EP# 29 False Sirens and the Castle of Shadows: Caryl Chessman, the Red Light Bandit and Leap Castle’s Haunted History

Send us a text

In this gripping episode, J and Kai take listeners from a controversial true crime case to one of Ireland’s most haunted castles.

Have you ever heard the saying, “Justice is blind”? Well… sometimes, justice isn’t just blind—it’s bound, gagged, and shoved into the backseat of a moving car with no idea how it got there. J unpacks the chilling case of Caryl Chessman, the so-called Red Light Bandit, who terrorized post-war Los Angeles by impersonating a police officer, using a flashing red light to pull over unsuspecting couples before robbing—and, in some cases, assaulting—his victims. His arrest in 1948 led to one of the most controversial legal battles in U.S. history, as he was sentenced to death under California’s Little Lindbergh Law, a statute that classified even brief abductions as capital offenses.

But Chessman’s story didn’t end with his conviction. Representing himself in court, he fought to delay his execution eight times, becoming a bestselling author and an international symbol in the fight against the death penalty. His case ignited protests worldwide, with figures like Eleanor Roosevelt and Marlon Brando advocating for clemency. Yet, in a tragic twist, a last-minute attempt to halt his execution was lost due to a misdialed phone call. J explores the evidence, the trial, and the haunting question that lingers to this day—was Chessman truly guilty, or did America execute the wrong man?

Kai then takes us deep into the chilling halls of Leap Castle, a fortress soaked in blood and shadow, where history and horror intertwine. Once home to the brutal O’Carroll clan, this stronghold witnessed treachery, fratricide, and mass executions, earning its place as one of the most haunted locations in the world. At its heart lies the infamous Bloody Chapel, where a priest was murdered mid-mass by his own brother, his spirit doomed to linger within the stone walls. Below the chapel, a hidden oubliette was discovered, filled with hundreds of human remains, victims left to die in agony.

Yet the most chilling presence in Leap Castle is the Elemental, a malevolent entity with glowing red eyes and the stench of rotting flesh. Thought to predate the castle itself, this shadowy force is believed to have been awakened by violent history or ancient curses. Those who have encountered it speak of an oppressive dread, a force that watches from the darkness, waiting. Could this be a lingering remnant of Ireland’s ancient past, or something far more sinister?

Join J and Kai as they dive into these unsettling tales of deception, terror, and the unexplained. Whether it’s a man condemned to die or a castle that refuses to rest, some stories refuse to be forgotten.