October 19, 2025 • 6 mins
Tired of the indoor vs outdoor training debate? In this episode, we break down the real strengths of each approach and how to use them strategically in your training. Discover why indoor training isn't just a weather backup – it's a precision tool for building specific fitness. Learn the four key strategies for maximizing trainer effectiveness, plus the three biggest mistakes that sabotage indoor sessions.
We'll also explore what outdoor riding offers that no trainer can replicate, and how to intelligently balance both throughout your training year. Whether you're a trainer skeptic or an indoor devotee, this episode will help you get more from every pedal stroke, regardless of where you're riding.
Topics covered:
Youtube: /@pedalmyway
Instagram: /pedalmyway
Bluesky:@pedalmyway.bsky.social
We'll also explore what outdoor riding offers that no trainer can replicate, and how to intelligently balance both throughout your training year. Whether you're a trainer skeptic or an indoor devotee, this episode will help you get more from every pedal stroke, regardless of where you're riding.
Topics covered:
- The unique advantages of indoor training precision
- What outdoor riding develops that trainers can't
- Four strategies to maximize trainer effectiveness
- Three common indoor training mistakes to avoid
- How to integrate both approaches strategically
Youtube: /@pedalmyway
Instagram: /pedalmyway
Bluesky:@pedalmyway.bsky.social
Mark as Played
Transcript
Episode Transcript
Available transcripts are automatically generated. Complete accuracy is not guaranteed.
Speaker 1 (00:06):
Welcome back to another episode of Ask the Pedalist podcast.
I'm your host Mukund and today we're diving into a
topic that every cyclist grapples with, especially during winter months
or when life gets busy, and that is indoor versus
outdoor training and specifically how to maximize the effectiveness of
your trainer sessions. Let me start with a confession. Five
(00:29):
years ago, I absolutely hated indoor training. I thought it
was boring, ineffective, and just a poor substitute for the
real thing. But here's what changed my mind, understanding that
indoor and outdoor training aren't competitors. They're complementary tools that
serve different purposes in your cycling development. Let's start with
(00:52):
why indoor training has become such a game changer for
cyclists at every level. The biggest advantage control. When you're
on a trainer, you control every variable. Weather can't derail
your workout, Traffic lights can't interrupt your intervals, that headwind
that crushes your motivation gone. This control translates into training
(01:12):
precision that's simply impossible to achieve outdoors. Consistently need to
hold exactly two hundred and fifty watts for twenty minutes,
your trainer will hold you accountable to every single wat.
Try doing that outdoors with hills, wind, and traffic. It's
nearly impossible. Indoor training also maximizes your time efficiency. A focused,
forty five minute trainer session can deliver more targeted training
(01:36):
stimulus than a two hour outdoor ride where you're coasting,
stopping at lights, or soft pedaling up that gradual climb
because you're chatting with friends. But all those watts you've
built on the trainer need to translate to actual cycling performance.
Outdoor riding teaches you how to handle bike dynamics, read terrain,
manage pacing over varied conditions, and develop the mental toughness
(02:00):
that comes from dealing with weather, fatigue, and unpredictable situations.
There's also the neurological component that many cyclists overlook. Outdoor
riding constantly challenges your balance, coordination, and by handling skills.
These microadjustments keep your nervous system sharp and improve your
overall cycling efficiency in ways that a static trainer simply
(02:23):
cannot replicate. Now let's get practical. How do you make
your indoor sessions as effective as possible? First, structure as
everything don't just hop on the trainer and ride aimlessly.
Every indoor session should have a specific purpose. Threshold work
vo two max intervals, endurance based building, or recovery spinning.
Plan your workout before you clip in. Second, create the
(02:46):
right environment. Temperature control is crucial. You'll sweat more indoors,
so fans aren't optional, they're essential. I recommend at least
one powerful fan directly in front of you, and if possible,
a second one for additional airflow. Overheating will kill your
power output and make sessions miserable. Third entertainment versus focus.
(03:07):
This might be controversial, but hear me out. For easy
endurance rides, go ahead and watch that Netflix series. But
for high intensity work ditch the distractions. Focus on your
power numbers, your breathing, your form. The mental training you
get from suffering through hard intervals without distraction will pay
dividends when you're racing or riding hard outdoors. Fourth, use
(03:32):
structured training plans or apps. Platforms like Trainer, road Swift
or suffer Fest provide systematic progression and take the guesswork
out of workout design. They also add a competitive element
that can push you harder than you might push yourself.
Here's how I recommend integrating both approaches throughout your training year.
(03:53):
During base building phases, mix both freely. Use indoor sessions
for specific threshold or interval work where precision matters. Use
outdoor rides for longer endurance work where you can practice pacing, fueling,
and handling skills when weather is poor or time is limited.
Indoor training is your best friend, but don't let it
(04:13):
become a crutch. Even in winter. Try to get outside
at least once a week to maintain those real world skills.
As you approach your key events or racing season, shift
the balance toward outdoor training. You need to practice the
specific demands of your goals, whether that's climbing real hills,
handling crosswinds, or racing in a pack. Let me share
(04:36):
three big mistakes I see cyclists make with indoor training.
Mistake number one training too hard too often. The precision
of indoor training can become addictive. Every session becomes a
suffer fest because you can see those numbers. I've been
guilty of this myself, staring at that power meter like
it's a video game score. But remember, easy days should
(04:58):
still be easy even in Mistake number two ignoring bike
fit indoors. Your position on the trainer should mirror your
outdoor position. Don't get lazy with set up just because
you're inside. Your body doesn't know the difference, and neither
will your knees when they start complaining. Mistake number three
not simulating outdoor conditions when it matters. If you're training
(05:20):
for a hilly race, use gradient simulation. If you're preparing
for time trials, practice your error position on the trainer,
Make your training specific, and race day will feel like
deja vus, the good kind. Here's what I want you
to take away from this episode. Indoor and outdoor training
each have unique strengths. Indoor training excels at precision, consistency,
(05:43):
and efficiency. Outdoor training provides real world application, mental resilience,
and skills development. The most effective cyclists use both strategically.
Use indoor training to build your engine with precise, structured workouts.
Use outdoor training to tune that engine for real world performance.
(06:03):
Don't fall into the trap of thinking one is superior
to the other. There are tools in your training tool kit,
and like any good craftsman, you should know when to
use each tool for maximum effect. That's a wrap on
today's episode. There is also a companion blog post at
pedlemway dot com, where we provide more details on these topics.
Give it a read at your leisure. If you found
(06:25):
this helpful, consider sharing it with a fellow cyclist who
might benefit. Until next time, keep those wheels turned, whether
they're spinning on a trainer or rolling on the open road.
Welcome back to another episode of Ask the Pedalist podcast.
I'm your host Mukund and today we're diving into a
topic that every cyclist grapples with, especially during winter months
or when life gets busy, and that is indoor versus
outdoor training and specifically how to maximize the effectiveness of
your trainer sessions. Let me start with a confession. Five
(00:29):
years ago, I absolutely hated indoor training. I thought it
was boring, ineffective, and just a poor substitute for the
real thing. But here's what changed my mind, understanding that
indoor and outdoor training aren't competitors. They're complementary tools that
serve different purposes in your cycling development. Let's start with
(00:52):
why indoor training has become such a game changer for
cyclists at every level. The biggest advantage control. When you're
on a trainer, you control every variable. Weather can't derail
your workout, Traffic lights can't interrupt your intervals, that headwind
that crushes your motivation gone. This control translates into training
(01:12):
precision that's simply impossible to achieve outdoors. Consistently need to
hold exactly two hundred and fifty watts for twenty minutes,
your trainer will hold you accountable to every single wat.
Try doing that outdoors with hills, wind, and traffic. It's
nearly impossible. Indoor training also maximizes your time efficiency. A focused,
forty five minute trainer session can deliver more targeted training
(01:36):
stimulus than a two hour outdoor ride where you're coasting,
stopping at lights, or soft pedaling up that gradual climb
because you're chatting with friends. But all those watts you've
built on the trainer need to translate to actual cycling performance.
Outdoor riding teaches you how to handle bike dynamics, read terrain,
manage pacing over varied conditions, and develop the mental toughness
(02:00):
that comes from dealing with weather, fatigue, and unpredictable situations.
There's also the neurological component that many cyclists overlook. Outdoor
riding constantly challenges your balance, coordination, and by handling skills.
These microadjustments keep your nervous system sharp and improve your
overall cycling efficiency in ways that a static trainer simply
(02:23):
cannot replicate. Now let's get practical. How do you make
your indoor sessions as effective as possible? First, structure as
everything don't just hop on the trainer and ride aimlessly.
Every indoor session should have a specific purpose. Threshold work
vo two max intervals, endurance based building, or recovery spinning.
Plan your workout before you clip in. Second, create the
(02:46):
right environment. Temperature control is crucial. You'll sweat more indoors,
so fans aren't optional, they're essential. I recommend at least
one powerful fan directly in front of you, and if possible,
a second one for additional airflow. Overheating will kill your
power output and make sessions miserable. Third entertainment versus focus.
(03:07):
This might be controversial, but hear me out. For easy
endurance rides, go ahead and watch that Netflix series. But
for high intensity work ditch the distractions. Focus on your
power numbers, your breathing, your form. The mental training you
get from suffering through hard intervals without distraction will pay
dividends when you're racing or riding hard outdoors. Fourth, use
(03:32):
structured training plans or apps. Platforms like Trainer, road Swift
or suffer Fest provide systematic progression and take the guesswork
out of workout design. They also add a competitive element
that can push you harder than you might push yourself.
Here's how I recommend integrating both approaches throughout your training year.
(03:53):
During base building phases, mix both freely. Use indoor sessions
for specific threshold or interval work where precision matters. Use
outdoor rides for longer endurance work where you can practice pacing, fueling,
and handling skills when weather is poor or time is limited.
Indoor training is your best friend, but don't let it
(04:13):
become a crutch. Even in winter. Try to get outside
at least once a week to maintain those real world skills.
As you approach your key events or racing season, shift
the balance toward outdoor training. You need to practice the
specific demands of your goals, whether that's climbing real hills,
handling crosswinds, or racing in a pack. Let me share
(04:36):
three big mistakes I see cyclists make with indoor training.
Mistake number one training too hard too often. The precision
of indoor training can become addictive. Every session becomes a
suffer fest because you can see those numbers. I've been
guilty of this myself, staring at that power meter like
it's a video game score. But remember, easy days should
(04:58):
still be easy even in Mistake number two ignoring bike
fit indoors. Your position on the trainer should mirror your
outdoor position. Don't get lazy with set up just because
you're inside. Your body doesn't know the difference, and neither
will your knees when they start complaining. Mistake number three
not simulating outdoor conditions when it matters. If you're training
(05:20):
for a hilly race, use gradient simulation. If you're preparing
for time trials, practice your error position on the trainer,
Make your training specific, and race day will feel like
deja vus, the good kind. Here's what I want you
to take away from this episode. Indoor and outdoor training
each have unique strengths. Indoor training excels at precision, consistency,
(05:43):
and efficiency. Outdoor training provides real world application, mental resilience,
and skills development. The most effective cyclists use both strategically.
Use indoor training to build your engine with precise, structured workouts.
Use outdoor training to tune that engine for real world performance.
(06:03):
Don't fall into the trap of thinking one is superior
to the other. There are tools in your training tool kit,
and like any good craftsman, you should know when to
use each tool for maximum effect. That's a wrap on
today's episode. There is also a companion blog post at
pedlemway dot com, where we provide more details on these topics.
Give it a read at your leisure. If you found
(06:25):
this helpful, consider sharing it with a fellow cyclist who
might benefit. Until next time, keep those wheels turned, whether
they're spinning on a trainer or rolling on the open road.
Popular Podcasts
Las Culturistas with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang
Ding dong! Join your culture consultants, Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang, on an unforgettable journey into the beating heart of CULTURE. Alongside sizzling special guests, they GET INTO the hottest pop-culture moments of the day and the formative cultural experiences that turned them into Culturistas. Produced by the Big Money Players Network and iHeartRadio.
Crime Junkie
Does hearing about a true crime case always leave you scouring the internet for the truth behind the story? Dive into your next mystery with Crime Junkie. Every Monday, join your host Ashley Flowers as she unravels all the details of infamous and underreported true crime cases with her best friend Brit Prawat. From cold cases to missing persons and heroes in our community who seek justice, Crime Junkie is your destination for theories and stories you won’t hear anywhere else. Whether you're a seasoned true crime enthusiast or new to the genre, you'll find yourself on the edge of your seat awaiting a new episode every Monday. If you can never get enough true crime... Congratulations, you’ve found your people. Follow to join a community of Crime Junkies! Crime Junkie is presented by audiochuck Media Company.
Stuff You Should Know
If you've ever wanted to know about champagne, satanism, the Stonewall Uprising, chaos theory, LSD, El Nino, true crime and Rosa Parks, then look no further. Josh and Chuck have you covered.