Backwards Compatible #44 - The Best (and Worst) Game Collections

Want a shout out on the show? Shoot us a text and share your thoughts, game suggestions, etc.!

Episode 44 - The Best (and Worst) Retro Game Collections

Lou and I are diving into the world of game compilations, remasters, and collections! Some are incredible value-packed bundles, while others feel like quick cash grabs. But before we go any further, let's get something out of the way—Lou absolutely hates the original Tomb Raider games on PS1. Like, with a passion. He thinks they control like a drunk tank rolling down a hill. So, if you’re a Tomb Raider fan, prepare for some heated opinions!

We also talk about what makes a game collection truly great. Super Mario All-Stars on SNES set the gold standard, not just bundling games together but actually improving the graphics and gameplay—something modern collections rarely do. On the flip side, we discuss disappointments like Super Mario 3D All-Stars and GTA Trilogy: The Definitive Edition, which somehow managed to make their games worse.

From Rare Replay to The Orange Box, we break down the best bang-for-your-buck collections, while also debating whether digital-only bundles are helping or hurting game preservation. Are these collections the best way to play retro games legally, or is emulation still king? Tune in and find out!

Support the show

We've got merch!

Check out the site for some awesome Gen 'S' swag :)