Scary Stories We Tell

Scary Stories We Tell

Storytelling is as old as time and for some of us, the darker the story the more the intrigue. Scary Stories We Tell navigates the muddy trails of true crime, supernatural frights, and horror culture. Let us be your storytellers on this bizarre journey.

Episodes

March 14, 2024 94 mins
Mark as Played
Chris, Emma and Dustin journey back into the backlogs, files, and stories of these United States with a return to the Haunted States series all about the state that borders the one two of the hosts live in: Iowa!

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided...
Mark as Played
January 17, 2024 46 mins
Chris, Jess, and Maggie bring their rewatch of Lost Tapes to a stunning and somewhat underwhelming conclusion with a look at an over-meme'd "cryptid": reptilians.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd.

For more episodes of Scary Stor...
Mark as Played
Join Chris and Emma as they delve into the spooky world of r/paranormal and other user-submitted content over at Reddit with The Reddit Files.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd. Don't forget to check out our official Facebook a...
Mark as Played
December 13, 2023 77 mins
Chris and Emma are joined by artist Dustin Rutledge continue their newest series SurrealTube, a look at surreal, weird, and strange YouTube content, with a look at David Firth's Salad Fingers.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd.

F...
Mark as Played
Chris and Jess continue their look at Animal Planet's found footage horror anthology series that often misses but sometimes lands its cryptids subject matter: Lost Tapes. This episode focuses on the Beast of Bray Road.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is p...
Mark as Played
Join Chris and Emma as they delve into the spooky world of r/paranormal and other user-submitted content over at Reddit with The Reddit Files.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd. Don't forget to check out our official Facebook a...
Mark as Played
Chris is joined once again by SurrealTube co-host Emma to talk about what she's been up to in the last year, if the manifestation train is still rolling, and just general spookiness.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd. Don't for...
Mark as Played
November 8, 2023 55 mins
Chris and Emma are joined by artist Dustin Rutledge continue their newest series SurrealTube, a look at surreal, weird, and strange YouTube content, with a look at David Firth's Salad Fingers.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd.

F...
Mark as Played
October 25, 2023 37 mins
Chris and Jess continue their look at Animal Planet's found footage horror anthology series that often misses but sometimes lands its cryptids subject matter: Lost Tapes. This episode focuses on the Quetzlcoatl.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provide...
Mark as Played
October 18, 2023 72 mins
Chris and Emma journey back into the backlogs, files, and stories of these United States with a return to the Haunted States series all about the state that has more gardens than anything else (we actually don't know if that's true or not): New Jersey.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "S...
Mark as Played
October 11, 2023 94 mins
Join Chris and Sierra and Alecia, the hosts of Twisted & Uncorked, as they talk all about the internet, some of the horrifying lore surrounding the web, and much more in this super-sized crossover episode!

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by...
Mark as Played
Chris is joined once again by screenwriter Richard Hatem to talk about John G. Fuller's The Ghost of 29 Megacycles, demonic possession, and more!

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd. Don't forget to check out our official Facebook...
Mark as Played
September 20, 2023 31 mins
Chris and Maggie continue their look at Animal Planet's found footage horror anthology series that often misses but sometimes lands its cryptids subject matter: Lost Tapes. This episode focuses on yet another big boy of the cryptid world: the Wendigo.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "St...
Mark as Played
Join Chris and Emma as they delve into the spooky world of r/paranormal and other user-submitted content over at Reddit with The Reddit Files.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd. Don't forget to check out our official Facebook a...
Mark as Played
Chris has his mom Cindy on the show for the first time to talk about her beliefs in the supernatural, paranormal, and everything in between.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd. Don't forget to check out our official Facebook and...
Mark as Played
August 30, 2023 69 mins
Chris and Emma are joined by artist Dustin Rutledge continue their newest series SurrealTube, a look at surreal, weird, and strange YouTube content, with a look at David Firth's Salad Fingers.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd.

F...
Mark as Played
August 23, 2023 63 mins
Chris and Jess journey back into the backlogs, files, and stories of these United States with a return to their Haunted States series all about another state that's quickly becoming one of the most diserable places to live in the US: Tennennesse.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay H...
Mark as Played
Join Chris and Emma as they delve into the spooky world of r/paranormal and other user-submitted content over at Reddit with The Reddit Files.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd. Don't forget to check out our official Facebook a...
Mark as Played
August 2, 2023 34 mins
Chris and Jess continue their look at Animal Planet's found footage horror anthology series that often misses but sometimes lands its cryptids subject matter: Lost Tapes. This episode focuses on one of the big boys of cryptids, a true legend, the Yeti.

You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "S...
Mark as Played

Popular Podcasts

    How do the smartest marketers and business entrepreneurs cut through the noise? And how do they manage to do it again and again? It's a combination of math—the strategy and analytics—and magic, the creative spark. Join iHeartMedia Chairman and CEO Bob Pittman as he analyzes the Math and Magic of marketing—sitting down with today's most gifted disruptors and compelling storytellers.

    Eye On College Basketball

    CBS Sports’ official college basketball podcast is the most entertaining and informative of its kind. Gary Parrish and Matt Norlander bring the sport into your ears at least three times per week with commentary, reporting, insider information and statistical analysis throughout college basketball all year long.

    The Questlove Show

    The Questlove Show builds on the award-winning Questlove Supreme podcast, bringing listeners into intimate, one-on-one conversations with peers, influences, and friends. Hosted by Ahmir “Questlove” Thompson, each episode uncovers the unexpected — from morning rituals and hidden talents to the art and experiences that shaped a guest’s journey. Sometimes playful, sometimes profound, always curious, QLS offers rare insight into leaders in music, film, television, comedy, literature, mental health, and beyond. It’s a fresh, unpredictable spin from a trusted source — a place where randomness is encouraged, tangents are welcomed, and conversations are anything but ordinary.

    Dateline NBC

    Current and classic episodes, featuring compelling true-crime mysteries, powerful documentaries and in-depth investigations. Follow now to get the latest episodes of Dateline NBC completely free, or subscribe to Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content: DatelinePremium.com

    The Dan Bongino Show

    The Dan Bongino Show delivers no-nonsense analysis of the day’s most important political and cultural stories. Hosted by the former Deputy Director of the FBI, former Secret Service agent, NYPD officer, and bestselling author Dan Bongino, the show cuts through media spin with facts, accountability, and unapologetic conviction. Whether it’s exposing government overreach, defending constitutional freedoms, or connecting the dots the mainstream media ignores, The Dan Bongino Show provides in-depth analysis of the issues shaping America today. Each episode features sharp commentary, deep dives into breaking news, and behind-the-scenes insight you won’t hear anywhere else. Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-dan-bongino-show/id965293227?mt=2 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4sftHO603JaFqpuQBEZReL?si=PBlx46DyS5KxCuCXMOrQvw Rumble: https://rumble.com/c/bongino?e9s=src_v1_sa%2Csrc_v4_sa_o

Advertise With Us
Music, radio and podcasts, all free. Listen online or download the iHeart App.

Connect

© 2026 iHeartMedia, Inc.