When Self-Help Stops Working

Send us Fan Mail

Most people assume that if something works, they should keep doing it.

And for a while, that’s true.

Routines, habits, and structure can help you manage stress and bring things back under control. But there’s a point where those same approaches stop producing the same result—and most people don’t recognize it when that happens.

Instead, they try to do it better.

More consistency. More discipline. More control.

In this episode, I walk through why that instinct can start to work against you, how the gap between effort and outcome gets misread as personal failure, and how to recognize when what you’re doing is no longer matched to what you’re dealing with.

This isn’t about abandoning self-help. It’s about understanding where it applies—and where it doesn’t.

If you’re enjoying Uncommonly Remarkable, you can follow or subscribe wherever you’re listening. It helps more people find the show.

Uncommonly Remarkable℠ is a health and wellness show focused on understanding how the body works and how everyday choices shape long-term health.

I’m Artis Beatty, a doctor of optometry and Chief Medical Officer at MyEyeDr. While my professional background informs how I think, the perspectives shared here are my own.

Episode Transcript

SPEAKER_00 (00:00):
The same things that help you feel better can end up

(00:03):
making things worse.
It doesn't happen quickly, andit's not usually obvious when
it's happening.
And by the time you notice itisn't working the same way,
you've already been relying onit.
People find something thathelps: a routine, a structure, a
way of handling things thatactually makes them feel more
stable, and it works, so theykeep doing it.

(00:27):
They feel more like themselvesand things feel more manageable.
What doesn't get examined iswhat exactly it's working on.
If it's stress, pressurebuilding up that needs somewhere
to go, having a structured wayto handle it helps.
But stress isn't the only thingthat can make you feel like
you're not okay.
And when something else is goingon, most people don't stop and

(00:50):
ask whether what they're doingstill makes sense.
They assume the approach is fineand they just need to do it
better.
So things get tighter, theroutine becomes more rigid, and
they start holding themselves toit more strictly.
And sometimes that helps.
Sometimes consistency really isthe issue.
But sometimes it doesn't.

(01:13):
And that's where it gets harderto tell what's actually going
on.
When the effort goes up and theresults don't follow, the
attention moves away fromwhether it's helping and onto
whether you're doing itcorrectly.
Are you being consistent enough?
Are you following through?
Are you actually committed tothis?

(01:33):
The question stops being, isthis working?
And becomes what's wrong withhow I'm doing it?
And if what you're dealing withisn't just stress anymore, if
it's closer to emotionaldistress or depression, focusing
on doing it better tends to makethings worse because you're
trying to handle it like it'sstress when it really isn't.

(01:54):
And the gap between how hardyou're trying and how you
actually feel starts to looklike evidence of personal
failure.
There's a version of this that'seasy to miss.
You keep doing what you'redoing, you stay consistent, you
follow through, and it doesn'tland the same way.
So you tighten up, and that'swhere it starts to work against

(02:14):
you.
Someone in that position canstill look from the outside like
they're doing everything right.
They're keeping the routine,they're showing up, they're not
falling apart in any visibleway.
But internally, what used tofeel stabilizing now feels like
one more thing they'restruggling to keep up with.
And the more that's true, theharder they often push because

(02:36):
that's what they've learned todo when something isn't working.
This connects to something fromthe last episode: the
distinction between stress,distress, depression, and
crisis.
The kinds of things people do ontheir own, routines, habits,
they tend to work well forstress.
They can still help withemotional distress, but they're
less reliable and they requiremore awareness about whether

(03:00):
they're actually landing.
With depression, the sameapproaches often don't produce
the same results, and there's areal risk of reading that as a
personal shortcoming rather thana signal about fit.
And if someone is approachingcrisis, continuing to treat it
as something they should be ableto manage on their own can delay
them getting what they need.

(03:22):
So the issue really isn't withthe approaches themselves.
A lot of them are genuinelyuseful.
The issue is whether they'rebeing applied to the right
thing.
Part of why people stay in thisloop is that doing something,
having a practice, a way ofhandling it, creates a sense of
agency.
And that feeling of agencymatters, but it can also make it

(03:46):
harder to step back and askwhether what you're doing is
actually matched to what you'redealing with.
Because stepping back feels likegiving something up, even when
what you're actually doing isgetting more accurate about the
situation.
It doesn't feel dramatic whenthis is happening, and it shows
up more as a different question.
Not how do I do this better, butis this the right thing to be

(04:10):
doing here?
Sometimes that question bringsyou back to the same habits,
just used a little differentlyor with less rigidity.
And sometimes it pointssomewhere else, towards talking
to someone or towardsacknowledging that this is
bigger than something you workthrough on your own.
Neither of those is a failure.

(04:31):
They're just different responsesto different situations.
If you've been doing the thingsyou're supposed to do and it's
not getting better, or it'sgetting harder to keep doing
them, that's worth payingattention to.
Not as evidence that you'redoing anything wrong, but as
information about what you mightactually be dealing with.
Because the goal isn't to manageit perfectly, it's to see it

(04:54):
clearly enough that what you donext actually makes sense.
This is uncommonly remarkable.
Thanks for listening.