Francesca Rudkin: McDonald's read the room wrong trying to put a restaurant in Wānaka

There’s a Dominos and a Subway, but there will be no McDonald’s in Wānaka - at least at the currently proposed site. Yesterday, Commissioners declined to grant consent for a McDonalds restaurant, largely due to the location. 

The proposed location was at the edge of town - where urban meets rural living. It is regarded as outside the urban growth boundary for Wānaka, at one of the town’s entrances, directly underneath magnificent Mt Iron.  

A McDonalds was deemed to be at odds with rural living, the design of the building and surroundings not consistent with the landscape values of the site and its wider context. Commissioners considered reports and findings about the architecture, noise, traffic and future planning.  

Queenstown Lakes District Council opened the proposal up for public submissions and of the 367 made, 340 opposed the development and 21 supported it. 

While there were some who would have liked the opportunity for a Big Mac for dinner, many locals thought it would increase traffic, drink driving, litter, take business away from existing local businesses, stand out like a sore thumb, and have a visual and aesthetic impact on the town.  

Their issue was – was this really a fitting gateway for a town all about healthy living and the environment, yoga and wellbeing, ditching disposable coffee cups, and slashing waste? 

Or has the horse already bolted when it comes to Wānaka’s image and culture? The town’s population has increased from 10,000 to 18,000 in a decade, it's surrounded in subdivision development, and then there’s the Three Parks development not too far down the road from the proposed McDonalds site - which is home to a Mitre 10 Mega, Warehouse, and numerous other outlets.  

Last night Queenstown District Deputy Mayor Quentin Smith told Andrew Dickens on Newstalk ZB’s Drive the proposed setting and McDonald's wasn't a good fit.  

So did McDonalds just get it wrong – did they not read the room? Being tucked away in the Three Parks Development or the centre of town might have made it easier to gain consent. But would even that be acceptable for locals?  

I say good on the folks of Wānaka – who doesn’t love a David and Goliath battle?  

There are apparently over 41 thousand McDonalds in the world. There is one about an hour away from Wānaka. Does another small town need a golden arch? I personally love rolling into New Zealand towns, exploring what’s on offer, finding the best homemade pie (should out to Miles Better Pies in Te Anau), and having a chat with locals. It’s good to get away from the familiar.  

Tourists don’t visit a stunning place like Wānaka because it has a McDonalds, so it comes down to the community. If the community feel it doesn’t reflect their values for whatever reasons —protecting the vista, their brand, local businesses or just plain old snobbery— then I say go for it. Fight the fight. Just like magnificent Kaikoura did. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Episode Transcript

Speaker 1 (00:00):
While there is a Dominoes in a subway, but there
will be no McDonald's in Wonica, at least at the
currently proposed site. Yesterday, commissioners declined to grant consent from
McDonald's restaurant, largely due to the location. So the proposed
location was at the edge of town where urban meets
rural living. It's regarded as outside the urban growth boundary
for Wonaco at one of the town's entrances, directly underneath

(00:22):
the magnificent amount iron and McDonald's was deemed to be
at odds with rural living, the design of the building
and surroundings not consistent with the landscape values of the
site in its wider context. Commissioners considered reports and findings
about the architecture, noise, traffic, and future planning. Queenstown Lakes
District Council will opened the proposal for public submissions. There

(00:43):
are about three hundred and sixty seven may to t
One hundred and forty were very much opposed to the development.
Twenty one supported it. While there were some who would
have liked the opportunity for a big Mac for dinner,
many locals thought it would increase traffic, drink driving litter,
take business away from existing local businesses, stand out like
a saw thumb, and have a visual anesthetic impact on

(01:03):
the town. Their issue was, was this really a fitting
gateway for a town all about healthy living and environment,
yogur and well being, ditching disposable coffee cups and slashing
waste or has the horse already bolted when it comes
to Wanaka's image and culture. The town's population has increased
from ten thousand to eighteen thousand and a decade. It's

(01:25):
surrounded in subdivision development, and then there's the Three Parks
development not too far down the road from the propos
McDonald's site, which is home to a might attend Mega,
a warehouse and numerous other outlets. Last night, Queenstown District
Deputy Mayor queen And Smith told Andrew Dickins on news
Talks he'd be the proposed setting and McDonald's wasn't a
good fit.

Speaker 2 (01:44):
It may be parts of town where this activity might
be appropriate, and if this was within a commercial within
the town center or within a commercial zone within the town,
I there say there's very little that anybody could do
to stop that.

Speaker 1 (02:00):
McDonald's just get it wrong. Did they not read the
room being tucked away in the Three Parks development or
the center of town might have made it easy to
gain consent, but would even that have been acceptable for locals?
I say good on the folks of Wanica. Who doesn't
love a David and Goliath battle. There apparently over forty
one thousand McDonald's in the world. There's one about an
hour away from Wanicah. Does another small town need a

(02:21):
golden arch? I personally love rolling into New Zealand towns,
exploring what's on offer, finding the best homemade pie, shout
out to Miles better Pies in Tiano, and having a
chat with locals. It's always good to get away from
the familiar. Tourists don't visit a stunning place like Wanica
because it has a McDonald So it comes down to
the community. If the community feel it doesn't reflect their

(02:43):
values for whatever reason, protecting the vista, their brand, local businesses,
or just plain old snobbery, and I say, go for it,
fight the fight, just like the magnificent I cord it did.
For more from early edition with Ryan's Bridge. Listen live
to News Talk said Be from five am weekdays, or
follow the podcast on iHeartRadio.