Talking to Death with Payne Lindsey

High Strange Season 2 goes deeper into real encounters, credible witnesses, and the explanations that never seem to stick. More firsthand accounts. Bigger moments. And more times where the official story starts to wobble.
This isn’t about believing everything. It’s about following the story until it actually makes sense… or until it gets too strange to ignore.
New season. Same curiosity. Same skepticism.

Payne and team are hard at work investigating a new case on Up and Vanished: In the Midnight Sun.

In the meantime, please enjoy this Re-Released episode with Jason Flom. He is a renowned music industry executive, entrepreneur, and advocate for criminal justice reform. As the CEO of Lava Records, he has been instrumental in the success of numerous artists, contributing to the rise of icons Katy Perry and Lorde. Beyond his achievemen...

Jeremy Corbell, an acclaimed investigative filmmaker known for his deep dives into the world of the unexplained and extraordinary. Jeremy takes us on a journey through his experiences in documenting and unraveling UFO phenomena and other mysteries that lie on the fringes of science and understanding. He shares fascinating stories from his investigations, discussing how he approaches the challenge of seeking truth in a realm filled ...

Maggie Freleng is a Pulitzer prize winning journalist and podcast host. Join us as she takes us behind the scenes of her riveting journey through the world of unsolved mysteries and the pursuit of social justice. Known for her fearless deep dives and unyielding dedication, Maggie opens up about the highs and lows of investigative journalism, offering a rare glimpse into the painstaking efforts involved in bringing forgotten cases b...

In this episode, we sit down with MAVS (Makeup and Vanity Set), the composer and musician behind the iconic soundtracks of Tenderfoot TV's podcasts, including Up and Vanished, Atlanta Monster, and High Strange. MAVS opens up about the creative process that has shaped the haunting and cinematic scores integral to each show. From the serendipitous way he first connected with Tenderfoot to the experimental techniques he uses to craft ...

Rainn Wilson, widely celebrated for his unforgettable portrayal of Dwight Schrute on "The Office," delves into his multifaceted career, personal growth, and the passions that fuel his creative endeavors. He's an accomplished writer, producer, and a fervent advocate for issues close to his heart. We'll explore his insights into the challenges and triumphs of his acting career, his philosophical outlook on life, his deep involvement ...

In this episode, Payne chats with David Robinson, a father who has been searching for his son, Daniel Robinson, a young geologist who mysteriously disappeared in the Arizona desert. David shares the heart-wrenching story of Daniel's disappearance, the ongoing search efforts, and the challenges he has faced in seeking answers and justice. He talks about the impact of Daniel's case on his family, the support from the community, and t...

WARNING - This week Payne sits down with star of MTV's Jackass, Steve-O, the legendary daredevil and entertainer. Known for his wild stunts and fearless attitude, Steve-O opens up about the journey that has shaped his unique career in entertainment. He shares candid stories of his most outrageous escapades, reflecting on the blend of humor, adrenaline, and the pursuit of pushing boundaries. Beyond the stunts, Steve-O discusses his ...

Madison McGhee is the creator and host of the gripping podcast "Ice Cold Case," where she investigates the cold case murder of her father, John C. McGhee. J.C. was found shot in their family home, a crime that has haunted Madison for years. Driven by a deep desire for justice and closure, Madison uses her podcast to explore the details of her father's murder, uncover new leads, and bring attention to the unresolved case. Her relent...

Matt Frederick is a co-host of the iHeart podcast "Stuff They Don't Want You To Know," where he explores conspiracy theories, hidden truths, and mysterious phenomena. Matt's ability to delve deep into complex topics while maintaining an accessible and entertaining style has solidified his reputation as a leading voice in the realm of conspiracy and mystery podcasts. He's also the Executive Producer of many Tenderfoot shows includin...

Jerry Clark is a seasoned music executive and the charismatic host of the iHeart podcast "Story Time with Legendary Jerry" With a wealth of experience in the music industry, Jerry brings a unique perspective to his storytelling, sharing captivating behind-the-scenes tales and insider insights from his extensive career. His podcast delves into fascinating interviews with industry legends, making it a must-listen for music enthusiast...

Payne Lindsey is a renowned podcaster, filmmaker, and investigative journalist best known for co-creating and hosting the hit true crime podcast "Up and Vanished" and "High Strange". His compelling storytelling and meticulous investigative work have captivated audiences, leading to the reopening of cold cases and shedding light on unsolved mysteries. Lindsey's work has earned him a dedicated following and a reputation for bringing ...

Shane Pittman is a Paranormal Investigator and producer of the Netflix series "28 Days Haunted" and "The Holzer Files" on the Travel Channel. With a keen eye for storytelling and a passion for the unexplained, Shane has brought chilling and compelling content to audiences, capturing the eerie and often unexplainable phenomena encountered by investigators. Shane's dedication to producing high-quality, engaging shows has made him a r...

Danny Murphy is a versatile media figure, excelling as both a podcaster and comedian. As the host of "Not Another True Crime Podcast," Danny delivers excellent banter on both current and old true crime cases, engaging listeners with his sharp wit and insightful commentary. Additionally, he hosts "Virtual Reali-Tea" for the New York Post, where he covers the latest in celebrity gossip and entertainment news. His ability to connect w...

Live from CrimeCon, Payne chats with renowned investigative journalist Chris Hansen. Best known for his groundbreaking TV series "To Catch a Predator," Hansen shares insights into his most compelling investigations, the ethical dilemmas of undercover journalism, and the evolving landscape of online crime. Discover the stories behind the headlines and gain a deeper understanding of the impact and legacy of his fearless reporting. Do...

Live from CrimeCon, Payne sits down with John Ramsey, the father of the late JonBenét Ramsey and investigative journalist Paula Woodward, author of the book, Unsolved: The JonBenét Ramsey Murder 25 Years Later, about the infamous murder case. John shares his personal reflections on the impact of the media and public scrutiny on his family. Paula Woodward delves into new evidence and theories presented in her book. Together, they ex...

Payne sits down with George Chidi, journalist and host of the gripping podcast "King Slime: The Trial of Young Thug and YSL". George provides an in-depth look into the high-profile trial, unpacking the complex web of allegations surrounding Young Thug and the YSL gang. With his insider knowledge and investigative prowess, Chidi sheds light on the legal battles, the personalities involved, and the broader implications for the music ...

On this week's episode, Payne chats with Ben Bowlin, co-host of the "Stuff They Don't Want You to Know" podcast. Ben takes us behind the curtain, to reveal some of the most intriguing conspiracies, myths, and unexplained phenomena out there. Discover his favorite episodes, the challenges of researching controversial topics, and his insights on why these mysteries captivate our imaginations. This episode promises to be a fascinating...

Payne chats with the dynamic hosts of the "I've Had It" podcast, Jennifer Welch and Angie “Pumps” Sullivan, as they share their personal journeys and the pivotal moments that led them to say, "I've had it!" With a mix of humor and sincerity, they reveal how they turn frustration into powerful conversations, and how their podcast has become a platform for change and connection. Don't miss this hilarious episode full of whacky storie...