Divine Divorce? Catholic Annulments Explained with Father David Mowry

Faith, Family Law, and Finding Peace: Understanding Catholic AnnulmentsIn this enlightening episode, divorce attorney Seth Nelson and Pete Wright welcome Father David Mowry, a Roman Catholic priest and assistant professor at the University of St. Mary of the Lake in Mundelein, Illinois. With the recent election of Pope Leo XIV (the first American-born Pope), the conversation explores the intersection of Catholic faith and family law, specifically focusing on the church's approach to marriage, divorce, and annulments.Seth and Pete dive deep into the Catholic Church's perspective on marriage as both a sacred covenant and a legal institution. Father Mowry explains how annulments differ fundamentally from civil divorces, detailing the extensive process and support systems the Church has in place. The discussion reveals how the Church's approach to failed marriages isn't about finding loopholes, but rather about determining whether a true marriage existed in the first place according to Catholic teaching.Questions we answer in this episode:

• How does a Catholic annulment differ from a civil divorce?
• What happens if one spouse refuses to participate in the annulment process?
• How does the Church support children whose parents are going through divorce?

Key Takeaways:

• The Catholic Church views marriage as a permanent covenant—annulments determine if a valid marriage ever existed
• Annulment processes include extensive pastoral and legal support systems
• Local priests serve as initial guides but specialized Church courts handle the formal proceedings

This episode offers invaluable insights for anyone navigating the complex intersection of faith and divorce. Whether you're Catholic or simply interested in understanding different approaches to marriage dissolution, Father Mowry's explanation of the Church's compassionate yet structured approach to failed marriages provides a fascinating perspective on healing and moving forward.Links & Notes

• Learn more about Father David Mowry on his website
• Schedule a consult with Seth
• Got a question you want to ask on the show? Click here!

• (00:00) - Welcome to How to Split a Toaster
• (00:27) - Meet Father David Mowry
• (04:31) - Catholic Annulments vs. Divorce
• (05:16) - Civil vs. Church Law Around Marriage
• (12:20) - Annulments – The Loophole
• (18:05) - What the Church Looks at
• (20:27) - Counter to Catholic Thinking?
• (23:08) - A Way to Set People Free
• (24:06) - Unwlling Participant
• (25:46) - When It’s Contested
• (27:34) - Appeals Process
• (28:15) - Judges
• (31:50) - Emotional Infrastructure
• (36:55) - Working with the Kids
• (41:31) - Where the Job Begins and Ends
• (45:06) - Historical Records
• (46:47) - Pete’s Story
• (48:35) - Wrap Up