Ep. 15 | Finding Your Next Pastor | Ed Short

Episode 15: Show Notes

Episode Overview
In this insightful episode of the Revitalize My Church podcast, host Bart Blair engages in a deep conversation with Ed Short, a seasoned ministry leader whose experience spans over four decades in pastoral ministry and church consulting. Their discussion provides crucial insights for churches navigating the challenging waters of pastoral transition, with particular emphasis on situations involving the departure of long-tenured leaders.

The Foundation: Assessment Before Action
Ed Short emphasizes that the key to a successful pastoral transition begins long before the search itself. Churches must first take a careful look inward, assessing their current effectiveness and understanding their unique cultural dynamics. This period of self-reflection allows the church leadership to dream about future direction and develop a clear vision for where they want to go. Without this crucial groundwork, churches risk making hasty decisions that could lead to unsuccessful pastoral placements.

The Modern Search Process
Gone are the days when finding a new pastor was as simple as posting a generic job description. Today's effective search process requires a comprehensive approach that goes far beyond basic qualifications. Ed discusses the importance of creating detailed, specific job postings that clearly communicate both the church's current reality and future aspirations. He strongly advocates for the use of multiple assessment tools, including the Working Genius assessment, DISC profiles, and spiritual gifts inventories, to ensure a thorough understanding of potential candidates.

Building Chemistry and Relationships

One of the most overlooked aspects of the pastoral search process is the importance of relationship building during the candidating phase. Ed shares valuable insights about moving beyond formal interviews to create opportunities for genuine connection. He recommends including extended visits that involve both the candidate and their spouse, suggesting activities that allow for natural interaction and conversation. These informal settings often reveal more about potential fit than traditional interview questions ever could.

The Compensation Conversation

The discussion takes a practical turn as Ed and Bart address the often sensitive topic of pastoral compensation. They emphasize the importance of creating packages that allow pastors to focus fully on ministry without financial stress. The conversation includes thoughtful considerations about cost of living differences between locations and the importance of basing compensation on skills and experience rather than family size. They challenge churches to think generously about their overall package while acknowledging the real constraints many congregations face.

Creating Healthy Transitions

The final portion of the episode focuses on best practices for managing the actual transition between pastors. Ed strongly recommends considering a temporary break for departing long-term pastors, suggesting a 9-12 month period away from the church. This approach gives new leadership space to establish relationships and build trust before implementing changes. He emphasizes the critical importance of the first year, encouraging new pastors to focus on relationship building rather than immediate vision casting.

About Ed Short

Ed brings a wealth of experience to this conversation, having served as a Lead Pastor for 25 years, along with roles as...