Tracy Anderson, the mastermind behind the Tracy Anderson Method, sued ex-trainer Megan Roup for allegedly stealing her routines and licensing them to Equinox. The US District Court just ruled against Anderson’s copyright claim. Join Scott Hervey and Jamie Lincenbergfrom Weintraub Tobin on "The Briefing" as they discuss the case’s impact on fitness entrepreneurs.
Get the full episode on the Weintraub YouTube channel here or listen to this podcast episode here.
Show Notes:
Scott
Exercise is a multi-million-dollar business, and nobody knows that better than Tracy Anderson, celebrity fitness trainer and creator of the Tracy Anderson Method. The Tracy Anderson Method is a fitness routine that combines choreography, fitness, and cardiovascular movement, and it served as the foundation for multiple exercise studios and 19 home videos. Anderson sued one of her former trainers, Megan Roup, for ripping off her routines to create her own choreography-based dance cardio workout, which Roup later licensed to rival gym chain Equinox Holdings. The US District Court for the Central District of California recently ruled on Rupp's motion for summary judgment, denying Anderson's relief on her copyright claim. I'm Scott Hervey from Weintraub Tobin, and I am joined today by Jamie Lincenberg. We're going to talk about exercise routines and copyright and what this case means for celebrity trainers and fitness entrepreneurs in this next installment of “The Briefing.”
Jamie, welcome back to “The Briefing.”
Jamie
Thanks, Scott. It's Good to be here and to get into this case. I've actually done the Tracy Anderson method and Megan Roup's classes.
Scott
That's great. That's great. You speak from first-hand experience, so this is great. Exactly. All right, so let's talk about the cases. The facts are fairly straightforward. Anderson is a fitness trainer who developed the Tracy Anderson method. She has studios in LA, New York, Madrid, London, and she's got merch, lots and lots of merch. She has truly built a fitness empire. Roup was a trainer in a Tracy Anderson gym from about 2011 to 2017. And Roup signed a trainer agreement upon her employment, which contained a mostly standard confidential information provision, which identified workouts, movements, exercise, routines, exercise formulas, nutrition advice, content, sequences, dances, muscular structure, work, and equipment as being, “confidential information”. After Roup left Anderson's employment, she founded TSS, another choreography-based dance cardio workout.
Jamie
Two weeks after terminating her employment with Tracy Anderson in February 2017, Roup sent emails to potential clients, including clients of Anderson's, announcing her development of TSS, her choreography-based dance cardio workout. In March 2017, Roup announced on social media her launch of TSS, equals Equinox licensed TSS from Roup, and while working with Equinox, Roup prepared an instructor training manual for TSS, which Anderson alleges included much of the same information contained in Anderson's confidential training materials.
Scott
So after some initial law in motion, Anderson's remaining claims were whittled down to copyright infringement and breach of contract. Roup then moved for summary judgment on both of those remaining claims. So as to the copyright claim, Anderson asserted that Roup infringed on the copyrights Anderson has in her home videos since the videos copy the choreography, movements, sequences, and the routines from the videos. Anderson is in arguing that Roup copied the home videos themselves, but that she copied the underlying routines that are captured on the footage. Anderson believes that the copyrights in the home videos extend to the routines that are captured in the home videos.
Jamie
So, Roup didn't dispute the similarity between hers and Anderson's exercise dance routine. However, she does argue that Anderson can't prove its copyright claim because A...