it. It. Well,
it's kind of looking as the negative sign, but that's
kind of been the sentiment for past eight months really,

(17:34):
So if I were to summarize that for somebody who
is either not a financial reports so it does not
know what options are, it would be if things go
above thirty thousand dollars, a lot of people will be happy.
The problem is fewer and fewer people are actually buying
and selling right now. Exactly Well, on that extremely mixed note,
thank you both for being here. I appreciate it as
always pleasure, Thanks for having us. That was Bloomberg Senior

(17:59):
Editor DA and Bloomberg reporta Emelina Cole. You can find
more of their work on the Bloomberg Terminal and on
Bloomberg dot com, and of course, check out our twice
weekly newslesso, Bloomberg Crypto. This is Bloomberg Crypto, a daily
podcast from Bloomberg and iHeartRadio. For more shows from iHeartRadio,

(18:21):
visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get
your podcasts. Send us your comments, questions or suggestions for
the show to Crypto at Bloomberg dot net. The supervising
producer of Bloomberg Crypto is Vicky Vergelina. Our senior producer
is Janet Babin. Our producers are Mohammed Farouk and Sharon Barrero.

(18:43):
Our associate producers are Ty Butler and Moses on m.
Desto wonder At is our engineer. Original music by Leo Sidron.
I'm Stacy Mariechmal We'll be back Tomorrow, mbop We hated

(19:03):
and felt in every
Advertise With Us

Popular Podcasts

1. Las Culturistas with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang

1. Las Culturistas with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang

Ding dong! Join your culture consultants, Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang, on an unforgettable journey into the beating heart of CULTURE. Alongside sizzling special guests, they GET INTO the hottest pop-culture moments of the day and the formative cultural experiences that turned them into Culturistas. Produced by the Big Money Players Network and iHeartRadio.

2. The Joe Rogan Experience

2. The Joe Rogan Experience

The official podcast of comedian Joe Rogan.

3. Dateline NBC

3. Dateline NBC

Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations.

Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2024 iHeartMedia, Inc.