Hancock's Presidents Reserve Bourbon Whiskey Review

Welcome back to DadDimes on the Rocks! Today, we’re diving into a Buffalo Trace Distillery gem that doesn’t always get the same hype as its siblings—Hancock’s President’s Reserve Bourbon Whiskey. This single-barrel bourbon carries some mystery, a strong pedigree, and a smooth, refined profile. Let’s break it down!

The Story Behind Hancock’s President’s Reserve

Named after John Hancock, this bourbon comes from the Buffalo Trace Distillery, specifically from their high-rye mash bill #2, which it shares with Blanton’s, Elmer T. Lee, and Rock Hill Farms. Unlike many Buffalo Trace bottles, Hancock’s President’s Reserve doesn’t come with an age statement, adding to its mystique. While it’s not as widely discussed as Blanton’s, it has a dedicated following among bourbon lovers who appreciate its smooth yet spicy profile.

Key Details

• Type: Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
• Proof: 88.9 (44.45% ABV)
• Mash Bill: Buffalo Trace’s high-rye Mash Bill #2 (estimated 12-15% rye)
• Age: No official statement, but believed to be 6-10 years
• Distillery: Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky

Bottle Presentation

Hancock’s President’s Reserve comes in a stately, no-frills bottle with a gold label and wax seal. It’s simple yet elegant, with an old-school charm that reflects its traditional craftsmanship.

Tasting Notes

Nose
A sweet and spicy aroma with notes of honey, vanilla, caramel, and light cinnamon. Hints of toasted oak, dried fruit, and baking spices add complexity.

Palate
The first sip is buttery smooth, with a mix of toffee, honey, and vanilla up front. The rye spice builds mid-palate, bringing in notes of pepper, citrus zest, and nutmeg. The mouthfeel is soft but carries enough heat to remind you it’s a high-rye bourbon.

Finish
Medium-length with lingering oak, brown sugar, and a light herbal note. It’s not overpowering, making it an easy-drinking bourbon for both newcomers and seasoned drinkers.

How Does It Compare?

Compared to Blanton’s, Hancock’s President’s Reserve is lower in proof and softer on the palate, but it still carries the signature sweet-rye balance. It has a bit more honey and caramel than Elmer T. Lee, but it’s not as bold as Rock Hill Farms.

Best Ways to Enjoy

🥃 Neat – The smooth character makes this an easy sipper straight from the glass.
🧊 On the Rocks – A light chill brings out the honey and caramel notes.
🍸 Classic Manhattan – The high-rye mash bill makes it a great base for cocktails.

Final Thoughts

Hancock’s President’s Reserve is a hidden gem in the Buffalo Trace lineup. While it doesn’t carry the same cult following as Blanton’s or Stagg, it delivers a well-balanced, easy-drinking experience with enough complexity to keep bourbon enthusiasts engaged. The lower proof makes it approachable, and the high-rye spice adds just the right amount of kick.

💰 Worth the Price? If you can find i